Star Wars Legends Fan Group discussion

27 views
Updates & Introductions > Group Related Comments, Questions or Suggestions

Comments Showing 1-50 of 55 (55 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (last edited Dec 26, 2020 12:22PM) (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
If you have a suggestion for me and my fellow mod Zuzana, please post it here.
Tell us What You Think!

In order to make this group work for you, let us know what you are thinking! What is working for you? What should we change? A feature, reading challenge or event you would like to see? Any other suggestions? We want to hear it!

We appreciate your help!


message 2: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Thanks for posting


message 3: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Jan 19, 2021 01:56PM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Hi, I've put together a reading challenge as promised. Check it out. :) What do you think?

Star Wars Yearly Reading Challenge

Duration: One year from your start date.

Rules:
‣ Choose your level & category, choose your books/comic books and get to reading!
‣ You can use every book/comic book only once (i.e. for one task)
‣ When you've finished a book or a comic book rate and date it
‣ You may count any books over 100 pages and any comic book over 70 pages
‣ Legends and/or New Canon books are allowed depending on the category you've chosen
‣ Re-reads are allowed
‣ You can change your level and category at any time

Levels:
Jedi Initiate = 5-7 books
Jedi Padawan = 8-10 books
Jedi Knight = 11-13 books
Jedi Master = 14-16 books
Chosen One = 32 books (every task twice)

Categories:
Legendary Hero - Legends books & Comic books only
Rising Star - New Canon only
Maverick - Both Legends and New Canon

Tasks:
1. Read a SW stand-alone book.
2. Read a SW book that's part of a series.
3. Read a SW short story anthology.
4. Read a SW comic book collection.
5. Read a novelization of a SW movie.
6. Read a graphic novelization of a SW movie.
7. Read a middle-grade or a young adult SW book.
8. Read a book set anytime before The Phantom Menace.
9. Read a book set during the prequel movies era.
10. Read a book set in the interim between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope.
11. Read a book set during the Original Trilogy.
12. Read a book set after Return of the Jedi.
13. Read a book with a male main character other than Luke, Han, Obi-Wan and Anakin/Vader.
14. Read a book with a female main character other than Leia (and Rey).
15. Read a book with Luke, Han, Obi-Wan, Anakin/Vader or Leia (or Rey) as the main character
16. Read a non-fiction book on the history of SW, its pop culture significance or making of the movies or a biography/memoir of a member of SW cast or crew.


message 4: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 23, 2020 06:28AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
I think that you can make a new section - Reading challenges. Put this one there. And you can add one or two new challenges later on. One for comic book readers and one mini-challenge for people who don't like to commit for a year but still want to try something fun.
Any thoughts?


message 5: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments I was thinking of seeing about coming up with a readathon for March and April leading up to Thrawn: Greater Good. I'll work on the prompts for that and we can work it in as a mini challenge.


message 6: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Great idea, Rebecca.


message 7: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Potential rules and prompts for a Star Wars read-a-thon.
Rules:
1. Read at least 1 Star Wars book.
2. It can be from Legends or Disney continuity.
3. Books may count for more than 1 prompt.

Prompts:
1. Strength: however you define strength or a strong character pick a book with a character you deem strong.
2. Tear jerker: Pick a book that makes you cry or focuses on a tragic character.
3. Aliit: The Mando'a word for family, Pick a book that focuses on how the events of the Star Wars universe impacts a family, or a found family dynamic.
4. Relaxing: Pick an old friend to reread, or if you are new here pick a book that just sounds like a fun time.
5. Werda: The Mando'a word for shadows and stealth, pick a book that focuses on the cloak and dagger, espionage, or covert operationd side of Star Wars.
6. Artistically done: Pick a book about the making of Star Wars, the cultural impact of Star Wars, or a Star Wars book you'd deem a classic even if it wasn't part of the franchise.
7. Redemption: Pick a book that has redemption as a key theme.
8. Strategically or Tactically minded: Pick a book that actually pays attention to sound strategies and tactics in either the political or military arenas.


message 8: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 24, 2020 12:02AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Very creative! Love it, Rebecca.
I see you're using Mando'a words as prompts.
The Mandalorian by Adam Christopher is coming out in November. It could be a great opportunity to roll out this Read-a-thon in September as a preparation for the new Mandalorian book. What do you think?

The Mandalorian (Star Wars) by Adam Christopher


message 9: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments That would work to!


message 10: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Hopefully they kept the language the same as it was in the Republic Commandos game and books.


message 11: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 24, 2020 04:53AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
There can be more than one Read-a-thon a year. Why don't have one for March & April with Chiss related prompts?

I haven't read anything Thrawn related yet. So somebody more knowledgeable has to step in. ;)


message 12: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Will do.


message 13: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Rebecca wrote: "Hopefully they kept the language the same as it was in the Republic Commandos game and books."

Even if they change it, it doesn't matter - The Legends universe still exists (and will always exist). In my head-cannon EU and Disney continuity are just two alternate realities coexisting peacefuly beside each other.


message 14: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Rebecca wrote: "Will do."
That's fantastic. Thanks.


message 15: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Very true Vode. Star Wars is a multi-verse.


message 16: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments For the Thrawn one we don't have examples of the language beyond names and a few phrases that weren't always translated. So I'm thinking either another acrostic that spells Admiral Thrawn or having it be based on the Chiss Family ranks or Chiss Political hierarchy.


message 17: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Both sounds interesting. Or we could just do a Timothy Zahn oriented mini-challenge. He sure wrote enough SW books.


message 18: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments I'll come up with a few sets of prompts and we can go from there.


message 19: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Thrawn read-a-thon
There a three sets of prompts. you may mix and match, complete a set, or do all the prompts.
Rules:
1. Read at least one book that has Thrawn as a main character or antagonist.
2. Books from Legends and Disney continuity count.
3. Books may count towards more than one prompt.

1st Set of Prompts: Admiral Thrawn acrostic.

1. Artistically done: Pick an Art of Star Wars book, Star Wars Propaganda, or a book on the art of war in Star Wars.
2. Desperate times call for desperate measures: Wether it's the hero and villain teaming up or a villain is an honorable man on the wrong side of history, read a book where characters find themselves unlikely allies.
3. Moriarty: Pick a Thrawn novel where at least one villain is the Moriarty to his Sherlock.
4. Intellect: Pick a book that shows off Thrawn's quick thinking, adaptability, and sound logic.
5. Reckless: Pick a book where characters see Thrawn as reckless because they just don't understand him or how he thinks.
6. Alienation: Pick a book that explores how alienated Thrawn can be from others wether amongst the Chiss or in the Empire.
7. Loyalty and Leadership: Pick a book that explores what makes an officer a good commanding officer and one men and women are loyal to.
8. Treason: Read a book that shows Thrawn dancing on the edge of Treason and what makes Treason Treason Treason.
9. Hero or Villain: Read a book that makes you question who the heroes and villains are.
10. Rebels: Pick s book set during 20BBY to The Battle of Endor that features Thrawn as either a main character or side character.
11. Ascendancy: Read any novel set in the Unknown Regions that explores the Chiss.
12. Warrior: Read Thrawn to explore his ideas on the way of the warrior.
13. New Republic Era: Read a book from the original Thrawn Trilogy: Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, The Last Command.

The second set of prompts are inspired by the Chiss Family Ranks. These prompts are listed from highest rank to lowest rank.

1. Blood: Read at least one book from the original Thrawn trilogy: Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, The Last Command.
2. Cousin: Read any other book or short stories by Zahn that focuses on Thrawn.
3. Ranking Distant: Read a book that focuses on the Chiss and or Thrawn that is not written by Zahn. This can include the middle grade series Clone Wars Secret Missions, The Dark Nest Trilogy, The Heir to the Empire Guide book, etc.
4. Trial-Born: Read Outbound Flight and then Thrawn Ascendancy: Chaos Rising.
5. Merit Adoptive: Read a nonfiction work or literary work Zahn said inspired how he wrote Thrawn. Historical figures he drew on were Erwin Rommel and Alexander the Great. I will also accept books by or about Admiral Yi Sun-sin. Even though he was not mentioned by Zahn as an inspiration for Thrawn, the two are uncannily similar in many ways. The main literary influence was Sherlock Holmes, so either a Sherlock Holmes mystery or a nonfiction book about Sherlock Holmes would also count.


message 20: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Make that 2 sets. I typed that there were 3 sets.


message 21: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
I love your suggestions. I don’t understand the vast complexity of Chiss culture. I might try running a few challenges later. With it being Xmas Eve, I’m super busy wrapping presents. Got to go!


message 22: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
How about a challenge where you have to read a book or books with the Senate or political reasons are important? Or a Leia with a lightsaber book challenge?


message 23: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Rebecca wrote: "I was thinking of seeing about coming up with a readathon for March and April leading up to Thrawn: Greater Good. I'll work on the prompts for that and we can work it in as a mini challenge."

i have only read a few new canon Thrawn books because my library doesn’t have them and I don’t have the cash to spend.


message 24: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments I buy most of mine used at thrift stores and used book stores like 2nd and Charles.


message 25: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Also, Merry Christmas everyone!


message 26: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Merry Xmas to u 2, Rebecca.


message 27: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Merry Christmas!


message 28: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 25, 2020 03:51AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Rebecca, great job on the Chiss prompts. I especially love the second set. What a great idea with the books that inspired Zahn.


message 29: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Feb 05, 2021 01:18AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Akindle wrote: "How about a challenge where you have to read a book or books with the Senate or political reasons are important? Or a Leia with a lightsaber book challenge?"

You see?! Challenges are fun. And I think that you need some group activities to grow the group. Especially with so small community you need something other than discussions (which are limited by small number of members) to attract new people - e.g. Book of the month (i.e. group read), buddy reads and challenges.

There is only a small number of active Star Wars reading GR groups ( that's a plus for you) - what made me hesitate before I joined was that you have no listed group reads - they appear in the groups search (on the main page) - something that catches your eye - an immediate sign that the group is at least semi active.

If you're interested I'd like to join as a co-mod.


message 30: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments A kindle, does your library have Libby or Hoopla? They may have a wider selection of audiobooks and digital copies available on those apps.


message 31: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Interlibrary loan takes longer but is also a good way to get books.


message 32: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Rebecca wrote: "Interlibrary loan takes longer but is also a good way to get books."

I will try that when i have time, thanks.


message 33: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Zuzana wrote: "Akindle wrote: "How about a challenge where you have to read a book or books with the Senate or political reasons are important? Or a Leia with a lightsaber book challenge?"

You see?! Challenges a..."


I noticed that this was the only Legends centric group. I would love to have you as co-mod. I’m adding you now. I can create a secret group for us two mods.


message 34: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 25, 2020 03:02PM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Thanks, Akindle. You can add me. I'm looking forward to the collaboration. :)

Mod chat thread would be great.


message 35: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
I just added you and am trying 2 get the private group made.


message 36: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
I'm PMing you with the private group link.


message 37: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Fantastic. :) I've been preparing some features already.


message 38: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Zuzana wrote: "Akindle wrote: "How about a challenge where you have to read a book or books with the Senate or political reasons are important? Or a Leia with a lightsaber book challenge?"

You see?! Challenges a..."


I only have the one group read up and it is self paced to let busy people have enough time.


message 39: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Akindle wrote: "I'm PMing you with the private group link."

It doesn't work. It wants me to ask permission to join. And when I do it says: Sorry, that group is secret.


message 40: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
I have 2 chall. up as I've forgotten about 1 and added another one today.


message 41: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 26, 2020 08:04AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Akindle wrote: "I only have the one group read up and it is self paced to let busy people have enough time."

The thing is the group read doesn't close when the month is over. It is open for further discussion.

But there is an option - a new group read for - faster readers and people who weren't interested in the previous book.


message 42: by Allyssa, Former Moderator/Group Founder (new)

Allyssa Smith | 791 comments Mod
Thanks for helping. Should we move this chat over to the private group. I think I sent u a link in the PM.


message 43: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments So, in the Around the Workd in 80 books group I'm part of on Goodreads we do a world lit Bingo challenge. Maybe we could have people suggest prompts and then make a bingo challenge of those prompts. Then readers go for as many bingo rows or blackout as they have time for. It could also be a way to incorporate a prompt like read a book where Leia uses a lightsaber.


message 44: by Cooper (new)

Cooper | 62 comments That would be cool. It would be a fun little extra thing to keep in mind while reading Star Wars books, and there would be a lot of fun and different options for prompts.


message 45: by Cooper (new)

Cooper | 62 comments Rebecca wrote: "I was thinking of seeing about coming up with a readathon for March and April leading up to Thrawn: Greater Good. I'll work on the prompts for that and we can work it in as a mini challenge."



That would be really cool! I love Thrawn as a character but have just read the Thrawn trilogy and the canon novel Thrawn. I need to catch upon the canon novels before Thrawn: Greater Good, and would read just about any Legends book with him in it.


message 46: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Dec 27, 2020 03:14AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Rebecca wrote: "So, in the Around the Workd in 80 books group I'm part of on Goodreads we do a world lit Bingo challenge. Maybe we could have people suggest prompts and then make a bingo challenge of those prompts..."

Something like this?


Prompts will be up for discussion.


message 47: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments yes! Something like that!


message 48: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
We'll need 24 propts or preferably more so we can choose the best.

If you have any prompt ideas for a fun SW BINGO post them here:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

We'll pick 24 best ones during January and post the BINGO as a February Monthly Challenge


message 49: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca | 958 comments Zuzana, for the prompt in the Chiss reading challenge for read a nonfiction book about a military figure or Sherlock feel free to make it about Sherlock or any military figure rather than specific ones like I currently have listed.


message 50: by Zuzana, Jedi Apprentice (last edited Feb 04, 2021 04:16AM) (new)

Zuzana | 1640 comments Mod
Yeah, Rebecca, I thought about that. I'll need to make minor adjustments to some of the prompts to make them more inclusive. I'll get back to you about it before I post the challenge.

e.g. 4. Trial-Born: Read Outbound Flight and then Thrawn Ascendancy: Chaos Rising. - seems a bit restrictive especially when prompt #2 is Read any other book or short stories by Zahn that focuses on Thrawn.

I might change # 4 to Read any non Star Wars book by Timothy Zahn.


« previous 1
back to top