5183 Fall 2025 Information Resources and Services for Children discussion
Reading Responses 1 (Wk 3: 9/8 -14): Evaluating and using children’s literature
1. Bell, C. (2014). El Deafo. Amulet Books.
2. Newbery Medal 2015, Sequoyah Book Award intermediate nominee 2017, Charlotte Huck Award 2013
3. El Deafo by Cece Bell is a memoir in graphic novel format that recounts the author’s experiences growing up with hearing loss. Cece uses her quirky sense of humor and her superhero alter ego to navigate life and the extra challenges that come with her disability.
4. I believe this book won awards because it is so relevant to such a specific demographic. As a person who is hard of hearing myself, I know how challenging it can be to navigate the world. I absolutely loved seeing a fictional character who is just like me. Bell wrote about her own childhood experiences in an engaging way. Her biographical account of growing up with a disability is entertaining, insightful, and offers a glimpse into the world of hearing loss for those who do not have personal experience. The graphic novel format can be very effective at reaching younger or reluctant readers. I have recommended this book to countless intermediate age readers, especially any students who face any sort of roadblock or challenge.
1. Brunelle, L. (2024). Life After Whale. Holiday House.
2. Robert F. Sibert Informational Book Medal, 2025 (Winner), Flora Stieglitz Straus Award, 2025 (Winner)
3. A journey through how the death of a whale, or Whale Fall, creates an a new ecosystem at the oceans floor. A life-cycle story that begins with death.
4. In my opinion, this book is the Robert F Sibert Informational Book Metal because it is truly a unique book. Lifecycles are a commonly taught skill and that is reflected in children's literature- but rarely do we see those life cycles take place underwater. It is packed full of valuable information, immersive-feeling pictures and a look into a process we would never get to see. I think it is very deserving of the awards that it received as well as the number lists and honors it had accumulated as well. This is definitely one I would recommend to a child, especially one fascinated with oceans, deep ocean animals, and the cycle of life. This is also one I would love to develop a lesson around or even just get to talk through it with students. It is wordy- so I wouldn’t read it to my younger age students, but I think students in second grade and on would enjoy this book and be interested to read more about whales or other things mentioned in the text.
1. de la Peña, M. (2015). Last stop on market street. Penguin Young Readers Group.
2. -ALA Notable Children's Books-Younger Readers Category, 2016
-Newbery Medal, 2016
-Notable Books for a Global Society, 2016
3. CJ and his grandmother are taking a bus to the soup kitchen to serve other less fortunate than them and is struggling with the differences around him. CJ is noticing how his friends have cars, how the boys on the bus have headphones with music, but his grandmother shows him how to see the beauty in everything.
4. This book won several awards because of the message it delivers. CJ's story is written in a way that children can identify with. At times, we all look around and wish we had things we do not have and therefore struggle to see the beauty of what is right in front of us. As adults, parents, librarians, and educators, it is our job to help teach children this valuable lesson. I recommend de la Pena's book to help open doors for those discussions. The illustrations are well done and engaging for children, which will help hold their attention while reading or being read to.
1. Williams, V. B. (1982). A Chair for my mother. Greenwillow Books.
2. - Randolph Caldecott Medal, 1983 (Honor Title)
- Boston Globe-Horn Book Awards: Picture Book, 1983
3. After a devastating fire at their home, Rosa her mother, and her grandmother work diligently to save their coins until a large jar is filled so that they can go and buy a large comfortable chair.
4. This story explores themes every child should encounter: community, determination, and the celebration of family bonds. The illustrations do not just accompany the story; they elevate it. We see a story unfold through Rosa's eyes of hard work, dedication, love, and empathy. Not only would I recommend this book to children. I have read this book to my students in the past, and it has opened doors for meaningful conversations about hope, healing, and determination. The story allows children to reflect on what it means to care, work, and dream together as a family.
1. Nelson, V. M. (2009). Bad news for outlaws: The remarkable life of Bass Reeves, deputy U. S. marshal.
2. Coretta Scott King Book Award - Author, 2010 (Winner)
3. When it came to keeping the peace in Indian Territory, no man was better for the job than Bass Reeves, one of the first black deputy U. S. marshals. A crack shot with a strong sense of justice, Reeves always got his man, and his clever tactics and devotion to duty gave him success in the face of racial prejudice and certain danger on the outlaws' trails.
4. This book won the Coretta Scott King award because it highlights the story of a black man in a period of American history that black people are often excluded from, that of the gun-slinging American west in the mid-to-late 19th century. I think this book deserved its award because it is a thoughtful and entertaining telling of the life of someone that many children may not have heard of from their history class. I would recommend this book to a child because it is a fun way to explore some of the true history of a time period that already appeals to children. What is more fun than the story of a wild west lawman rounding up outlaws?
Kelsey, E. (2012). You are stardust. Owlkids Books.
Kirkus Reviews' Best of 2012
An imaginative book that blends science and storytelling to show children how they connect to nature and growth.
Nonfiction picture books for young children are relatively rare. This book brings creativity and imagination to science, allowing kids to picture the earth breathing like them and sneezing that grows flowers. It seems fantastical, but it's all real and based on factual science. I agree that this book is award-worthy. I loved reading this book to my daughter when she was little, and it became even more important after the loss of a beloved pet. It allowed them to see that we come from ancient beginnings and return to that place; together forever in the long cycle of Earth and Stardust. I would recommend it to a child and have read it to my own; we also own it, and it is a good book.
1. Goodluck, L. (2022). Forever cousins (J. Nelson, Illus.). Charlesbridge.
2. 2024 AILA – American Indian Youth Literature Award
2023 Charlotte Huck Book Award - Honor
2022 Junior Library Guild Selection
3. Two young, Native cousins find letters, traditions, and memories keep them connected when one moves from the Rez to the city. The story celebrates family, identity, and the enduring bond of love that stretches across any distance.
4. Forever Cousins won awards and recognition because it demonstrates the resilience of family bonds with a focus on Native voices, voices that are often underrepresented in children’s literature. It is a relatable story about finding love even across distance. Laurel Goodluck’s tender storytelling and Jonathan Nelson’s vibrant illustrations show both the pain of separation from and the joy of connection with those you love. I think the book is particularly award worthy because it authentically represents Native American culture, while remaining inclusive to any child experiencing similar circumstances of missing a loved one. I would absolutely recommend this book to children because it helps foster empathy, cultural awareness, and reassurance.
My Daddy Is a Cowboy1. Seales, S. (2024). My Daddy Is a Cowboy. Abrams Books.
2. Caldecott Medal Nominee (2025), Coretta Scott King Book Award for Illustrator (2025), Boston Globe-Horn Book Award Nominee for Picture Book (2025), and Donna Norvell Award Nominee (2026).
3. My Daddy Is a Cowboy is a beautifully illustrated story that captures a Panamanian father and daughter duo who set out on an early morning horseback riding adventure into town. On their journey into town, her daddy tells her cowboy stories filled with pride, love, and confidence, and while hearing these stories and seeing her city from a different vantage point, she too realizes she is also a cowboy who is full of confidence.
4. I think this book won awards for the beautiful illustrations and heartwarming storytelling. The illustrations were absolutely incredible and a really unique art style compared to other children’s books. The Afro-Latino representation in this book was refreshing to see, as well as the highlighting of the intriguing world and culture of Black cowboys. I absolutely believe this book has earned all of the awards it has received because it was a genuine feel-good read, has beautiful illustrations, and explores a unique perspective. I would recommend this book to a child because I think the illustrations are stunning, and it could help broaden their understanding of the world and different cultures.
Ruby Finds a Worry1. Percival, T. (2018). Ruby Finds A Worry. Bloomsbury
Children’s Books.
2. Judy Newman Book Award Winner 2020, Texas Mockingbird List 2020-21, and Washington Children's Choice Picture Book Award, 2021, Grades K-3.
3. When Ruby finds a worry, all she can do is worry about it! Until she finds someone who helps her see shrinking her worry was easier than she thought.
4. I believe this Ruby Finds a Worry has received these awards and honors because of the wonderful way it handles talking about worrying with children! I absolutely think this book deserves these distinguishments as it handles the complex topic of worries in a very accessible way for children. In this way, it really puts anxiety into perspective. I would absolutely recommend this book to students. I think there is a wonderful social emotional lesson here for a class or students you notice dealing with a lot of anxiety or worries
Forever Cousins1. Goodluck, L. (2022). Forever cousins (J. Nelson, Illus.). Charlsbridge.
2.
a. 2024 American Indian Library Association Youth Literature Best Picture Book Award
b. 2022 National Council of Teachers in English Charlotte Huck Award
c. 2022 Junior Library Guild Selection
3. Cousins Kara and Amanda are separated after Kara's family moves back to the Rez. Each girl will face their fears and discover if time and separation will affect their friendship.
4. I believe this book won awards because it discusses the Native experience of having family living in separate places, while keeping a connection alive. I do think it deserved the award because of how it depicts Native life, culture, and familial bonds. I would recommend this book to a child. The theme of familial bonds enduring after separation is a great topic to learn about while also showcasing Native culture. Additionally, there is some wonderful age-appropriate explanation about the Indian Relocation Act of 1956, Native culture, and more in the author's note.
1. 
Abed, O., Aly, H., Salama, M., & Bahna, C. (2024). The book that almost rhymed. Playaway Products, LLC.
2.
2025 Redbud Read-Aloud Award
A School Library Journal Best Book of the Year
An ALSC Notable Book
A Book Riot Funniest Picture Book of the Year
3.
This picture book shows how an interrupting younger sister is affecting her older brother's supposed-to-be-rhyming story. The brother showcases anger at the changes, his unwillingness to share, and frustration before realizing that allowing his sister's input made his story better.
4.
I believe this book got the recognition it did due to the relatability and immersive story it created. I used this book as a read-aloud for my elementary kids last year, and they absolutely loved the ruined rhymes. We would talk about what the rhyme should have been and laugh at the replacement. It got kids using the rhyming skills a lot of them were practicing in class but then "ruining" the rhyme with the funny sister's decisions. Sharing is a hard concept to grasp while growing up and I think the story shows a new way to experience sharing. Instead of just sharing things, it is sharing a story. I would recommend this book to a child who is looking for something funny and has amazing pictures.
1.Harrison, V. (2023). Big. Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.
2. 2024 Caldecott Medal, Coretta Scott King Award Honor Book, 2024 Notable Children’s Book.
3. The story of a young girl who goes on a journey of self love and discovery as she learns that words have the power to both tear one down and build one up.
4. This story follows a young girl as she learns to navigate the words of others and how she chooses to allow them to define her. I believe that this book was award winning because it is a beautiful depiction of how a young girl needs to learn to navigate what others say about her and what she chooses to believe about herself. It is easy to read, follow, and the main character’s challenge is one that everyone can identify with in some way unfortunately. It is an example of how we can choose to overcome the words of others. With those things combined with strong writing and beautiful illustrations, I think this book is very deserving of its awards and is one that I would recommend to a child as it is an example of self love and choosing to be who you want to be.
1. Santat, D. (2014). The adventures of Beekle: The unimaginary friend. Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.
2. 2015 Caldecott Medal, Notable Children’s Books.
3. Beekle the Imaginary Friend goes on an adventure from an island where imaginary friends are born to find his perfect match: a new friend.
4. I believe this book was awarded because it features a beautiful, immersive, and heartwarming story about an imaginary friend finding his place that is relatable and inspiring. It also features beautiful illustrations and accessible writing. I think it has the perfect balance of silly with the imaginary island Beekle is born on and relatability as Beekle searches for his place and a friend in the world. I found this story very charming and definitely think it is worthy of the awards it was awarded. Because of this book’s storytelling and message, I would recommend it to a child and also think it would be a great addition to a library story time.
1. Rex, A. (2023). The story of gumluck the wizard: Book one. Chronicle Books. 2. Sequoyah Book Award Nominee, Publisher's Weekly Best Books of the Year, and Booklist reviews.
3. Gumluck is a small wizard with big dreams of helping people, even if his magic causes a little chaos! With the help of a grumpy raven, he sets off on a hilarious and heartwarming adventure to become a hero.
4. I believe this book received awards and nominations because of the accessibility towards children. This book hits a lot of the qualifications for 'transition' books as pointed out in Rocklin's article. Children are able to explore themes like self-acceptance, resilience, and belonging through humor and quirky illustrations. The language of the book itself utilizes simple sentence structures, repetition, and rhyming techniques to keep readers interested. While this book might challenge some young readers, it's playful techniques and engaging story encourage learning, growth and confidence in reading.
Citation:Woodson, J. (2018). The day you begin (R. López, Illus.). Nancy Paulsen Books.
Awards:
Jane Addams Children’s Book Award (2019)
National Book Award Longlist (2018)
School Library Journal Best Book of the Year (2018)
Annotation:
A young girl feels isolated at school because her name, food, and experiences are different from her classmates, but she learns that sharing her story creates connections and understanding. This picture book uses lyrical text and vibrant illustrations to celebrate courage, empathy, and the value of diversity.
Response:
I think The Day You Begin received awards because it addresses feelings of difference and belonging in a way that children can understand. Jacqueline Woodson’s writing is poetic and moving, while Rafael López’s illustrations add color and energy to the emotional story. The combination creates a book that appeals to both children and adults. I agree that the book deserves recognition because it prompts conversations about empathy and inclusion in classrooms and families. I would recommend it to children, especially those in early elementary grades, because it validates feelings of insecurity while encouraging them to find connection with others.
1. Cordell, M. (2017) Wolf in the Snow. Feiwel & Friends.
2. Caldecott Medal Winner 2018
Boston Globe Best Book of 2017
School Library Journal Best Book of 2017
3. A little girl and a wolf cub are lost in the snow. Can they find their way home?
4. I think this book won the Caldecott medal because of its incredible art. This book is made up entirely of pictures; there are no words that go along with the art, other than the occasional howl of a wolf. Its ability to tell this story without words makes it both beautiful and perfect for children. I do think it deserved the award; the beautiful and simple story is perfect for children. The stark red of the little girl against the white of the snow, along with the friendship she created with the wolf cub, makes this book a lovely and moving story. I would recommend this book to a child, especially those on the younger side, as they can enjoy the story themselves, the lack of words meaning that they do not need an adult to read to them.
1. Laan, T. (2024) John the skeleton. (A. Cullen, Trans.). Yonder. (Original work published 2020)
2. 2025 Mildred L. Batchelder Award Winner, 2025 USBBY Outstanding International Book
3. Follows a retired classroom skeleton, John, as he settles down with Gram and Gramps, who live in the Estonian countryside, and learns about their slow-paced way of life and what it means to exist with them, grow old with them, and care for them and their small circle of community.
4. This book won the 2025 Mildred L Batchelder Award for an outstanding translated work of fiction that originates in a country outside the US. I believe this book won an award due to the simple nature of the story being used as an avenue to show Estonian culture and to normalize death in a light-hearted and age-appropriate way. The book references and explains Estonian cultural beliefs, traditions, drinks. Narrative point of view of a skeleton experiencing things for the first time is a unique way to explore connection, aging, death, and grief.
I would recommend it to a child who may be experiencing loss their life or is asking questions about death and growing old. I do not think this book is for every child, but I think it is appropriate for children who are ready to have these conversations. Death is discussed in an age-appropriate way. In the book, the grief that follows death is shown in the context of allowing the feelings as they come and finding connection with loved ones past death.
1. Sciezka, J. & Smith, L. (1992) The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales. Viking Press.
2. Caldecott Medal 1993
3. The book reimagines classic fairy tales with a satirical, humorous twist, featuring the Stinky Cheese Man being a primary example of a familiar story (The Gingerbread Man) who is characterized by a unique feature, his smell.
4. The book The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales likely won the Caldecott Honor Award, because of its imaginative illustrations, clever design, and creative storytelling. It broke traditional picture book conventions by using satire, fractured fairy tales, and witty humor that appealed to both children and adults. I think it deserved the award because it encouraged readers to think and reminisce about familiar stories while also enjoying a new and funny spin to the fairy tales. I remember reading this when I was in elementary school and loved the title of the book as well as how funny it was to say “Stinky Cheese man”. I would recommend this book to a child because it sparks curiosity, supports a love of reading through humor, and demonstrates how stories can be told in surprising, imaginative ways. I’ve mentioned this book to my 4 year old daughter and the title alone made her laugh and added a request for me to read it to her.
1. Bradley, K. B. (2020). Fighting Words. Dial Books for Young Readers.
2. John Newbery Medal (2021) and Golden Kite Award (2021).
3. In this heartbreaking novel, Della Roberts finds the strength to speak out against the abuses she and her sister, Sookie, endured. They learn to find the courage throughout foster care, school bullies, and mental health.
4. I loved this book, even though it did cause my heart to break in several places. This book is so important for representation and speaking out against child sexual abuse, mental health struggles, and foster care. Students need to be able to see themselves within the characters they read about, and any student who reads this book might feel empathy and understanding for someone who has gone through what Della and Sookie went through, or find comfort in knowing they aren't alone. This is something the author makes sure to mention not only in her prose but in the author's note as well. I would think that this book won the awards it did because of the strength of the words that were used, the careful approach to such a controversial subject. I don't know if this is a book I would choose for a book club or would widely recommend it to any student, but it is one that I think absolutely deserves a place on the shelves in a library.
1. Stein, D.E. (2010). Interrupting Chicken. Candlewick Press.
2. Caldecott Medal Nominee, Florida Reading Association Children’s Book Award, California Young Readers Medal Nominee for Primary.
3. A humorous tale of a little chicken that has a habit of interrupting stories at bedtime. A PaPa chicken whose patience takes a turn for a surprise resolution to an impatient chicken.
4. I believe this book won the awards it did because it is a funny, relatable book that parents and children experience regularly. It won the Caldecott Honor because the pictures and colors are excellent, visually stimulating illustrations. The illustrations vary in special features that change within different contexts of the story, which also incorporate vivid details. I would recommend this book to children because I have read it to my own children, and they love it. I believe this book is a book in which kids relate and visually put themselves in the story, making the story come alive in their imagination.
1. Wright, B.R. (1987). Christina’s Ghost. Scholastic.
2. Oklahoma Sequoyah Book Award for Children, Texas Bluebonnet Award, Georgia Children's Book Award.
3. Separated from her family and forced to spend the summer with her uncle in an old mansion, Christina gets visited by the supernatural. The little ghost dressed as a sailor tries desperately to communicate with Christina about a murder.
4. I believe this book won its awards because it is a fascinating and page-turning book that keeps children reading until the end. It has a great mix of suspense and a sinister twist that leaves the reader unable to guess the end. I believe that this book deserves its many awards. The Sequoyah Award is an award that children vote on. Children thought this spin-tingling book was a great read for others their age, and I agree. This is a book that will hold audiences of all generations. Written almost forty years ago, it remains a stimulating read for children while still being appropriate for its target age.
The Snowy Day1. Keats, E. J. (1962). The snowy day. Viking Press.
2. Caldecott Medal (1963), Horn Book Fanfare Book (1963), ALA Notable Children’s Book
3. Peter wakes up to a fresh snowfall and explores his neighborhood, discovering joy in the simple experiences of winter. The book uses bold collage illustrations to capture the wonder of a child’s perspective.
4. The Snowy Day received the Caldecott Medal for its groundbreaking illustrations and for centering an African American child at a time when such representation was rare in picture books. The combination of vivid collage art and simple yet powerful storytelling creates an immediate sense of wonder that resonates across generations. I believe it deserved the award because it opened new doors for diversity in children’s literature while also appealing to the universal joy of discovery. I would recommend this book to children ages 3–7, as it affirms their everyday experiences and encourages them to see beauty in the ordinary.
1. Rogers, A. L. (2024). Chooch helped (R. L. Kunz, Illus.). Heartdrum.
2. 2025 Caldecott Medal
3. Little Chooch is eager to “help” his family, which often creates more mess much to his older sister’s dismay. After another frustrating mess made by Chooch, Sissy finally discovers that patience and being her little brother’s teacher is its own gift.
4. Chooch Helped won the Caldecott Medal because of the heartfelt storytelling combined with the beautiful illustrations that bring to the forefront Cherokee family life and traditions. The book captures an all too well known sibling experience; the older sibling frustrated by the ‘baby’ wanting to help, but instead causing more problems. Andrea Rogers’ story is cloaked in tender humor and remains culturally authentic. Rebecca Kunz pairs the words with stunning illustrations. I would recommend this book to children because it explores the ups and downs of sibling relationships, and promotes representation of Cherokee people, their language, and traditions.
Onyx & Beyond
1. McBride, A. (2024). Onyx & Beyond. Feiwel & Friends.
2. Oklahoma Childrens Sequoyah Book Award Nominee for 2026 (recognized by the Oklahoma Library Association)
3. As a young child, Onxy is navigating grown up challenges. The Civil Rights Movement is ramping up around him and he faces a problem at home that could land him in the foster care system. Onxy learns the value of a caring community and how a trusted voice can have a lasting impact.
4. This is an absolutely beautiful story of a boy finding his way through adolescence and by telling the story with poetry from his perspective it allows the reader to have the most tender insight into his inner thoughts and feelings. I believe this book was nominated for the Children's Sequoyah Book Award for 2026 because it tackles the historical events surrounding the Civil Rights Movement as well as other challenging topics like foster care, family illness, divorce, loss, loneliness and isolation from the perspective of a school age boy. There are funny situations that kids would enjoy and dreams of flying to space mixed with some extremely tender moments. I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to upper elementary age students because it is relatable, entertaining, and does not shy away from difficult subjects. I think kids long to be included in difficult discussions, and this book gives a pathway for those types of reflections to occur. I highly recommend!
*side note - this would also be a great book for a struggling upper elementary reader who needs to grow in confidence to read chapter books. The chapters are written in prose form and are on the shorter side.
Dear Mr. Henshaw1. Cleary, B., & Zelinsky, P. O. (1983). Dear Mr. Henshaw. Morrow.
2. This book won the John Newbery Medal.
3. Leigh Botts has a favorite author, and for an assignment, writes to him. They stay in touch over the years as Leigh grows and navigates life's challenges.
4. I believe this book won the Newbery Medal due to its real life applications. Most children today struggle with divorced parents, loneliness, the struggles of being a young child in a new school, and bullying. The book is not overly heavy but allows children to recognize they are not alone with various struggles they might encounter in their own lives.
Creepy Carrots!
1. Reynolds, A., & Brown, P. (2012). Creepy Carrots. Simon Schuster Books for Young Readers.
2. Caldecott Medal Nominee (2013), Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Picture Books (2012), and numerous other regional awards. To name just 2 of many regional awards: Iowa Goldfinch Award (2015) and Pennsylvania Young Readers' Choice Award for Grades K-3rd (2014).
3. The last thing Jasper Rabbit expected was for his favorite treat to spook him in the night! This is a highly entertaining story of Jasper and a delicious nightmare that comes true. The story leads up to a twist at the end and is sure to have you on the edge of your seat.
4. This book won numerous awards, but the one I would like to highlight is the Caldecott Medal nominee for the awesome illustrations you will find throughout this children's picture book. Each page tells the entertaining story of Jasper and the spooky sightings that occur after he continues to pick the crisp and clearly addicting carrots from Crackenhopper field. I think early elementary kids enjoy the illustrations in this book because of the bright carrot colors that seem to pop off the page in contrast to the grey backgrounds. Equally eye catching are the relatable "spooky" scenes that end up looking totally different when a parent turns on the light - on each page you can see how Jasper's eyes are playing tricks on him. You start to wonder if the carrots are actually creeping in with vengeance, or if they are conspiring against Jasper for another reason! I highly recommend this book - both for kids to check out and read and also for educators to use as a fun read aloud - especially in the fall holiday months when kids are drawn towards spooky stories! I would also highly recommend other books in this series linked here too:
Jasper Rabbit's Creepy Tales! (Boxed Set): Creepy Carrots!; Creepy Pair of Underwear!; Creepy Crayon!
1. Emberley, M. (2022). I did it! (M. Emberley, Illus.). Holiday House.
2. 2023 Theodor Seuss Geisel Award Winner, 2022 Kirkus Starred Review, 2023 Booklist Starred Review
3. In I Did It!, Michael Emberley celebrates both determination and friendship as a child works through the challenges of trying something new. With playful illustrations and minimal text, the story highlights perseverance, shared encouragement, and the joy of accomplishment.
4. This book won the Theodor Seuss Geisel Award because it represents the best of early reader literature—accessible language, supportive illustrations, and a storyline that encourages confidence and resilience. I believe it absolutely deserved the award, as it not only empowers emerging readers but also normalizes the ups and downs of learning. The book also received a Starred Review from Kirkus, reinforcing its literary and developmental value. I would enthusiastically recommend this book to children because it fosters both literacy growth and social-emotional learning, making it enjoyable for kids and meaningful for caregivers to share.
1. White, E. B., & Williams, G. (1952). Charlotte's web. First edition. Harper & Brothers.
2. John Newberry Medal (1953), Laura Ingalls Wilder Award (1970), Massachusetts Children’s Book Award (1984)
3. Wilbur is a livestock pig that is saved from slaughter by the farmer's daughter. He befriends a spider named Charlotte who continues to help Wilbur thrive on the farm.
4. Your response to these questions: Why, in your opinion, did this book win an award? Do you think it deserved the award? Why or why not? Would you recommend this book to a child? Why or why not? Your answers to #4 should be about 100 words
I think this book won these awards because it tackles complex events/struggles and presents them in a way that children can understand. It was well-received by its original audience, enough so that various movies have been made adapting the story. Furthermore, it's included in many children's literature lists. Charlotte's Web deserved its awards, and is considered a great classic in children's literature. I would recommend this book to a child. I think that the animals as main characters is a very fun concept and makes the life lessons more engaging to young readers.
1. Maillard, K. (2019). Fry bread: A native American family story. Roaring Book Press.
2. Robert F. Sibert Informational Book Medal (2020) and American Indian Youth Literature Picture Book Honor.
3. Fry bread is food, but within these book’s pages you’ll discover that fry bread is so much more than just nourishment to Native Americans. In short, rhythmic prose, Maillard shares the cultural significance behind this community anchor.
4. I believe this book won the Sibert Medal because of the valuable information in offers to its readers about a culture often overlooked in literature. The book highlights the history, significance, and heritage of fry bread in Native American communities, and very much deserves this award. The book’s illustrations are colorful and invite children to learn more about a culture they may not have previously known existed. I would recommend this book, especially for a read aloud during Native American Day or Indigenous Peoples’ Day. The last eight pages of the book are Author’s Notes that delve deeper into the tradition of fry bread, and could help enhance learning as librarians lead discussions with children during this important week.
1. Latham, I., & Shamsi-Basha, K. (2020). The cat man of Aleppo. Penguin Random House.
2. Caldecott Medal (2021)
3. The Cat Man of Aleppo tells the true story of Alaa, an ambulance driver who stays behind in war-torn Syria to aid his neighbors and stray cats. The book’s unique sketches and bright colors accentuate its themes of compassion and hope.
4. Yuko Shimizu’s powerful illustrations won The Cat Man of Aleppo its Caldecott Medal. Each stroke gives definition and difference to each character, location, and animal friend. Shimizu does a wonderful job of bringing the side effects of the Syrian War to the forefront of the book’s illustrations without overshadowing the context of Alaa’s story. I would recommend this book to any child, as it offers historical and relevant context to a story that highlights themes of compassion, perseverance, and dedication. These are topics that I think should be presented to all children, regardless of their circumstances.
1. Denise, Christopher. (2022). Knight Owl. Little, Brown and Company.
2. Caldecott Medal (2023), Bill Martin Jr. Picture Book Award (2024).
3. A small but determined owl fulfills his dream of knighthood, using bravery and cleverness to connect with others.
4. Knight Owl received the Caldecott Medal for captivating its readers through a balance of shadowy images matched with vivid bursts of color. Denise’s illustrations are based on his childhood adventures in Irish castle ruins, giving his book a unique artistic style that draws its readers into the fun story of a little owl with big plans and great courage. I would recommend this book to any child. Its playful message of courage is inspiring to children of all ages. This book aids the library’s mission of encouraging children to believe in themselves and to face challenges with confidence.
1). Ho, J. (2021). Eyes that Kiss in the Corners (D. Ho, Illus.). Harper.
2). Eyes that Kiss in the Corners was a Bank Street Best Children’s Book of the Year, a School Library Journal Best Book of 2021, and a Golden Poppy Book Award Winner.
3). Eyes that Kiss in the Corners follows a young girl who finds beauty in being different through the love she sees woven through the eyes of her family and her culture.
4). In my opinion, this book won multiple awards because it honours the value of being yourself. Children look at their peers, their parents, other adults, and sometimes it’s hard to be confident in yourself. This book beautifully highlights the individuality of the protagonist while also acknowledging the different kinds of beauty amongst her friends. The illustrations perfectly meld the words and images together to create prose that is worthy of being called poetry. This book deserved its awards because there is nothing more important for children than to recognize their own worth and develop a love for themselves and their roots. I would absolutely recommend this book to a child because every child needs to know how important they are.
1). Barnett, M. (2012). Extra Yarn (J. Klassen, Illus.). Balzer + Bray.
2). Extra Yarn was a Caldecott Honour Winner, it was a winner of the Boston Globe-Horn Book Award, and it was a School Library Journal Best Book of 2012.
3). Annabelle finds a mysterious and never-ending box of yarn and spreads joy throughout her small town by knitting sweaters for people, animals, and even things that don’t wear sweaters! How long will it take for Annabelle to run out of yarn?
4). In my opinion, this book won awards because its main character showcased a strength to stand up to evil even when faced with personal gain. She chose to continue spreading joy and making her entire town a happier place even when she was threatened. Yes, I do think it deserved awards because it shows that happiness and joy is more important than being rich. Annabelle was rich in happiness, and the book highlighted this very well. I would recommend this book to a child because it is a sweet story that shows the innocence and beauty of spreading happiness and joy.
I Have Heard of a Land1. Thomas, J. C., & Cooper, F. (2000). I Have Heard of a Land. Joanna Cotler Books.
2. Coretta Scott King Award
3. I Have Heard of a Land uses beautifully detailed illustrations and a poetic writing style to tell the story of African Americans moving west to Oklahoma territory during the land runs. A young African American woman dreams of owning land, a three room log cabin, and possibilities seem endless.
4. I believe this book won the Coretta Scott King Award because of the story it told. The 1889 and 1893 land runs in Oklahoma were pivotal moments in history especially for many African Americans as the land runs promised opportunity in land ownership, the building of community, and the creation of better livelihoods. This book tells the story of resilience, hard work, and courage of African American pioneers during this period of history. Furthermore, this book draws upon the experience of the authors own family to tell this story creating an intimate portrayal of the hard efforts and opportunities many sought after. The illustrations also captivate the audience of the book and lend to the content of the story.
1. Stead, R. (2009). When You Reach Me. Wendy Lamb Books.
2. Newbery Medal, Boston Globe-Horn Book Award, Parents' Choice Book Award.
3. Sixth grade year takes a strange turn for Miranda as she begins to lose her best friend, make new friends, and help her mother win a game show. But when she starts to receive mysterious notes asking for her to help prevent a tragic death, she must rely on the one thing she can help her: her belief in herself.
4. I think this book won, and deserved, the Newbery Metal along with several additional awards because it was an interesting take on time travel while including themes of everyday struggles or daily life that children and other ages can relate to. Seeing Miranda go through a normal and simple life was comforting and helped show that it's okay to not have a lot of materialistic things or that you can have an enjoyable upbringing if events and living are simpler. We see several character developments throughout the story that are wholesome and slowly see how Miranda is developing into a caring, good-hearted individual. This book is recommended for ages 10 and up, which I would agree with and recommend. The time traveling aspect could be confusing to a younger population.
The Graveyard Book1. Gaiman, N. (2008). The graveyard book. HarperCollins.
2. Newbery Medal (2009), Carnegie Medal (2010), Hugo Award for Best Novel (2009)
3. After his family is murdered, a boy named Nobody Owens is raised by ghosts in a graveyard where he learns lessons about life, death, and courage. Neil Gaiman blends gothic fantasy and coming-of-age themes in this haunting yet heartwarming tale.
4. I think The Graveyard Book won awards because it captures a universal story of growth and identity while set in a unique, imaginative world. Gaiman masterfully balances dark themes with warmth and humor, making the book both unsettling and comforting. The originality of having a child raised by ghosts, along with the lyrical writing, makes it stand out in children’s literature. I believe it deserved its awards because it challenges young readers to think deeply about mortality, bravery, and belonging without being heavy-handed. I would recommend it to older children, especially those who enjoy fantasy and slightly spooky stories.
Monster Hands1. Kane, K., & McMillan, J. (2024). Monster Hands (Dion MBD, Illus.). Nancy Paulsen Books.
2. ALSC 2025 Notable Children’s Books Selection, Horn Book Fanfare Best Book of 2024, 2024 Booklist Editors’ Choice Pick
3. Monster Hands tells the story of two Deaf siblings who use American Sign Language to confront nighttime fears together. This award-winning picture book celebrates siblings, ASL, and the power of imagination in overcoming anxiety.
4. I think Monster Hands deserved its awards. By centering Deaf siblings using American Sign Language, it brings authentic representation to kids who may rarely get to see themselves on the page. At the same time, the story has universal appeal; many children will likely relate to feeling scared at night and finding comfort in a sibling’s support. The book mixes playful suspense, warm illustrations, and cultural authenticity, making the book memorable and meaningful. I would recommend this book to kids due to its storytelling, message, and representation of Deaf culture.
The Bees of Notre-Dame1.
Browne, M.P., & Goodale, E.B. (2023). The bees of Notre-Dame. Random House Studio.
2.
2024 National Council of Teachers of English Orbis Pictus Award for excellence in nonfiction.
2025 Oklahoma Library Association Sequoyah Award nominee
2025 Texas Library Association Texas Topaz Nonfiction Gem
3.
The bees who live on the roof of Notre-Dame are abuzz because their home is ablaze! Will the bees survive and have a chance to rebuild?
4.
I believe this book won awards because it highlights something positive that came from a tragic, real-life event. This book also educates readers about a little-known fact involving a historical building. While a work of nonfiction, it reads like a story and has wonderful illustrations. It is engaging, interesting and children can delve deeper into subjects such as bees, the Notre-Dame, Paris, rescue efforts, rebuilding, and more after reading this book. Children may also become emotionally invested because they want to know what happens to the bees and Notre Dame after a fire. For these reasons, I would recommend this book to a child. Additionally, this book conveys a message of hope; that Notre Dame will be rebuilt by people coming together, “just like the bees.”
1. Rockwell, T. (1973). How to eat fried worms. Random House.
2. Mark Twain Award (Missouri, 1975), Golden Archer Award (Wisconsin, 1975), ALA Notable Children’s Book (1973)
3. Billy accepts a bet to eat fifteen worms in fifteen days, leading to both gross-out humor and creative problem-solving. The book uses comedy and competition to explore themes of friendship, persistence, and courage.
4. How to Eat Fried Worms won awards because it captures the humor and daring spirit of childhood in a way that feels authentic to kids. Rockwell balances the “gross” premise with a clever story about resilience, peer pressure, and the lengths children will go to prove themselves. I used to read this every year to my fourth graders, and it never failed to capture their attention and spark laughter. I think it deserved its recognition because it continues to engage reluctant readers. I would recommend it to children ages 8–12 because the humor and suspense make it a fun and memorable read.
Forever Cousins
1. Goodluck, L. (2022). Forever cousins (J. Nelson, Illus.). Charlesbridge.
2. American Indian Youth Literature Award (2024), Charlotte Huck Award Honor Book, Junior Library Guild Gold Standard
3. Two close cousins are separated when one of the cousins moves from the reservation to the big city.
4. This book won the award because it deals with actual events that happen in the American Indian culture. It shows how some Native Americans have to leave their reservations for whatever reason. It shows life in a different culture and gives readers a look into how close families are when they live on the reservation together. I definitely think it deserved the award because it helps readers understand how different cultures are and how they celebrate things. I would definitely recommend this to a child because it's important for children to learn about different cultures and their way of life.
My Daddy is a Cowboy
1. Seales, S. (2024). My Daddy Is a Cowboy. Abrams Books.
2. Caldecott Medal Nominee (2025), Coretta Scott King Book Award for Illustrator (2025), Boston Globe-Horn Book Award Nominee for Picture Book (2025), and Donna Norvell Award Nominee (2026)
3. A father and daughter take an early morning horseback ride through their town. On the ride, her father tells her stories about being a cowboy that makes the daughter feel pride and that she too can be a cowboy.
4. This book won an award for its illustrations which are shown on every single page of the book. The pages are beautifully illustrated and show bright colors. The story is also sweet and shows a lovely relationship between a father and daughter. I definitely think it deserved to win the illustration award and be nominated for the others for the story it tells. It also has a interesting family dynamic where they are African American and Latino which gives readers a look into mixed race families. I would definitely recommend this book to a child just based on the illustrations, but also for the story as well. My favorite part was at the end when the daughter tells her dad "my favorite part was spending time with you" which melted my heart as I am a daddy's girl.
1. Steig, W. (2005). Sylvester and the magic pebble. Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers.
2. Caldecott Medal (1970)
3. A young donkey finds himself in a rocky situation after using his magic pebble in a moment of fright.
4. This book won the Caldecott Medal for the playful watercolor illustrations featured throughout the picture book. Steig's colorful illustrations portrayed the scenes in an enticing manner, drawing the listener into the story. I believe this book deserved the Caldecott Award for portraying the story in a clear but playful way. Steig's use of imperfect lines and shapes, enhanced by the use of vivid colors, added a child-like touch to the illustrations. I would recommend this book to children age 4 and up. Although a younger child would likely appreciate the illustrations, the themes in the story may be hard to grasp at a younger age.
The funny little woman by Arlene moselMosel, A., & Lent, B. (2007). The funny little woman. Paw Prints ; Dutton.
Caldecott medal
An old woman goes on an adventure chasing after a runaway dumpling and meets the oni.
The funny little woman won the Caldecott medal because of the illustrations. I think it deserved the award; the drawings were fun, creative, and fairly detailed. I would recommend it to a child; it was a fun little story that made me laugh. I don’t think it was too wordy, but it also wasn’t super fast and lacked reading material.
Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak
Sendak, M. (2013). Where the wild things are. Dref Wen.
Caldecott medal
Max leaves for a faraway land where he can be as wild as he wants, where he meets other wild things just like him.
Where the Wild Things Are won the Caldecott for its portrayal of children’s emotions in the illustrations and story, I think it deserved to win because the story accurately reflects how kids feel and might imagine. I would recommend the book; it wasn’t my favorite this week, but it still had a good story to it, and I think it is something that a child would like or could see themselves in.
Joseph Had a Little Overcoat1. Taback, S. (1999). Joseph Had a Little Overcoat. Viking Press.
2. National Jewish Book Award for Children's Picture Book (1999), Caldecott Medal for U.S. Picture Book Illustration (2000)
3. The book follows Joseph and his unique overcoat. As the overcoat gets old and worn, he turns it into a smaller article of clothing using the still good material. This process continues throughout the book with smaller and smaller articles.
4. I wanted to start off with a real classic and my mom used to read this one to me when I was a child. To speak to why the book won that Caldecott medal, it has a unique visual style. In addition to the bright, striking colors, the pages include holes that allow illustrations on one side of the page flip to incorporate into the other. This ties into how the overcoat keeps getting changed into different articles of clothing going from an overcoat to a button. The National Jewish Book Award comes from the book being based on an old Yiddish song. This is a touching story about working with what you have and it deserves its accolades.
1. Smith, L. (2023) Stickler Loves the World. Random House Studio.2. 2025 Donna Norvell Award
3. A unique creature, Stickler, who is enraptured by everything around it, enthusiastically helps a new friend explore the world for the first time.
4. Stickler Loves the World won the children’s choice Donna Norvell award. I can see why it was chosen off the nominee list by students, as it is engaging, full of heart, and a little silly. I think this book is valuable because it gives readers the vocabulary to talk about elements of the natural world. And as the story goes on, the reader is encouraged to be looking to see the world from a new perspective of wonder. The illustrations are whimsical and textured, while still clear in their representations. I think it is a great book to use to encourage a wonder-walk in nature.
The Little Engine That Could1. Piper, W. (1930). The Little Engine That Could. Platt & Munk.
2. Indie's Choice Book Awards Picture Book Hall of Fame (2012)
3. This famous story is about train cars full of toys and fruits that are having trouble getting taken over the mountain and to the valley for all the good boys and girls. Then a friendly little engine manages to pull the cars over the mountain through perseverance.
4. This book has a nice message about kindness and perseverance. The luxury passenger train and the freight train are too proud to help so they pass by. The little blue engine is earnest and eager to help so he gladly takes the responsibility of pulling the cars. Because he is such a small engine, he has trouble pulling them up the hill. Through effort and positive thinking, he accomplishes the goal. A book get admitted into a hall of fame by being renowned even much after the fact. This book has stuck itself in our collective consciousness ninety-five years after publication. People remember "I think I can!" The messages of kindness and believing in yourself have resonated for nearly a century making this book deserving of its accolades.
Book Name: Bodega Cat Series: Picture Purrfect by Hilda Eunice 
Hilda Eunice BurgosCitation: Burgos, H. E. (2024). Bodega cats: Purrfect picture. Kokila.
Awards, Honors, Best Book List, Starred Reviews:
Junior Library Guild Gold Standard Selection
Kids Indie Next List pick
Amazon Best Children’s Books of 2024, Ages 6 to 8
A Publisher’s Weekly Best of Summer 2024 Read
Maryland Library Association Blue Crab Young Reader Award, 2025
Children’s Book Council Favorites Awards: Children’s Favorites 3rd to 5th grade list AND Librarian Favorites 3rd to 5th grade list
School Library Journal summer reading recommendations
Bank Street College Best Children’s Books of the Year
Reviews
Kirkus review
Publishers Weekly review
Dominican Writers Association article
Annotation: This picture book celebrates the unique culture of New York City bodegas through the eyes of a child, Miguel, and the charm of their resident cats. Burgos highlights community, family, and cultural pride while weaving in warm illustrations that showcase everyday life. The book offers young readers a representation of urban Latino neighborhoods, fostering conversations about place, identity, and local traditions.
Reasons why: I believe that this book won an award because of its representation of the younger audience of the hispanic community as well as the community of business owners in the bustling city of New York. This helps readers feel a connection to the main character and their family as the setting was fun and lively, with the point of view jumping from the small child Migeul to the newfound cat, Lolo. It is a lighthearted story of a boy finding a cat, as well as discovering his love of art and sharing that with his traditional family. This touches on the themes of identity and family which is great for kids. As well as the concept of it being a picture book, with little illustrations on every chapter or so brings to life the story and the passion from Miguel and his dreams of being an artist.
Susan Patron
Book Name: The Higher Power of Lucky by Susan Patron
Citation: Patron, S. (2006). The higher power of Lucky. Atheneum Books for Young Readers.
Awards, Honors, Best Book List, Starred Reviews:
John Newbery Medal, an award annually by the Association for Library Service to children, a division of the American Library Association, to the author of the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children.
Annotation:
This Newbery Medal–winning novel follows ten-year-old Lucky Trimble in the small desert town of Hard Pan, California, as she searches for her “Higher Power” while coping with fears of abandonment. Patron blends humor, honesty, and a strong sense of place to explore themes of resilience, independence, and a sense of belonging. The book is frequently discussed in school and library settings for its candid approach to children’s emotional growth and its controversy over language use.
Reasons why: I believe this book won an award because of its writing itself, and the amazingly detailed characterization of each person, and of the town of Hard Pan. There are lots of books out there where kids have to overcome some obstacle in order to grow and change and become more mature, but I don’t think many of them are written this well, or with this same style. The story is a little heartfelt and might not be the happy ending books that children are used to reading but these are emotions that children face every day with the sad situations like losing a parent. This books connects those feelings for readers and stands out for that.
1. Citation (APA 7th edition):Goodluck, L. (2022). Forever cousins (J. Nelson, Illus.). Charlesbridge.
2. Awards/Honors:
• American Indian Youth Literature Award, Picture Book Honor (2022)
• Bank Street College Best Children’s Books of the Year (2023)
• Starred Review from School Library Journal
3. Annotation:
Two young cousins, separated when one family moves from the city to the reservation, discover that their bond of love and kinship remains strong despite distance. This heartfelt picture book explores Native identity, family connections, and resilience.
4. Response
I think Forever Cousins won awards because it does a great job of including Native voices and stories, which aren't always found in children's books. The story by Laurel Goodluck is about family, but it is based on Native American customs. Jonathan Nelson's drawings show warmth and national pride. The story is powerful for everyone because it feels both personal and general. I think it should have won the awards because it not only tells a moving story but also shows real people. I would definitely suggest it to kids because it shows how important family, belonging, and cultural heritage are in a way that is easy to understand and has meaning.
5183 Fall 2025 Information Resources and...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Dream Catcher (other topics)The Higher Power of Lucky (other topics)
Picture Purrfect (other topics)
The Little Engine That Could (other topics)
Joseph Had a Little Overcoat (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Susan Patron (other topics)Hilda Eunice Burgos (other topics)
This week, you will read two award-winning children’s books. You must not use one of the required books for this class as your choice.
Note: You may not be able to add a book, if the book has already been added to the group bookshelf by another student. In this case, you will just be able to add your post. No points docked for reading the same book as others in the class.
Part 2: Answer to the following questions in the comment area. Your response this week should focus on one of the two books you chose to read.
1. A citation for the book, formatted in APA format. (Add a book cover/link to the book in the comment area, if possible. When you click on the link “add book/author,” a pop-up “add a reference” will appear where you can search for a book and add a link or book cover.)
2. State which award(s) the book received. (List up to 3 awards, honors, best book lists, starred reviews, etc.)
3. A brief annotation for the book, no more than two sentences. Make sure to read Broderick’s essay “How To Write a Fiction Annotation” in Week 3 in the Canvas module before you write an annotation.
4. Your response to these questions: Why, in your opinion, did this book win an award? Do you think it deserved the award? Why or why not? Would you recommend this book to a child? Why or why not? Your answers to #4 should be about 100 words.