Fantasy Buddy Reads discussion

Inheritor (Foreigner, #3)
This topic is about Inheritor
22 views
Archive [Retired Buddy Reads] > Inheritor (Foreigner #3)[June 12, 2024]

Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Yanique, Thread Master (new)

Yanique Gillana | 2840 comments Mod
This is a Buddy Read for Inheritor by C.J. Cherryh starting on June 12, 2024.
Inheritor (Foreigner, #3) by C.J. Cherryh

Happy Reading


message 2: by Nirkatze (last edited Jun 26, 2024 01:58AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nirkatze | 20930 comments Thank you!

Foreigner is a huge ongoing series, but is largely sorted into three book arcs. I figure we can request trilogy by trilogy, and adjust as necessary. If we go straight through, here's a schedule:

Arc 1:
1. Foreigner (Apr 12) [Link]
2. Invader (May 12) [Link]
3. Inheritor (Jun 12)

Arc 2:
4. Precursor (Jul 12) [link]
5. Defender (Aug 12) [link]
6. Explorer (Sep 12) [link]

7. Destroyer (Oct 12)
8. Pretender (Nov 12)
9. Deliverer (Dec 12)

4th Trilogy, 2025
10. Conspirator (Jan 12)
11. Deceiver (Feb 12)
12. Betrayer (Mar 12)

13. Intruder (Apr 12)
14. Protector (May 12)
15. Peacemaker (Jun 12)

16. Tracker (Jul 12)
17. Visitor (Aug 12)
18. Convergence (Sep 12)

19. Emergence (Nov 12)
20. Resurgence (Dec 12)
21. Divergence (Jan 12 2026)

22. Defiance (Feb 12 2026)
Probably have a book or two more by this time.

Audio: 1-19 are on Audible as Audible Only. Apparently the audiobook contract fell apart so the last few have yet to be converted, and the audio is in limbo.

Ebooks: no library/subscription copies available. Check your Libby!

Open Library has a lot of books in this series on ebook (but not all). It also has volunteer-made audiobooks.

https://openlibrary.org/authors/OL264...


message 3: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
I'm committed to this series, after how much I loved book 2... bought audiobooks for the next 10 months of BRs on the Audible sitewide sale that just dropped...

Most books are $3.49 or $4.19, with a few randome exceptions that are more expensive (that, and how many books I was buying led me to stop there, and see if the more expensive later books might be cheaper in November's Black Friday sale)...

Also, starting now, a bit early...


Tammie | 5948 comments Timelord Iain wrote: "I'm committed to this series, after how much I loved book 2... bought audiobooks for the next 10 months of BRs on the Audible sitewide sale that just dropped...

Most books are $3.49 or $4.19, with..."


Thanks for telling us about this. I'm going to buy them.


message 5: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
Been devouring this book last night and this morning...

Sometimes I struggle to make sense of the mental gymnastics going on with the Atevi factions, on audio, even when it's all being explained to Bren by Ilsidi/Jago/etc, but I love it anyway, and things are coming to a head now at the 85-90% mark... in very interesting ways...

I read blurbs for these first 3 books, and some overviews of the trilogies of the series, but I don't know which characters are short-term vs long-term, except for a few key ones like (view spoiler)


message 6: by Nirkatze (last edited Jun 18, 2024 08:26PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nirkatze | 20930 comments The characters I remember being long-term are (view spoiler)


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Zoomed through this today... these really are comfort reads, almost... also totally did not remember anything about this one...

Chapter 2 (view spoiler)

Chapter 3 (view spoiler)

Chapter 5 (view spoiler)


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Chapter 11 (view spoiler)

Chapter 14 (view spoiler)


Barry (boprawira) | 1212 comments Finished.

This series is fast becoming one of my favorites. Very well-written, and well-developed Atevi society. Although the climax is a bit too short in this book. Anyway some thoughts:

Jago (view spoiler)

Bren (view spoiler)

Hanks (view spoiler)

Jase (view spoiler)

Ilisidi (view spoiler)

Really looking forward to the next book!


message 10: by Anny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anny | 248 comments Barry wrote: "Finished.

This series is fast becoming one of my favorites. Very well-written, and well-developed Atevi society. Although the climax is a bit too short in this book. Anyway some thoughts:

Jago ..."


Saw the discussion, do you mind if I join the conversation now and then?

Re: Family (view spoiler)

Ilisidi (view spoiler)


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Welcome Anny! I have to say I agree on family--(view spoiler)

re: Ilsidi--love her! And her grandma-voice in narration is great... (view spoiler)

re: Climax--(view spoiler)

re: Reveal--(view spoiler)


Nirkatze | 20930 comments I take it that everyone is interested in continuing! Does keeping the 12th and going onwards at 1/month work for everyone? If so, I'll put in requests for the next trilogy.


message 13: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
I bought through book 12, and expect to buy the rest on a future sale... I'm in for the long haul...


Tammie | 5948 comments I'm continuing. I bought all the available audio books but two.


Tammie | 5948 comments Nirkatze wrote: "Zoomed through this today... these really are comfort reads, almost... also totally did not remember anything about this one...

Chapter 2..."


Chapter 2- I'm glad that is explained. I had noticed that about him on the covers too.

The chapter 3 thing about Algiri had me giggling.

Your chapter 5 spoiler- Good point. Bren has grown so much since then.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments I love the sneaky humor in these books!

I'll go ahead and request the next set of books then, per schedule above.


message 17: by Tammie (last edited Jun 25, 2024 07:37AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tammie | 5948 comments Nirkatze wrote: "Chapter 11

I agree with you about this. I really liked how the author explains these things about Jake. I probably wouldn't have thought about some of this if she hadn't brought it up. Jake has at times annoyed me with his attitude, but I can also understand him because of this.

Chapter 14..."


I agree! (view spoiler)


Tammie | 5948 comments Up to chapter 21. (view spoiler)


Nirkatze | 20930 comments re: Translators--seriously!! Why aren't there more? I wonder if it has to do with aptitude, or interest? Most Mospherans seem to be pretty self-centered... or cultural centered... but I find it hard to believe that like, basic Atevi isn't a requirement from elementary school... at least the children's language...

re: Chapter 21--lol... (view spoiler)


message 20: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
You'd think they'd divert any mathy kids into a Translator program... there have to be more than 1-2 in a generation, right?...


message 21: by Tammie (last edited Jun 24, 2024 03:13PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tammie | 5948 comments Nirkatze wrote: "re: Chapter 21--lol..."

LOL that's funny!


message 22: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
Something about that spoiler comment (not sure I read it before), makes me think of First Law world, and Joe Abercrombie's gritty sex scenes... sex scenes, not lovemaking :D


Tammie | 5948 comments Finished! I enjoyed this one. I especially am interested in (view spoiler). I also liked the way it ended (view spoiler).


message 24: by Anny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anny | 248 comments Nirkatze wrote: "re: Translators--seriously!! Why aren't there more? I wonder if it has to do with aptitude, or interest? Most Mospherans seem to be pretty self-centered... or cultural centered... but I find it har..."

I believed it had to do with the war. The war was said to be caused by miscommunication due to humans contacting various Atevi or different Atevi contacting different humans? Frustratingly , the war itself was never really explicitly explained to us.

In any case, the solution to this miscommunication problem was the ruling that at any one time there will be one and only one Paidhi that will serve as the translator between human and Atevi. It was to prevent possible misunderstanding where one translator said A when another translator said B. That was enough to cause war with Atevi apparently.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Anny has a good point... but maybe it's time for that law to be revisited... I wonder how long humans had cohabited with the Atevi before the war broke out? You'd think they'd realize that humans can't be evaluated on the same criterion as Atevi after enough time... but I suppose if Atevi as a whole perceived humans as a whole as a threat... it's not as simple as someone getting in trouble for being impolite...


message 26: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments I have the audio up to 21... I am in for the long haul:)))

Through Ch. 5 ... (view spoiler)


message 27: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments About the translators. I read it as Anny said, it is part of the treaty to have only one. I can kind of see the point of the miscommunication. Look what happened when Hanks got to the Mainland. She had her agenda and I am thinking, the politics are rife for a rebellion, but if such actually starts, I think her actions are the catalyst. Translators in this case are not just translators, but diplomats more than anything. This is why, if there are going to be more than one, they have to have a strict code of ethics and a strong understanding that they have to speak with one voice, sticking to the same strategy. So they should be thought not only language, but everything that goes with kind of being a secretary of state... History, diplomacy, economics, psychology, sociology and so on... Otherwise they can become pawns in anyone's game...

And Nirkadze, a great point about having to learn at least the Children's Atevi language, maybe teach it in school from first grade on...


Nirkatze | 20930 comments It seems like the main issue there isn't necessarily translation though, but policy... individual low-level man'chi Atevi aren't going to be making decisions that could cause inter-species conflicts... maybe if there was more interactions, there'd be less mis-understandings... If all Atevi had met humans, they'd be less likely to see them as the monsters in the closet. But restrict access to higher level political peoples...

LOL I love how we're trying to solve planetary problems in books!


message 29: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments Hahaha! We are, and we can't solve our problems here ...

This was awesome! I am completely in love with this series! Once again, feel so lucky to be reading several excellent Sci-fi series this year! It has been such a treat!
As you guys were saying (view spoiler)

Great series!!!


Nirkatze | 20930 comments LOL Ilsidi is awesome!!! And I agree on labelling Jace as "teachable"--good word for him. As for (view spoiler)


message 31: by Anny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anny | 248 comments Nirkatze wrote: "Anny has a good point... but maybe it's time for that law to be revisited... I wonder how long humans had cohabited with the Atevi before the war broke out? You'd think they'd realize that humans c..."

I think the history said that at first humans and Atevi got along swimmingly well and some form of relationship started to form between them. Then inevitably some human would have done something that offend the Atevi and then war happened.

I mean cultural difference was something that was hard to explain, simply because usually everyone know what to do and what not to do. Like in certain culture in my country, if you don't provide certain items to guests, you're considered insulting them. Even outsider who lived there were expected to honor this norm.

In other example, if you're invited to dinner and you praised the hosts food instead of his family, he would ostracize you because he assumed that you insulted his family. This despite the guest coming from different culture. I guess people had this unreasonable expectation that what they considered polite to be something that every reasonable people should know regardless where they come from.

Another example, if a guest arrived at your house and suddenly spit on the floor, would you be horrified? You might decide that this person was barbaric and rude. But in other culture (notably mainland China a few decades ago), this behavior was considered normal and people there wouldn't bat an eye at this.

But in Atevi case I supposed the problem was made worse because in some ways, Atevi was society that put high value on honor and pride and face. An Atevi might chose to go to war with humans not because humans were perceived to be a threat but because they cannot let themselves being embarrassed or slighted since that would cause them to lose face/standing in Atevi society.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Top post has been updated with links to the next arc's BRs!


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Thank you for sharing all the cool cultural connections, Anny!

I'm really curious if the war was an cultural insult misunderstanding, or if the Atevi thought that the humans were dangerous due to something they did... I think it's said that they still don't know or understand what it was that set the Atevi off...


Barry (boprawira) | 1212 comments Also, it seems like Mospheirans are really so casual about the Atevi. Like, there's no curiosity at all. I'd imagine if they're stuck with the Atevi as their next door neighbors forever, more people would be more interested in learning about the Atevi, including its language. And they would have more ... positive view of the Atevi in general. I don't know if there has been deliberate attempt by the more conservative faction in Mospheira to influence the education curriculum and to depict the Atevi as the enemy.

Although, I do agree that the policy of limiting contact to just a single paidhi is probably a good idea. Considering Mospheirans got Hanks in their midst ... And judging from Bren's experience, relationship with the various power brokers in Atevi is fraught with ... the risk of deadly consequences due to slight misunderstanding.

***************

I'll be continuing with the series. At least the next trilogy. I'll probably finish it, but there are still a lot of books until the end. So I can't really make that promise right now hahaha.


message 35: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments Anny, great examples! Thanks for sharing!

Barry, reading fiction it sure makes no sense to us that the humans wouldn't be more curious and learn about the Atevi culture and language. However, look at Americans. How many, unless they are forced to by proximity or jobs, are interested in learning more Spanish or French? Just because of the neighbors, let alone other, more distant languages. Yes, we have scholars and very few intellectually curious folks, but the majority believe that everyone should learn English and be grateful that we are interested enough in them to chat, but not bother with cultural differences, because everyone should live the way we do, right?! On paper, in a fictional series, we see so clearly how important it is to understand the other culture's point of view, but we don't even bother in real life... It's very sad...


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Good point about Americans... I was thinking about along Barry's lines when reading Anny's analysis--as a teacher of a World Language, I find lack of curiosity to be almost criminal. One of the most frustrating tropes I find in SFF is when people of one culture blame people of another culture for not knowing all the nuances of the culture they are just visiting. I think I remember this happening a lot in Wheel of Time--with the Aiel especially. Like, why do they not get that cultures are different and take that understanding with them before they judge or make decisions? Why don't they make active effort to find out more? But it took characters almost 12 books to get to that point... and like Choko says, many people around the world don't ever consider it....


message 37: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments What is even worse is when people learn about culture specific differences and use them as a bludgeon, against them, without trying to understand the reasoning behind them first and then judge....


message 38: by Anny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anny | 248 comments I suppose the problem with learning Atevi language was the level of difficulty. Let's not forget how Bren said to speak proper Atevi you have to do simultaneous calculation in your head for every word you speak. Even Bren who was professionally trained used to get headaches trying to work all the math all the time. That would be a pretty huge barrier for normal people. I think this point actually was trivialized in the book, since we read the English version and of course there were none of these supposed complications that were actually supposed to be there.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments I do remember some of the math aspects popping up regularly--things like felicitous odd numbers and 8 being a particularly nasty number... details like that showing up.

I read The Sparrow a few weeks ago, and one thing the aliens in that society do is raise a child dedicated to learning the language of any new culture they come into contact with. I also grew up in an immersion program--so I can't help but think if they started young enough, they could raise a generation of people who were fluent in Atevi... but for that to happen, they'd really need cooperation of native Atevi teachers.


message 40: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
Nirkatze wrote: "I do remember some of the math aspects popping up regularly--things like felicitous odd numbers and 8 being a particularly nasty number... details like that showing up.

I read [book:The Sparrow|33..."


Did this come out before or after Discworld started?... with it's hate of the number 8 / Octarune?


message 41: by Anny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anny | 248 comments Nirkatze wrote: "I do remember some of the math aspects popping up regularly--things like felicitous odd numbers and 8 being a particularly nasty number... details like that showing up.

I read [book:The Sparrow|33..."


For some reason all math lovers seemed to especially love prime numbers. Eight was terribly infelicitous because it was dividable into two and four (which further was dividable into two twos). Ten was marginally better because it was only dividable into two and five. Thirteen being prime number seemed to be very felicitous :)

Not sure if this was mentioned already, but Mospheiran government did not want a person fluent in speaking Atevi. They want someone who will take note of what was said, pass said note to the relevant department that will parse them and crafted appropriate response and pass them back to the translator who will pass it to the Atevi in writing. This was what Bren's predecessor did, he never spoke a single word to the previous Aijin or any other Atevi. Speaking directly to the Atevi was a breach of conduct and the government was terribly unhappy with Bren because he was overstepping his role.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments I don't remember that aspect, so I'm not sure if it's been pointed out already or not, it's easy to forget or overlook things on audio--but that is a really cool point, about Bren breaking norms even before crap hit the fan...


Tonari no Emily (emlfem) | 5115 comments I'd hate to think what they thought of #12 lol

Love all the discussion here! I'm about halfway through now and it's weird how much we live in Bren's head, but still get so much info about the world and the well three cultures now... Would like to know more of what Jace's culture is like back on the ship.. Very structured as Bren conjectured..
Also Ilsidi is my all time favorite. Love me a badass grandma!


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Badass grandmas are the best! I feel like we made a list in some other BR that featured one... trying to think of more now and coming up blank...


message 45: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timelord Iain | 35229 comments Mod
Ilona Andrews is all about badass grandmas...

Kate Daniels: (view spoiler)
Hidden Legacy: Grandma Frida
Innkeeper Chronicles: Caldenia (kinda)

Ilona Andrews is also all about monster dogs...


message 46: by Choko (new) - added it

Choko (chokog) | 12597 comments Grandma Mazur, I think of the Sea Witch as such, the different grandma witches in WI, and a ton of others... They are always the best!


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Yes!! Luideag!!


Barry (boprawira) | 1212 comments Ilisidi reminds me of Olenna Tyrell and Avasarala.


Nirkatze | 20930 comments Two more awesome grandmas. The best!!


Tammie | 5948 comments She reminded me a bit of Avasarala too.


« previous 1
back to top