Biography, Autobiography, Memoir discussion
General Chit Chat

But please be careful since it's not unusual to find a book entered twice or three times and then if the author is done wrong, it is a huge mess to clean up.
Also, note that GR is now adding extra spaces between the first and last names of some authors when there is more than one of the same name. eg James McBride, the author The Color of Water: A Black Man's Tribute to His White Mother and many other books has THREE spaces between his first and last name, so if you try to look it up in the add book/author search under author, you won't find the right one unless you enter it with the three spaces in between.

I've never added any to Goodreads I feel like I have enough to do in my own job.
My husbands brother passed away last Saturday. We will be gone tomorrow and Friday for the funeral so I probably will not get here for a few days. Behave yourselves while I am gone!

I'm sorry for your loss.

I am also sorry for your loss!

Seem to be a lot of death notices lately.
I picked up a book called Long Live the Queen: 23 Rules for Living from Britain's Longest-Reigning Monarch. The hags mags were full of Prince Phillip's death which is the only time I had ever seen him on the cover. Usually they have pics of the latest princess dramas in them. The last one I saw announced that Princess Meghan (is she still a Princess??) had a baby in secret. Though how it can be a secret when the news is splashed all over the cover of New Idea I don't know.

Two words: Kevlar corset!

No promises.
...but seriously, sorry to hear about your BIL.

She is still pregnant and due in June is what I found. Any links to the girl having already been born...?

I was totally kidding and had no idea she was pregnant.

Sorry--couldn't read your tone of voice and/or facial expression and I knew she was pregnant.

How is anyone supposed to know THAT? How does anyone find what they need under those circumstances?
I spend a lot of time at Goodreads making requests of the Goodreads librarians to merge duplicates, correct titles, correct the names of authors, add summaries, etc.
I'm constantly surprised at how many true-crime bios list the killer as the author of the book, for instance, even when the title explains that the book ends after the hanging "as Gawd surely intends for all Sinners of her Ilk" and even when I happen to know the killer was illiterate. A quick Google search shows me the cover of the book with the author's name embossed on it in gold leaf, more often than not. Tsk!

Ugh cataloguing errors. It irks me too.
Makes my job harder. Thankfully I can usually figure out rules to prevent them.
We have authority files in databases mean to show the correct spelling and wording. What annoys me is when different catalogues use CAPS and some use lower case, but it's the same word. Then when it gets put together you get twice as much info but in the same fields. arrgh.

Exactly, how are they supposed to know it? It's bad enough for librarians to have to learn and remember it, but for regular users it's horrible! And even then, there are people with librarian privileges who aren't very good at it, who don't know (even if they are good at it) and I don't know how much it has helped.

First off, most children's books are too skinny to have a spine big enough to stick a label of 3 digit numbers on. When you add decimals it makes it even longer.
Second, a lot of subjects are all over the place in the Dewey decimal system, when they ought to be together.
eg. take gardening. Most gardening books are at 635 but then you get gardening books in the 740s because its part of house design and landscape. And if you have any kind of collection thats not right next to each other, so you miss them.
Or biographies. Most are in 920s by subject but there are also some in all the other categories all across the dewey decimal system depending on profession. eg civil rights activists in 300s, famous singers in 700s, plus sports figures, inventors in 600s, religious figures in 200s.
Ok if you've got time to roam and pick each book from the shelf, but a lot of people don't cos they aren't librarians who work with the books and put them in order every day! (if teacher only gives you 10 minutes to find a book, you could be sunk if its not right there).


Having language books in 400s and literature books in 800 also doesn't really make sense, they ought to be together.
Selina wrote: "I worked with the LC system for an Engineering Library..I think it was Library of Congress system, because if we shelved all the engineering books by Dewey every book would be in the 600s and the t..."
I guess I've never really thought about it, it's just always been that way. Do you have any ideas of a system that would work better?
I guess I've never really thought about it, it's just always been that way. Do you have any ideas of a system that would work better?

BISAC is used in bookshops, it gives categories, not numbers.
METIS is a system used in some school libraries and there are 26 topic/subject areas (each having a letter of the alphabet) and like subjects are grouped together.
Some librarians just put books together in labelled bins or tubs so children can just flick through instead of trying to sort them in order on the shelf.
Some libraries have genrefied their collection, it works for large collections of fiction, and non fiction by grouping like subjects together but still in dewey order within that.
I'm trying to figure out the best thing to do with my school library collection, since the non fiction isn't being used that much, teachers find it hard to teach and as they are a bit lazy they would rather go on google lol.
I find it really silly to have the history section NOT in chronological order. And then New Zealand books are in the 993s right at the very end next to Antarctica. Its like we are an afterthought...

I like whatever system was used at my university library in Canada, back before it was digital. I don't remember it being the LC system, but it wasn't Dewey.
I agree that for specialized libraries that Dewey doesn't work well.


Karin wrote: "I have a question. Why is is that if I read a thread, I can't click a link back to General, but get taken to the main discussion board? I have never seen this on any other GR group before."
That is a good question and one I haven't noticed before. Does anyone know the answer? I've looked all over and can't find a box that has to be checked. I'll try to find out.
That is a good question and one I haven't noticed before. Does anyone know the answer? I've looked all over and can't find a box that has to be checked. I'll try to find out.

I have no idea how to fix it either and I am one of the mods of a secret group (nothing lewd or rude, just teammates of a huge reading game and we got close--had a lot of fun together).

I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I would have gone for...a totally unique name that had nothing to do with royalty. Maybe Hermione Muggles.
Selina wrote: "Apparently Princess Meghan had a daughter in California and is calling her Lilibet Diana.
I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I would have gone..."
Maybe trying to make amends?
I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I would have gone..."
Maybe trying to make amends?


I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I would have gone..."
I think that Meghan meant she wanted to avoid the official list of royal names, not names of loved ones. By choosing Lilibet, which is not on the official royal names list, Harry and Meghan together have followed the very common custom of naming someone after close and/or deceased family members. Llilabet is the Queen's nickname, but it could never be given as a royal name. Harry was close to both his mother and his grandmother, so I think that Harry had a huge say in choosing this name. I am not sure why the press is crediting Meghan with naming their child all by herself :)
Since Meghan is married, I am not sure if we are to call her Meghan Markle or not


Everyone in the USA still does!
Karin wrote: "I notice that we can't go directly to any of the folders from threads, and wonder if it might be some kind of group setting or something else that a mod can change. I tried a thread in a different ..."
I have been trying to figure it out and haven't had any luck. I don't think it's anything I can set. I've looked everywhere I can think of . Anyone have any suggestions?
I have been trying to figure it out and haven't had any luck. I don't think it's anything I can set. I've looked everywhere I can think of . Anyone have any suggestions?
Karin wrote: "Selina wrote: "Apparently Princess Meghan had a daughter in California and is calling her Lilibet Diana.
I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I ..."
https://www.insider.com/meghan-markle...
I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for her child. I ..."
https://www.insider.com/meghan-markle...
Karin wrote: "I notice that we can't go directly to any of the folders from threads, and wonder if it might be some kind of group setting or something else that a mod can change. I tried a thread in a different ..."
Ok I think I have it figured out but I'm not sure how to explain it. I think it has always been that way and we just noticed it now. I'll try and if I don't explain it very well someone else can try.
If you go to the top of this page you should be able to click on the top line that says biography, autobiography and memoir, right? If you click on it then you will go back to the main page. The next line that says 'general chit chat' you cannot click on because that's where you are now. It can't take you there because that's where you are. I checked several other groups and they are all the same way. If you can't click on the top line then it has to be you because I can click on it.
Hope that helps. If that's not the problem you are having let me know.
Ok I think I have it figured out but I'm not sure how to explain it. I think it has always been that way and we just noticed it now. I'll try and if I don't explain it very well someone else can try.
If you go to the top of this page you should be able to click on the top line that says biography, autobiography and memoir, right? If you click on it then you will go back to the main page. The next line that says 'general chit chat' you cannot click on because that's where you are now. It can't take you there because that's where you are. I checked several other groups and they are all the same way. If you can't click on the top line then it has to be you because I can click on it.
Hope that helps. If that's not the problem you are having let me know.

I thought she didn't want to be royal and could pick any name she wanted for..."
Thanks--this makes a lot of sense! I couldn't imagine she'd still be Meghan Markle or Princess.

In any other group I am in, I can click on the folder, go to a topic in it and then click back to the folder :) It now works here with the buddy reads folder! Here is a link to one of the threads there. "Buddy Reads" is a live link as is "Discussion" https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Karin wrote: "Koren wrote: "Karin wrote: "I notice that we can't go directly to any of the folders from threads, and wonder if it might be some kind of group setting or something else that a mod can change. I tr..."
yes. I see that now. There should be a link that goes back to the 'discussion' page. I don't know why it is doing that and I don't see anywhere that I can fix it. I'll try to find someone to ask.
yes. I see that now. There should be a link that goes back to the 'discussion' page. I don't know why it is doing that and I don't see anywhere that I can fix it. I'll try to find someone to ask.


History usually.

It is part biography but I would consider it more history. If it was a full biography of Churchill I would consider it biography.

Yes, that's what I think as well, but was curious when I saw how many people have shelved it biography. It's more of a biographical glimpse into one part of his life, but not a biography because of everything else that is covered.

The Bench
We have a few copies in the bookshop, but nobody has shown any interest. I read it and thought, well, nice but why did she have to mass publish this vanity book. It was obviously only meant for her husband to read, because it's written at his level.

1937-2020
Accordionist - Best Known for her role In Ferris Bueller's Day Off
https://chicago.suntimes.com/2021/7/1...

[book:The Benc..."
And what would you say his level is?

..."
I don't know, it just seems its a book for him and nobody else to read. lol. It's very simple and some of the sentences are like 'This is your bench, Where life begins, For you and our son our baby, our kin'.
I don't have a baby son with Meghan, that's for sure. Or a bench.

They also asked me if she illustrated it, but I have to say she didn't, it was someone else.
No buyers yet.
Just a thought I had- so many times on social media the spelling and grammar are so bad you can't understand what someone is trying to say but I rarely see that on Goodreads. Could it be that readers are just better spellers?

Although is it harder to edit on social media?
My spelling and grammar tend to be poor when I am typing on an ipad, and some sites don't let you edit easily, you post something, and then see there's a mistake but it's too late and won't let you change it.

If it were me I wouldn't listen to sale reps saying its the next big thing and order heaps without even reading it or looking at it first. I think they just expect you to buy whatever according to the cover, title and author.
They'll all get sent back to the publishers to be pulped eventually if nobody buys them.
Books mentioned in this topic
Small Fry: A Memoir (other topics)The Watergate: Inside America's Most Infamous Address (other topics)
Surviving Cissy: My Family Affair of Life in Hollywood (other topics)
Surviving Cissy: My Family Affair of Life in Hollywood (other topics)
Surviving Cissy: My Family Affair of Life in Hollywood (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Gina LaManna (other topics)Christian Picciolini (other topics)
Not every book is in the database, for that matter. You can always just add it. I've done it many times.