Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge discussion
2019 Read Harder Challenge
>
Task #2: An alternate history novel
message 1:
by
Book Riot
(new)
Dec 17, 2018 09:31AM
Mod
reply
|
flag
ideas for anyone who doesn't have any:11/22/63
The Yiddish Policemen's Union
The Man in the High Castle
His Majesty's Dragon
The Underground Railroad
I'm planning on either the next in the Temeraire series (I think I am at #3), Dread Nation, or River of Teeth.
I just found The Calculating Stars, which is the first one I've gotten excited about. Also considered Dread Nation.For those who haven't read it and enjoy a little Tudor silliness, My Lady Jane is a fun one.
How far does ‘alternate history’ stretch? I started reading Mark Hodder’s Burton and Swinburne series last year which is an alternate Victorian era (where Victoria is assassinated and time travel and steampunk are the name of the game), is this on the nose for this task? If so I’ll get the next one!
Kimberley wrote: "How far does ‘alternate history’ stretch? I started reading Mark Hodder’s Burton and Swinburne series last year which is an alternate Victorian era (where Victoria is assassinated and time travel a..."I'm going with something along the same lines: Sorcery & Cecelia: or The Enchanted Chocolate Pot so I think it is right on task!
Azrah wrote: "Any YA suggestions? (I've already read My Lady Jane)"
You could try Wolf by Wolf which I read for a Reader Harder challenge a few years ago - it's set in the 1950s after WW2 was won by the Axis powers.
I am planning to read The Only Harmless Great Thing by Brooke Bolander. I love her writing style and was planning to read this anyway, so I'm thrilled that it fits this prompt.
Kimberley wrote: "How far does ‘alternate history’ stretch? I started reading Mark Hodder’s Burton and Swinburne series last year which is an alternate Victorian era (where Victoria is assassinated and time travel a..."Yes, this counts. =)
I'm choosing River of Teeth for this one, but some others that fit this task are(note: some are series but I've only listed the first in each):Dread Nation
The Black God's Drums
First Light
The Dragon Ring
Stardust
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell
The Last Werewolf
Chasing the Star Garden
Jackaby
The Bear and the Nightingale
Marvel 1602
In Romance specifically I can think of:
Tanya Anne Crosby has some stuff like her Guardians of the Stone books, her Highland Brides books. . .
The Duchess War
The Girl Who Stepped Into The Past
(I know there are others, but it is late and my mind's blanking. . . if I think of more I'll come back)
I'll probably wrap up the Unwind series with UnDivided. I'm not sure I can recommend it, though, lol. It's not great writing, but it's a good enough plot I keep going back for more.
The Bear and the Nightingale would qualify as alternate history? It's been on my to-read list, and I'd love to use it if it does, but i can't tell from the description.
A Darker Shade of Magic ya, fantasy Lies Sleeping urban fantasy
A School for Unusual Girls ya, historical fiction, fantasy
Methuselah's Children sf
Right now, it's looking like The Yiddish Policemen's Union, The Man in the High Castle, or Karen Memory for me. Though I have so many to choose from, it's anybody's guess what will win out in the end.
Oh, I'm not sure how I forgot to suggest this one. It was one of my fav reads this year.Sunshine
It is such a good book. Highly recommend it.
Teresa wrote: "A Darker Shade of Magic ya, fantasy "
A Darker Shade of Magic is adult, not YA. The author writes adult stuff under V.E. Schwab and her YA stuff under Victoria Schwab. Just don't want anyone to mix that up.
Tabitha, indeed she has. I saw that 1600+ people shelved it as YA, but I prefer going by the author's intent. Thank you.
I'll maybe try Plan D by Simon Urban (the Berlin Wall never fell, the GDR still exists in 2011). It also has less than 100 reviews & the English edition was translated from German by a woman (Katy Derbyshire).My other options are Everfair by Nisi Shawl, Through Darkest Europe by Harry Turtledove and River of Teeth by Sarah Gailey.
I read a number of Harry Turtledove's alt-WWII books in high school and his Through Darkest Europe came out this year and sounds very interesting.
Tabitha wrote: "I'm choosing River of Teeth for this one, but some others that fit this task are(note: some are series but I've only listed the first in each):Dread Nation
[book:T..."
Is Stardust alternate history? I have seen the film but wanted to read the book too and would love if it fit this prompt, but I don't recall it being alternate history at all. Please say I am misremembering.
Bonnie wrote: "Tabitha wrote: "I'm choosing River of Teeth for this one, but some others that fit this task are(note: some are series but I've only listed the first in each):[book:Dread Nation|3..."
It's been years, but I don't remember Stardust being remotely Alternate History. It's just straight up fantasy IIRC.
It might also be a stretch to consider Marvel 1602 as alternate history. (And personal opinion, as much as I adore Gaiman, it also wasn't very good, honestly.)
The Mirage by Matt Ruff is a great alternate reality book that focuses on the Middle East. It really shifts today's perspective, making Iraq the center of power and different Christian sects are labeled as 'terrorists'.
I'm going with either Dread Nation or American War.Edit: just realized as I posted that American War is not eligible... womp. Will probably still read.
Cobweb Bride is a book I read years ago and loved, then at least. Cobweb Bride is a history-flavored fantasy novel with romantic elements of the Persephone myth, about Death's ultimatum to the world.
In an alternate Renaissance world, somewhere in an imaginary "pocket" of Europe called the Kingdom of Lethe, Death comes, in the form of a grim Spaniard, to claim his Bride. Until she is found, in a single time-stopping moment all dying stops. There is no relief for the mortally wounded and the terminally ill....
I read Sputnik's Children in 2018 and recommend it, if anyone is still looking for their alt. history pick.
(Disclaimer: My friend wrote this book but I do think it's a genuinely good choice for this task.)From Unseen Fire is an alternate history of Rome where there's magic/mages. It also has Remus founding Rome instead of Romulus. If anyone has read Kushiel's Legacy it kind of has worldbuilding like that. i.e. There's magic and the founding myths of each nation are a little different than they are today. Worth a read if you like something that delves into how magic might change a society, and also if you are just into historical-fantasy with tons and tons of characters.
what about The Mammoth Book of Alternate Histories? it's an anthology of alternate history short stories. it also only has 43 reviews at the time of posting, so would work for challenge #9
I have Turtledoves Blood and Iron for this one. It was confusing since I thought it was first in the series, but it's really not. It's the first in a trilogy, but as part of a larger series. Ithink is enjoy it more of i had a better background for the characters and events.
I'd recommend Leviathan by Scott Westerfeld or The Rewind Files by Claire Willet. Leviathan is an alternative WW1 where Axis has mechas and Allied has advanced genetic breeding/manipulation
The Rewind Files is an alternative timeline/time travel book where Watergate never happened. Highly reccomend!
i'm also making a compilation list of everyone's suggestions for each task if that's easier for people c: https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/1...
Sandra wrote: "Severance is fantastic and would work well for this task (it's set in an alternate 2011)."Thank you for this! Severance has been on my TBR list for a months, and I am so glad it fits a prompt so I know I will get to it.
I am currently reading the Ex Machina series by Brian K Vaughn. It has an alternate history element to it. It is set within a time period where things in history are changed due to this NY mayor who has certain powers. There are alternate history elements but also pure fiction. Wondering if this could be used for this challenge.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
Books mentioned in this topic
Kindred (other topics)Dread Nation (other topics)
American Hippo (other topics)
Taste of Marrow (other topics)
River of Teeth (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Justina Ireland (other topics)Sarah Gailey (other topics)
Philip K. Dick (other topics)
David R. Gillham (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
More...

















