Sci-Fi & Fantasy Girlz discussion
Discussions & Debates
>
What are you reading now?
message 1:
by
Alicja, ἀπὸ μηχανῆς Θεός
(new)
Apr 17, 2014 08:06AM

reply
|
flag


It's the last of its trilogy and very interesting. In Flewelling's fantasy world there's a country where usually Queens reign (because of the phrophecy of an oracle). The Tamír Trilogy is about the time a king usurped the throne and pretty much about how brave wizards conceiled the true heir - Tamír - from her uncle's eyes by making her appear to be a boy. The best thing about it: she doesn't know it until much later.
So you get a character who is actually a girl but grows up believing that she's a boy. Even after she turned back she's still unsure about a lot of things. She's still a warrior since the country's queens were always warriors but she has a hard time coming to terms that her body is different.
I really love that since, you know, she's still the same person, only with a different gender. It's brilliant. Also, she's a really good warrior and all the other characters in this book are great too. <3
(Also, it shares the world of the Nightrunner series. Since Tamír builds the new capital there's also a quick overview of her history in the Nightrunner books.)

It started badly for me -- too little of the characters from The Enchantment Emporium. The story is told from multiple POVs, which is not a technique I'm overly crazy about, and one of the initial POVs is a character I find deeply unsympathetic. I think that's a poor narrative choice, actually, and a good learning point for me as an author. There were other POVs that Huff could have written from on the same plot-line. Those POVs could have started as "corporate" as Amelia Carlson's and then become more sympathetic over time. I think that might have drawn me in more.
There's also no central "romance" to this story, and while I like Charlie's poly lifestyle, the romance between Allie and Graham in The Enchantment Emporium definitely drew me into that story.
Finally, there hasn't been much magic so far. Given the amount of time Huff dedicates to setting up the magical system in The Enchantment Emporium, I felt like she could have made more use of it, earlier on here.
Ah, well, hopefully the book will continue to improve!

Since I don't work and two of my classes involve reading books...
I've started 8 or so books but I am almost done with Johnny Tremain by Esther Forbes, halfway done with Great Expectations.
I finished Goosebumps The Horror At Camp Jellyjam. I just found out that Goosebumps was originally written with girls in mind, but appeals to both genders. (http://www.washingtonpost.com/goosebu...). Just found this out so I wanna annoy everyone with this information.


What I written was based on what R.L. Stine has said about his books.
"The secret of “Goosebumps” . . . was it was the first book series to appeal equally to boys and girls. . . . In fact, these books were originally done for a girl audience. And then the fan mail started coming in, and it was half from boys. I have a boy and a girl in every book. . . . [The books are] aimed at 7-to-12-year-olds. Second-graders can read them."
I meant originally it was geared toward girls -- so who knows how they may have continued to package the books if it continued on. Horror books glittery and pink could have been a possibility..



Really? I'm surprised. I haven't read it in years but traditionally horror genres (as I remember them from decades ago) are considered to be boys' domain. Plus, its usually more common that something meant for boys appeals to girls but not the other way around. Go Goosbumps!

http://www.buzzfeed.com/erinlarosa/bo...
I'm not going to do all of those, but most seem like things I should have under my (reading) belt.

When I see Fyodor Dostoyevsky's name I shudder. We had to read Crime and Punishment and then Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina one semester in high school and then write up a 15+ page paper on comparison and contrast between the two novels and their themes, styles, etc. I remember that assignment 13 years later still because, despite not being a teen who was not keen on dramatics, I thought that this would drive me to cut myself. It was THE most horrible experience during high school (which includes bullying and other traumas). Sorry, tangent, but the mention of either of these two books brings back nightmares.

I guess that would be a kind of successful reading experience.... At least, it would qualify as potentially life changing (since that's the premise of the list.)
I'm not real psyched about all of those, but several are "should-have-read-by-now" books. I'm probably NOT going to read Life of Pi anytime soon, but The Diving Bell and the Butterfly is definitely on my list.

I also remember reading Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance in high school and loving it. It has been on my re-read list for years along with Khun's Structure of Scientific Revolutions, The Heart of Darkness, and Kiss of the Spiderwoman. I'd be interested to see if they still hold their appeal 10+ years later.

When I see Fyodor Dostoyevsky's name I shudder. We had to read Crime and Punishment ..."
Oh wow, I enjoyed Crime and Punishment but I read it on my own. That's amazing that your teacher did that to the students, that much work... could kill a potential reader.

Wow, what a complicated book. I didn't think this would be such a difficult read but I guess my main problem are the infodumps. Eco pauses the narration for lots of background information that you probably need - but it's quite a lot when it goes over 3 pages.
What's actually really funny: apparently William is some sort of Sherlock Holmes-esque character. The main character's name is 'Adson'. Rhymes with Watson, am I right?
Anyway, apart from me not understanding many religious things (even with all the infodumps) it's so far quite interesting. I like William's deductions.



Matthew, the premise sounds interesting. Let us know if its any good once you are done.
I am currently reading:




Ha! Exactly what I was going to say :)
I am currently reading Daemon a techno-thriller about a game designer who created software to monitor the internet for his obituary and start "doing things" after he dies.
Also The Husband's Secret I'm not too far into it yet to say anything about it.

That actually sounds pretty cool. What a way to gain immortality!

Well, it takes some time to get used to the infodumps. I'm on page 116 and not much happened so far. I admit I skimmed two pages of description because I didn't think they were relevant.
Mark, what do you think of Traitor's Blade so far?
Apparently at least one review has it that the main characters are too alike. Is that true?

Well, it takes some time to get used to the infodumps. I'm on page 11..."
Will let you know tonight when I am home from work, will have read a load more by then so will more imformed.

Well, it takes some time to get used to the infodumps. I'm on page 11..."
Ok, not really sure about the characters so far, only seeing whats happening from one view point, but its very well written and worth reading.

Matthew, the premise sounds interesting. Let us know if its any good once you are don..."
I certainly will. And I forgot, I'm also reading The Giver




The thing about this book is: there are no human characters. The story takes place in a complete alien world. You get floating islands, lots of different races (apparently sometimes mixed-species), shapeshifters, and so on. Apparently, it's not unusual in this book if characters have scales.

I am back to historical fiction as I just started




I just finished The Heroes and loved it! Next is Sheepfarmer's Daughter, supposed to be a battle fantasy with a female protagonist so I'm excited about it.

Edit: Here it is
Anyway, I'm currently reading Vernon God Little and the narrative annoys me to no end - but I'm curious enough to continue reading (I want to know how it ends). All the adult characters seem to be completely oblivious to what that Lally guy does. That's quite disturbing, among other things (like, for example: the main character regretting that he didn't take advantage of a drunk girl... seriously? Ugh.)
This really makes me think twice about what books to get in the future.

I checked out the reviews, seems quite a few people had issues with it. Despite getting the blurbs, reviews, star ratings, etc. there is always a chance of getting a crap book (or mediocre one) or one that just isn't for us. One book that is highly rated by tens of thousands I hated, it was Memoirs of a Geisha.


That was interesting, also cleared up that Geishas don't sell their 'virginity'. Some reviewers didn't seem to like her though because apparently you're not allowed to be proud of your accomplishments if you're a woman. (I didn't have the feeling the author was in any way 'stuck up' because let's face it, the stuff Geishas do is hard!)
Err, so much to that.

I didn't like Memoirs of a Geisha because (I'll put it in the spoilers but since you'll never read it, feel free to get spoiled) (view spoiler)
And that is why I hated Memoirs of a Geisha. Thanks for letting me rant. :)

I didn't like [book:Memoirs of a Geisha|..."
Wowza! Excellent rant! And I completely agree with you.
-Em

So badly written that its fantasy.
We can talk about how a male author wrote her as he sees women... or maybe just Japanese women. It is interesting that he wrote her as opportunistic, shallow, and unchanging.
Plus, in this thread we can talk about anything we are reading, not just fantasy and sci fi as per my instructions in the first post. :P

So badly written that its fantasy.
We can talk about how a male author wrote her as he sees women... or maybe just Japanese wo..."
Not just Arthur Golden's portrayal, but the myth of the "eternal feminine" is really interesting to me. What is appealing about a childlike character who never develops? I see it a lot, particularly in women characters. In fact, there was a little bit of it in the episode of "Almost Human" that I watched last night, where it was portrayed in a female sexbot that couldn't evolve beyond her programming. There she was portrayed as a character to be pitied. In Memoirs of a Geisha, I don't think the character is (intentionally) to be pitied. She's rewarded in the end by getting what she desires. How often are "eternal child" female characters rewarded?


Yeah, I'd be pissed off as well if that was about me too. Funny how most readers love the book and never noticed that she remains, as E.J. put it, an "eternal child" throughout. They also appear to have no problem with her manipulating and then pushing aside when convenient "good" guy for a childish infatuation that he actually calls love and they think its love, an insta-love formed from an impression and that is long and lasting without developing over a long time or facing trials.
E.J., its even worse that she gets rewarded for it than pitied. I think we all know an "eternal child", both men and women, who never develop and remain childlike throughout their lives. That part is realistic. But rewarding such a character means that it may be actually a desired state (plus, I think Golden had some stereotyped ideas about what a Japanese woman and a Geisha should be and it colored his representation of the character.

I think it's really interesting that she's "rewarded." I'm not saying it's good or moral or anything, just interesting. I can't think of any other "eternal child" characters in sci-fi/fantasy or other fiction who are rewarded that way. The typical plot is to reward the character who has developed. Getting what they want is the reward for completing their character arc. Memoirs is unusual in that way. Again, I'm not making a value judgment about it at this point, just noting that it's usual in fiction, maybe unique (or maybe I'm just not widely-enough read). I wonder if that's part of Memoir's popular appeal?

Not sure. I guess it has the insta-love appeal, the soul mates appeal. (view spoiler)

I am currently reading Daemon a techno-thriller about a..."
OOO I just put it on my want to read list.

An annoying, viscous, boring, sexist book with a measely thin mystery to it.
Books mentioned in this topic
Dreadnought (other topics)All the Birds in the Sky (other topics)
The Short Drop (other topics)
The Dragon Throne (other topics)
The Oracle's Queen (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Rachel Aaron (other topics)Rachel Bach (other topics)
Rachel Bach (other topics)
Shannon Mayer (other topics)
K.J. Bishop (other topics)
More...