YA Buddy Readers' Corner ♥ discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Team Threads Archive
>
Team Crying (S) - Chat! ✔
I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D
Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profile private after she was outed in this group
Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"Profile - https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/5...
Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profile private after she was outed in this group"
O.o I found it though. Just realized I also friended her though. Want me to link a review?
Also how do you unfriend someone?
Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profile private after she was outed in ..."
I don't think we'd be able to see it since we're not friends with her
Bookbuyer wrote: "Also how do you unfriend someone?"I think there's an option for it on their page
Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profile private after she was outed in ..."
Yes please! Not sure if it'll work, but worth a shot?
Here is a Jessica review (copied/pasted) exactly: **spoiler alert** I really liked this book. I like how Seraphina is recognized as the true heir to the throne. I hate how during her ceremony, her mother is killed, and the kingdom is destroyed. I like how Neela doesn’t abandon her, and how they begin to travel together to try and find someone to help them. I like how they meet up with Ling, Ava, Becca, and the rest of the group. I hope that Astrid comes back in the next book. I love how they did the blood bind.
Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Also how do you unfriend someone?"I think there's an option for it on their page"
KK. I'll see if I can find it. Just want the option.
Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profile private after..."
Sure. I'll try. Anyone in particular so you can compare?
Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think she made her profi..."
See if you can find Deep Blue, that's what jamie posted above
Wolf: **spoiler alert** I really liked this book. I like how Gemma and Jake help Lyra and 72. I like how they discover the secrets of the Haven and how they try to figure out who they are. I hate how bad the replica's were treated so terribly. I like how in the end two couples walk away from the mess of their lives. I rate this book 5 stars
Jamie wrote: "Here is a Jessica review (copied/pasted) exactly: **spoiler alert** I really liked this book. I like how Seraphina is recognized as the true heir to the throne. I hate how during her ceremony, her ..."Which book is that?
Different books but look at the style. the "I like" and the "**spoiler alert**" are the same
Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think ..."
KK. :)
Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "I'm now attempting to find a review by Wolf so that I can compare them but I'm not having much luck 8'D"I think ..."
Nope. Maybe she wised up?
The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica .
Jamie wrote: "Wolf: **spoiler alert** I really liked this book. I like how Gemma and Jake help Lyra and 72. I like how they discover the secrets of the Haven and how they try to figure out who they are. I hate h..."If this is for Replica this is Wolf's review - ** spoiler alert ** I really liked this book. I like how Gemma and Jake help Lyra and 72. I like how they discover the secrets of the Haven and how they try to figure out who they are. I hate how bad the replica's were treated so terribly. I like how in the end two couples walk away from the mess of their lives. I rate this book 5 stars.
Oops seems I'm a step behind. :S
Are you friends with Wolf as well Jamie?
Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?
Yeah she is on my friends list (although all this BS...). Makes it easy to see stuff like this I guess.
Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked
Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers honestly, given the similarities between them ._.(Also - why do they not use spoiler tags? They're there for a reason D:)
Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
So at least they're not copy pasting reviews from one account to the other I guess?
Natalie wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
So at least they're not copy pasting reviews fro..."
Not yet.
Natalie wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
So at least they're not copy pasting reviews fro..."
But there was something similar enough between them that Sarah kicked out Jessica
No, there are a couple of the same books and they are worded differently but the style is the same. And the behavior of Jessica on Barcelona and the sudden quite is suspicious.
Yeah, that behavior doesn't exactly scream "innocent of all charges", huh? ._.
Jamie wrote: "Yeah she is on my friends list (although all this BS...). Makes it easy to see stuff like this I guess."Same. But I've never unfriended someone. :S
Natalie wrote: "Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers honestly, given the similarities between them ._.(Also - why do they n..."
I sometimes forget. :( But I always try to click it!
Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Jamie wrote: "Yeah on Barcelona https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...First page.
If you look at the review styles, it is exactly like Wolf's revi..."
Yea I don't normally read reviews of others either (unless I am genuinely curious about their opinion on a particular book). But Sarah's response to her review had me taking a look as to what led her to that being Jessica.
Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "Yeah she is on my friends list (although all this BS...). Makes it easy to see stuff like this I guess."Same. But I've never unfriended someone. :S"
Me either
Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers honestly, given the similarities between them ._.(Also..."
It's less remembering to click it... it's more if they're going to write "spoiler alert" at the beginning why not use the built-in function by Goodreads, or use the tags, y'know?
Nothing wrong with just forgetting to click it, it just seems odd...
Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
So at least they're not copy pas..."
I trust Sarah. :)
By the way (100% being nosey now :P) but did anyone notice this?https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Post by Wolf followed by a post almost immediately after (...well 6 min later) from "Jessica" ;D
Jamie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Jamie wrote: "Yeah on Barcelona https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...First page.
If you look at the review styles, it is exactl..."
I guess it helped/hurt that she was on your team this month. :)
Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers honestly, given the similarities betwe..."Maybe she doesn't know about it? Or uses her phone????
Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
So at least they'..."
Oh 100%. Sarah would read reviews all the time from all the challenges, so if anyone would notice it'd be her c:
Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers honestly, given the si..."That's a good point... I always tend to write my reviews using my computer for that very reason!
And in after thought I shouldn't have shared those reviews because of the spoiler reason but wanted you to see how they announce it exactly the same.
SO if I inadvertently spoiled a book I am so sorry!
Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Andrea wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Jamie wrote: "The first one is Deep Blue. The other is Replica ."Does Jessica have Replica?"
Nope just checked"
..."
Yup. She's one of the few people who 'likes' my reviews so I always know if she has seen my review or not. :)
Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Bookbuyer wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Yep, those are definitely pretty similar styles o.O Be hard pressed for those two be from two completely different reviewers hone..."Same. I don't know how people have the patience to do their reviews on the app. It's shite. -.-
Jamie wrote: "And in after thought I shouldn't have shared those reviews because of the spoiler reason but wanted you to see how they announce it exactly the same."NP. I still didn't really read it and it's not very detailed. Just basic stuff that you can probably read in the blurb. :)
Well Deep Blue might actually be a bit of a spoiler. lol. But I don't think I was planning on reading it anyway. Plus I have the memory of a goldfish. :P
Jamie wrote: "SO if I inadvertently spoiled a book I am so sorry!"I mean I've read both of those books and that review for Replica is literally so vague for having a spoiler tag. Also none of those really scream review to me ya know? It's more a summary than anything and not a very good one.
Bookbuyer wrote: "Well Deep Blue might actually be a bit of a spoiler. lol. But I don't think I was planning on reading it anyway. Plus I have the memory of a goldfish. :P"Please do not waste your time on that series. Alaina and I read it and it's not worth it
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
YA Buddy Readers' Corner ♥
Books mentioned in this topic
A Superior Spectre (other topics)Serpentine (other topics)
A Superior Spectre (other topics)
A Superior Spectre (other topics)
A Superior Spectre (other topics)
More...
First page.
If you look at the review styles, it is exactly like Wolf's reviews and was bust..."
Me either. I almost never read other people's reviews.