Middle Grade Madness! discussion

76 views
CYOA Challenge 2020 > CYOA Questions

Comments Showing 51-100 of 102 (102 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Dee Dee (new)

Dee Dee (Dee Reads for Food) (dee_reads_for_food) Hey, I'm just wondering how closely we need to stick to the prompts because I'm wondering if Camp Half-Blood can count as a 'secret group'?


message 52: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Dee Dee wrote: "Hey, I'm just wondering how closely we need to stick to the prompts because I'm wondering if Camp Half-Blood can count as a 'secret group'?"
You have to stick to it pretty closely yeah but also Camp Half-Blood definitely counts as a secret group!


message 53: by Dee Dee (new)

Dee Dee (Dee Reads for Food) (dee_reads_for_food) OK well I'm definitely ready for chapter b!


message 54: by Dee Dee (new)

Dee Dee (Dee Reads for Food) (dee_reads_for_food) I just did. Woop!


message 55: by Kadi, Creator (last edited Jul 09, 2020 07:33AM) (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Dee Dee If you've finished reading the book please leave a comment on here: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/... following the instructions so I can update my spreadsheet and send you Chapter B!


message 56: by Ilsen (new)

Ilsen | 517 comments Can The Lightning Thief count for Task 1b? I know there’s a slight focus on the father but I don’t know.


message 57: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Ilsen wrote: "Can The Lightning Thief count for Task 1b? I know there’s a slight focus on the father but I don’t know."
Yeah I'd say it counts! Percy's relationship with both has father and his mother drive the plot and are a main plot device...


message 58: by Ilsen (new)

Ilsen | 517 comments Oooh yay!! Then I’m definitely picking that one!


message 59: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Ilsen 🙌🏻🎉 let me know in the chapter completed page when you’ve finished it!


message 60: by Cheridan (new)

Cheridan Elder I loved Chapter A and think I will be choosing option 1b. Does Building Blocks by Cynthia Voigt fit the requirements?


message 61: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Cheridan I’m so glad you liked Chapter A! And yeah Building Blocks definitely counts. It also sounds like an amazing book! I love time travel so I’ve added it to my TBR and maybe I’ll get round to reading it soon too...


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments Chapter A is absolutely amazing!!!
You are really good at writing and I can't wait to read the next chapters! Suspense has already been built and the action starts right away which is pretty amazing!
Congrats! Really :)

By the way, I choose the Lightning Thief too for task 1B XD


message 63: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Domi oh my gosh thank you so much😱❤️❤️ I’m so glad you enjoyed the first chapter! I think the writing definitely gets better from there onwards.
And the Lightning Thief is a great choice! Hope you enjoy reading it and let me know when you’ve finished it on the completed chapter discussion page so I can send you the next chapter👏🏻


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments I was wondering: would it be possible to take the Lightning Thief for 2B?
It kind of is a secret group because the camp can't be known by mortals...
Just tell me if it's possible :)))


message 66: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Yep the Lightning Thief definitely counts for 2b. Enjoy reading it!


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments Thanks!!
And I will ;) I love this book!


message 68: by Hanya (new)

Hanya For chaper A, I'm choosing 2b. I'll be reading Grave Mercy by Robin LaFevers, will it count?


message 69: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Hanya I haven’t read it myself but it definitely sounds like it satisfies the requirements of task 2b so I’d say go for it!


message 70: by Tishara (last edited Jul 20, 2020 11:43AM) (new)

Tishara Corcoran Would Illuminae work for chaper E option 1b or what about Perfect Escape


message 71: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Tishara wrote: "Would Illuminae work for chaper E option 1b or what about Perfect Escape"

I think both books would work so pick whichever you'd like to read the most!


message 72: by Enchanted fox (new)

Enchanted fox (enchanted-fox) Does "Alfie the doorstep cat" by Rachel Wells work for task 1b, chapter B? The portuguese edition I own has a door on the cover, you can check it out on my cyoa tag.


message 73: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Four-eyes wrote: "Does "Alfie the doorstep cat" by Rachel Wells work for task 1b, chapter B? The portuguese edition I own has a door on the cover, you can check it out on my cyoa tag."

Yep it definitely counts! Go for it😊


message 74: by Kevin (last edited Jul 26, 2020 07:27AM) (new)

Kevin Connor | 9 comments For Chapter A and option 2b Does Devolution: A Firsthand Account of the Rainier Sasquatch Massacre count? The cult/group would be the group that decides to embrace the nature so extensively and thus doom themselves. In this book they were cut off from the cities for so long because of this cult thing that Bigfoot eventually understood that they were helpless from the outside world and decided to walk into their homes in the day.
If you do see it in my bookshelf, ignore the dates.


message 75: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Kevin yep it definitely sounds like it counts! Enjoy reading it😊 let me know in the completed chapter page when you’re done!


message 76: by Jawahir (new)

Jawahir the Bookworm Hi there, so for Chapter I , task 2b I want to choose Eliza and Her Monsters. The online secret identity of the MC is exposed in the real world and so she begins to lose her sanity because of it. Does this fit with the theme of paranoia?


message 77: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Normally I wouldn’t be able to confidently say that it counts but I’ve actually read half the book so I can definitely confirm that Eliza and Her Monsters counts for that task, Jawahir! Enjoy reading it!


message 78: by jessica (last edited Jul 28, 2020 09:30AM) (new)

jessica (abookishjess) | 684 comments For Chapter B, will Neverwhere (London Below, #1) by Neil Gaiman work for task 2b?


message 79: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Yep Jessica that works for it! Enjoy reading it😊


message 80: by Tishara (new)

Tishara Corcoran For chapter h 2b would Verity fit


message 81: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Tishara yeah I think it counts, go for it!


message 82: by Tishara (new)

Tishara Corcoran Would Hello Girls work for chapter M 1b


message 83: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
Wow that book looks and sounds so great😍 I think it counts for 1b yeah! Go for it, count wait to hear what you think of it!


message 84: by nat (new)

nat | 8 comments For chapter D (Deal or No Deal) task 1b, would The Silence of Bones fit the mystery genre?


message 85: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
nat wrote: "For chapter D (Deal or No Deal) task 1b, would The Silence of Bones fit the mystery genre?"

Yep Nat that book definitely fits into the mystery genre!


message 86: by Enchanted fox (new)

Enchanted fox (enchanted-fox) Can I read "The Knife of Never Letting Go" for chapter J, task 1b?


message 87: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Four-eyes yeah it counts, enjoy reading it!


message 88: by Ilsen (new)

Ilsen | 517 comments For Chapter C, can I read House of Salt and Sorrows for Option 2B?


message 89: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Ilsen I thought it was a bit greyish but some of the other editions are more bluer so I'd say yeah it counts go for it!


message 90: by Ilsen (new)

Ilsen | 517 comments That’s why I’m asking! I’m so unsure. It’s kinda blue ish..


message 91: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Ilsen I’d say it’s blue enough so go for it!😊


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments I'm not sure if it works but I was wondering wether or not this book could work for reading a book with a framed photograph:

The Austere Academy (A Series of Unfortunate Events, #5) by Lemony Snicket

Thanks xD


message 93: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Domi Unfortunately I'd say no! I reckon that's not really like a photograph or a picture in the sense that I meant it, like I meant a literal photograph, not a drawing kind. Hopefully you can find another book?


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments Okay! I'll try finding something :) Thanks!


message 95: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Domi let me know if you have any more questions😊


message 97: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Dee hey that’s totally ok! To be honest it’s completely my fault I’ve left it so long that I’ve kinda forgotten what the storyline I was writing was🤦🏻‍♀️ I’m still going to try and finish the chapters for those waiting but who knows when I’ll do that.

I really hope this hasn’t put you off taking part in other events on the group! And this year’s big event will be like the August mg reading challenge that happened in 2019 if you’re interested in checking that out before all the info for the 2021 version is out (it’s like the 2019 challenge but I’ve added some stuff to make it even more interesting). I’ve already started working on it last night, I figured out some tricky codes on google sheets so points can auto-accumulate and I’m going to be so much more organised with this year’s event👏🏻 and hopefully we can never repeat my disorganisation of this event with any other one ever again😂


Domitylle (can only update books rn. sorry) (dom_brlw) | 55 comments Heyyy! I was just wondering, is there a chapter after chapter M or not yet? ☺️
Thanks in advance for your answer!! ✨


message 99: by A Robin Reads (new)

A Robin Reads (arobinreads) Kadi: is this still going?


message 100: by Kadi, Creator (new)

Kadi P (kadi_p) | 4291 comments Mod
@Domi how did I not see your post😭 Sorry! I'm working on Chapter N and I'm also writing the chapter after that as well at the same time so hopefully I'll have them both done and ready for you by maximum end of this week! I've almost finished them both.

@Robin yep it is! Although for some it's not until I finish Chapter N😬 I have you down on my spreadsheet as last having been given Chapter H. Is that correct? The spreadsheet needs major updating so I wouldn't be surprised if it's wrong. Let me know what Chapter you were last given and if it is H and you've finished it I can send you the next chapter!


back to top