Historical Romance Book Club discussion
Gaol/Buddy Reads & Challenges
>
Mad About Series Challenge - 2019

I'm not finished How the Marquess Was Won yet, but so far my top 3 Pennyroyal Green reads are the same as you. I didn't love Since The Surrender that much, but so far my least fav is #1, The Perils Of Pleasure. Glad I didn't read that one first, or it might have put me off the wholes series. I only gave it 2.5 stars.

14 series! Wow!

I applaud you who chose to read Pennyroyal Green or Maiden Lane. I have read a few books from each series but hesitate to tackel that many in sequence.

14 series, Well done

Yeah it's taking me ages to get through Pennyroyal Green, and I have been reading other books in between.

This book was nice but not mind-blowing. I went 3 to 3.5 stars.



Congratulations! Finished a year of reading in only seven months. Good job.

Congrats!

I coming in late, but I would like to get done with 2 series before the end of the year!
Passionate (Level 1) : UPTO TWO series
Reluctant Royals Series By Alyssa Cole
1) A Princess in Theory By Alyssa Cole 8/8/2019 5 stars
2)A Duke by Default BY Alyssa Cole
Reid Family Series by Joanna Lindsey
1) The Heir
2)
3)
4) Let Love Find You 9/22/2019 4 stars


I am enjoying them. They are not time travel. They are about two feuding Highland Clans. The Lochmore and McCrieff, Start in the late 1800 go back to 1298.


Darbella, you sounds like me when I name my favorites. I'm like....
#2,#4,#5,#8,#10,#11
Umm. So half the series!!

Sam, way cool!"
Darbella
I am also not a fan of time travel.

I see you are reading Karen Hawkins An Affair to Remember.
I am at present on page153. I like the humour of this book and look forward to Anna teaching Anthony a few Lessons . Hope you are enjoying your read.
This is one of my M,A,S. books

Have now started reading
Talisman Ring Series by Karen Hawkins."
Congrats!

I find it funny sometimes what authors choose to emphasize. Sh..."
Lots of fun in this book. Loved the children.
Brandon's story next for me.

Like most of the books in this series, I gave it 3 stars. I liked it OK, but it's pretty light. Pleasant entertainment, though, and I do intend to read the last one as well.


Like most of the books in this series, I gave it 3 stars. I liked it..."
I read the Bridgertons for my series challenge last year. I think the first book was my favorite. Then the rest for all 3/4 stars. 8 books in a series is is a little much for me in a row.

I agree. I started the series last September (2018) and here I am still with one to go. It's just too much to read them all straight after each other. It's a rare series when I can do that.
I also liked the first two better than the others. I quite enjoyed the Cinderella retelling one as well. But some have been a bit meh.


I agree. 8 is too many to read at a stretch. I am comfortable with 3/4 books in a series.
I did the same with Penyroyal green series. I read 4 books and got sidetracked. I still plan to finish the series, probably next year.


The authors I read later on like Milan, Hoyt and Linden are more my kind of authors but I'm definitely grateful to Bridgerton's for getting me into this genre.

@Tanya - I know what you mean. For me, the storylines in the Bridgertons are sometimes a little juvenile, but there is the sweet/cute factor. I generally prefer more serious and emotional HRs such as Duran, Balogh, Burrowes, and I'm a big Kleypas fan. But yeah, you do tend to have a soft spot for the HRs you first read. For me that would be Georgette Heyer and Judith McNaught.

I have now completed my challenge. Series 8 finished and 35 book read in total.
I am an Addicted series reader, and will probably read more this year LOL

I have now completed my challenge. Series 8 finishe..."
You are a legend, Shaz! Glad you enjoyed the Karen Hawkins series.

Dozen series??? Wow! Well done!
I do like a decent Western romance now and then too. I've read a few I really liked.

Oh my! Well done! I think I've only read like two series this year...

Congrats Marianna! I am going to check out your lists. I haven't read many historical westerns but really enjoyed the Lorraine Heath Texas series.

Congrats Marianna! I am going to check out your lists. I haven't read many historical westerns but really enjoyed the Lorraine..."
Yeah, the Lorraine Heath Texas series was one on my series.
I also enjoyed some Amanda Forester and Caroline Linden series, and none of theirs were Western.

Tied for first place with 5 stars are

That's great! Can't complain about a series with more than one 5-star book, even as series as long as this one.




I really liked Not Quite A Lady. It was my fav out of the series, actually. I know what you mean about it feeling different from the others, but for me that was a good thing. I actually prefer a more serious tone anyway. Not sure whether I finished the whole series, actually, but I'm pretty sure I read 1, 2 and 3.

Not Quite a Lady is number four, so maybe you read all but the last one. I can and do really enjoy serious historical romance too. Maybe it was just the expectation from the tone set in the first couple.
Not Quite A Lady was my favorite too, Jan. It seems to be a hit or miss one. I still haven’t read the last book though.

Oh, oops. I should check which ones I've read. I think the last one (#5) just didn't appeal to me and that's why I didn't read that one.

Yes, I can see how it would be hit or miss.


Books mentioned in this topic
The Dangerous Lord (other topics)The Dangerous Lord (other topics)
The Dangerous Lord (other topics)
Wicked Delights of a Bridal Bed (other topics)
At the Duke's Pleasure (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Amanda Forester (other topics)Caroline Linden (other topics)
Amy Sandas (other topics)
Olivia Parker (other topics)
Alyssa Cole (other topics)
More...
Wow!