A really interesting mix of political drama and superhero comic.
Short version: I liked it. It's well done. Good narrative. Good story. Smart comic.
The longer version.... Well.... Through no fault of the book itself, I'm afraid this comic is starting to show its age a bit.
The comic was written between 2005 and 2010, and set between 1999 and 2008.
That's not a long time ago historically, or even technologically. But since this book deals with pressing social issues of the day, 7 years is a *ton* of time politically.
For example, they tackle gay marriage in the book. And some of what's done must have seemed like an outrageously radical progressive stance. But now, 7 years later, everyone can see what way the wind is blowing on the issue. In another 5-10 years, kids who read this might (hopefully) shrug in confusion at this, thinking, "What's the big deal about two guys getting married?"
For me the big difficulty was my perception of the police. The comics are set in New York City, and as I write is now in late 2014, the NYPD.... well.... they're embroiled in their own complicated and emotionally charged politics. This series deals so much with issues of race and civil rights, having nobody bring up the issue of racism in the police felt really, really odd to me.
Which is a good thing, really. It shows that the series is believable and well-written. But again, the downside of that verisimilitude is that it feels very much out of time now, 7 years later.
That aside, the series is really well written. Amazingly well written, in all honesty. Not that you'd expect anything less from Vaughan.
He deals with complex issues carefully, showing many sides. Showing the valid disagreements. Playing out the arguments. Taking great care not to come off as liberal or progressive, republican or democrat. As a result, I didn't feel like I was being preached at or pandered to. That has to have been a nightmarish balancing act... but he pulled it off.
Good series. Good writing. Good art.
Good comic.