The Challenge Factory discussion

218 views
♦SS Archives♦ > R9: SS~How to Play, Help & Discussion Thread

Comments Showing 101-150 of 180 (180 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Camilla wrote: "Quick question: One of the bonus options is to read more than 3 books in the same series and another is to start and finish a series with more than 4 books.
Question is whether these two series ca..."


Let me think about this as I don't want to say no off the bat.


message 102: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Jun 09, 2017 01:17PM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Mary: Harry Dresden's Love Slave wrote: "Does this look black enough for the alternate cover option?

No Mark Upon Her (Duncan Kincaid & Gemma James, #14) by Deborah Crombie

I had this actual edition when I loaded the CDS up and it's very dark in person."


I'm sorry but this one does not work. It doesn't look black actually. It's more of a dark blueish green hue but not enough black for 50% of the cover.

I'm looking at this cover though Die stillen Wasser des Todes (Duncan Kincaid & Gemma James, #14) by Deborah Crombie (the German edition) and this one might.
So if you can't find about black cover, you can use the German edition cover , okay?


message 103: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Camilla wrote: "Quick question: One of the bonus options is to read more than 3 books in the same series and another is to start and finish a series with more than 4 books.
Question is whether these two series ca..."


Okay. After careful consideration, I'm going to say No. if you want two Bonus points, then we gotta have two separate series.

Thanks for your patience


message 104: by Camilla (new)

Camilla (cyqua) Ezinwanyi wrote: "Camilla wrote: "Quick question: One of the bonus options is to read more than 3 books in the same series and another is to start and finish a series with more than 4 books.
Question is whether the..."


No problem, that seems totally fair, just wanted to check :-) Enjoy your holiday!


message 105: by Danielle Gypsy Soul (last edited Jun 16, 2017 07:55PM) (new)

Danielle  Gypsy Soul (afdaniellet) | 1919 comments Ezi,

If we don't have all the completion posts by 11:59 on Thursday does that mean we don't roll for this week? I think it's supposed to be 11:59 on Friday that makes it late - at least that's what we've done in previous years. If we didn't make the deadline do we just wait and turn them in for next week? Also if the same person doesn't turn them in later in the game and it's their second time I know they are eliminated from your team so can you post without that person? (Hopefully won't happen but It'd be nice to know ahead of time).


Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments I had similar questions. I have had a crazy week and so was not reminding everyone. We had a few late posts and are still currently waiting on one.
Is it posting or finishing the book before 11:59 on Thursday that is important or both?


message 107: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Jun 21, 2017 01:26PM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
I am back from Vacation. Thank you for your patience.

1. Danielle: if everyone's post isn't in by the cut-off time, YES, you lose a turn. Don't roll for that week.
You can use your FREE pass for that week if you don't want to lose your turn.

Free pass can't be use to win (last week) ~ see rules for more details on this caveat

2. Alison: I only consider a "Completed Post" as finishing. So it doesn't matter if you finished the book, you have to have a completed post with the info by the deadline

Thank you guys for the questions and I am sorry I am just returning.


message 108: by Alison (Lady Coffin) (last edited Jun 21, 2017 03:01PM) (new)

Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments Ezinwanyi wrote: "I am back from Vacation. Thank you for your patience.

1. Danielle: if everyone's post isn't in by the cut-off time, YES, you lose a turn. Don't roll for that week.
You can use your FREE pass for ..."


Ok, but just to double check.
Under the heading: **VERY IMPORTANT**
A team can NOT advance if all reviews are not in by the deadline. That being said, players need to have their reviews in latest by Friday. Technically, a review isn't late until after Thursday 11:59p. But your team captain cannot roll until ALL of the team reviews have been posted.

So, they need to in at the latest on Friday, but it is technically late as of before Friday?????
Is the midnight Thurday a typo?? should it be 11:59 pm Friday for Reviews? with books needing to be completed before 11:59 on Thursday?

If not I am really confused. Just trying to get it all straight, so I don't mess this up as a first timer to this particular challenge and the captain.


message 109: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Hey Alison,
I will respond in your group thread, but yes, the review needs to be in by Thursday 11:59pm


message 110: by Thenia (new)

Thenia | 245 comments Hey Ezi, for some reason our thread wasn't renamed to include our team name. Could you please edit it? The team name is Baker's Dozen.


message 111: by Elena (new)

Elena  | 205 comments Hi! Sorry if I'm being a pain, but I just wanted to make sure that 4 books is enough for the "start and finish series" bonus. The reason I'm asking is in one place it says "more than 4" and in another - "4 and more", and I only have time to finish one book before midnight :). Thank you!


message 112: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Jun 22, 2017 02:22PM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Elena wrote: "Hi! Sorry if I'm being a pain, but I just wanted to make sure that 4 books is enough for the "start and finish series" bonus. The reason I'm asking is in one place it says "more than 4" and in anot..."

1. You need 4 or more books read in a series that has at least four books.
You can give me more specific example so I can understand the fact pattern.

Thenia wrote: "Hey Ezi, for some reason our thread wasn't renamed to include our team name. Could you please edit it? The team name is Baker's Dozen."

Updated


Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments Ezinwanyi wrote: "Elena wrote: "Hi! Sorry if I'm being a pain, but I just wanted to make sure that 4 books is enough for the "start and finish series" bonus. The reason I'm asking is in one place it says "more than ..."

I had actually questioned that but then stopped worrying temporarily.
So if it says 4 primary books in a series. Is that enough?
Or would it need to be 5 primary books in the series?
Or, is it 4 primary books in the series, and say 6 works total. but do you need to read the other two? They would need to meet the minimal page count, etc... I am guessing.

the Twilight series might be a good example. as it has 4 primary works, but shows 10 total works. A few of them are between novellas that are long enough, others are however collections or special reprints. So, in that example I am guessing that Midnight Sun (Twilight, #1.5) & The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner (Twilight, #3.5) would work, maybe Life and Death: Twilight Reimagined because it does contain within it, Twilight & Life and Death: Twilight Reimagined but would then usurp both of those separately. as would any of the collections that contain the primary works.
So many different ways things are listed, and some between tales are full on novellas were as others ar very short stories.


message 114: by Elena (new)

Elena  | 205 comments Ezinwanyi wrote: "Elena wrote: "Hi! Sorry if I'm being a pain, but I just wanted to make sure that 4 books is enough for the "start and finish series" bonus. The reason I'm asking is in one place it says "more than ..."

Thanks for answering, Ezi. I just wanted to clarify what the required minimum was because the series I'm reading has exactly four books in it. Rules state - "there must be more than 4 books in that series" - which makes it sound like 4 is not enough. So 4 and more works perfectly, thank you :).


message 115: by Elena (new)

Elena  | 205 comments Ezi, one of my teammates is having a family emergency and wasn't able to post her book, won't be for a few days possibly. And we're not sure what the protocol for unpredictable circumstances is. Do we skip a roll this week and wait until she has a chance to update? We don't have a free pass at this point. Thank you!


message 116: by [deleted user] (new)

Just wanted to check something for reading a whole series does it have to be finished for example

I have been reading the one true mate series there is five at the moment but their is more to come would I still get the free pass or not.

Thank you


message 117: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Elena wrote: "Ezi, one of my teammates is having a family emergency and wasn't able to post her book, won't be for a few days possibly. And we're not sure what the protocol for unpredictable circumstances is. Do..."

I will check your team thread now. Thanks


message 118: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Jun 23, 2017 09:23AM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Question: Reading the series. There are two different points that can be earned here.

✸You can get a point for reading three or more books in a series (this series has 7 books, I think)
Throne of Glass (Throne of Glass, #1) by Sarah J. Maas Crown of Midnight (Throne of Glass, #2) by Sarah J. Maas Heir of Fire (Throne of Glass, #3) by Sarah J. Maas

✸ANOTHER One point can be earned for starting and finishing a different series up to the current published book even if the series isn't finished.
For instance, you can read Written in Red (The Others, #1) by Anne Bishop Murder of Crows (The Others, #2) by Anne Bishop Marked in Flesh (The Others, #4) by Anne Bishop Vision in Silver (The Others, #3) by Anne Bishop Etched in Bone (The Others, #5) by Anne Bishop (the current book)
I believe the author will be publishing more in The Others universe without Meg and Simon as lead characters.


message 119: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
HALF BOOKS DON'T COUNT unless they meet the page requirement.
Example: Scandal And The Duchess (MacKenzies & McBrides, #6.5) by Jennifer Ashley (Mackenzies & McBrides #6.5) is 160 pages so this one would be acceptable!

The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner An Eclipse Novella (Twilight, #3.5) by Stephenie Meyer (Twilight #3.5) is 153 pages so this one would work as well


message 120: by Laura (new)

Laura | 884 comments Ezinwanyi wrote: "Elena wrote: "Ezi, one of my teammates is having a family emergency and wasn't able to post her book, won't be for a few days possibly. And we're not sure what the protocol for unpredictable circum..."

We have a similar situation with team 1.


message 121: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
I think a lot of teams are forgetting you guys have a FREE PASS that you can use when someone is late or has an emergency.

I do hope your teammates are okay.


message 122: by Louise (new)

Louise | 1600 comments For ✸ One point can be earned for reading three or more books in a series

Does this have to be a new series or can we use re-reads?


message 123: by Louise (new)

Louise | 1600 comments Hi Ezi will this work for #3 Fallen in Love (Fallen, #3.5) by Lauren Kate


message 124: by Louise (new)

Louise | 1600 comments Hi Ezi, can I get an answer to the posts in msg 124 &125


Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments Louise wrote: "Hi Ezi, can I get an answer to the posts in msg 124 &125"

I think your questions might all be answered in message 3 at the begining of this thread.


message 126: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Jul 06, 2017 04:07PM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Louise wrote: "For ✸ One point can be earned for reading three or more books in a series

Does this have to be a new series or can we use re-reads?"


Hi Louise,
1. No Re-reads on any of the Bonus points
2. Half numbers are FINE as allowed as long as they meet the requirements. I gave two examples in the rules if you need further clarification or an illustration


message 127: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Alison (Lady Coffin) wrote: "Louise wrote: "Hi Ezi, can I get an answer to the posts in msg 124 &125"

I think your questions might all be answered in message 3 at the begining of this thread."


Thanks Alison


message 128: by Mandy (new)

Mandy Sickle (thereadingdiaries) | 1343 comments Hey Ezi! Quick question since the new rule all reviews have to be in Thursday by midnight. If we are missing a review do we either use our free pass or not roll?


message 129: by Alison (Lady Coffin) (last edited Jul 07, 2017 06:53AM) (new)

Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments I was wondering if I missed something or if you have an option for reading books #10 and above after we have rolled way past them?
I wasn't sure if it would work like the "✸Half books: ½ or .5 count only if they meet the page requirement AND will be judged by preceding whole number numeral on goodreads." or if once we roll past 19 we are just out of luck.
This week we landed on space 36, so I am wondering if reading a 13th or 16th book in a series was an option?


message 130: by Plethora (new)

Plethora (bookworm_r) | 487 comments Will this work for Alternate Cover Item - Buildings?

The Summer Before the War



message 131: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Mandy wrote: "Hey Ezi! Quick question since the new rule all reviews have to be in Thursday by midnight. If we are missing a review do we either use our free pass or not roll?"

Use your free pass


message 132: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Alison (Lady Coffin) wrote: "I was wondering if I missed something or if you have an option for reading books #10 and above after we have rolled way past them?
I wasn't sure if it would work like the "✸Half books: ½ or .5 cou..."


36th: 3, 6, or 36th are the only options.


message 133: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Plethora wrote: "Will this work for Alternate Cover Item - Buildings?

The Summer Before the War
"


This works


message 134: by Denise, Manufacturing Director (new)

Denise (destiny_chan) | 7414 comments Mod
Team 2 has a member MIA since before the latest roll. Jaime hasn't checked in with us, replied to PMs or apparently been on GR at all since 02 July. We used our free pass last Friday to make up for her missing review, so that's no longer an option if she doesn't turn up before the next deadline. What do we do?


message 135: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Denise wrote: "Team 2 has a member MIA since before the latest roll. Jaime hasn't checked in with us, replied to PMs or apparently been on GR at all since 02 July. We used our free pass last Friday to make up for..."

If she continues to be MIA then we will have to let her go from the team. So keep me in the loop


message 136: by Denise, Manufacturing Director (new)

Denise (destiny_chan) | 7414 comments Mod
What about the rest of the team if she doesn't show? Do we miss Friday's roll and continue next week or can we roll this week if all remaining team members have their reviews in?


message 137: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Denise wrote: "What about the rest of the team if she doesn't show? Do we miss Friday's roll and continue next week or can we roll this week if all remaining team members have their reviews in?"

Per rules, if she doesn't show up this week (by thursday) she's off the team. And you all can continue with Friday's roll


message 138: by Denise, Manufacturing Director (new)

Denise (destiny_chan) | 7414 comments Mod
Ok, thanks! We're still hoping she'll be back, but it doesn't seem all that likely at the moment.


message 139: by Mandy (new)

Mandy Sickle (thereadingdiaries) | 1343 comments Can you read a Manga if it meets the page requirements?


message 140: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Mandy wrote: "Can you read a Manga if it meets the page requirements?"

No ma'am. I am sorry I am ignorant, but is Manga like comic books?


message 141: by Mandy (new)

Mandy Sickle (thereadingdiaries) | 1343 comments Ezinwanyi wrote: "Mandy wrote: "Can you read a Manga if it meets the page requirements?"

No ma'am. I am sorry I am ignorant but is Manga like comic books?"


Not ignorant at all =D It's a Japanese comic basically. I wasn't sure and one of my team asked so I thought I better check. Thank you!!!


message 142: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Thanks for explaining.
I will say no to Manga until further research. It seems like comics don't have the same number of words on a page like book.
So a 300 page manga might really be like 100 page paperback.
But like I said above, I'm not that knowledgeable.

I will look online at some manga


message 143: by Donna, Chief Inspector (last edited Jul 16, 2017 01:00AM) (new)

Donna (dkflynn33) | 3146 comments Mod
Ezi, I need some clarification for my team. We had a player that was really late with her review. I rolled as soon as she had it in but there is a question if we should have rolled or not. Should we have waited until next week to roll? Or are we ok? We do have a free pass. This is the first time that I have co-captained and I am a bit confused.


message 144: by Alison (Lady Coffin) (last edited Jul 20, 2017 12:02AM) (new)

Alison (Lady Coffin) S | 2318 comments Questions on these two Bonus Points:
✸ One point can be earned for reading three or more books in a series
AND
✸ One point can be earned for starting and finishing a series (there must be more than 4 books in that series...I will entertain series with spin-offs) ~ no re-reads on this one.


If we read three or more books from the series could the be book #2, #3 and #5? Or do we need to read consecutive books?

And sort of a similar question for the Starting and Finishing a series. If for a week we read book #1 then another week read book #2 but read say 3+4 in between when we do not get a correct roll, but then read say #5 the last book in the series a few weeks later with an appropriate roll. Would we get credit for reading Start to Finish? Or do they all need to be read for the challenge with a matching roll?

Hope I am explaining myself, and not talking in circles.


Angie ~aka Reading Machine~ (wolffaerie17) | 2160 comments Will this work covers item animal Outlaw MC Bear (Beartooth Brotherhood MC Book 1) by Bella Love-Wins ?


message 146: by [deleted user] (new)

hi I have a problem with our group the bakers dozen (team 13) one person didn't get review in on time as goodreads was playing up and another didn't finish but I'm not sure if we have a free pass or not and our captin hasn't been in the group in a couple of days either


message 147: by Carrie (last edited Aug 01, 2017 04:16AM) (new)

Carrie  (icanhasbooks) | 595 comments The Earth, My Butt, and Other Big Round Things by Carolyn Mackler Would this work for alternative multiple colors? There's purple background, blue jeans, and yellow words for the title?


message 148: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Donna wrote: "Ezi, I need some clarification for my team. We had a player that was really late with her review. I rolled as soon as she had it in but there is a question if we should have rolled or not. Should w..."

I think I answered this on pm. I had advised you to go ahead and roll.


message 149: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (last edited Aug 04, 2017 08:52AM) (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Alison (Lady Coffin) wrote: "Questions on these two Bonus Points:
✸ One point can be earned for reading three or more books in a series
AND
✸ One point can be earned for starting and finishing a series (there must be more than 4 books in that series...I will entertain series with spin-offs) ~ no re-reads on this one.

Questions 2) Starting and Finishing a series. If for a week we read book #1 then another week read book #2 but read say 3+4 in between when we do not get a correct roll, but then read say #5 the last book in the series a few weeks later with an appropriate roll. Would we get credit for reading Start to Finish? Or do they all need to be read for the challenge with a matching roll?"


Question 1) They do not need to be consecutive, but they need to be in the same series and meet page requirements
For example: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (Harry Potter, #1) by J.K. Rowling Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (Harry Potter, #3) by J.K. Rowling Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (Harry Potter, #4) by J.K. Rowling

Questions 2): Great question...I must say I didn't anticipate such a situation although I should have.
Hmmmmmm....When I thought of this one, I was thinking of a series that one read within the context of this game. So you used all the books within this particular game.
I am inclined to follow the spirit of that, and require that you would have had to use all of the books in that series in this game.
✸BUT✸ I am willing to listen to arguments if you disagree. So, go ahead and convince me, HEHEHE, I can be flexible.


message 150: by Ezi, Factory Superintendent (new)

Ezi Chinny (ezinwanyi) | 16657 comments Mod
Angie ~aka Reading Machine~ wrote: "Will this work covers item animalOutlaw MC Bear (Beartooth Brotherhood MC Book 1) by Bella Love-Wins?"

yes ma'am


back to top