The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
TASK HELP: Fall Challenge 2018
>
20.9 - Moderators' Pet - Danielle M's task: Neil Simon
date
newest »
newest »
Mod
I think option 3 is missing a word? Is it supposed to be read a book that’s part of a trilogy?
i'm assuming for option 3 - a book that has trilogy in the series info is acceptable - i.e Surrender of a Siren - (The Wanton Dairymaid Trilogy #2) ....
Dee wrote: "i'm assuming for option 3 - a book that has trilogy in the series info is acceptable - i.e Surrender of a Siren - (The Wanton Dairymaid Trilogy #2) ...."Yes, that works.
Diane Whitney wrote: "Will you accept Dance of Death as part of a trilogy? On the books main page under ISN, lists series and it is both Pendergast #6 and Diogenes #2. When you click on Diogenes #2, the tr..."Yes, I will accept as it is part of the Diogenes Trilogy.
Will you accept these series as a trilogy?Both have 3 main books, but they also have short stories included in the series:
Thanks!
I'm sorry, but it looks like there are five primary works, so it's a series - but not a trilogy.
No problem. I have 2 other books that are marked as a trilogy in Goodreads, so I’ll use any of thoseThanks!
Does the series name has to have trilogy in it? Or do series with 3 primary works fit? E.g. would Rotten Rapunzel work?
Rina wrote: "Does the series name has to have trilogy in it? Or do series with 3 primary works fit? E.g. would Rotten Rapunzel work?"
Three primary works will fit.
Danielle wrote: "Rina wrote: "Does the series name has to have trilogy in it? Or do series with 3 primary works fit? E.g. would Rotten Rapunzel work?"
Three primary works will fit."
ohh thanks - that opens up some other options - i was figuring you needed trilogy
makes me lean towards Blood Oath - as the series as 3 entries - https://www.goodreads.com/series/2093...
and the description on the 3rd book - Outlander meets post-Civil War unrest in the conclusion to Melissa Lenhardt's fast-paced historical series.
Dee wrote: "Danielle wrote: "Rina wrote: "Does the series name has to have trilogy in it? Or do series with 3 primary works fit? E.g. would Rotten Rapunzel work?"
Three primary works will fit..."
In my mind, three primary works in the same series IS a trilogy. Once a fourth is published, it would no longer be a trilogy. I would bet that this author intends to write more books for this series, which is why it isn't labeled a "trilogy", but as it stands right now, it definitely qualifies.
Do I understand that you're not counting a series that has a 3.5 published so I could use The Viscount and the Vixen for Opt 3 or not?
KSMary wrote: "Do I understand that you're not counting a series that has a 3.5 published so I could use The Viscount and the Vixen for Opt 3 or not?"There are three primary works in that series, so yes, you could use The Viscount and the Vixen.
Hi! Could you verify
for Humor on the main page? Thank you!
Cait S wrote: "Hi! Could you verify for Humor on the main page? Thank you!"Hi, Cait.
Genre verification is actually done here, in the Genre Verification thread.
Kayla wrote: "Can I please have My Grandmother Asked Me to Tell You She's Sorry verified for Humor?Thank you!"
Hi, Kayla.
Genre verification is actually done here, in the Genre Verification thread.
The Seasonal Reading Challenge
Books mentioned in this topic
My Grandmother Asked Me to Tell You She's Sorry (other topics)My Grandmother Asked Me to Tell You She's Sorry (other topics)
Castle Hangnail (other topics)
Castle Hangnail (other topics)
The Viscount and the Vixen (other topics)
More...
Broadway lost an icon last month with the passing of legendary screenwriter Neil Simon. Select one of the following options and read a book that fits that task:
Required: State the option you used when you post.
Option 1: Neil Simon was well known for writing comedic plays. Read a book with a main page genre of Comedy or Humor.
Option 2: One of Neil Simon’s best known plays was The Odd Couple. It premiered on Broadway in 1965, and was later adapted for film in 1968 and television in 1970. Read a book first published between 1965 and 1970, inclusive.
Option 3: Some of my favorite movie adaptions are Brighton Beach Memoirs and Biloxi Blues, which along with Broadway Bound make up “The Eugene Trilogy.” For this task, read a book that is part of a trilogy. A book that is identified by Goodreads as one of three primary works in a series qualifies as part of a trilogy.