Review Group discussion

102 views
Finished rounds > Group 134 In this World - Mod: Neil

Comments Showing 101-150 of 175 (175 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by W.T. (last edited Mar 19, 2017 11:03PM) (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments My review of Who Killed Vivien Morse?

https://www.amazon.co.uk/review/R4BWK...

https://www.amazon.com/review/R1MDIA3...

I got confused trying to review it on GR because there appear to be two copies and I wasn't sure which to review:https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=wh...

Added GR review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


message 102: by Diana (new)

Diana Febry (dianaj) | 151 comments James - received & downloaded. Will make a start this evening.
Neil - sorry! Computor on a go slow will get the correct links up asap.


message 103: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks for the reviews, W.T., I think Diana might want to confirm which edition to post your review to on Goodreads, they both have the same publication date but different publishers.


message 104: by Diana (new)

Diana Febry (dianaj) | 151 comments OMG! I've never seen those 19 reviews before or have any idea why a 2nd page has been set up in my name with about half my books added. Would a reader have done that? I'm contacting Goodreads now to ask them to sort it out and transfer the reveiws over to where they should be. I hope I don't end losing them all. Argh! But thanks for highlighting the issue!


message 106: by Dave (new)

Dave Saari | 157 comments Diana: I sent a pdf on February 27. I will attempt to send again, but I am travelling without my computer so may not manage it for a few days. In the meantime can you check to be sure you didn't receive it? Thanks.


message 107: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, James.

Diana, Keep us posted on how things go


message 108: by W.T. (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments I think what you need is a Goidreads librarian, Diana. They can combine two editions if you accidentally have two. I think someone may have submitted a review before you put your version of it up, and that might be how you got two. Icdi know a GR librarian can fix it for you.


message 109: by Marco (new)

Marco Peel | 143 comments Thank you very much James!


message 110: by Diana (new)

Diana Febry (dianaj) | 151 comments Got it Dave. Thank you WT - Goodreads librarians sorting the duplicate edition/profile. Guests just arrived - I'll post the UK links tomorrow Neil.


message 111: by W.T. (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments Glad you got it worked out, Diana. I will add my review on GR tonight.
I've completed the two books I've received so far but still need copies of the other two.


message 112: by Meriel (new)

Meriel Brooke | 97 comments Thank you for your review, Diana and please note Neil's comment on the links.


message 113: by Gene, Admin (new)

Gene Kendall | 1207 comments Mod
My reviews of "My Father's Kingdom" -- a historical novel that's enjoyable for audiences of any era:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/review/RGVVO...
https://www.amazon.com/review/R3J1TLV...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


message 114: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Gene

As the observant amongst you will have noticed today is the deadline for the first reviews to be posted, the vast majority of which have been done, so thanks to all who have been reading hard


message 116: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, James


message 117: by Meriel (new)

Meriel Brooke | 97 comments Hi Diana,
Thanks for your review, but I've just noticed that your Round 2 reviews for Sugar Pants are going to the wrong book.
The Amazon.com review is correct, but the other two have gone to an earlier version of the book called Sweet Mungo, and therefore have not been added to Sugar Pants reviews on Amazon UK or Goodreads.
I would be grateful if you could please transfer them please.


message 118: by W.T. (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments Erin, it looks like I have your book for round 2. Please message me so I can give you my email. Thanks!


message 120: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Dave


message 121: by Diana (new)

Diana Febry (dianaj) | 151 comments Sorry, sorry, sorry. You may have guessed I'm not a whizz on the computor!
Round 1 -
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
https://www.amazon.com/gp/review/R11Q...
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/customer-...
Sorry I'm late with the notification but I did complete the review before the deadline.
The correct uk links -
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/customer-...
I confirm I've moved .uk review to Sugar Pants but it's not showing yet.


message 122: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Diana, could you just confirm the Sugar Pants review on Goodreads is fixed as well.


message 123: by Marco (new)

Marco Peel | 143 comments Thank you very much Dave for a very thorough review!


message 125: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Samuel


message 126: by David (last edited Mar 22, 2017 11:31AM) (new)

David Fisher | 116 comments W.T. wrote: "If anyone else is supposed to get a copy of my book, please message me. Thanks!"

Yes, me, David. Pls send to my email at skipper.dsf@gmail.com. MOBI preferred.


message 128: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Dave


message 129: by W.T. (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments Hi Erin,

I tried to message you about getting a copy of your book, which I have for round two. GR says it "can't find user" even though I copied your name directly from your author page. Could you please message me? Thanks.


message 131: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks for the review, David, that's two down for you. Could you just have a look at the Amazon.com link as it doesn't seem to be working properly.


message 132: by David (new)

David Fisher | 116 comments Neil wrote: "Thanks for the review, David, that's two down for you. Could you just have a look at the Amazon.com link as it doesn't seem to be working properly."

A hash tag had crept in from somewhere. The link is now working. Thanks for pointing it out.


message 134: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Meriel.


message 135: by Gene, Admin (last edited Apr 02, 2017 10:24AM) (new)

Gene Kendall | 1207 comments Mod
My review of "Sugar Pants":
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

ETA - Amazon reviews here (wasn't sure if all reviews were kosher for Amazon, but apparently it's okay.)

https://www.amazon.com/review/R3C0WZ0...
https://www.amazon.co.uk/review/R3M9Y...


message 136: by Neil (last edited Apr 02, 2017 11:32AM) (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Gene


message 138: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Dave, looks like that is you all done. Hope to see in you a future round


message 139: by Dave (new)

Dave Saari | 157 comments Thanks, Neil. This group is a terrific resource for authors, and I really appreciate the hard work you moderators put into it. I'll definitely jump in again for future rounds.


message 141: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, David.

And a gentle reminder as I am here that R2 reviews are due by 7th April


message 142: by W.T. (new)

W.T. Fallon (wtfallon) | 31 comments Erin and James, I have finished reviewing the other two books I've received and am eager to read and review yours. Goodreads doesn't want to let me message you. You can send copies if your book (preferably mobi) to me at wtfallonauthor@gmail.com. If you have tried to contact me and for some reason I didn't get your message, I apologize. Thanks!


message 143: by Erin (new)

Erin Daniels | 96 comments W.T. wrote: "Erin and James, I have finished reviewing the other two books I've received and am eager to read and review yours. Goodreads doesn't want to let me message you. You can send copies if your book (pr..."

WT you're a saint - sorry I didn't see this sooner. I've emailed you!


message 144: by Kathleen (last edited Apr 04, 2017 10:29AM) (new)

Kathleen Rowland (kathleenrowland) | 71 comments Good Morning, 18+ this world. Is there room for me to join you authors and reviewers? I am heading to the books on the review exchange pages. Thank you. My book is below.

Unholy Alliance

I have selected this book to review:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...


message 145: by David (new)

David Fisher | 116 comments Neil wrote: "Thanks, David.

And a gentle reminder as I am here that R2 reviews are due by 7th April"


Sent on 28.03.
Round 3 still in the works. Maybe you meant this one.
I read the books out of order.
Sorry if it caused a problem. I'll mend my ways.


message 146: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments David, the comment wasn't aimed at you but a general note to the whole group


message 147: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Kathleen wrote: "Good Morning, 18+ this world. Is there room for me to join you authors and reviewers? I am heading to the books on the review exchange pages. Thank you. My book is below.

[book:Unholy Alliance|344..."


Kathleen, this group is full and already in progress. You will have to look out for a "Now Forming" group to join. There is a one-for-one review thread here https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/... - there are a number of books on that list that fall into 18+ category.


message 148: by David (new)

David Fisher | 116 comments Neil wrote: "David, the comment wasn't aimed at you but a general note to the whole group"

OK, Neil. You had me worried for a moment.


message 150: by Neil (new)

Neil Carstairs | 662 comments Thanks, Sam, I will try and remember you this time


back to top