Shut Up & Read discussion

This topic is about
Small Favor
Archives
>
Small Favor by Jim Butcher
message 1:
by
Sheri, Bookworm
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jun 01, 2014 06:10PM

reply
|
flag
I will go quickly through this one. If I put comments pertaining to the plot I will use spoilers.
I like Harry, but what is it that is attracting all these powerful women? Is it the close contact with the yumminess that is Thomas or that he has destroyed some seriously powerful bad guys?

There was one about Thomas' birthday, and another about Gard (Marcone's magically adept security consultant) that both took place before this one.

:P
Just teasing Alyssia. He does have some great qualities and others that can grate on the nerves. He is very good to women and children, a loyal friend, very protective and willing to sacrifice himself.
While he is good to women and general thinks well of them, but sometimes his behavior is condescending.
Alyssia wrote: "Did you guys read the stories in Side Jobs that go between the last book and this one?
There was one about Thomas' birthday, and another about Gard (Marcone's magically adept security consultant) ..."
I just checked the book out from the library but haven't started on it yet. I am hoping to read it this weekend - at least the ones up to where we are now.
There was one about Thomas' birthday, and another about Gard (Marcone's magically adept security consultant) ..."
I just checked the book out from the library but haven't started on it yet. I am hoping to read it this weekend - at least the ones up to where we are now.
Leigh wrote: "Alyssia wrote: "Maybe it's that all women are attractive to Harry?"
All except you. lol"
Lol!
All except you. lol"
Lol!

There was one about Thomas' birthday, and another about Gard (Marcone's magically adept secur..."
There's another one after this book, so that'll work out. I keep popping back and forth.
You'll be pretty surprised about Gard, I think.

There was one about Thomas' birthday, and another about Gard (Marcone's magically adept secur..."
FFS don't read the one after Changes untill you finish that book.
it has all the massive spoilers that could ever spoil the [spoilers removed] feels.
unless you want the feels to be mitigated. I dunno. I don't really mind spoilers so much. but then again, i am a robot.
Haha, thanks! I hate spoilers, but I'm horrible about looking ahead at next books in the series, and even just reading book descriptions a lot of times gives stuff away that I didn't want to know. I'll just read the stories up to where we are now and then read them as we go.

I think that is exactly it. I can't think of a woman he hasn't sexualized... oh, Mother Winter.
He finds all women sexually attractive, even Georgia who he discribes as being plain. but some aspects of her he still will be dramatic about describing. and it gets sorta draining to read it over and over and over again.
They comment on this in teh RPG setting book, where they illustrate a lot of the nearly naked supermodels that are usuallly kicking Harry's butt.

I think that is exactly it. I can't think of a woman he hasn't sexualized... oh, Mother Winter.
He finds all women sexually att..."
There was a lot LESS sexualizing of the lady who turned out to be a guy in a turtleneck. Go figure.
:(
So where is everyone on this? I'm behind, of course. I always try to do too much at once :) Don't worry, I'll catch up.
I just finished it. As always a lot of stuff going on in this one. The Archive is one bad-ass little girl. I can't imagine having all that knowledge and power since she was born. That would totally suck and be cool at the same time. She had no childhood or friends.

I'm still reading Alyssia. I was having a hard time getting into it for some reason and let myself get sidetracked by other things. I'm hoping to be finished today.
Are we reading Shield of Winter this week?
Are we reading Shield of Winter this week?
So we haven't really discussed this one. Have you finished Alyssia?
What did you guys think of (view spoiler)
What did you guys think of (view spoiler)

It's going on and on and on.
Right now, Harry is at Shedd with the Archive.
Alyssia wrote: "It's going on and on and on.
I'm getting that with them, too. Right in the middle they've been seeming to drag a lot. Once I get past that point everything's good and I end up enjoying the book, but I know what you mean.
I'm getting that with them, too. Right in the middle they've been seeming to drag a lot. Once I get past that point everything's good and I end up enjoying the book, but I know what you mean.

I feel like the books are getting fairly formulaic?
I like them, but they definitely drag.
Alyssia wrote: "I think sometimes there's too much going on in a book. It's like Butcher thinks he needs to have multiple threats all at once AND a surprise twist/aha! moment EVERY TIME or he'll lose his audience...."
I am getting the same feeling. I have enjoyed them but at times it feel repetitious.
(view spoiler)
I am getting the same feeling. I have enjoyed them but at times it feel repetitious.
(view spoiler)
I set up a thread for Turn Coat:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Want me to set one up for
too? Vaughn said she's ready to start, too...so whenever you all want to start.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Want me to set one up for

I sent up one for Iron Kissed, too. I figured people can just start when they are ready. I probably won't start it until Sunday.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

I'm glad that Michael is getting retirement? I guess?
Eh. This one didn't do much for me. There were a lot of inconsistencies and minor annoyances, and it took me a while to get through.
The short story following it in Side Jobs is pretty cute though. There are several, but I read the one about the Day Off this morning.
What do you two think about (view spoiler)
How long until she dies some horribly painful death?
I'm thinking .. Turn Coat. What with the betrayal implied. Eh?
I would like to see more of Molly in the action. She's been his apprentice now for three years?
Re you spoiler - I could take it or leave it. I'm not a huge fan of Luccio. I don't necessarily hate her, I guess I'm must indifferent towards her.
So who do you think will/should get the sword(s)? My guesses would be (view spoiler)
Re you spoiler - I could take it or leave it. I'm not a huge fan of Luccio. I don't necessarily hate her, I guess I'm must indifferent towards her.
So who do you think will/should get the sword(s)? My guesses would be (view spoiler)

Buuuut, that would be too awesome.
It's clear Murphy should get one? They've been hinting at it for books on end. I don't know about the other one?
What do you think?
Will Harry wield one? I really don't see that being a good option.
I've been reading through the short stories. I'm not usually a fan of shorts just because they usually aren't tied to the stories in any way other than having the same characters. However, these ones are integrated into the novels, which is neat.
The first one is how Dresden and Murphy met. Not a super great story by itself, but I like that we got to see that initial meet.
Loved Billy and Georgia's wedding story.
The first one is how Dresden and Murphy met. Not a super great story by itself, but I like that we got to see that initial meet.
Loved Billy and Georgia's wedding story.

also, listening to Marsters being Thomas being sexually aroused ... is criminal fun.
I wish I had these on audio :( I loved Marsters' voice for these books. I had audio for the first five but have been reading them since.

It would be ...amazing.
Ok. I don't think it would happen. Persay. But
Amazing.
Alyssia wrote: "Can you imagine Thomas with the sword of love?
It would be ...amazing.
Ok. I don't think it would happen. Persay. But
Amazing."
*Evil laugh* He does seem to control himself quite well, but...
It would be ...amazing.
Ok. I don't think it would happen. Persay. But
Amazing."
*Evil laugh* He does seem to control himself quite well, but...

I forgot about Sanya. He was one of the coin holders for a while...so you make good points for Thomas. Also: hot :D
I want to see more from Molly, too. Would that be something to have Thomas a sword bearer. He is so yummy! Can we make that happen? That would up his hotness. I was sad about Michael. Be careful what you wish for...you may get it but not the way you want it.
Has anyone seen The Fault In Our Stars? You know it is a bad sign we you start crying during the previews. I am emotional spent. My poor baby girl cried her eyes out. Mom to the rescue with chocolate candy, cherry coke and a funny movie. We ate all the candy and laughed on the couch. Good times!
I haven't seen it, and I'm not sure I want to. I loved the book and don't want it ruined by the movie. Is the movie good?

The movie is very good. It says true to the book but of course book has more. They kept the best quotes/scenes.