Comfort Reads discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
General
>
What are you reading right now? (SEE NEW THREAD)
message 101:
by
Chrissie
(new)
Mar 01, 2010 08:15AM

reply
|
flag
I still have the very nice book on my shelf in a prominent place. I will put it on my tbr list, too!

Reading the Peter Wimsey novels for the first time? What a treat.
I love the Count. A good translation helps; there are some bad ones out there.

I do that as well, I mix up German and English quite readily, and French and Spanish (the little Spanish I do know). My German is getting rusty (actually, more my spoken German, I haven't visited my family for quite a while). But, I've always been better at reading and writing languages (all languages) than speaking and/or pronouncing them.

Thanks, I just noticed it. I was away from my computer for a few days and just catching up with email and/or GR discussions.


Chrissie wrote: "Gundula, I don't think
We started the new thread not because we were "supposed to" but because this one was getting cluttered with our language chat. :) I think "Learning a new Language" is a perfect fit for Gundula, too! Welcome back to the threads!
We started the new thread not because we were "supposed to" but because this one was getting cluttered with our language chat. :) I think "Learning a new Language" is a perfect fit for Gundula, too! Welcome back to the threads!

Also, anyone can start a special topic thread in the Just To Chat - Off Topic folder.

Chrissie wrote: "Jeanette, that IS what I meant - we are not suppose to talk about it HERE! Thanks for setting up the new thread. The thing is it is so hard to stick to JUST ONE TOPIC when one starts talking. Don't..."
Sorry Chrissie -- online chatting is never as understandable as talking face-to-face. I just wanted to be sure you knew that I started a new thread to be polite and to make it less confusing, with our language threads and the other books threads. I didn't want you to feel that we had been sent away because we aren't supposed to be talking here. Lee and Lisa and everyone else in this group are some of the friendliest people I've come to know. (Well, now I'm worried that I'm repeating what you already knew, yet again!) :-)
Sorry Chrissie -- online chatting is never as understandable as talking face-to-face. I just wanted to be sure you knew that I started a new thread to be polite and to make it less confusing, with our language threads and the other books threads. I didn't want you to feel that we had been sent away because we aren't supposed to be talking here. Lee and Lisa and everyone else in this group are some of the friendliest people I've come to know. (Well, now I'm worried that I'm repeating what you already knew, yet again!) :-)

read "shell seekers" first. i think i like "coming home" better time frame wise. i also have "september" on my book shelf to read sometime.
Chrissie wrote: "Jeanette, that IS what I meant - we are not suppose to talk about it HERE! Thanks for setting up the new thread. The thing is it is so hard to stick to JUST ONE TOPIC when one starts talking. Don't..."
All I can say is I love the passion and conversation here. I'm happy to see these wonderful discussions taking place and appreciate the way you are all seeing what needs to be done in terms of thread management. :-)
All I can say is I love the passion and conversation here. I'm happy to see these wonderful discussions taking place and appreciate the way you are all seeing what needs to be done in terms of thread management. :-)

I have the Penguin Classics, which seems to be a good translation.
Diane wrote: "i'm reading "coming home" by rosamunde pilcher. this is my second book by her and am really enjoying it.
read "shell seekers" first. i think i like "coming home" better time frame wise. i also hav..."
Diane, I once read a book by Rosamund Pilcher's son and the title now escapes but it was pretty good. I'll have to go and check my shelf for the title. It was a comfort type read.
read "shell seekers" first. i think i like "coming home" better time frame wise. i also hav..."
Diane, I once read a book by Rosamund Pilcher's son and the title now escapes but it was pretty good. I'll have to go and check my shelf for the title. It was a comfort type read.

Mary wrote: "I finished the amazing Let the Great World Spin - 5 stars. ..."
Hey, that's on my Kindle...goodie! I got a surprise Jodi Picoult in the mail today (Diane, I pre-ordered that well before the challenge so it doesn't count! Haha!)
Hey, that's on my Kindle...goodie! I got a surprise Jodi Picoult in the mail today (Diane, I pre-ordered that well before the challenge so it doesn't count! Haha!)

Hey, that's on my Kindle...goodie! I got a surprise Jodi Picoult in the mail today (Diane, I pre-orde..."
I love surprises!! And I hope you like Let the Great World Spin as much as I did!!

Is this the book from the creepy looking movie??"
Jeannette -- I'm sorry it took me so long to get back to you. We were without a home computer so once I left work for the weekend, that was it! I did not think Shutter Island was "creepy" in a horror sort of way. More of a mystery/psycotic (sp?) thriller. A page turner for sure!

Diane D. wrote: "Jeannette wrote: "Diane D. wrote: "I am reading Shutter Island -- definitely not a comfort read!"
Is this the book from the creepy looking movie??"
Jeannette -- I'm sorry it took..."
But there is a movie out right now with DiCaprio called "Shutter Island" and the previews are definitely creepy!
Is this the book from the creepy looking movie??"
Jeannette -- I'm sorry it took..."
But there is a movie out right now with DiCaprio called "Shutter Island" and the previews are definitely creepy!


read "shell seekers" first. i think i like "coming home" better time frame wise. i also hav..."
I loved Coming Home even more than The Shell Seekers. September is pretty good as well. I have the Coming Home DVD, which I thought was quite well done - 4 hours of delight! Definitely a comfort read and movie for me!


I am reading The Summer Book. I almost can't describe it. The writing, the imagery and the characters are all so fascinating.


I actually only started reading it because I tend to be somewhat ocd about reading an authors entire bibliography when it is someone I really like. There was a 15 year gap between this book (which was her first) and the next one.
I recommend this book
Hi Sheila, I didn't know Mary Higgins Clark wrote anything but creepy mysteries! That's pretty neat that you discovered something different written by her.

Hi Sheila - and welcome! I enjoyed Mount Vernon Love Story also, and was surprised to find that Mary Higgins Clark had written it. Very nice book, indeed!
Chrissie wrote: "Jeannette, that is Tove Jansson for you! Great huh?! Too bad you are not reading it in Swedish. I wonder if the translation could be as good as the original."
Sorry -- can't read Swedish. But, I like the book. It isn't gripping and it really doesn't have an obvious plot, so it's hard to categorize. Is it autobiographical at all?
Sorry -- can't read Swedish. But, I like the book. It isn't gripping and it really doesn't have an obvious plot, so it's hard to categorize. Is it autobiographical at all?

Chrissie wrote: "Not that I know of. It is the writing style that is so different with Tove Jansson. I do not know if that gets across in a translation. I am glad you are enjoying it."
The writing style and the interaction of the girl and her grandma. They spar and grumble but they truly love each other. And Sophia is so wise for her age and yet still a child. I love the image of the old lady hobbling out to look for the little house that was washed away and then working late to recreate it (dirt and all) to reassure the little girl.
The writing style and the interaction of the girl and her grandma. They spar and grumble but they truly love each other. And Sophia is so wise for her age and yet still a child. I love the image of the old lady hobbling out to look for the little house that was washed away and then working late to recreate it (dirt and all) to reassure the little girl.




Katri, of course - there wil be good and bad translators. A good translator will not translate the text word by word, but instead simply get the feeling and message across. I did translation when I was in Sweden and the funny thing is how you sometimes find yourself fixing crappy original text. However some texts ARE harder to translate than others. Take poetry - that must be almost impossible!

My main problem with some translations (at least some of the German translations of books I have read in both German and the original) is when whole sections are abridged and/or changed. I know that is what happened with Enid Blyton in German translations and I don't think that is suitable. On the other hand, I have also read some slavish English translations of German children's literature, where the translators have tried to translate word for word and parts (especially those that use idiomatic expressions) end up sounding forced and unnatural. Translation is an art form and not at all easy. It takes both language knowledge and a feel for both of the languages.
My husband's company was purchased a few years ago by Siemens. The CEO is (obviously) German and gave a big speech in English to the new "team" members to rally them to beat the competition. He meant to say something like "we'll leave them shaking in their boots." Instead the CEO took the German saying "machen sich in die Hose" and translated it literally to English "they will pee their pants". When my husband told me about this language gaffe, I just shook my head. My husband cringed at the time; his co-workers just looked momentarily stunned. He couldn't think of the appropriate English phrase on the fly, either!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Forever (other topics)The Big Sky (other topics)
Anil's Ghost (other topics)
Burial Rites (other topics)
Goodbye Sarajevo: A True Story of Courage, Love and Survival (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Michael Ondaatje (other topics)Wendell Berry (other topics)
Robert K. Massie (other topics)
Edmund Morris (other topics)
Susan Fromberg Schaeffer (other topics)
More...