The Selection (The Selection, #1) The Selection discussion


420 views
Last one to post wins!

Comments Showing 951-1,000 of 1,925 (1925 new)    post a comment »

message 951: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Right?! It was the one thing in the guidebook that I was just immediately like YES. I AM DOING THAT ONE 100%. 😂🧜🏻‍♀️ haha. And manga 💕💕 what mangas have you read? Fruits Basket is an absolute favorite of mine.


message 952: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly I think it's a fantastic goal!!! 😁
Let's see, I read Maid Sama, Kamisama Hajimemashita, a few arcs of Black Butler, the first bit of the original Yu-Gi-Oh manga, My Hero Academia: Vigilantes, and Pandora Hearts to an extent. I bought Cactus's Secret but I haven't gotten around to it yet. 😅 Oh my goodness I remember watching the older Fruits Basket anime they did! There's a new one out now, but I remember the first one ends on a heartbreaking note and I was scared it might get more sad in the manga! 😂 It was sooo good though! 😍


message 953: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Hahaha yessss, I have the original anime on dvd from way back when, I used to watch it on a portable dvd player when we went places. 😂 The original anime didn't end on a cliffhanger or anything, but it ended very unfinished so that sucked for anime only watchers. But you need to absoutely watch the new adaptation or read the mangas because it is the best, most well resolved and satisfying ending ever. Some mangas rush them etc, but it makes me so happy.


message 954: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Oh thank goodness!!! It totally broke my heart when the original anime adaptation was over and I was scared to trust the series again 😂 I'll have to give it another go! 😁 What other manga have you enjoyed?


message 955: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Omg Fruits Basket season 2 started today and I cant wait to watch the new episode!!! Moving forward it will be the first time any of it will be animated and I can't wait to watch it on screen!! 😍😍😍 And My Little Monster, Noragami, and Ouran High School Host Club are also great. I could give you even more anime recommendations lol.


message 956: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly I'm so glad they made a new Fruits Basket, like, it totally deserved to be continued! 💕 I never read the manga for Ouran High School Host club or Noragami, but I did watch the anime for both. I loved them soooo much 😍😍😍 I'm not familiar with My Little Monster, I'll have to try it out sometime! Manga or anime?


message 957: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Both, but the anime doesn't go until the end of the manga. It doesn't cliffhanger or anything but I specifically got the manga after watching the anime because I needed to see if the characters got together haha. And I LOOOOVE Noragami, I'm still waiting on a new season! 😂 Attack on Titan must be my favorite anime though.


message 958: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Okay, thanks! 😁 Ugh, I know! I want a new season of Noragami so badly I'd fund it myself if I had the cash 😂 I never really got into the Attack on Titan itself I'm afraid, but that first opening is probably my favorite opening of all time. It's just so epic 😎


message 959: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Aw bummer haha 😆 Attack on Titan is just SO intense and emotional fueled and I love that. And YES the intros are amazing haha.

OMG Callie haha I know it's so hard right?!? I was too indecisive to be able to choose one! The only thing I chose so far was the additional Merpeople Linguistics training which I'm SO excited about and immediately knew was for me! I love that option and it offers an immediate placement offer after completion too! I'm going to see what I end up reading and maybe choose a career based on that later on, or not lol


message 960: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I can give you some suggestions!
Heartless,
Fangirl,
The Hearts We Sold,
Shiver,
Foolish Hearts,
Heart of Iron,
The Upside of Unrequited,
The Twelve Days of Dash and Lily.


message 961: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yay, glad I could help!!
Lol correction though:
Dash and Lily's Book of Dares**** (this is book 1, both books have hearts though lol)

Also:
Anna & the French Kiss,
Alex and Eliza,
Queen of Hearts,
Finale 💜💜
How the Grinch Stole Christmas! Grow Your Heart Edition loll

Let me know what book you end up doing for that one!


message 962: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Also Dash and Lily isn't too long of a book lol! And hahaha I love Christmas, it's the best extending it 😆 Hopefully the wait times are actually shorter than the estimate too! You should waitlist a bunch in case 🤗


message 963: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Callie, I totally ended up going with the Librarian one too! 😂 There were so many choices I had to tell myself I can go for another one next year if I want 😂
Dude, I need to read Finale, but I've been on the waitlist for it since I began reading Legendary. And I still haven't gotten it. 😝
I think you can read Christmas books in April if you want! It's an odd year, we might as well break out the Christmas stuff! 😁


message 964: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I hope you get Finale soon!!

And Librarian is a good choice! Not too many exam requirements, only 5. NEWTS requirements are harder though lol. There are three grades for the NEWTS:
Outstanding - 3 books
Exceeds Expectations - 2 books
& Acceptable - 1 book
So 7 books total to complete your Librarian career when NEWTS come around.

So far I've done Charms and Astronomy and none of the careers have both of those except for Alchemist which just has ALL of the exams lolol and I want to do something easier so I'm still undecided. Feeling really good now that I've gotten 2 of the exams down though! :)

And I keep watching the Hogwarts Library master list of all of the OWLS taken so far and it just keeps getting added to every few minutes, it's crazy, I love it lol. 4.3 million+ pages read so far!


message 965: by Yulia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Yulia Neal whats going on here?


message 966: by Hasi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hasi Ponnathota You must be new here! I joined to win the challenge but realized that some people have been keeping up with this post for years. Everyone just has friendly conversations now! :) Welcome!


message 967: by Yulia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Yulia Neal Hasi wrote: "You must be new here! I joined to win the challenge but realized that some people have been keeping up with this post for years. Everyone just has friendly conversations now! :) Welcome!"

Ok, i see now. Thanks! i'm still kinda new to goodreads, up until a week ago i didn't even realize that you can do anything here besides review books!


message 968: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I used to rarely use goodreads except to check book descriptions, and now I use it all the time. 😂 I think its really fun when you find friends to follow! It's fun to check on what they're reading and have read so far this year. And you can set reading challenges for the year so I like seeing how many books my friends have read so far for theirs!


message 969: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Lol I should update the OWLs library masterlist thing... I have yet to do that! 😅
Hello Yulia! Lol I always thought Goodreads was only for keeping track of books you read, so I was surprised to find so much other stuff on here too 😂


message 970: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick It's over 7 million pages read now!! 😱 It's super quick to add to, too!


message 971: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Got them added! I'm afraid this month has not been my strongest reading month so there isn't much to added to the total, lol 😆 If there are this many pages being read for OWLs, can you imagine how many pages will be read for NEWTs? 😳


message 972: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I know lol!! 😳😳😳 it's gonna be crazy! I just try to actually picture the number of pages for the OWLS and 🤯😂😂 and the newts will be even more lol! And I've only read 2 mangas so far so 🤷🏻‍♀️ I'm sticking to quicker reads so I might do some comics next.


message 973: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Lol right?? It's going to be insane looking at the NEWTs one! Even more insane than OWLs... 😮😁Dude, I don't blame you! Would the first volume of Fruits Basket count for Transfiguration? Because that was what I was planning for that class. 😂


message 974: by Blue (new) - added it

Blue Muffin Does this thing go on till infinity???


message 975: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yep!

Omg Holly I missed your reply! Yes Fruits Basket will totally count!! 😍💖 Did you read it yet? I need to get back to reading a bit more, the month is almost up!


message 976: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Lol yeah, this thing shall continue until Goodreads stops working I feel
Gahhh Fruits Basket is totally bringing back memories! I have only the last chapter of the first one to go, and then I'll make that first one off! 😍 I totally missed this series... I am so going to finally finish it! 😁


message 977: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I should reread it too!! I totally considered when you mentioned it too. I reread it now and then, and the later half of the series is just sooooo good I love it so much. I'm a few episodes behind on the show, 3 or 4 episodes from the newest season and I cant wait to be able to binge them all together haha.


message 978: by Janis (new) - rated it 5 stars

Janis Ender Hi again


message 979: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Hello!
You totally should! Now I'm ultra excited to get to the second half of it... 😁😍 Yeah, I'm totally waiting to be able to binge watch it lol


message 980: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Lol I reread it last night hahaha, using it for my Transfiguration too! I always love how volume 1 ends. I need to try and read everyday now because I didn't the last 2 weeks and fell behind on my OWLS lol. And I'll probably watch the episodes of FB that are out before the season ends, but it'll be nice because no matter when I decide to catch up now, I have a bunch to watch. <3


message 981: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Then we both now have Trasfiguration complete! 😁 It was so good!!! 😍😍😍 Did you ever decide what to go for in OWLs? So much FB to watch... I think I'm going to finish the manga before I start watching the new series, actually. That way I don't get confused about what's happening 😂


message 982: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yeah I guess jumping back and forth in the series can be confusing haha, being at the beginning in the mangas, but the middle on the show. 😂 And no hahha, I haven't even looked at the OWLS stuff in 2 weeks, so I only have 3 completed. It's not necessary to choose a career though. But I DID want to do the Merpeople Linguistics tho so I need read a book for that! I might just reread my "Mermania" book since it starts with M and is super appropriate for it haha and is short. I need to quick find all short reads 😂 how many owls have you done?


message 983: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick And wait have you watched any of the new Fruits Basket adaptation at all then? I just havent started season 2 yet, which I'm so excited to do! 🤗


message 984: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Oh shoot, what's required for the Merpeople Linguistics? I can't get the file open on my phone for some reason. And I totally forgot I wanted to do it...I hope you find some short ones to do!!! Let's see, I've done 4 so far. I am finishing the 5th now 😁
I saw the first episode when it first came out and then couldn't find the time to watch the next episode when it came out. 😅 It was pretty busy at the time, so for now, I haven't seen much!


message 985: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick It just has to start with the letter M!
Oh wow so you really don't know much about the story at all then haha!! Wow you have so much to look forward to, it gets SO amazing!!


message 986: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick P.S. That's the Herbology OWL btw (book starting with M) 🙂


message 987: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Oh sweet! Thank you! 😁
Is the new adaptation different than the original one? I watched all of that and cried buckets when it ended lol! I couldn't get my hands on the manga so that first adaptation was all I had 💕


message 988: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick I have all the original mangas!! And I'm so thankful lol although the collectors editions out now are BEAUTIFUL and I want them too 😂😍❤❤ And the original one was also pretty accurate, but they changed a few things/the order of a few things. I remember people being annoyed with what they changed at the end with Kyo's true form reveal but u cant remember if it was how they unfolded it/changed the order or what. This new adaptation is more spot on with the books although theyve changed a few small things too. They're both pretty good. I haven't rewatched the original show in a while to say exactly though, but the original had SUCH amazing comedic energy, I feel like it's a little toned down in the new one but I still love it. Same story, same voices for the most part. 🤗🤗


message 989: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Ok I pulled Mermania off my shelf to reread again for the Herbology Owl/to satisfy the Merpeople Linguistics course lol. Very appropriate book choice right. 😂 And it's a reallly quick read!


message 990: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly I just looked up the collectors editions and I absolutely love them! They are SO pretty!!!! 😍😍 Oooh, now I can't wait to be able to compare what's changed! I haven't had the chance to continue the series yet, but I plan to make my goal for May only manga other than audiobooks, of course) so hopefully then I'll be able to gve myself the time to read it all! 😁🤞 Oh yay! Yes, I'd say it's a fantastic choice for the Met people Linguistics class! 😄 You know, I forgot to add that book to my next bookhaul list. I have to remember to add it. It just looks so cute!


message 991: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Wait, on the laptop version of goodreads I think you can still reread a book witbout removing it from your shelf, can't you? I feel like I've done that before, but maybe I dreamt it... 😅


message 992: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yep, you just go to the book's page on Goodreads and hit that tab underneath the book's image, and change the status to Currently Reading. Same as on the app. And it just adds another "read date" to that book for you. You never have to remove and re-add it. That would be silly since people are always rereading books haha.

And ooo "m"angas for "M"ay! An M theme! And I think I decided I'm going to continue trying to complete the OWLS for now, even though the month is technically ending, I'm going to keep the prompts up on my wall until I finish it for me.


message 993: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Lol okay, that's what I thought. I got confused, sorry! I totally thought you meant you pulled Mermania off your goodreads shelf to reread and I was like, "I didn't think you had to remove it from the shelf to do a reread..." 😂😂
Yep! I figure it's fitting! 😁 Hey, whatever works for you! I think that's actually a good idea. I mean, it's meant to be for fun anyway, so I say it's a great idea to extend it a bit. 👍


message 994: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Ohhh haha no I meant my bookshelf. 😆 And I mean, once April is over you can't add your books read to the OWLS list anymore, so your pages read won't contribute to this year's OWLS page count. But I can still finish the OWLS on my own time just for my own satisfaction and decide if I want any of the careers later on. It's kind of a cheat haha, but also just for my own satisfaction of finishing it eventually. :) I can't wait to see what the page count officially ends at though, it was 14 million and something pages a little earlier, I wonder if we'll hit 15 million before it closes tonight.


message 995: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyssa Now I win :)


message 996: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Good luck, Marie!
Yeah, I mean I don't see anything wrong with bending the rules a bit for your own personal challenge. I mean, it's not like it can hurt anyone and the point of a reading challenge is to challenge you to read more/keep reading so I'd say it's succeeding on that front!
It looks like we did it!!! We hit 15 million!!!


message 997: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yeah, exactly. :) It's just to motivate yourself to read, and since I've had no motivation it's nice to leave it up to try to motivate me to do it! :) and yessss!!! I was so excited we hit 15 million! 😄 that's such a satisfying number


message 998: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly Exactly! And if it works, then hey, more power to ya! 😁📖 I bet the person who created the challenge is super excited and happy! It's quite an accomplishment!
Hey... So random question, do you still have the friend code thing for BookOutlet? I totally didn't make an account before and just remembered you had a code... 😅


message 999: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick Yes absolutely!!!! Let me grab the link again! ❤


message 1000: by Taylor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taylor Emerick https://bookoutlet.com/Loyalty/Referr...

Here you!! It'll give you $10 off $25. 🤗 And you can get sooo many books with that, and it'll only cost $15.🤗 yay free books!!!


back to top