J.D. Robb discussion

Apprentice in Death (In Death, #43)
This topic is about Apprentice in Death
180 views
In Death Books > Apprentice in Death (Spoiler Zone)

Comments Showing 51-100 of 159 (159 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments My audio was there about midnight, I just had to refresh.


Sandra Hoover (sandrahoover) | 11212 comments Mod
My copy was waiting on Kindle this am - but I pre-ordered. I also used one of my Audible credits for the audio. I know...I'm obsessed! lol


message 53: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments Read Chapter 3 during my lunch hour at work. OMG! I am in love with this book already!! Some characters and things I'd been wondering about from books in the recent past are brought up again in this book, just like I'd hoped they'd be. NR definitely did not disappoint! I know I'm a sap, but I've already been sniffling........it is soooooo good! THANK YOU NORA!!!!!!!!!!


message 54: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments When I pre ordered Sandra,not was on sale for $9.59 which was cheaper than my credits so I bought it.


Sandra Hoover (sandrahoover) | 11212 comments Mod
Dawn wrote: "When I pre ordered Sandra,not was on sale for $9.59 which was cheaper than my credits so I bought it."

Just remembered I did the same thing, Dawn. I was surprised it was on sale as a preorder but it was. I keep my credits for full price books.


message 56: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments Me too. It was priced like it should be for a whispersync special, but when I went to audible there it was. It was $5 cheaper than the ebook. But I will take whatever deal they want to give me.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
They'll lower the price on the eBook in a couple of weeks.


Lynnette Hartwig (69mustanglady) | 40 comments Just finished last night. Amazing book.


Sheri Morell (smorell22) | 2165 comments Went by Walmart on my way home from work and they do not have the book. I am so disappointed. Was really looking forward to starting this one tonight. Will try a different Walmart tomorrow closer to work since i get off at noon tomorrow.


message 60: by Mdy (new)

Mdy | 224 comments Just finished listening to it. I loved it. Think it's become one of my favorites. Looking forward to our discussions.


message 61: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments I loved the book, but decided I need to listen again to really make up my mind. I also can't wait for our discussions.


message 62: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments Sheri wrote: "Went by Walmart on my way home from work and they do not have the book. I am so disappointed. Was really looking forward to starting this one tonight. Will try a different Walmart tomorrow closer t..."

I was in one today and looked but didn't see it either. Maybe a Target?


Sheri Morell (smorell22) | 2165 comments I was able start reading last night. I ventured back out and found it at Kroger. will continue to read when I get off at noon today.


message 64: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments Yay Sheri. I am bookmarking favorite quotes today...someone remind me I did this when we discuss lol


message 65: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments Finished reading Apprentice this morning. LOVED it!!!! I'm planning to listen to the audio version this coming week. Thank you Nora! It is a great installment!!


SB*needs low angst books* I started and just a few chapters in.


Sheri Morell (smorell22) | 2165 comments I finished reading this one tonight. I tried spreading it out a little to make it last but once I got to a certain point I couldn't put the book down. another great read


Maggie | 1576 comments So excited, I was browsing through my town's Overdrive system and this found this; it wasn't with the new releases and didn't come up when I put in a request for it. What a great surprise! Starting it tonight!


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
That's wonderful, Maggie!

I'm reading it now. It's so good to be back in the In Death world.


Sharon Kallenberger Marzola | 3059 comments I just finished! I love it. I think the last two books are among some of the best of In Death series.

Roarke and Eve have some great moments and I love a couple of reveals. Can't wait to discuss.


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments I'm starting it tomorrow on my day off. Going to be my reading day. Can't wait! :)


message 72: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments Sharon wrote: "I just finished! I love it. I think the last two books are among some of the best of In Death series.

Roarke and Eve have some great moments and I love a couple of reveals. Can't wait to discuss."


I'm right there with you Sharon. Can't wait to discuss.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
We'll make this a spoiler zone on the 15th.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
***This is now a spoiler zone***


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Just finished this and...wow! Loved it.


SB*needs low angst books* I have to say I really enjoyed it. I think when I was listening to everything unfold felt very different than previous books. Was I the only one who thought this?

Also the female cop that came on board whose name was Shelby was who? It didn't ring any bells.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Different in what way?

Officer Shelby was a beat patrol officer who first showed up in the last book, Brotherhood in Death. Eve brought her on to mentor now that Trueheart is no longer in training as he's now a detective.


message 78: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments I had a few favorite exchanges. Here is one
Roared "Will this new sort of understanding, as it were, also table the daily sniping between you and Sommerset?"

Eve "Not a chance in hell."

Roared "Well then, there's something to look forward to."


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
There were quite a few in this one. This happened at a particularly good moment.


message 80: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn | 3250 comments It was a laugh out loud moment...like he had to ask lol


SB*needs low angst books* Jonetta wrote: "Different in what way?

Officer Shelby was a beat patrol officer who first showed up in the last book, Brotherhood in Death. Eve brought her on to mentor now that Trueheart is no lo..."


First it seemed the case came together quickly in that they knew who they were dealing with. The other thing was the investigation itself. Peabody was involved but they usually have more time with each other during the investigation. This one seemed to have the working independently so they had limited time and jokes with each other. You also didn't get to see some of the interviews you normally do like with the stepfather and his son. You were told about it thru Trueheart. So it just seemed different. Even in one that reminds me of this which was Delusion in Death and one that feature a case similar this one just seemed a little different on everyone's inclusion.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Dawn wrote: "It was a laugh out loud moment...like he had to ask lol"

It's pretty clear what these two are up to and it has everything to do with mutual respect.


message 83: by Jonetta (last edited Sep 15, 2016 01:15PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Sbyrd wrote: "First it seemed the case came together quickly in that they knew who they were dealing with. The other thing was the investigation itself. Peabody was involved but they usually have more time with each other during the investigation...."

I found this to be a wonderful change. It showed Eve's maturation. She relied on her team and included other units. It was clear she was in charge but she let everyone do their jobs. You can see her really developing as a leader.

Bringing Lowenbaum in quickly had everything to do with the pace of the investigation. He and Eve worked really well as a team.

Letting others handle the volume of interviews was really smart. She took their assessments and honed in on the ones she needed for follow up. Eve has trained this team and it showed.

I really like how the series is evolving. It would have bored me if it was the same old investigative patterns.


message 84: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments Dawn wrote: "I had a few favorite exchanges. Here is one
Roared "Will this new sort of understanding, as it were, also table the daily sniping between you and Sommerset?"

Eve "Not a chance in hell."

Roared "W..."


Yes, lots of great exchanges in this one and I always enjoy Roarke's commenting on the relationship and sniping between Eve and Summerset. It always adds amusement, for the reader and especially for Roarke.


message 85: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments There were so many great moments. One that stands out to me is the discussion between Eve and Roarke about redecorating their master bedroom, and more specifically about the bed he already purchased on impulse, unsure if she would even like it. Then, she realizes that the bed cover is the same color and material as her wedding dress......as we've said before, but it bears repeating GOD WHAT A MAN! I also loved how he shared the myth/story of the bed with her. It obviously had an impact on him when he read it, because he memorized it so that he could share it with her. The bed has massive posts, celtic carvings, etc. She usually likes furnishings much simpler and plainer. Curious, why do you think she loved this bed?


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments I think my favorite was when Eve said she had a "Roarke boost" i.e. the booster. But Mira asked her if that was euphemism for sex and when did she have time for it while interviewing suspects. Lol!! I laughed out loud at that one.


message 87: by Jeanine (new) - added it

Jeanine Tucker | 196 comments Quynh wrote: "I think my favorite was when Eve said she had a "Roarke boost" i.e. the booster. But Mira asked her if that was euphemism for sex and when did she have time for it while interviewing suspects. Lol!..."

Oh I know! Hysterical!


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Jeanine wrote: "There were so many great moments. One that stands out to me is the discussion between Eve and Roarke about redecorating their master bedroom, and more specifically about the bed he already purchase..."

These two are so connected. Somehow, I believe she knew there was a history to that bed.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Quynh wrote: "I think my favorite was when Eve said she had a "Roarke boost" i.e. the booster. But Mira asked her if that was euphemism for sex and when did she have time for it while interviewing suspects. Lol!..."

I laughed out loud, too.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
I loved Eve's redesigned office. I've not seen her so excited in quite some time.


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments Yeah, I love the redesign aspects of her office, she was like a kid in a candy store. I think Eve was more open to the new bed partly because of the story behind it but the design on it represents Roarke's roots too. Plus the story behind the bed symbolizes it as a marriage bed. Even though Eve love the bed Roarke had when they first slept together, this new bed is now their own marriage bed. I love he bed covers too, only Roarke would think of details such as that. Sigh.


SB*needs low angst books* I agree that this really showed Eve's maturing in how she is dealing with things in her personal and professional life. I did appreciate that a whole lot which I thought was great.

It felt different because of being a subject that we are seeing right now and so it seemed to reflect that and so there were jokes as always but it seemed to have a feeling of somberness as well. I didn't pick up that Lowenbaum had an affect on the pace but I felt he had an seemed to be the reflection of how everyone was feeling.

Jeanine, I enjoyed the Roarke, Eve, Summerset exchange too. I always love getting more glimpses of how they all feel about each other.

The girl was one that was the most interesting part to me. I felt that one thing that never seemed picked up on which was something I felt was that her father was so infatuated with having a boy and even though he loved his daughter he was always about having his son. I wonder if that had some other influence for Willow.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
Did anyone think that Willow had something to do with Susann's death? I was so sure we'd learn she pushed the woman.


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments It did have an influence on her. Reginald would take Willow on father/daughter trips that would generally be seen with father/son activities. Hunting trips, shooting range, etc. He never encouraged her to do the more "girly teenage" stuff but he would enforce things like combat knives, tools. I think he was molding her into the ideal vision of a son.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
He even called her Will. The evil in this girl was so created by nurture.


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments That thought never occurred to me Jonetta. I just assumed she was alone when she ran into the road and got hit by a car. At one point, Willow said that her dad would leave Susann behind anyway so I don't think she saw her as a threat. Though I wouldn't put it behind her not to harm Susann if she felt jealous of her father giving the wife all the attention. Like Eve said, Willow and Rayleen would get along great. Terrifying thought, but they would scheme up some stuff together if given the chance.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
When she got pregnant with a son, I felt that might have changed things.


Quynh (quynh_o) | 1269 comments I think it would eventually. That resentment of being replaced. She thought Susann as weak so it would be the son that might get her torture more than the wife would, even if she lived.


SB*needs low angst books* Jonetta, I did think that she had something to do with it and surprised it didn't go that way.

I actually think the reason she hated her stepbrother was first he was a boy and that her Dad actually liked him and I think that is why she hated him so much. He was a boy and that was what he really wanted. I also think that if the father had a boy then he would have not given Willow the time he normal did if the child was born.

I think she hated the mother because she had a boy and that was what her Dad wanted.

The way he called the girl Will and encouraged her becoming a boy to hide. He seemed to encourage her to be the boy he wanted and never had.


Jonetta (ejaygirl) | 15057 comments Mod
I agree, Songbyrd. Reggie was terribly selfish.


back to top