Hugo & Nebula Awards: Best Novels discussion
Contemporary H/N Talk (Archives)
>
(2021) Post *YOUR* Hugo 2021 nomination lists
date
newest »

message 51:
by
Ed
(new)
Mar 07, 2021 08:28AM

reply
|
flag

And for NEXT year's award, "Hanging with Doctor Z" https://hangingwithdoctorz.com/episode/

...because the spreadsheet is woefully short on the dramatic categories. Presumably only the fantasy/scifi/horror shows would be eligible? There are a bunch here that I hadn't even heard of that look really interesting!
Not on this list - "Future Man"! It is weird and goofy and amazing. I love it. Its appeal is probably very limited, but I'm in that group and I think the third season is worth nominating. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wgNI...
Also, I edited my previous post since I learned that "Steven Universe" and "The Good Place" are not eligible for this year.

Best Novel
The Relentless Moon; Mary Robinette Kowal
Uranus; Ben Bova
Dead Lies Dreaming; Charles Stross
Imaginary Numbers; Seanan McGuire
Starborn and Godsons; Larry Niven
Best Novella
Squishy's Teams and Maelstrom; Kristine Kathryn Rusch
The Physicians of Vilnoc; Lois McMaster Bujold
Masquerade in Lodi; Lois McMaster Bujold
Semper Augustus; Nancy Kress
Take a Look at the Five and Ten; Connie Willis
Best Novelette
Conversations in the Dark; Robert Reed
You and Whose Army; Greg Egan
Two Truths and a Lie; Sarah Pinsker
Hacksilver; Elizabeth Bear
The Monk of Lingyin Temple; ThXia Jia
Best Short Story
The State Machine; Yudhanjaya Wijeratne
A Princess of Nigh-Space; Tim Pratt
A Considerations of Trees; Beth Cato
Fourth Nail; Mur Lafferty
Cooling Chaos; Gregory Benford
Best Series
Grand Tour Series; Ben Bova; Uranus
Diving Universe; Kristine Kathryn Rusch; Squishy's Teams and Maelstrom
Lady Astronaut; Lady Astronaut by Mary Robinette Kowal,; The Relentless Moon
Shannara: The Fall of Shannara; Terry Brooks; The Last Druid
Star Carrier; Ian Douglas; Stargods
Best Dramatic Presentation, Long Form
The Vast of Night
Tenet
Greenland
2067
Save Yourselves
Best Editor, Short Form
John Joseph Adams
Shelia Williams
Neil Clarke
Jonathan Strahan
Trevor Quachri
Best Editor, Long Form
Shelia E. Gilbert
Best Professional Artist
Ivor Kovac; https://www.deviantart.com/ivor-kovac
Best Semiprozine
Escape Pod
Strange Horizons
Uncanny Magazine
Beneath Ceaseless Skies
Astounding Award for the Best New Writer, sponsored by Dell Magazines (not a Hugo)
Micaiah Johnson; The Space Between Worlds
WorldconReader wrote: "Sorry about the formatting..."
A very interesting list, and welcome to the group!
A very interesting list, and welcome to the group!
Kristenelle wrote: "I found this list of 2020 tv shows https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/...
...because the spreadsheet is woefully short on the dramatic categories. Presumably only the fantasy/scifi/horror shows would be eligible? There are a bunch here that I hadn't even heard of that look really interesting!"
Yeah, nothing that isn't SFF is eligible. It's quite a comprehensive list but I've seen almost all the eligible shows (I watch a lot of TV) except Dr. Who and Star Trek, since I've never gotten into those series.
2020 SFF shows I saw but wouldn't nominate:
The 100 S7
Into the Night S1
Omniscient S1
Utopia S1
Raised by Wolves Season 1 (but yes to the pilot episode for the short-form category, it was great)
Westworld S3
Supernatural S15
3% S4
The Mandalorian S2
I still think Lovecraft Country, Dark S3, Altered Carbon S2 are the top SFF tv for me this past year.
His Dark Materials S1 was so bad I didn't even give S2 a chance.
Otherwise I haven't seen: Umbrella Academy S2, The Boys, Tales from the Loop, The Plot Against America, Upload, What we Do in the Shadows.
I've just started watching Devs.
...because the spreadsheet is woefully short on the dramatic categories. Presumably only the fantasy/scifi/horror shows would be eligible? There are a bunch here that I hadn't even heard of that look really interesting!"
Yeah, nothing that isn't SFF is eligible. It's quite a comprehensive list but I've seen almost all the eligible shows (I watch a lot of TV) except Dr. Who and Star Trek, since I've never gotten into those series.
2020 SFF shows I saw but wouldn't nominate:
The 100 S7
Into the Night S1
Omniscient S1
Utopia S1
Raised by Wolves Season 1 (but yes to the pilot episode for the short-form category, it was great)
Westworld S3
Supernatural S15
3% S4
The Mandalorian S2
I still think Lovecraft Country, Dark S3, Altered Carbon S2 are the top SFF tv for me this past year.
His Dark Materials S1 was so bad I didn't even give S2 a chance.
Otherwise I haven't seen: Umbrella Academy S2, The Boys, Tales from the Loop, The Plot Against America, Upload, What we Do in the Shadows.
I've just started watching Devs.
message 61:
by
Kateblue, 2nd star to the right and straight on til morning
(last edited Mar 13, 2021 10:57AM)
(new)
-I quit watching Dev's after about 4-5 episodes. I didn't like anybody and I didn't care.
-Umbrella started out great, but I think they blew it by messing with the characters before we really got to know them.
-The Boys was great tho' dark. I was ready for it to be resolved, though, and therefore tired of it, but I will vote for it.
-I thought What we do in the Shadows was stupid, but I never like situation comedies, so you can't go by me.
-Upload, we watched a couple and then we forgot to watch it anymore, so it was not that immersive, obviously. At least for us.
-I really want to see Lovecraft Country, but I am not paying.
-Altered Carbon was too confusing, and I didn't even get through season 1. I do not plan to return, even though I watched more of it than I wanted to because it looked like it SHOULD be so good.
-I have never heard of Dark, Into the Night, Omniscient, Utopia, or Raised by Wolves (pilot only). Where are they streaming, please?
-Umbrella started out great, but I think they blew it by messing with the characters before we really got to know them.
-The Boys was great tho' dark. I was ready for it to be resolved, though, and therefore tired of it, but I will vote for it.
-I thought What we do in the Shadows was stupid, but I never like situation comedies, so you can't go by me.
-Upload, we watched a couple and then we forgot to watch it anymore, so it was not that immersive, obviously. At least for us.
-I really want to see Lovecraft Country, but I am not paying.
-Altered Carbon was too confusing, and I didn't even get through season 1. I do not plan to return, even though I watched more of it than I wanted to because it looked like it SHOULD be so good.
-I have never heard of Dark, Into the Night, Omniscient, Utopia, or Raised by Wolves (pilot only). Where are they streaming, please?
Dark, into the night, and omniscient are all foreign language Netflix originals.
Dark is an extremely meticulous time travel show about a small German town that experiences an apocalypse. It is going to go down in history as an absolute classic of the time travel genre, and is probably the best SF show Netflix has produced. It's very complicated and confusing though, with lots of interconnected characters, plotlines, and mysteries. Some of the best casting I've ever seen, with characters portrayed amazingly at different points in their lives. Season 3 was its finale.
Omniscient is a pretty standard surveillance dystopia out of Brazil, but not with a depressing tone.
Into the Night is a French series about an apocalypse where everyone caught in sunlight dies, and follows a group of air travellers on a red eye plane as they fly circles around the globe trying to stay alive.
Utopia is on Amazon, is a really dark and ultraviolent comic book-y plague/conspiracy thriller. It wasn't great and got cancelled after its first season.
Raised by Wolves is on HBO Max and is a postapocalyptic survival story where two androids arrive on an exoplanet with several human embryos to start a new human civilization after the earth's destruction. Created by Ridley Scott (aliens) it starts out super strong but runs into some frustrating pacing problems and stale tropes.
Dark is an extremely meticulous time travel show about a small German town that experiences an apocalypse. It is going to go down in history as an absolute classic of the time travel genre, and is probably the best SF show Netflix has produced. It's very complicated and confusing though, with lots of interconnected characters, plotlines, and mysteries. Some of the best casting I've ever seen, with characters portrayed amazingly at different points in their lives. Season 3 was its finale.
Omniscient is a pretty standard surveillance dystopia out of Brazil, but not with a depressing tone.
Into the Night is a French series about an apocalypse where everyone caught in sunlight dies, and follows a group of air travellers on a red eye plane as they fly circles around the globe trying to stay alive.
Utopia is on Amazon, is a really dark and ultraviolent comic book-y plague/conspiracy thriller. It wasn't great and got cancelled after its first season.
Raised by Wolves is on HBO Max and is a postapocalyptic survival story where two androids arrive on an exoplanet with several human embryos to start a new human civilization after the earth's destruction. Created by Ridley Scott (aliens) it starts out super strong but runs into some frustrating pacing problems and stale tropes.

message 64:
by
Kateblue, 2nd star to the right and straight on til morning
(last edited Mar 13, 2021 12:22PM)
(new)
I will look for Dark and Into the Night and try them. I have been avoiding foreign language dubbed and subtitled in English because . . . often the English subtitles don't match the dubbed English words. it gives me a headache, watching mouths move and watching subtitles and listening to English when nothing matches. (I have tinnitus, which mostly I ignore, but sometimes I need help.)
When I don't get a headache, I often like the foreign ones. Home for Christmas (not SF or F) was great.
When I don't get a headache, I often like the foreign ones. Home for Christmas (not SF or F) was great.

Ed wrote: "Wow, "Into the Night" sounds like something where I would simply not be able to suspend my disbelief! Same for Snowpiercer."
Yeah, Snowpiercer didn't work for me much either (as a film). I never even gave the show a chance since I heard they turned it into a police procedural.
Kateblue wrote: "I have been avoiding foreign language dubbed and subtitled in English because . . . often the English subtitles don't match the dubbed English ..."
Pick one! You're not supposed to listen to dubbing and read subtitles simultaneously! If I am understanding you correctly. But subtitles never match audio, dubbed or original, because there isn't enough space/time for full capture, so as a rule dialogue gets condensed.
Yeah, Snowpiercer didn't work for me much either (as a film). I never even gave the show a chance since I heard they turned it into a police procedural.
Kateblue wrote: "I have been avoiding foreign language dubbed and subtitled in English because . . . often the English subtitles don't match the dubbed English ..."
Pick one! You're not supposed to listen to dubbing and read subtitles simultaneously! If I am understanding you correctly. But subtitles never match audio, dubbed or original, because there isn't enough space/time for full capture, so as a rule dialogue gets condensed.
message 68:
by
Kateblue, 2nd star to the right and straight on til morning
(last edited Mar 13, 2021 11:24PM)
(new)
ACtually, I did do one that way that was in French. I don't know if it was the show's fault or mine. It was Netflix, I think, and it was about a pair of siblings who had a company that produced something that let you read the mind of your lover. I was SO confused, even after I changed the language to English. So confusing show, maybe. And I used to study French, but I could not understand it at all
Maybe I will try again.
Maybe I will try again.

Gabi wrote: "Just to make no mistake (still trying to figure out how the categories all work) - so I can nominate a whole series in the category long-form? It doesn't have to be a movie? And in short form I nom..."
From what I see from nominees in 2020, 2019 and 2018 yes, separate eps in shorts and seasons in long
From what I see from nominees in 2020, 2019 and 2018 yes, separate eps in shorts and seasons in long

A very interesting list, and welcome to the group!"
Thank you very much!
(I just finished watching Star Trek Picard, and loved it... I need to do some ballot updating... :-)
I've updated my ballot on the DisCon site, so this is pretty much final for me. Nominations due by Friday night.
NOVEL
Harrow the Ninth
Network Effect
The Ministry for the Future
+ two books I want to read so want them to be nominated:
The Doors of Eden
The Space Between Worlds
NOVELLA
NOVELETTE
Burn or The Episodic Life of Sam Wells as a Super by A.T. Greenblatt
SHORT STORY
Badass Moms in the Zombie Apocalypse by Rae Carson
The Translator, at Low Tide by Vajra Chandrasekera
Callme and Mink by Brenda Cooper
SERIES
The Murderbot Diaries
The Stormlight Archive
Little Brother
DRAMATIC PRESENTATION: LONG FORM
Lovecraft Country
Dark Season 3
Wolfwalkers
Altered Carbon Season 2
The Vast of Night
DRAMATIC PRESENTATION: SHORT FORM
The Expanse 5x04: Gaugamela
The Good Place 4x13: Whenever You're Ready
Lovecraft Country 1x01: Sundown
Lovecraft Country 1x07: I Am.
Lovecracy Country 1x09: Rewind 1921
BEST FANCAST
The Coode Street Podcast
Feminist Frequency Radio
The Worldshapers
BEST VIDEO GAME
Hades
Kentucky Route Zero Act V
The Last of Us Part 2
ASTOUNDING
Micaiah Johnson
Simon Jimenez
Emily Tesh
Lindsay Ellis
NOVEL
Harrow the Ninth
Network Effect
The Ministry for the Future
+ two books I want to read so want them to be nominated:
The Doors of Eden
The Space Between Worlds
NOVELLA
NOVELETTE
Burn or The Episodic Life of Sam Wells as a Super by A.T. Greenblatt
SHORT STORY
Badass Moms in the Zombie Apocalypse by Rae Carson
The Translator, at Low Tide by Vajra Chandrasekera
Callme and Mink by Brenda Cooper
SERIES
The Murderbot Diaries
The Stormlight Archive
Little Brother
DRAMATIC PRESENTATION: LONG FORM
Lovecraft Country
Dark Season 3
Wolfwalkers
Altered Carbon Season 2
The Vast of Night
DRAMATIC PRESENTATION: SHORT FORM
The Expanse 5x04: Gaugamela
The Good Place 4x13: Whenever You're Ready
Lovecraft Country 1x01: Sundown
Lovecraft Country 1x07: I Am.
Lovecracy Country 1x09: Rewind 1921
BEST FANCAST
The Coode Street Podcast
Feminist Frequency Radio
The Worldshapers
BEST VIDEO GAME
Hades
Kentucky Route Zero Act V
The Last of Us Part 2
ASTOUNDING
Micaiah Johnson
Simon Jimenez
Emily Tesh
Lindsay Ellis

Gabi wrote: "I just submitted my final ballot (with a lot of white spaces ... next year I have to pay more attention to the non-novel/novella/short story categories). Now I'm excited to see how the short list w..."
Congrats! You may share the list if you wish (it ought to appear in your registered email)
Congrats! You may share the list if you wish (it ought to appear in your registered email)

Here it is:
Since I saw that "Stormlight Archive" isn't eligible this year I left out the series nomination. And next year I have to pay a lot more attention to the semipro zines and artists.
Best Novel
The Doors of Eden; Adrian Tchaikovsky
The Book of Koli; M. R. Carey
The Vanished Birds; Simon Jimenez
Piranesi; Susanna Clarke
Or What You Will; Jo Walton
Best Novella
The Stone Weta; Octavia Cade
Firewalkers; Adrian Tchaikovsky
Sweet Harmony; Claire North
Dawnshard; Brandon Sanderson
Best Short Story
The Bone Stalk Walks; K. T. Bryski
The Ransom of Miss Caroline Connelly; Alix E. Harrow
Real Animals; Em North
The Girlfriend's Guide to Gods; Maria Dahvana Headley
Best Related Work
Beowulf: A New Translation; Maria Dahvana Headley
Best Dramatic Presentation, Long Form
Star Trek Discovery, season 3
Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form
Forget me not; Star Trek Discovery 3x04
Su'Kal; Star Trek Discovery 3x11
Best Professional Artist
Rovina Cai; The Book of Dragons
Lodestar Award for Best Young Adult Book (not a Hugo)
A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking; T. Kingfisher
Astounding Award for the Best New Writer, sponsored by Dell Magazines (not a Hugo)
Simon Jimenez; The Vanished Birds
Nomination stats: http://file770.com/total-number-of-20...
smaller number of nominees actually means a greater chance of our underdogs like Adrian Tchaikovsky ending up in the short list
smaller number of nominees actually means a greater chance of our underdogs like Adrian Tchaikovsky ending up in the short list
Gabi wrote: "After I've seen the nomination list of the Nebula I have little hope ^^'."
Hope dies last
Hope dies last
Books mentioned in this topic
The Ministry for the Future (other topics)Network Effect (other topics)
The Doors of Eden (other topics)
Harrow the Ninth (other topics)
The Space Between Worlds (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Adrian Tchaikovsky (other topics)Nghi Vo (other topics)
Simon Jimenez (other topics)
Jason Sanford (other topics)
Lavie Tidhar (other topics)
More...