twilight lovers! discussion
Characters and Cast
>
Edward or Jacob?
message 101:
by
Kiara
(new)
Jun 25, 2008 03:25PM
oh. wait you wrote that..... that was so good. ur a great writer Brttany!!!!!
reply
|
flag
I would totally choose edward!!!! Jacob would be like my BFF, and he didn't imprint on Bella; therefore it can't happen. Sorry guys but edward is better.
I think edward is much better because he would never leave her again and actually is willing to stay behind with bella for the fight unlike jacob
oh and also jacob is just a jerk! especially cuase he is trying to get bella to like him (by kissing her against her will) and she doesn't. ugh, such a jerk! i luv edward!
I agree with message 5! jacob is weird; when i imagine him he's sweaty and smelly. when i imagine edward he's gorgeous and strong.
Edward 110% but I just can't hate Jacob, he was there for Bella and like Bella in the book i can't see him not being in her life (as a firend of course), you can't truly dislike Jacob, he can get annoying though.
I so agree with Alexis Jacob is cool in his own way..but i am so a team Edward
i like that she picked Edward, despite what he said, I think that him saying that proved how muched he loved her; it was a tragically romantic wayk to prove it...
it wasn't against her will in eclipse the second time.she totally kissed him back...
maybe not really at first.
but then she did. he shocked her into realizing that she wanted to kiss him.
plus i think that having someone who is warm, who can kiss you with extreme passion and who can stand at the sidelines and watch me fall for another guy is totally worthy of my love.
jacob is hotter anyway.
tall guys are hotter.
not cold guys who shimmer.
But you do admit that she has fallen for another guy. So, perhaps temperature and height are not more important than one's actual feelings. And although Jacob may physically be "hotter," many people believe--and I have heard it a thousand times-- that cold hands mean, warm heart.
I totally agree with Eliza about the Jacob/Bella kiss. I will say that I'm kind of neutral about the "Team Edward","Team Jacob thing," but it gets kind of annoying when everyone (mostly everyone, pardon me) gives Jacob all kinds of crap about THE KISS when Bella clearly asked him to the second time. What's a hormonal guy supposed to do? I'll also add that I agree that someone with a warm body temperature is much more attractive to me than someone who is freezing. But that's my personal opinion for myself, not Bella.
Because they were meant to be together. She had already given him her heart way before she met Jacob and even though Edward left, he ended up coming back and I think his reason for leaving in the first place was fair. She can't just cut Edward out of her life. She can't even go one afternoon without him wothout going bonkers.
eliza ur my fav person rite now u are soooo rite jacob is wwaaaaaayyyyyy hotter and edward is definately cold
I don't see why some people are so extremist about it. I think Edward is a better choice for Bella because he's who she wants more. I'm not saying that she doesn't like Jacob, but when Edward left she died inside; when Jacob had to ignore her for the pack she just accepted it, to an extent. She still tried to figure things out and fix it, but she didn't spend every night crying herself to sleep and completely empty. Personally, I would want a mixture of the two. Edward is charming, inteligent, and a complete gentleman. Jacob, on the other hand, is knowledgeable and fun. He like to do things just because they're there. Edward can be a little stiff for my tase, but at the same Jacob is too reckless. (There is a difference between inteligent and knowledgeable)
also, even though the book is fiction and it never really happened, an outside observer has to look at what is best for bella. she has a family that cares about her, and a clear future ahead of her.
she can pick edward, who she loves clearly, i'm not saying she doesn't love him, and get married, turn into a vampire and have a difficult interaction in society from there on out. I mean, she will never age, she can't stay and make friends with anyone, she will always have to move around and could be in danger for the rest of her life.
or she could pick jacob, who ages more slowly but still ages, live a life with love, because she loves him also, have children, a family, and still be able to function within society, still be able to interact with her family.
How would her family react to their daughter looking eighteen forever and they could possibly be eighty.
i think that choosing edward would be a reckless decision. family is important to a person, and if she chose edward then she would have to give up a family, she would give up her parents and the possiblility of having children.
i think the whole problem between the team jacob or team edward thing is that the love you want for bella is the love you want for yourself.if she chose jacob, then jacob fans would love it and edwardians would hate it. vice versa.
but i think that if i could choose i would choose jacob, for the fact i could still live near my family, still interact with them and have children.
bella had no clue that jacob's family was werewolves, where she knew something was up with edward's family from the start.
I agree with you Sarah. I don't know whay people are so opposed to either Jacob or Edward. They are both charming in their own way and maybe it has to do with the fact that they are so opposite besides the fact that they both love Bella deeply. But personally, I like Edward as Bellas soulmate and Jacob as the bestest friend in the world. That's just how I see it. And besides, Bella can't live without Edward regardless if she could be happy with Jacob also. This is what she wants. She was never really a social person throughout the entire book to begin with so it's not TOO much to give up besides her parents and Jacob.
EDWARDDDDDD!!!!I'm definitely obsessed with him.
But I feel so bad for Jacob. He's such a good guy. I really hope he finds someone else that he will be happy with in Breaking Dawn... and Bella better not get jealous... she's done enough crying and moping around about Jacob in front of Edward... Edward loves her and shouldn't have to see her upset over another guy.
Yeah I was annoyed at Bella at the end of Eclipse too... Don't get me wrong I still love Bella, but when Jacob was going off to fight the newborns and she asked him to kiss her, at first it was to save his life... but then she liked it and wanted it and said she was in love with him.
I feel like that's not fair to Edward... she should love him so much that she doesn't have room to be in love with anyone else, you know? I mean, Edward would do ANYthing for her. He's so in love with her that he could never love anyone else!
And then lead Jacob on when she knows she'd never chose him over Edward. Poor Jacob.
I like Jacob, but I like Edward more and I want Bella to be with Edward period I dont want Bella to be with Jacob at all but its not my decision.
I think Bella is being just a teensy bit selfish. It would hurt Jacob more for her to stay and she knows that. She needs to move on, realize that she is going to be with Edward forever regardless of her other feelings and let Jacob go so she can be happy with Edward. There shouldn't be a guilt trip when she knows in her heart which person is right for her.
I would chose Edward because...
1)Vampires rock
2)Jacob can be very jerkish
3)Bella and Edward's love is stronger than Bella and Jacobs love
4)Edward only left her in the second book because he wanted to protect her
5)Yeah... i just think Edwards better for her safety too.
1)Vampires rock
2)Jacob can be very jerkish
3)Bella and Edward's love is stronger than Bella and Jacobs love
4)Edward only left her in the second book because he wanted to protect her
5)Yeah... i just think Edwards better for her safety too.
omq! i need to read the first chapter of breaking dawn!!!!! i can't wait till it's almost my birthday cause then the book will be out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! omqomqomqomqomqomqomqomq!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
yea.i agree w/ message 134but remember when they talked about the leader of the wolf crew.how he fell in love w/ that one girl when he was really in love w/ that girl's cousin.he couldn't help it. so how would she know that jacob wouldn't be like that guy.
she should just pick edward, even though she can't have a family.but his family's great and they'll never leave her :)
stell i don't think Jacob should have kiss her.
me either. i didn't like that jacob kissed her. kiara says to jacob "Bad Dog" and grabs newspaper to whack here. Jacob starts running. "Come back here" said Kiara chasing after jacob. jkjkjkjkjk i really don't belive in violence even though if it was fun
yeah for the winter Jacob is so HOT, but for the summer Edward is so COLD, which by the way is good gor me cause i like summer.
hahahah i never thought of it that way. lol!
She does LOVe Jacob but not the same way she LOVE Edward.
Didn't she find out that she is love with Jake just like she is in love with Edward in the last book. But, she just loves edward more.
edward all the way, i hav no once of love for jacob at all (hes an asshole, sry to all of u on team jacob)first of all, edward is perfect for bella cuz he cannot stop loving her, he cant b altered
he would evn sacrifice himself for her
wen bella went off to the volturi in NM, jacob didnt sacrifice himself wen he thought bella was in trouble
also, there is a chance jacob is goin to imprint (an he didnt imprint on bella) so i dont get y he should b wit her or y bella should choose him
there r many other reasons but this rant is gettin a bit too long xD
Agreed!!! Edward & Bella r the perfect match! Jacob is just trying 2 cause tension in their relationship. He's the biggest asshole I've ever heard of! He proves over & over again that he's not worth Bella's love!! & he's such a perv in Eclipse!! Sry 2 all the team Jacob people, but I HATE EVRY OUNCE OF JACOB BLACK!!!!!!!
edward!!! jacob is a bad flee bag!!!
gogogo edward!!!!
Okay first of all to clear this up.. Jacob CAN'T imprint on Bella so sorry to all the die hard Jacob fans who wish that would happen. It won't. I definately like Jacob as a BEST FRIEND for Bella and nothing more. I agree with Brittany- Edward has been waiting a century to find his true love, he can't love anyone else, Jacob still has that chance to find someone else. Edward was there first, no matter what anyone says, I truly believe that Edwards' reasoning for leaving Bella is justified and he knows NOW that it was a mistake but at the time he thought he was doing it for her. Everything he does is for her. ANd he even said he would spend the rest of his existence making it up to her. If that isn't love i don't know what is. Kayla- Your list is 100% dead on. ALl those reasons and so much more make it obvious that Edward is right for her. I understand where Eliza- is coming from with the family thing but think about it, the Cullens are practically her family already, she loves them
almost as much as she loves her own and to be honest, she's leaving Jacob ( who she can't be with) Renee (who she seldom sees) and Charlie (who she just started living with again) for a whole new family with brothers and sisters who understand this world that she stumbled upon and for which she can't escape (The Volturi won't let her). Edward and Bella would sacrifice themselves for each other there isn't a bond more strong. She loves Jacob but it's not the same. She'll be able to heal without him but she won't without Edward. Think on that... lol
Edward! i totally agree with Alexis, his actions in New Moon were 10000000% justified. Go Edward!!!!!!!!
me too!! jacob never had a chance anyways. y try???
yeah. And I'd rather be with a vampire that can keep his anger controlled than being with a werewolf who could kill u by just ship shaping.
EDWARD!!!!!!!! Jacob is out of the question. Jake is twisted to think that Bella is the one for him. Even though they are in love, it is not as deep. Bella can live without Jacob but definitely not Edward. Plus I can't believe anyone would choose Jacob over Edward. First of all he is always there to protect her. Second he was going to die for her. third he is beautiful. oh yeah and he LOVES her. I love Edward!
twilight lovers!
Books mentioned in this topic
New Moon (other topics)Breaking Dawn (other topics)
