Israel SciFi and Fantasy Book Club discussion
Book Discussions
>
What are we reading? (2017)
message 51:
by
Shlomo
(new)
Feb 24, 2017 08:09AM

reply
|
flag

I finished the Buddy read On Basilisk Station which tottered between 2 and then 4 stars and finally got 3.5.
I also finished the first book of the graphic novel The Complete Maus which is neither fantasy or fiction. It was also not very compelling which was a disappointment.
I have now started 1984 a dystopian fantasy which is now riding a wave of renewed popularity. I last read it when I was 12, before 1984 was in our past.
Despite the depressing content the prose is so clear and well constructed I am enjoying it.
I also finished the first book of the graphic novel The Complete Maus which is neither fantasy or fiction. It was also not very compelling which was a disappointment.
I have now started 1984 a dystopian fantasy which is now riding a wave of renewed popularity. I last read it when I was 12, before 1984 was in our past.
Despite the depressing content the prose is so clear and well constructed I am enjoying it.

Most of it is made clear in second half and most plotlines are resolved in one way or another. The book is engaging and Steven Erikson has very reach language, but sudden intoduction of new concepts which were not discussed before is troublesome. So I am not sure I will continue reading the series.
I have just finished 1984 which has become extremely popular at the moment.
It is difficult to classify it as fantasy but it is a classic of the dystopian genre.
I first read it in 1981 when it chillingly represented an extreme evolution of the some of the regimes then in existence: the USSR was still alive and well, China was closed and Cambodia was just starting to recover from the horrors of Pol pot.
Now the world regimes are a little different but his ideas abut newspeak and doublethink are still frighteningly plausible.
It is difficult to classify it as fantasy but it is a classic of the dystopian genre.
I first read it in 1981 when it chillingly represented an extreme evolution of the some of the regimes then in existence: the USSR was still alive and well, China was closed and Cambodia was just starting to recover from the horrors of Pol pot.
Now the world regimes are a little different but his ideas abut newspeak and doublethink are still frighteningly plausible.

I loved We Are Legion (We Are Bob), it's very original and a great exploration of the topic.
I just finished reading The Lies of Locke Lamora and was pleasantly surprised, it was pretty good.
Currently reading Ancillary Justice, pretty hard to get into so far...

Now reading Bernard Cornwell, not sci-fi.

Currently reading Ancillary Justice, pretty hard to get into so far...
I liked it, very original main protagonist.

Currently reading Ancillary Justice, pretty hard to get into so far...
I liked it, very original main protagonist."
I've heard good things about it, and the idea of the character (as much of as I've learned so far) seem interesting but I'm listening to the audio book version and I rarely able to differentiate when the character says something versus when it thinks it, or when/where the current part is taking place - the time jumps are difficult in this audio book.
I finished Lock In which was great, even though I managed to reader some spoilers when I was half-way through.
I am supposed to be starting The Big Eye but am busy in London on a work trip.
I am supposed to be starting The Big Eye but am busy in London on a work trip.
The Way of Shadows was a good book. Now I'm listening to Daemon, and I'll probably read another book. It might be A Darker Shade of Magic, but I also consider The Black Company or The King Beyond the Gate

Genia wrote: "The Black Company is a bit odd, it feels very eighties, now, in terms of writing style, but I would recommend it nonetheless."
Yeah, I know it might feel somewhat eighties, I have no problem with that.
Yeah, I know it might feel somewhat eighties, I have no problem with that.

I really enjoyed the first 6 books. After that it gets... weird.
I pretty much gave up on Ancillary Mercy, and am now reading The Three-Body Problem, and Imaginary Cities.
Ann Lackie's series has never striked me as a series I may enjoy. It's likely I'd DNF this book if I start reading it.
I'm currently listening to Norse Mythology. The writing and the narration by Gaiman are really great, but the tales are just ok, they're not too interesting. I think it's a hyped book just because Gaiman wrote it.
I'm currently listening to Norse Mythology. The writing and the narration by Gaiman are really great, but the tales are just ok, they're not too interesting. I think it's a hyped book just because Gaiman wrote it.

Ancillary Justice is a pleasant stand-alone book. Its tone is bitter-sweet nostalgic, and there are hints of a fascinating wider world.
The rest of the series, though, does next to nothing to expand on the wider world, doesn't have the charm of the first one, and quickly devolves into "And then this happened...".
I have just finished The Big Eye. It is a semi-classic scifi, written in 1949 strongly affected by WWII and predicting an almost apocalyptic 1960.
The historical reference were interesting but it was a thrilling read. There were just too many detailed descriptions of the telescope and the emotions felt over-wrought and melodramtic. Also I had more or less guessed the plot twist at the beginning.
Now for another bookclub I am rereading The Eyre Affair. It is fantastic as usual. This is one of my favourite books and it never lets me down.
The historical reference were interesting but it was a thrilling read. There were just too many detailed descriptions of the telescope and the emotions felt over-wrought and melodramtic. Also I had more or less guessed the plot twist at the beginning.
Now for another bookclub I am rereading The Eyre Affair. It is fantastic as usual. This is one of my favourite books and it never lets me down.
What are you planning on reading soon ?
I'll go first. After Norse Mythology I plan on reading The Whitefire Crossing by Courtney Schafer. It sounds like a fun adventure book that I may enjoy. Courtney is great, I asked her to join a Q&A session for a buddy read and she agreed instantly :)
I've been wanting to read The Name of the Wind for years, but haven't done so by now because I wanted the trilogy to be completed, or at least be close to completion. It doesn't look like Pat is about to release book 3 in the foreseeable future, so I give up on waiting. I might start reading it after Whitefire Crossing.
I'll go first. After Norse Mythology I plan on reading The Whitefire Crossing by Courtney Schafer. It sounds like a fun adventure book that I may enjoy. Courtney is great, I asked her to join a Q&A session for a buddy read and she agreed instantly :)
I've been wanting to read The Name of the Wind for years, but haven't done so by now because I wanted the trilogy to be completed, or at least be close to completion. It doesn't look like Pat is about to release book 3 in the foreseeable future, so I give up on waiting. I might start reading it after Whitefire Crossing.

Nimrod wrote: 've been wanting to read The Name of the Wind for years, ..."
I have The Name of The Wind on my 'to read in 2017' list so I may join you.
I have The Name of The Wind on my 'to read in 2017' list so I may join you.
Esther wrote: "Nimrod wrote: 've been wanting to read The Name of the Wind for years, ..."
I have The Name of The Wind on my 'to read in 2017' list so I may join you."
Great :)
I have The Name of The Wind on my 'to read in 2017' list so I may join you."
Great :)

Shomeret wrote: "I am currently reading The Power by Naomi Alderman because it's the BOM in another group. I was initially reluctant to read it, but it's turning out to be very interesting."
Why were you reluctant and what changed your mind?
Why were you reluctant and what changed your mind?
I have finally taken Simcha's advice (it only took me about 5 years!!) and signed up for Net Galley.
I now have
The Mechanical Bird: A Tale of Two Ladies
Rotherweird
and
The Collapsing Empire
on my virtual shelf.
I now have


and

on my virtual shelf.

I was reluctant because it looked like a matriarchal dystopia. I have never liked one of those. The reason why it was selected by the other group as a BOM was because it made the Bailey Prize shortlist. So I thought this book might be very different and changed my mind. It is very different.
Shomeret wrote: "Esther wrote: "Shomeret wrote: "I am currently reading The Power by Naomi Alderman because it's the BOM in another group. I was initially reluctant to read it, but it's turning out ..."
Interesting. I will put it on my TBR list.
Interesting. I will put it on my TBR list.
I'm 61% through The Whitefire Crossing , and so far it's a quite good book. It's a really nice Sword&Sorcery\Epic fantasy.
I have been reading a non-genre book Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China which is heavy both physically and mentally.
So I have taken a light break with Rotherweird. It is one of the e-books I received from Net Galley.
So far it is very good, mixing a small amount of alternate 'Elizabethan' history with the narrative taking place in modern day Rotherweird, a vaguely steempunk town with medieval architecture but lots of modern touches.
I love the world building. There is also a central mystery so I will be interested to see how that pans out.
So I have taken a light break with Rotherweird. It is one of the e-books I received from Net Galley.
So far it is very good, mixing a small amount of alternate 'Elizabethan' history with the narrative taking place in modern day Rotherweird, a vaguely steempunk town with medieval architecture but lots of modern touches.
I love the world building. There is also a central mystery so I will be interested to see how that pans out.

I'm rereading American Gods in preparation for the TV series, and it's as good as I remember it. I'm also starting on Blood of Elves. I liked the previous short stories okay, but I wasn't as impressed as people led me to believe I would be. I hope the actual novel will correct that.
Genia wrote: "I'm rereading American Gods in preparation for the TV series, and it's as good as I remember ..."
I saw the trailer and it was very clear to me that I'm not going to watch the series.
Genia wrote: "I'm also starting on Blood of Elves"
I heard a lot of good things about The Witcher series lately.
I saw the trailer and it was very clear to me that I'm not going to watch the series.
Genia wrote: "I'm also starting on Blood of Elves"
I heard a lot of good things about The Witcher series lately.

Regarding the Witcher, the short stories were hilarious, the continuation not so much.

Wouldn't recommend it. I read it recently and although it's nice, it's nothing special and in my opinion there's absolutely no reason to read it again.
Anyway, for some personal reading updates, I've finished Ancillary Justice and you were right Vadim, it gets good, I really liked it in the end.
Also read the second book of the Bobiverse (For We Are Many) which was great, recommended if you've liked the first one.
Currently reading Ancillary Sword and The Lions of Al-Rassan. I really liked Tigana and the premise of The Lions of Al-Rassan sounded very interesting to me so I just moved it to the top of my reading queue. So far I'm loving it, granted the beginning had a little more urine flasks mentions than I've expected it, or any book, to have, but luckily I've passed through it and the story really pulled me in (and it's been like 100 pages since the last urine flasks mention).


I liked it, but Alaska seemed too arbitrary to me. I couldn't take it seriously. Have you read The Ambassador by Yehuda Avner? This is also an alternate universe. It involves a diplomatic effort to avoid the Holocaust.
Shomeret wrote: "I liked it, but Alaska seemed too arbitrary to me.."
Except that Alaska was proposed as an alternative 'Jewish Homeland'
The Frozen Chosen
Except that Alaska was proposed as an alternative 'Jewish Homeland'
The Frozen Chosen
I have just finished Doomsday Book which was just disappointing. I explained why at length in my review
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I don't think I will be reading any more Connie Willis
Now I have returned to Rotherweird which is still brilliant.
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I don't think I will be reading any more Connie Willis
Now I have returned to Rotherweird which is still brilliant.

Except that Alaska was proposed as an alternative 'Jewish Homeland'
The Frozen Chosen"
Yes, I read the book, Esther. I didn't see any logic in the choice of Alaska, and I didn't think it was likely.
Currently listening to The Crimson Queen by Alec Hutson. It's a really a good take on classic epic fantasy.
Reading Evil is a Matter of Perspective: An Anthology of
Antagonists. I've read a few really good short stories so far. Best stories were by Marc Turner, Jeff Salyards and Shawn Speakman. It's not out yet, though. It's a great opportunity for me to check out a lot of authors I have on my tbr.
Reading Evil is a Matter of Perspective: An Anthology of
Antagonists. I've read a few really good short stories so far. Best stories were by Marc Turner, Jeff Salyards and Shawn Speakman. It's not out yet, though. It's a great opportunity for me to check out a lot of authors I have on my tbr.


Haven't read it, was it any good?

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show......"
Didn't like it either. My wife continued to read other books in the series though.
Books mentioned in this topic
Storm Front (other topics)Storm Front (other topics)
Doomsday Book (other topics)
The Crimson Queen (other topics)
Evil is a Matter of Perspective: An Anthology of Antagonists (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Connie Willis (other topics)Bernard Cornwell (other topics)
Steven Erikson (other topics)