Clean YA Book Club discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
25 views
Monthly Group Nominations > CLOSED - January 2021 BOTM Nominations

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ann T, Adult Moderator (new)

Ann T (anntolman) | 454 comments Mod
Lets get those nominations started. Looking for 5 nominations. So looking forward to a new year.


message 2: by sumayyah (last edited Dec 02, 2020 02:41PM) (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) I'm hoping to start the new year with a banger so I choose The Thief by Megan Whalen Turner!

I've been dying to start this, and what better time than in the new year? Hoping for the best!

Content: According to a reviewer it is suitable for most ages but it is easier to comprehend around 14+ / No romance in book one at least


Elisabeth aka Elsie(Taylor's version) | 132 comments I was planning to read Matched, by Ally Condie..


message 4: by Ella (new)

Ella Ferris (eferris) Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen


message 5: by alvie (new)

alvie Matched would be a great one


message 6: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) ~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Something by Simone St. James."

I took a look, and I think her books look very interesting. Can you pick a specific one, because I'd love to read The Broken Girls or The Haunting of Maddy Clare


message 7: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) Elisabeth wrote: "I was planning to read Matched, by Ally Condie.."

This would be good for me too!


message 8: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) Ella Ferris wrote: "Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen"

And this, I've been meaning to read it.


message 9: by ~☆~Autumn (new)

~☆~Autumn sumayyah wrote: "~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Something by Simone St. James."

I took a look, and I think her books look very interesting. Can you pick a specific one, because I'd love to read [book:The Bro..."


Both of those are good but I remembered there are some bad words so maybe they don't belong on this list after all! P&P is way better than Matched which is awful. So sorry!


message 10: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) ~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "sumayyah wrote: "~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Something by Simone St. James."

I took a look, and I think her books look very interesting. Can you pick a specific one, because I'd love to r..."


I don't mind some bad words though, as long as they aren't overtaking the dialogue. And can I ask what "P&P" is?


message 11: by ~☆~Autumn (new)

~☆~Autumn Pride and Prejudice. Pride and Prejudice which is a classic everyone should read.


Elisabeth aka Elsie(Taylor's version) | 132 comments Pride and Prejudice is a good one too.


message 13: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) ~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Pride and Prejudice. Pride and Prejudice which is a classic everyone should read."

Oh, I get it. I just didn't know you abbreviated it lol


message 14: by Ann T, Adult Moderator (new)

Ann T (anntolman) | 454 comments Mod
I would like to nominate one too. With that, we have our nominations. That was quick. The moderators will be reviewing the books nominated to ensure they follow our clean guidelines. @Clarabelle and @Allyson, please start your reviews on:

The Thief by Megan Whalen Turner
Matched by Ally Condie
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
The Broken Girls or The Haunting of Maddy Clare both by Simone St. James
Guardians of the Garden by Theresa Pocock

Thanks all. Happy reading for December.


message 15: by ClaraBelle (new)

ClaraBelle (elsiecorriedale) | 68 comments Ann T wrote: "I would like to nominate one too. With that, we have our nominations. That was quick. The moderators will be reviewing the books nominated to ensure they follow our clean guidelines. @Clarabelle an..."

Thanks Ann, will do!


message 16: by Allyson, Group Moderator (new)

Allyson Jamison | 629 comments Mod
I recently read Matched and thought the first half was rather boring but after that it was amazing!!


message 17: by Ann T, Adult Moderator (new)

Ann T (anntolman) | 454 comments Mod
sumayyah wrote: "~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Something by Simone St. James."

I took a look, and I think her books look very interesting. Can you pick a specific one, because I'd love to read [book:The Bro..."


@Sumayyah and @Autumn - I have tried to look for ratings and reviews on both of these and having difficulty finding anything. I am waiting for answers from the Goodreads community, but haven't gotten anything back yet. Secondly, they are not considered YA.

At this time, I am asking you to nominate something else. I will try and get one of these from the library and read it personally to view her writing.

Thanks for your understanding.


message 18: by Allyson, Group Moderator (new)

Allyson Jamison | 629 comments Mod
I'll nominate Emily of New Moon by L. M. Montgomery. 😄


message 19: by sumayyah (new)

sumayyah (sumayyaha) Ann T wrote: "sumayyah wrote: "~☆~Autumn♥♥ wrote: "Something by Simone St. James."

I took a look, and I think her books look very interesting. Can you pick a specific one, because I'd love to r..."


Ah, well since I only found them recently I don't mind. Whatever is best for the group is fine with me :) If I think of anything to nominate, I will.


message 20: by Ann T, Adult Moderator (new)

Ann T (anntolman) | 454 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS ARE CLOSED. VOTING STARTS MONDAY 12/14/2020.


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.