Book lovers discussion
Books
>
What have you recently finished and loved




I've read all of hers except The Peach Keeper...liked them all!

SO good! I am from the south and so I love hearing some of the old wives tales she weaves into her stories that I grew up listening to. I just started the Peach Keeper last night and can tell it won't last me very long. :| Wish they were longer

Beautifully written with a real poignancy, full of fun and it took me right back to my own childhood of tree houses and dens in forests - such a shame that children cannot play in this way these days. Larry you have a 'goer' with this and I must write a review for amazon for you
Well done
Faith Mortimer
Author of;
Children of The Plantation
The Assassins' Village
The Crossing
Echoes of Life and LoveA King in a Court of Fools


I agree. I love her books! The Peach Keeper isn't as good as her others have been, but still good. I'll wait to hear if you think the same.

I'm glad you liked it too, Jo! For a first novel, I thought she did a wonderful job.

I see that lots of people seem to be enjoying this....it's on my tbr but who knows when I'll get to it...plus...I don't own it and it has a huge wait list at PBS!!!(paperback swap)

I see that lots of people seem to be enjoying this....it's on my tbr but who knows when I'll get to it...plus...I don't own i..."
Want me to send it to you? Shelli, I'll mail it to you tomorrow.

I see that lots of people seem to be enjoying this....it's on my tbr but who knows when I'll get to it...plus...."
AWESOME!!!!

Agree. He's a great writer, isn't he?"
He really is....

I agree! It had the makings for another great one...but it JUST missed the mark. It was too short and I didn't feel as connected to the characters as I was in her previous works...also...that magic touch she adds in all of her books was not the same in this one. Not my favorite, but I gave it four stars because I love the author and it wasn't awful by any stretch. Just not my favorite. I did love the underlying theme of friendship. Although, have you noticed that an underlying theme in some of her books is about daughters having troubled relationships with their mothers? Very controlling mothers at that. I wonder if she has a controlling mother or mother-in-law...?

Possibly, or there is a fair amount of them living in the south! :) I agree with everything you said about The Peach Keeper. I wanted it longer, and the magic element to be better. I can't wait for more of her books. I hope she has plenty of stories laid away in that head of hers! :)

Interesting about The Peach Keeper...I must have heard this from other's too because I rushed to read all 3 of the previous books but not this one....will still probably get to it sometime...but agree with you both...hope she writes more and keeps up with her previous standards!!!!

We are of the same mind! Have you come across any other writers you find are along the same line as Addison? I need something fun and magical for November. October's booked. So to speak....

Shelli, I would still advise you to pick up the Peach Keeper...it's still good...it's just that we all have such high standards now for Addison...but I still liked it. :) Maybe a warm and cozy read on a day when it's raining out and you have a hot drink at your fingertips. :)

Agreed, it wasn't a bad book by any means, just not quite up to par as compared to her others. Still read it!

I haven't found anything that is similar but I have heard that Alice Hoffman of "Practical Magic" fame is similar. Have you read any of her stuff? I haven't as of yet.

I've read a couple books by Hoffman - not Practical Magic - and I really liked them. I would never have drawn a comparison between her writing and Allen's, but now that you mention it, I can see some similarities.

I've read a coup..."
I'll have to check her out then.



I think I need to read that one!


I have this book and keep meaning to read it, but haven't heard anything fantastic about it to give me the push I need. Did you LIKE this book or LOVE it?

Can you tell me more about Hoffman pleeease :) I haven't read anything of hers. What do you like about her works? Is there a hint of magic to it? Is there humor? etc...what makes her kind of like Allen?

..."
I guess I would have to say I liked it and really liked Lionel....like I said...the story itself isn't anything new or exciting, it's just how Lionel approaches life in his situation that kept me interested. Plus.....I listened to the audio and the narrator was excellent....I'm not sure if the book would be as good without "hearing" Lionel.....although, my sister read it and she gave it 4 stars. It's a good read, but not one that is going to blow you away if that's what you're looking for...hope this helps!!

Very helpful :) thank you! I am putting this on my TBR for new year


Can you tell me more about Hoffman pleeease :) ..."
Jessica - I've only read a couple of Hoffman books, and it's been a few years since I read the last one. Her books, like Allen's, have a little bit of magic in them, but Hoffman's are a little more serious and not quite as light as Allen's. Both are good authors in my opinion.
I have a book by Alice Hoffman on my shelf but I've yet to it. Sort of like Meg Cabot. I know I should read them yet I haven't made time yet :(

Can you tell me more about Hoffman pleeease :) ..."
Just to put in my two cents....:) I've read Here on Earth and it was about as opposite as you can get from a Sarah Addison Allen book....very heavy and depressing...I disliked the characters too and gave it only 2 stars...of course, that is just my opinion, but it was not light and magical!!!

I loved it as well!


Sarah and Sadie, can you believe how young the author is? I hadn't looked at the author information until after I had finished the book. I expected an older scholarly Jewish man, maybe 65 years old and here's this young handsome smiling face. What a huge future he has. I read another of his books, I Am the Messenger. It's much lighter, but it was also outstanding.


Sarah...just read up on it before you decide to read it if you do....I really found the characters offensive....that has stayed with me more than the actual story....really heavy and depressing.

Books mentioned in this topic
Grave Mercy (other topics)Caught (other topics)
The Woods (other topics)
Shibumi (other topics)
Satori (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Harlan Coben (other topics)Trevanian (other topics)
Don Winslow (other topics)
Mark Chisnell (other topics)
Chris Knopf (other topics)
More...
Since I was supposed to be reading the second in September, I tried to slow myself down by re-reading Three Hearts and Three Lions by Poul Anderson. I first read it 40 years ago & loved it. Amazingly enough, I liked it as much or more this time around. Now that's a good story!
;-)