SciFi and Fantasy Book Club discussion
Group Business
>
Combi-Polling of GR & TSG
date
newest »
newest »
Mod
February 2025 Adaptive Fashion SciFi
Iron Widow 90 = 62gr + 28 tsg
Dead Space 53 = 42gr + 11 tsg
February 2025 Mod Curated Fantasy
Masquerade 66 = 58gr + 8 tsg
Diavola 45 = 39gr + 6tsg
DallerGut Dream Department Store 49 = 34gr + 15tsg
Winner is same on both sites, but runner up of GR poll finished third when combining the tally. Dallergut Dream Department Store will make the Runner Up poll at the end of the year.
March 2025 Mod Curated SciFi
We Are All Ghosts in the Forest - 37 gr + 16 tsg = 53 votes
Space Unicorn Blues - 38 gr + 6 tsg = 44 votes
So the winner is correct on TSG, but not in GR.
March 2025 Camp Fantasy
The Utterly Uninteresting and Unadventurous Tales of Fred, the Vampire Accountant - 43 gr + 16 tsg
Orconomics - 42 gr + 15 tsg
So correct on both sites.
Mod
Could we have links to the latest TSG polls (previous, current) in post #2 maybe? They can be hard to find, especially for those who don't use TSG. I'm thinking that people who don't use TSG have no idea what's happening in those polls, so can only look at GR polls. Or maybe add the links to poll msg #1 instead? (Can non-users see the results on TSG tho?) And the results could also be posted in the poll threads if/when the GR winner isn't the overall winner. (Sorry, I can't help it :P) And vice versa for TSG users to have easy access to GR polls.Also, I want to joke that this is the reason why I resigned as a mod XD It's not, but it's still giving me hives just thinking about this, so I wanted to be the first to publicly say this is not ideal, and it's OK to feel that way :) We'll get used to it!
Mod
Mod
We Are All Ghosts in the Forest - 37 gr + 16 tsg = 53 votes
Space Unicorn Blues - 38 gr + 6 tsg = 44 votes
So the winner is correct on TSG, but not in GR.
March 2025 Camp Fantasy
The Utterly Uninteresting and Unadventurous Tales of Fred, the Vampire Accountant - 43 gr + 16 tsg
Orconomics - 42 gr + 15 tsg
So correct on both sites.
I don’t mean to be sneaky, but does this mean that if I vote on both the GR & TSG polls my vote gets to count twice?Mwah, ha ha ha
😈
Mod
Mod
Lost Ark Dreaming - 33 gr + 14 tsg = 47 votes
Whalefall - 26 gr + 12 tsg = 28 votes
Winner is the same on both sites.
April 2025 Mod Curated Fantasy
To Shape a Dragon's Breath- 37 gr + 13 tsg = 50 votes
The Monsters We Defy - 37 gr + 10 tsg = 47 votes
TSG poll was a tie between TSADB and Her Majesty's Royal Coven.
Mod
Annie Bot - 50 votes (41 gr, 9 tsg)
After the Flood - 43 votes (32 gr, 11 tsg)
TSG winner is the runner up.
May 2025 High Fashion Fantasy
Witch King - 75 votes (59 gr, 16 tsg)
The Shadow of the Gods - 60 votes (49 gr, 11 tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
Mod
You Sexy Thing - 43 votes (31 gr + 12 tsg)
Stars in My Pocket Like Grains of Sand - 32 votes (27 gr + 5 tsg)
TSG poll was a tie between YST and Ambiguity Machines and Other Stories.
June 2025 Mod Curated Fantasy
The Pomegranate Gate - 47 votes (31 gr + 16 tsg)
Two Years Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights - 39 votes (30 gr + 9 tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
Mod
Dead Silence - 56 votes (45 gr + 11 tsg)
Midnight Robber - 39 votes (30 gr + 9 tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
July 2025 Global Inspiration Fantasy
One Hundred Years of Solitude - 62 votes (54 gr + 8 tsg)
The Gray House - 33 votes (24 gr + 9 tsg)
Winner on TSG was The Last Gift of the Master Artist.
Mod
Venomous Lumpsucker - 50 votes (39 gr + 11 tsg)
The History of Bees - 47 votes (38 gr + 9 tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
August 2025 Mod Curated Fantasy
The Teller of Small Fortunes - 62 votes (41 gr + 21 tsg)
Greenteeth - 40 votes (29 gr + 11 tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
Mod
Dungeon Crawler Carl - 65 votes (42gr + 23tsg)
Blood Over Bright Haven - 56 votes (34gr + 22tsg)
Winner is the same on both sites.
September 2025 Sep-Bender Mod Curated SFF
Of Monsters and Mainframes - 62 votes (35gr + 27tsg)
Saga, Volume 1 - 56 votes (39gr + 17tsg)
Winner on GR is the runner up.
SciFi and Fantasy Book Club
Books mentioned in this topic
Blood Over Bright Haven (other topics)Saga, Volume 1 (other topics)
Dungeon Crawler Carl (other topics)
Of Monsters and Mainframes (other topics)
Venomous Lumpsucker (other topics)
More...
We are committed to continuing on two platforms as one united club. This means polls containing the same books will be run on both platforms.
Due to TSG restrictions, the poll will run on GR for a week and the top 4 books in each poll will be added to a poll on Tsg. The polls will close at roughly the same time and results will be tallied. This may mean that "winners" on either platform might not reflect the true winner for our club. We'll try to be transparent with the tallies by posting them in the second post of this thread so that folks can easily prepare.
Feel free to post any queries or comments you have below.