2025 Reading Challenge discussion

213 views
ARCHIVE 2024 > TEAM Caught Read-Handed: I Spy

Comments Showing 51-100 of 281 (281 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Carrie (last edited Jul 30, 2024 09:40AM) (new)

Carrie | 348 comments I could have missed it but I think that we will need to use some of the Family Member prompts to fill Proper Titles on the triples. But that may have been before some books were changed out.


Edited to add: Nevermind, one of the books changed out DID fix that problem. I apologize lol. My excitement over this has me a little too impatient and I need to sit back and let it play out. I know you will let us know what we need still.


message 52: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Mansi V wrote: "I've also changed the other possible fits to a '-' instead of a 'x'. Sorry if it looks messy or confusing now!

Also this is just provisional! If you decide not read a book you've put on the sheet ..."


Thanks for starting the plan, Mansi. I added to it. 😊


message 53: by Mansi V (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments Oh wow perfect thanks!! Sorry I had to leave, so thank you for finishing it!!

Looks like we're really on track!! I'm hoping to read one more book but haven't added it because I'm not sure I'll get round to it but if I do, I'll look for a book that matches the remaining prompts


message 54: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments I´m back from my kayaking trip everyone!

I´ll start with a late but quick introduction:
I´m Alina, based in germany. I joined this group late last year and am mostly enjoying the Twin - Reads as I can finally discuss the books I read with someone. My friends from home and I are not really reading the same books so it´s nice to chat here. I always enjoyed reading - however during uni I had to read so many books that I couldn´t get myself to read any more just for myself. I finished my degree last year and since then I started reading again!
I´m really excited for this readathon and will put my books into our planning sheet just after I am finished with this comment!



Thanks for planning everything! I love our team-name and am impressed how well everything is turning out so far.

I´m off of work until 5th August - that´s why I only signed up for 2 to 3 books as I will have quite alot of work to do when I´m back at my job as my coworkers are going on their summer break then.


message 55: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments So i just put in 4 books - that are on my TBR and what I think which prompts they fill (with some prompts I think they might work but I won´t know until I read the book) - I hope this works. I can still read something else :)


message 56: by Mansi V (last edited Jul 30, 2024 06:21PM) (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments Alina wrote: "So i just put in 4 books - that are on my TBR and what I think which prompts they fill (with some prompts I think they might work but I won´t know until I read the book) - I hope this works. I can ..."

Nice thank you! Hope you enjoyed your trip, nice to meet you! We're at 52 books now so we might even be able to get all the prompts!

I just tidied the sheet, and google seems to suggest the woods are a biome so I added that too but I see you have a question mark next to the last book? I think the prompts only refer to things on the cover and title rather than what's in the book but somebody please correct me if I'm wrong!!

Edit: Goodreads makes me realise just how many explanation marks I use 😳


message 57: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Alina wrote: "So i just put in 4 books - that are on my TBR and what I think which prompts they fill (with some prompts I think they might work but I won´t know until I read the book) - I hope this works. I can ..."

Welcome back! I hope you had a wonderful trip, Alina.

Mansi is correct about how I Spy works. It's only cover art and titles for this one, so it won't matter what's between the covers.

I don't know if you've had time to read back through all our messages, but Lina reminded us that if you've started a book before the start date, then finish the last 100+ pages after midnight in your time zone, you can count it for a prompt. However, only the pages read during the readathon will count for page points.

I'm getting so excited!


message 58: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Alina wrote: "I hope this works. I can still read something else :)"

The Reappearance of Rachel Price by Holly Jackson A Murder of Crows (Nell Ward, #1) by Sarah Yarwood-Lovett

Alina, The Reappearance of Rachel Price doesn't fit the family member prompt since the family member title (mother, aunt, etc.) isn't in the title or cover.

I have two ideas:
1. Count this one for the color blue, then we shuffle others to cover Fruits and Veggies.
2. If you have it ready, you could switch to A Murder of Crows from your TBR (also a little shorter), which would fit Crime, Animal, or Things in the Sky. Then we shuffle others to cover Fruits and Veggies.

What do you think?


message 59: by Alina (last edited Jul 31, 2024 03:42AM) (new)

Alina | 257 comments Ohhh okay I´m sorry - I was only using the mobile version of goodreads during my trip and it was quite hard to read through everything (also I didn´t want to spend too much time on my phone haha)

So I just had another look into our sheet and corrected the prompts as I did put some in that were just in the plot of the book but not in the cover art or title.
i don´t have A Murder of Crows as I handed it to a friend. Also the books on my TBR shelve are mostly my physical books I have at home.

I also had look into my "want-to-buy" shelve and put in some books that fit a few more prompts than the ones I originally put in - I can just download these on my kindle if needed.

Questions though:
1. I put in the book The God of the Woods would that also count as Deities/Gods ? - I put a questionmark behind that prompt.

2. On the cover of The Last Gifts of the Universe there is a rocket - are we counting that one as a vehicle as it transporting people to the moon etc.?

3. Are We counting mushrooms as vegetables? I know they are fungus but I do believe that they count as vegetables for nutrition so I´m not sure about that one (Regrettably, I am About to Cause Trouble

4. Are we counting Husbands as family members? I´d say yes, I just want to make sure. The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

___
I took The Reappearance of Rachel Price off - as it doesn´t really fit the prompts.

Also I now put in way more books than I think that I am able to read - I´ll start pre-reading tonight though


message 60: by Mansi V (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments No worries! I think I might have to do no phones for the readathon aha. In response to your questions...
1) I think God should count, I meant to say before because Norine had Godkiller which I personally think should count under the god prompt, but I didn't say anything in the end because her books fit some other prompts

2) I think Rocket could count as vehicle, but see what others say too

3) Mushrooms definitely count as veg in my eyes!!

4) Husbands count as family members. I have a book with wife in the title I have lined up for that prompt in case I finish the others I read


message 61: by TerryJane, Challenges (last edited Jul 31, 2024 06:46AM) (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments No problem! I wouldn't want to be on my phone if I were in the outdoors either.

To your questions, I answer yes to all of them.

One of my books shows the lunar landing module on the cover. Albeit not a common vehicle, I marked it as such since it transported astronauts to and from the orbiting Apollo spacecraft. 🤷‍♀️

===

EDITED TO ADD: Using this cover would also add buildings, animal, and the color blue. Maybe clothes (spacesuit)?
The Last Gifts of the Universe A Novel by Riley August


message 62: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments TerryJane wrote: "No problem! I wouldn't want to be on my phone if I were in the outdoors either.

To your questions, I answer yes to all of them.

One of my books shows the lunar landing module on the cover. Albeit..."



Great! Thank you both! I started reading Howl’s Moving Castle and am trying to also start Regrettably, I am About to Cause Trouble before the readathon officially starts as it´s one of my books that is fitting the most prompts - I´m just not the biggest fan of reading different books at the same time.

For The different Cover: I´m not sure about how official it is? My version has Rory August as author, in yours it is Riley August. Also the version you showed seems to have a few more pages. If you guys say this fits better we can use that cover I just hope it´s not one of those scam-book versions haha.


message 63: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Alina wrote: "My version has Rory August as author, in yours it is Riley August."

Oops! I didn't catch the name difference. I just saw the blue covers in the editions list here.
https://www.goodreads.com/work/editio...

Perhaps the author transitioned and changed their name. I remember some confusion when I read The Map of Salt and Stars by then Jennifer Joukhadar who later changed his name to Zeyn or Zeynab Joukhadar. Some covers on GR show both the new name and the deadname. 😕

Back to Rory and/or Riley, I clicked some links for Rory that redirected to Riley pages and mentioned a space cat. The profile pictures are similar, as are their bios.
https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/...
https://www.goodreads.com/author/show...

That said, if we can fit the black 2022 Rory cover into the prompts, using the blue 2024 Riley cover won't be unnecessary. 🤷‍♀️


message 64: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments TerryJane wrote: "Alina wrote: "My version has Rory August as author, in yours it is Riley August."

Oops! I didn't catch the name difference. I just saw the blue covers in the editions list here.
https://www.goodre..."



I think you might be right about the author transitioning as in the amazon bio they/them pronouns are used. I just wanted to download the book onto my kindle but it seems the book isn´t on the german market until October first even though it was first published in 2022 - I couldn´t find a single digital or physical copy of it. I took it off the sheet now. I think I have enough other books lined up and if not I´ll have a look what else I could read.

Powerless (The Powerless Trilogy, #1) by Lauren Roberts Powerless
The God of the Woods by Liz Moore The God of the Woods
Howl’s Moving Castle (Howl’s Moving Castle, #1) by Diana Wynne Jones Howl’s Moving Castle
Regrettably, I am About to Cause Trouble by Amie McNee Regrettably, I am About to Cause Trouble
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

So these are the books I do have lined up now and ready to read either as physical edition or on my kindle. I might not be able to read all of them but we will see.


message 65: by Lina (last edited Jul 31, 2024 02:21PM) (new)

Lina | 823 comments So much happened since I last checked this feed. My week has been super crazy at work, but I have the weekend off so am hoping to get a lot of reading done then! :)
I just read through all of the comments - thanks also for looking through our sheet!
Good to have you here as well, Alina. Whereabouts in Germany are you from (only roughly, don't worry, and it's also okay if you don't want to share!).

Also, TerryJane, I find it great that we have people from multiple countries as well. Really looking forward to reading lots of interesting books together with you all and getting to know you a bit better.

Mansi, I definitely seem to be using a lot of exlamation marks on goodreads as well!

I am not yet sure whether I will be able to read all of the books I put into the sheet - but I will definitely try and have started multiple of them already (just as a warning in advance, especially Weyward and When the Moon Hatched might be tight fits... but else I will try to look for shorter replacements).

Very much looking forward to the Readathon! :)


message 66: by Mansi V (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments No worries at all! It's completely fair if you don't manage to get to reading all of the books. Around halfway through the challenge we can check how everyone's doing and adjust any prompts as needed! Glad I'm not the only one with exclamation marks haha!

I'm getting excited too, I'm a night owl so I will be be opening my book bang on midnight!


message 67: by Carrie (new)

Carrie | 348 comments Now that all of the prompts have tentatively been assigned to a book, how do we add new books? Do y'all want possible prompts marked with an x or a - ? I should have asked before I added my last one.


message 68: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Carrie, mark all possible prompts with an X. Mansi and I have been changing unused categories to - as books are assigned, so that we can switch things up if needed.

If we complete all the prompts, we will get a set of bonus prompts, and some of our books could get shuffled to accommodate those.

Lastly, everyone please note that there's a section all the way at the bottom for any books that are DNFed, too short, or don't fit any prompts. We can get page points for those. No graphic novels or comics, though.


message 69: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Alina wrote: "...it seems the book isn´t on the german market"

I have a similar problem with Cornelia Funke books. If only I knew more languages, I wouldn't have to wait for an English translation. *sigh*


message 70: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Random observation. The three books I've started are 400, 400, and 416 pages, but in audio, they run 8:05, 14:10, and 18:30 hours, respectively. I expect some variation due to different font sizes, narrators, etc., but I wouldn't think the difference would be so vast. Strange.

Also, I just downloaded How to Solve Your Own Murder this morning when came off hold. It could fit many prompts if it's needed -- crime, animal, building, parts of a house, things in a garden, weapon, accessory, and more.


message 71: by Lina (new)

Lina | 823 comments @TerryJane - regarding your audio book lengths: maybe one of them is a shortened version? Has happened to me before, for example with long historical fiction...

I am getting really excited! (but I sadly had to take on an additional shift tomorrow so I am working 12 hours and might not have a lot of time on the first day... oh well, will try to do better on Saturday!)

Also, TerryJane - which books from Cornelia Funke have you read? The Inkheart series? (and you are looking for the new one?)


message 72: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Lina wrote: "@TerryJane - regarding your audio book lengths: maybe one of them is a shortened version? Has happened to me before, for example with long historical fiction... "

These books are mystery, historical fiction, and a nonfiction (space program). None are abridged. That's the first thing I checked. 🤷‍♀️ (When reading multiple books, I have to choose different genres and/or timelines so I can keep them straight in my mind.)

I've read three of the Inkworld books and entered a GR giveaway for #4 this morning. 🤞 I've read part of the Reckless and Dragon Rider series, as well as some of her children and YA standalones, such as Thief Lord and When Santa Fell to Earth. 😁

Too bad about the change in your schedule, but it's good for the people who need your help. It looks like the readathon will start for you Europeans in just a few hours. I still have an 11.5-hour wait. ⏱


message 73: by L Y N N (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments Mansi V wrote: "Edit: Goodreads makes me realise just how many explanation marks I use 😳"
Me, too! LOL


message 74: by L Y N N (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments Oh, my! I LOVED The Thief Lord! I have yet to check out any more of her books. What would you-all suggest?


message 75: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments @TerryJane ohhh I love the fact that you know Cornelia Funke as she is a german author. I think Inkheart is one of the first books my uncle gifted to me as a preteen to get me into reading. I listened to the audiobooks a year back and just absolutely love the story. I haven´t read the new book yet but it´s most definitely on my list

I´m not sure about those different audio-lengths but maybe the writing styles of the books just make them "harder" to read? My kindle told me that I would need 22hours to read through The Fellowship of the Ring and I know that for other books that have around 400pages it only says that I need like 6-10 hours.

@Lina I´m from Sachsen-Anhalt (don´t know the english translation for that and too lazy to look it up haha) How about you?

@Lynn I only read Inkheart and the two following books of the series but those are clear recommendations


_____

It´s almost readathon time here in germany so I´m making myself ready to read the first pages until I fall asleep. Happy reading to all of you!


message 76: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments L Y N N wrote: "Oh, my! I LOVED The Thief Lord! I have yet to check out any more of her books. What would you-all suggest?"

I highly recommend the Inkworld trilogy: Inkheart, Inkspell, and Inkdeath. The fourth book is The Color of Revenge, but it won't be published in the US until November.


message 77: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Alina wrote: "@TerryJane ohhh I love the fact that you know Cornelia Funke as she is a german author."

We discovered her when my daughters were young and we listened to When Santa Fell To Earth during a trip. On another trip, my then 11 y/o started the Dragon Rider series and I followed her lead. Ms. Funke does such a terrific job bringing the reader into the worlds she weaves.


message 78: by Lina (new)

Lina | 823 comments I also read the Inkword trilogy when I was really young and loved it! Definitely planning on re-reading it at some point soon!

@Alina: ah, nice! I went there for a week a while back to hike, which was fun! :) We stayed in a castle, which was also very nice! I am originally from Hesse, but now living in Baden-Württemberg.

And I am also counting down minutes till the readathon starts! Will read a bit before going to bed :)


message 79: by Lina (last edited Aug 12, 2024 07:49AM) (new)

Lina | 823 comments I hope this is fine - I don't mean to break up conversation (just ignore this post) - but I always have fun keeping track in a progress post.

👀 Readathon AUGUST: I Spy (Team) 👀
Duration: August 02 - August 11, 2024

👀 Progress: 12/3
👀 - completed!
Pages: 2,519

August 02:
🎧Murtagh (124 pages) - completed
🎧Hello Stranger (20 pages)

August 03:
🎧Hello Stranger (87 pages) - completed
🎧What Moves the Dead (165 pages) - completed
🎧Momo (110 pages) - completed
📖The Secret Garden (25 pages)

August 04:
🎧The Bodyguard (302 pages) - completed
📖The Secret Garden (186 pages) - completed
📖The Burning God (60 pages)

August 05:
📖The Burning God (54 pages) - completed
📖When the Moon Hatched (42 pages)
🎧Small Things Like These (100 pages)
📖Marzahn, mon amour: Geschichten einer Fußpflegerin (78 pages)

August 06:
🎧Small Things Like These (28 pages) - completed
📖Marzahn, mon amour: Geschichten einer Fußpflegerin (65 pages) - completed
🎧Martyr! (21 pages)

August 07:
🎧Martyr! (15 pages)
📖When the Moon Hatched (56 pages)

August 08:
📖When the Moon Hatched (59 pages)
🎧Even Though I Knew the End (63 pages)

August 09:
📖When the Moon Hatched (51 pages)
🎧Even Though I Knew the End (73 pages) - completed
🎧I Hate You More (30 pages)

August 10:
🎧I Hate You More (244 pages) - completed
📖When the Moon Hatched (62 pages)
🎧Death by Hot Apple Cider (304 pages) - completed

August 11:
📖When the Moon Hatched (26 pages)
🎧Iron Widow (67 pages)

Books completed:

Murtagh (The Inheritance Cycle, #5) by Christopher Paolini Hello Stranger by Katherine Center What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1) by T. Kingfisher Momo by Michael Ende The Bodyguard by Katherine Center The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett The Burning God (The Poppy War, #3) by R.F. Kuang Small Things Like These by Claire Keegan Marzahn, mon amour Geschichten einer Fußpflegerin by Katja Oskamp Even Though I Knew the End by C.L. Polk I Hate You More by Alexandra Moody Death by Hot Apple Cider (Bookstore Cafe Mystery #9) by Alex Erickson

👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀


message 80: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Lina wrote: "I hope this is fine - I don't mean to break up conversation (just ignore this post) - but I always have fun keeping track in a progress post."

Absolutely fine, Lina! I made a list for easy access of our Tracking Posts in the third message of our team thread. I've added your link to it.

Happy reading, everybody!


message 81: by Mansi V (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments That's midnight for me!! Trying to multitask with reading whilst catching up on today's gymnastics haha

Have fun everyone 🥳🥳🥳


message 82: by Carrie (last edited Aug 12, 2024 09:49AM) (new)

Carrie | 348 comments Carrie's Tracking Post

**ISpy Readathon**
August 2-10

Books Read
Progress 11/10
One Year Gone by Avery Bishop A Fall of Marigolds by Susan Meissner The Mosquito Bowl A Game of Life and Death in World War II by Buzz Bissinger My Mother's Secret by J.L. Witterick Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate The Midwife of Berlin (Women of War #2) by Anna Stuart The Starfish Sisters by Barbara O'Neal One Italian Summer by Rebecca Serle Rock Paper Scissors by Alice Feeney The Reckoning by John Grisham Hillbilly Elegy A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis by J.D. Vance

[x] 1. One Year Gone: 132/359 (started on pg 227) COMPLETED. (Mixed Ebook/Audio) ⭐⭐⭐

[x] 2. A Fall of Marigolds: 206/370 (started on pg 164) COMPLETED. (Audio) ⭐⭐⭐⭐

[x ] 3. The Mosquito Bowl: A Game of Life and Death in World War II: 480/480 COMPLETED. (Ebook switched to Audio after page 67) ⭐⭐

[x] 4.My Mother's Secret : 196/196 COMPLETED (Ebook) ⭐⭐⭐⭐

[x ] 5. Before We Were Yours: 344/344 COMPLETED (Ebook) ⭐⭐⭐⭐

[x ] 6. The Midwife of Berlin: 404/404 COMPLETED (Ebook)⭐⭐⭐⭐ ◐

[x] 7. The Starfish Sisters: 369/369 COMPLETED (Mixed Audio/Ebook) ⭐⭐ ⭐◐

[x] 8. One Italian Summer: 260/260 COMPLETED (Ebook) ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

[x ] 9. Rock Paper Scissors: 294/294 COMPLETED (Audio) ⭐⭐⭐

[X ] 10. The Reckoning: 417/417 COMPLETED (physical book) ⭐⭐⭐⭐

[X] 11. Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis: 264/264 COMPLETED (Audio) ⭐⭐⭐


Pages Read: 3321 (through 8/11)

AUG 2: 359 pages total pages
-One Year Gone 132 pages
-A Fall Of Marigolds 206 pages
-The Mosquito Bowl 21 pages

Aug 3: 273 total pages
-The Mosquito Bowl 46 pages
-The Starfish Sisters 227 pages

Aug 4: 415 total pages
-My Mother's Secret 196 pages
-The Starfish Sisters 142 pages
-Before We Were Yours 77 pages

Aug 5: 333 total pages
-The Mosquito Bowl 235 pages
-Before We Were Yours 98 pages

Aug 6: 457 total pages
-The Mosquito Bowl 178 pages
-Before We Were Yours 169 pages
-The Midwife of Berlin 110

Aug 7: 328 total pages
-The Midwife of Berlin 294 pages
-Hillbilly Elegy 29 pages
-One Italian Summer 5 pages

Aug 8: 274 total pages
-Hillbilly Elegy 19
-One Italian Summer 255

Aug 9: 151 total pages
-Hillbilly Elegy 108
-The Reckoning 5
-Rock Paper Scissors 38

Aug 10: 329 total pages
-The Reckoning 202
-Rock Paper Scissors 127

Aug 11: 447 total pages
-The Reckoning 210
-Rock Paper Scissors 129
-Hillbilly Elegy 108


message 83: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Carrie wrote: "Carrie's Tracking Post

please link to this message for my tracking however I will not be updating it until I get back to my laptop after the weekend. We are traveling and I didn't not bring it. I ..."


Done! Have a great weekend, and safe travels. By the way, I loved A Fall of Marigolds. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did.


message 84: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments It's finally midnight! Here I go! 🕛😃


message 85: by Norine (new)

Norine | 18 comments terryjane!!!! going so well!!!! i cant read anymore today! im exhausted and my brain stopped functioning haha


message 86: by L Y N N (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments TerryJane wrote: "L Y N N wrote: "Oh, my! I LOVED The Thief Lord! I have yet to check out any more of her books. What would you-all suggest?"

I highly recommend the Inkworld trilogy: [book:Inkheart|28..."


Thanks!


message 87: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Norine wrote: "terryjane!!!! going so well!!!! i cant read anymore today! im exhausted and my brain stopped functioning haha"

Understandable! I haven't been up as long as you, and I still have hours to go before bed time. Go get some rest before your mind explodes. 🤯

Today I am finishing up some books that were in progress before the readathon, so it's not as impressive as it seems. 😉


message 88: by L Y N N (last edited Aug 02, 2024 12:45PM) (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments I ended up reading other things before this morning so I could finish the last 147 pages of What You Are Getting Wrong about Appalachia since I decided I wanted to take my time to properly absorb it. I would highly encourage you to read it, especially if you happened to read Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis. Vance, as with others who have written memoirs about growing up in "Appalachia" can only describe their own individual and unique experiences. But Elizabeth Catte's book provides you with information regarding the exploitation of the region by corporate entities as well as some of the more notorious greedy local politicians and businessmen that ruined the region in so many ways: destroyed infrastructure, virtual enslavement through "coal company" towns/stores, corrupt politicians, etc. She also includes some data regarding the ethnic diversity within the Appalachian region. Necessary information! Glad I waited and read it slowly enough to hopefully remember more of it!

Anyway, I had removed this from the planning sheet, so just marked the DOUBLES Body Part prompt as completed, but feel free to use it for the SINGLE prompt if that fits better!

Should finish Finlay Donovan Is Killing It and either Mrs. Dalloway or The Mysterious Stranger and Other Stories MYSTERIOUS STRANGER & OTHER ST tomorrow.

Happy reading, Read-Handed teammates!


message 89: by Billie-Jade (new)

Billie-Jade | 54 comments I have read Malibu rising today so I have added to the tracking under the predetermined prompt.


message 90: by Lina (last edited Aug 02, 2024 04:05PM) (new)

Lina | 823 comments I noticed that the Grand Total calculation in our sheet is off (the formula has the M row in it, not the L one...). I have now changed it so that it calculates the points correctly. I hope that was okay! (I mean the Grand Total on the bottom of the sheet)

Hopefully you all had fun today :)


message 91: by TerryJane, Challenges (last edited Aug 02, 2024 04:19PM) (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Lina wrote: "I noticed that the Grand Total calculation in our sheet is off (the formula has the M row in it, not the L one...). I have now changed it so that it calculates the points correctly. I hope that was..."

Hmm... I would think Column O would be the correct one since it totals the prompt points and page points.

EDITED TO ADD: Also, LYNN's prompt and/or page points haven't been added to the Tracking tab yet. That might be throwing things off. (I don't know what the formula was originally.)


message 92: by Lina (last edited Aug 02, 2024 04:44PM) (new)

Lina | 823 comments Well the original formula was: =SUMME(M127:M128)+M125
- which wouldn't make any sense because it would mean we end up with just the prompt points (as M127 and M 128 are always gonna be empty).
If we change it to =SUMME(L127:L128)+M125, which I have done, it adds the page points for the first and second part of the Readathon and then adds the prompt points - which means it would be checking whether all of the points have been correctly put into the other column (proof checking the O column).

There is just a different score until everyone has added the finished books (e.g., right now my score in the one Grand total is higher, because I have read 20 points of a book that I havent finished yet, so the 20 are being added to the Grand Total score at the bottom, but not to the other one.


message 93: by Mansi V (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments Wow congrats everyone you're all doing amazing!!

I'm going to a last minute family gathering over the weekend so probably won't be reading as much but will catch up during the week!

Lynn those books sound so interesting, they're definitely being added to my list. I don't know much about Appalachia but saw a show about soul food in Appalachia recently and it made me want to learn more


message 94: by Mansi V (last edited Aug 02, 2024 05:04PM) (new)

Mansi V | 236 comments Lina wrote: "Well the original formula was: =SUMME(M127:M128)+M125
- which wouldn't make any sense because it would mean we end up with just the prompt points (as M127 and M 128 are always gonna be empty).
If..."


Ahhhh ok I've got it! Thanks for doing that. I've also noticed the prompt points total isn't being calculated because I don't think it considers the '50' which is automatically entered through the 'yes' formula as a number if that makes sense? So I've changed the 2 50 prompts we've received so far to an actual number and now it counts them. If we need to re-jiggle any prompts later, I'll make sure to check the prompts total is still working

EDIT:on second thoughts, I've changed it back to the original formula because it might get confusing if we re-assign prompts later so it might be better to calculate the prompts total at the end


message 95: by TerryJane, Challenges (new)

TerryJane | 4026 comments Glad you folks are on the spreadsheet case! I fiddled with the Completed tab today to make the rows align correctly for the copy paste, but have not figured out how to make the grayed out formatting copy over. I'm just fixing that manually.

I just finished the last of my pre-started books, and have two hours left to read for August 2.


message 96: by L Y N N (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments @TerryJane
I’ll add my finished book and page total to the tracking sheet before going to bed. Just got home from the gym and fed the feline herd and the human husband! LOL


message 97: by L Y N N (last edited Aug 02, 2024 09:17PM) (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments Mansi V wrote: "Lynn those books sound so interesting, they're definitely being added to my list. I don't know much about Appalachia but saw a show about soul food in Appalachia recently and it made me want to learn more"
The first book about Appalachia I read was Jeannette Walls' The Glass Castle and it was amazing! I see that on Goodreads almost 1,241,000 members have rated it! That's amazing! The book club I facilitate read it 15 years ago and we all loved it, though her childhood was the antithesis of "ideal"! 😒 I can definitely recommend it as a memoir.

But I would read Catte's books before venturing into Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis, if you're interested in reading it. Honestly, now that I know even more about Vance, I'm wondering just how much of this may be true or made up...

And now I have a listing of books from Catte's book I would like to read. *sigh* 😉


message 98: by L Y N N (new)

L Y N N (book_music_lvr) | 2389 comments I'm confused. (Nothing new there!! LOL)

I've never seen a tracking sheet setup with "page points" in a column along with the books completed. I assume the number we list there is the number of pages in that specific book? Does that mean we don't get credit for pages read beyond that for the day? (I am leaving that blank for now!) But we have a double prompt completed!! YAY!!

Maybe I just need to leave this and go to bed. It's pretty obvious I'm tired! 🥱 Talk with you-all tomorrow!


message 99: by Alina (new)

Alina | 257 comments Whoa great progress everyone!

I haven´t been able to read much yesterday because my cat got sick and I had to go the vet with him. He´s better now though and I´m already catching up on my reading!

Yesterday morning I finished The Fellowship of the Ring - I only had a few pages left and wanted to be done before reading something new. I put it in the completeted tab to "DNF, no promt or <100p. I hope that was right.

I also have started Howl’s Moving Castle so far I like the writing style. The plot feels kind of random so far.



Thanks to everyone who´s making that spreadsheet work - I was never good with these formula sheets haha.

Happy second day of reading!


message 100: by Lina (last edited Aug 03, 2024 03:39AM) (new)

Lina | 823 comments Mansi V wrote: "Lina wrote: "Well the original formula was: =SUMME(M127:M128)+M125
- which wouldn't make any sense because it would mean we end up with just the prompt points (as M127 and M 128 are always gonna b..."


Yeah that formula isnt working - its not seeing it as numbers - so it is putting in a 50 or 100 or 150 in the M column, but not adding it to the M125 field (so also not the the lower grand total, that uses M125)... I have tried and it also isnt working for the doubles and triples, not just the singles; it is adding them to the O row though (so the grand total on the right works for prompt points)

Edit: I have now fixed the M125 field (even though the formula looks kind of ugly ...), the original one was: =SUMME(M18:M94), and the sum just didnt work as it somehow doesnt recognize the M column formula as real numbers; so I have now used the workaround from column O and just changed it to a + formula instead ... it is fine now :)


back to top