The Patrick Hamilton Appreciation Society discussion
Other stuff
>
Discuss the last book you read, or are currently reading
Andrew wrote: "I have just finished Fatal Pursuit by Martin Walker.
The ninth in a series of crime novels set in a small town near Bergerac in Périgord, and, like its predecessors, absolutely irresistible. The central character is Bruno, the town's chief of police, the recurring cast of other characters engaging, the descriptions of local culture, cuisine, wine, landscape and tradition fascinating and enticing. The crimes and mysteries spring as often from the murky and painful history of occupied and post-war France as from current social problems, and are richly and perturbingly informative. If you haven't yet discovered Martin Walker's Bruno novels, you are in for a treat!"
Nigeyb wrote: "Just ordered the first one"
Andrew wrote: "You won't regret it, though anything less Hamiltonian is hard to imagine!"
I'm about 80 pages into Bruno, Chief of Police by Martin Walker - the first of these books. Whilst no literary masterpiece, I am really enjoying the evocation of life in the Périgord region of the Dordogne - a place I've visited twice and loved. Lead character Bruno is an engaging fellow. I can see why this series has really taken off.
Thanks for the tip Andrew.
Bruno even has his own website...
http://www.brunochiefofpolice.com
The ninth in a series of crime novels set in a small town near Bergerac in Périgord, and, like its predecessors, absolutely irresistible. The central character is Bruno, the town's chief of police, the recurring cast of other characters engaging, the descriptions of local culture, cuisine, wine, landscape and tradition fascinating and enticing. The crimes and mysteries spring as often from the murky and painful history of occupied and post-war France as from current social problems, and are richly and perturbingly informative. If you haven't yet discovered Martin Walker's Bruno novels, you are in for a treat!"
Nigeyb wrote: "Just ordered the first one"
Andrew wrote: "You won't regret it, though anything less Hamiltonian is hard to imagine!"
I'm about 80 pages into Bruno, Chief of Police by Martin Walker - the first of these books. Whilst no literary masterpiece, I am really enjoying the evocation of life in the Périgord region of the Dordogne - a place I've visited twice and loved. Lead character Bruno is an engaging fellow. I can see why this series has really taken off.
Thanks for the tip Andrew.
Bruno even has his own website...
http://www.brunochiefofpolice.com

Andrew wrote: "If you haven't yet discovered Martin Walker's Bruno novels, you are in for a treat! "
Thanks Andrew.
I have just finished 'Bruno, Chief of Police' by Martin Walker
In short, 'Bruno, Chief of Police' is a quick, easy, undemanding read with some great insights too. I will be reading the second book soon.
Click here to read my review
4/5
Thanks Andrew.
I have just finished 'Bruno, Chief of Police' by Martin Walker
In short, 'Bruno, Chief of Police' is a quick, easy, undemanding read with some great insights too. I will be reading the second book soon.
Click here to read my review
4/5

I have just finished reading...
Rebecca West: A Modern Sibyl by Carl Rollyson
Click here to read my review
3/5
Rebecca West: A Modern Sibyl by Carl Rollyson
Click here to read my review
3/5


Originally published in 1939, the publisher sums it up thusly...
"It is Sunday, 4 October 1936. Oswald Mosley and the British Union of Fascists are planning to march through the Jewish East End. Over 100,000 Londoners take to the streets to stop them. This is a vivid eye-witness record of 'The Battle of Cable Street'. It tells a gripping story of a famous victory in the history of British anti-Fascism through the eyes of seven people caught up in the events of the day: an unemployed labourer; a bus-conductor; a young woman just out of prison; a policeman; two young Communists; and the titled widow of a beer baron. Their lives suddenly collide on the streets of Stepney. Like Chaplin in 'Modern Times', they are swept along by historical forces they cannot see, in a narrative of struggle that connects a narrow street in the East End of London to the battlefields of Spain and the concentration camps of Nazi Germany."
In his introduction to the 2011 edition, published by New London Editions / Five Leaves, Andy Croft writes: "October Day was seen at the time as an example of the new "Cinematic Fiction" of the late 1930s. Among the best-known exponents of this new and experimental kind of novel were Patrick Hamilton, Arthur Calder-Marshall and John Sommerfield. These romans à fleuve represented a break with the traditional unities of character and plot in favour of a large cast of characters connected only by historical accident."
It ain't every day that I'm able to strongly recommend a book before I've even reached the half-way mark, but today is such a day, and this is such a book. Simple as.
Thanks Mark. October Day by Frank Griffin sounds like essential reading. Perhaps even worthy of its own thread?

Originally published in 1939,..."
It certainly sounds like it shares a lot in common with John Sommerfield and May Day.

Originally publi..."
Which is a good thing in my opinion.
I’ve just finished Midnight at the Pera Palace: The Birth of Modern Istanbul by Charles King
Click here to read my review
Click here to read my review


Greg wrote: "I've just read The L-Shaped Room by Lynne Reid Banks, which I gave five stars. I have ordered the two other books in the trilogy, The Backward Shadow and Two is Lonely."
Great news Greg - loved your review
You may also want to comment on the official Lynne Reid Banks TPHAS thread here...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Great news Greg - loved your review
You may also want to comment on the official Lynne Reid Banks TPHAS thread here...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

I devoured the trilogy without skipping a word or regretting the time spent. Will look forward to reading your thoughts after you've read the other two.
And, in my experience, when Mark rates a book, it's about as close to a copper bottomed guarantee that the book is well worth reading as you can get.
#truefact
#truefact


This lean novel -- there's more fat on a butcher's pencil -- chronicles the life of Gary, a dipper... dips into purses, dips into pockets, dips in silver paper when his pint goes flat.
It's a story of childhood, of dreams, of hell and disappointment and lessons and redemption. Leyshon's gift is not only her ability to create a very real character, but also her ability to ease her reader into the character's head and masterfully control how the reader responds.
Lean and potent and visceral and moves along like an amphetamine sulphate rush.
Memoirs of a Dipper by Nell Leyshon added to the list Mark
Thanks as always.
'Leyshon is a master of domestic suspense' - Observer
'There's different ways to do it: I can slowly move closer step by step, or I can do it in one movement and bump into them. Easiest is in a pub then I can put my drink too close to theirs. Move my stool near theirs. Anything to cross the line.'
Gary is a dipper, a burglar, a thief. He is still at junior school when his father first takes him out on the rob, and proves a fast learner: not much more than a child the first time he gets caught, he is a career criminal as soon as he is out again. But Gary is also fiercely intelligent - he often knows more about the antique furniture he is stealing than the people who own it, and is confident in his ability to trick his way out of any situation, always one step ahead. But all that changes when he falls for Mandy...
Thanks as always.
'Leyshon is a master of domestic suspense' - Observer
'There's different ways to do it: I can slowly move closer step by step, or I can do it in one movement and bump into them. Easiest is in a pub then I can put my drink too close to theirs. Move my stool near theirs. Anything to cross the line.'
Gary is a dipper, a burglar, a thief. He is still at junior school when his father first takes him out on the rob, and proves a fast learner: not much more than a child the first time he gets caught, he is a career criminal as soon as he is out again. But Gary is also fiercely intelligent - he often knows more about the antique furniture he is stealing than the people who own it, and is confident in his ability to trick his way out of any situation, always one step ahead. But all that changes when he falls for Mandy...


Five stars
Casting its net from Francis Grose to Sid The Sexist and from Elizabethan London to Bronx hip-hop, Vulgar Tongues enlightens and entertains in equal measure while engaging the reader much like a brilliant raconteur propping up the bar one stool down. With a presentation every bit as rich and colourful as the subject matter itself, the origins and evolution and endurance of slang are laid out in chapters devoted to drink, drugs, body parts and bodily functions, music and military, crime and much else besides. Crossing continents and cultures, centuries and classes, slang fascinatingly alters and remains the same in equal part. Absorbing and revelatory, Vulgar Tongues is certain to charge you large and leave your wig fried.



I have just finished re-reading Rose Macaulay's 1956 novel "The Towers of Trebizond"
I first read Rose Macaulay's last novel in the early seventies, some twenty years after its publication, entranced by and from its famous opening sentence: ' "Take my camel, dear," said my aunt Dot, as she climbed down from this animal on her return from High Mass.' Over forty years later this marvellous book has lost none of its wit, prescience or relevance, with its themes of opposed religions, the search for faith, the necessity of love. Ostensibly a picaresque tale of a group of eccentric British characters travelling through Turkey and Syria as Anglican missionaries, it is by turns satirical, laugh out loud funny, poetic, elegiac and deeply moving.
5/5



Well, that's the only one I've read, and since it's the first in his major series, it seems the place to start. I plan to move on to the next volume soon.
The literary critic and historian Martin Seymour-Smith loathed Snow and called his work "drab", which of course it is in a way - but that's the appeal. How many books are there really about staking everything in your life on getting ahead in a SMALL way?
I was just looking at Snow's "Strangers and Brothers" series which, at least in terms of era and scope, appear to perhaps share some common ground with Anthony Powell's A Dance To The Music Of Time series, which I read a few years back and loved.


Happy new year Hamiltonians. I hope your new year has started on the good foot. I’ve finished a few books in the last few days.
The Power of the Dog is my first book by Don Winslow and, if it's typical, then I can't believe it's taken me this long to stumble across him. The Power of the Dog is epic and compelling and reminds me more than somewhat of James Ellroy. Yep, I don’t make that comparison lightly. Not saying it’s quite as good as Ellroy but it has the same scope and, like Ellroy, shines a light deep into the morally ambiguous, dark heart of the American dream….
Click here to read my review
I loved the other books I've read by Ben Macintyre so when I heard about Rogue Heroes: The History of the SAS, Britain's Secret Special Forces Unit That Sabotaged the Nazis and Changed the Nature of War I was keen to read it. Whilst not as jaw dropping as Agent Zigzag: A True Story of Nazi Espionage, Love, and Betrayal, or as edge-of-the-seat thrilling as Operation Mincemeat: How a Dead Man and a Bizarre Plan Fooled the Nazis and Assured an Allied Victory, it's nevertheless an absorbing read….
Click here to read my review
I have seen "Unspeakable Things: Sex, Lies and Revolution” described as a manifesto. A manifesto is a public declaration of policy and aims - something this book conspicuously lacks. It’s actually a selection of articles by a clever and gifted writer who highlights some important, sometimes shocking, things about our world. But that’s all it is….
Click here to read my review
From mid-October 2016 through to early January 2017 I read all eleven of the Bernie Gunther series - at least until April 2017 when the 12th instalment, 'Prussian Blue’, is due to be published. There are rich rewards for anyone who follows Bernie through this series and these continue in 'The Other Side of Silence’….
Click here to read my review
What about you?
The Power of the Dog is my first book by Don Winslow and, if it's typical, then I can't believe it's taken me this long to stumble across him. The Power of the Dog is epic and compelling and reminds me more than somewhat of James Ellroy. Yep, I don’t make that comparison lightly. Not saying it’s quite as good as Ellroy but it has the same scope and, like Ellroy, shines a light deep into the morally ambiguous, dark heart of the American dream….
Click here to read my review
I loved the other books I've read by Ben Macintyre so when I heard about Rogue Heroes: The History of the SAS, Britain's Secret Special Forces Unit That Sabotaged the Nazis and Changed the Nature of War I was keen to read it. Whilst not as jaw dropping as Agent Zigzag: A True Story of Nazi Espionage, Love, and Betrayal, or as edge-of-the-seat thrilling as Operation Mincemeat: How a Dead Man and a Bizarre Plan Fooled the Nazis and Assured an Allied Victory, it's nevertheless an absorbing read….
Click here to read my review
I have seen "Unspeakable Things: Sex, Lies and Revolution” described as a manifesto. A manifesto is a public declaration of policy and aims - something this book conspicuously lacks. It’s actually a selection of articles by a clever and gifted writer who highlights some important, sometimes shocking, things about our world. But that’s all it is….
Click here to read my review
From mid-October 2016 through to early January 2017 I read all eleven of the Bernie Gunther series - at least until April 2017 when the 12th instalment, 'Prussian Blue’, is due to be published. There are rich rewards for anyone who follows Bernie through this series and these continue in 'The Other Side of Silence’….
Click here to read my review
What about you?
Nigeyb wrote: "I've just finished...

Going Off Alarming by Danny Baker
Review here...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show..."
I've got front row tickets to see Danny Baker on stage...
The stage has always been my first love. Let me put that another way. I have never done anything like this before in my life. However, to travel from town to town addressing a fabulous gathering of like-minded chums each night seems to me exactly what Shakespeare would have done had not the hefty rent at The Globe kept him in London. As a consequence, William Shakespeare toured about as frequently as Kate Bush. Well not me. I own very few theatres anymore and so I am now totally free to charge about here and there wowing the folks with my anecdotal back catalogue, games involving sausages and impressive six octave range.
No two nights of this extravaganza will be the same. This is less of a boast than admission that a) I am hopeless at learning scripts and b) I still have no idea what I am going to include. Perhaps you can help? If youve read my books, watched the series based on them or, indeed, ever caught anything I have presented on television/radio then maybe you might contribute to the feast of reason and flow of the soul that I guarantee these evenings will contain. Questions like, Did your friend really eat saveloys from a pith helmet or What was meeting John Lennon/Michael Jackson/David Bowie/Kenneth Williams like? or, I suspect, most popular of all How comes youve made so many rotten TV programs, Dan?
I will of course arrive in front of you going off like a Cacophonous Catherine Wheel of Chat, armed with hundreds of tall tales to tell many complete with proof from my family picture album to stop you thinking I am simply raving. Ive been at this showman racket a full 40 years now my friends there is truly much to discuss and plenty to be held to account for.
A night at the theatre can either be deep dish or high kicking. What I promise to haul before you is very much in the latter category. Content wise I will make Springsteen and Dodd look like short changing slackers. I cant wait. This is the sort of radio Ive always wanted to do, ie, radio without radio. Just me and you.
In fact, if you dont show up Im going to do it in your local theatre anyway. So you may as well come. Why should the ushers have all the fun?
So, in short, roll up, pile in and hang onto your hats. I am back where I belong. On the stage! Shove over Tommy Steele theres a new sheriff in town
See you there.
Huzzah!

Going Off Alarming by Danny Baker
Review here...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show..."
I've got front row tickets to see Danny Baker on stage...
The stage has always been my first love. Let me put that another way. I have never done anything like this before in my life. However, to travel from town to town addressing a fabulous gathering of like-minded chums each night seems to me exactly what Shakespeare would have done had not the hefty rent at The Globe kept him in London. As a consequence, William Shakespeare toured about as frequently as Kate Bush. Well not me. I own very few theatres anymore and so I am now totally free to charge about here and there wowing the folks with my anecdotal back catalogue, games involving sausages and impressive six octave range.
No two nights of this extravaganza will be the same. This is less of a boast than admission that a) I am hopeless at learning scripts and b) I still have no idea what I am going to include. Perhaps you can help? If youve read my books, watched the series based on them or, indeed, ever caught anything I have presented on television/radio then maybe you might contribute to the feast of reason and flow of the soul that I guarantee these evenings will contain. Questions like, Did your friend really eat saveloys from a pith helmet or What was meeting John Lennon/Michael Jackson/David Bowie/Kenneth Williams like? or, I suspect, most popular of all How comes youve made so many rotten TV programs, Dan?
I will of course arrive in front of you going off like a Cacophonous Catherine Wheel of Chat, armed with hundreds of tall tales to tell many complete with proof from my family picture album to stop you thinking I am simply raving. Ive been at this showman racket a full 40 years now my friends there is truly much to discuss and plenty to be held to account for.
A night at the theatre can either be deep dish or high kicking. What I promise to haul before you is very much in the latter category. Content wise I will make Springsteen and Dodd look like short changing slackers. I cant wait. This is the sort of radio Ive always wanted to do, ie, radio without radio. Just me and you.
In fact, if you dont show up Im going to do it in your local theatre anyway. So you may as well come. Why should the ushers have all the fun?
So, in short, roll up, pile in and hang onto your hats. I am back where I belong. On the stage! Shove over Tommy Steele theres a new sheriff in town
See you there.
Huzzah!

Recommended with confidence, but beware: It'll have you obsessively revisiting your collection of Dr Feelgood platters.
Thanks Mark. I've had that on my radar for some time. I heard Zoe interviewed about it shortly after it was published and was committed to read it then. Needless to say, being prompted to revisit the Feelgood's back catalogue would be a pleasure. It's one of things I love about reading music related books.
Thanks for reminding me about it.
Thanks for reminding me about it.

Rock & Roll Gentleman is a refreshing break from all that.
A review of 'The Mask of Dimitrios' (1939)…..
Anything that is published by Penguin Modern Classics is instantly alluring in my mind and, given I’d heard positive things about Eric Ambler, I was keen to sample his work. I’d heard that 'The Mask of Dimitrios' (1939) (aka 'A Coffin for Dimitrios') was one of his very best.
Charles Latimer, an English crime novelist, is in Istanbul where he meets Colonel Haki of the Turkish secret police. Haki tells Latimer about Dimitrios Makropolous, a murderer, drug dealer, assassin and general rogue, whose body has just been fished out of the Bosphorus. Fascinated by the story, Latimer decides to retrace Dimitrios's steps across Europe to find out more about him.
The plot conceit of having a writer of detective novels as the protagonist is a great way of contrasting detective novels with real world investigation. The plot machinations of Latimer's investigation make 'The Mask of Dimitrios' a rich source of European history during the early 1920s through to the end of 1930s. Despite WW1 being over, Europe was still awash with ethnic cleansing, ideological conflict, political assassination, and crime. Prime ministers were assassinated, drugs, women and state secrets were bought and sold, and the fascists and communists took what advantage they could. Amoral entrepreneurs like Dimitrios exploited the situation and 'The Mask of Dimitrios' effectively relates his story.
For all the many good things about 'The Mask of Dimitrios’, Charles Latimer is an annoying character: a slow witted and naive prude who really should have foreseen the consequences of much of his decision making. It's hard to imagine that his detective fiction could amount to much. This aspect of the book confused me and undermined my enjoyment. However, putting this qualm to one side, it is an undeniably enjoyable, informative and compelling tale.
4/5
Click here to give my review a like
Anything that is published by Penguin Modern Classics is instantly alluring in my mind and, given I’d heard positive things about Eric Ambler, I was keen to sample his work. I’d heard that 'The Mask of Dimitrios' (1939) (aka 'A Coffin for Dimitrios') was one of his very best.
Charles Latimer, an English crime novelist, is in Istanbul where he meets Colonel Haki of the Turkish secret police. Haki tells Latimer about Dimitrios Makropolous, a murderer, drug dealer, assassin and general rogue, whose body has just been fished out of the Bosphorus. Fascinated by the story, Latimer decides to retrace Dimitrios's steps across Europe to find out more about him.
The plot conceit of having a writer of detective novels as the protagonist is a great way of contrasting detective novels with real world investigation. The plot machinations of Latimer's investigation make 'The Mask of Dimitrios' a rich source of European history during the early 1920s through to the end of 1930s. Despite WW1 being over, Europe was still awash with ethnic cleansing, ideological conflict, political assassination, and crime. Prime ministers were assassinated, drugs, women and state secrets were bought and sold, and the fascists and communists took what advantage they could. Amoral entrepreneurs like Dimitrios exploited the situation and 'The Mask of Dimitrios' effectively relates his story.
For all the many good things about 'The Mask of Dimitrios’, Charles Latimer is an annoying character: a slow witted and naive prude who really should have foreseen the consequences of much of his decision making. It's hard to imagine that his detective fiction could amount to much. This aspect of the book confused me and undermined my enjoyment. However, putting this qualm to one side, it is an undeniably enjoyable, informative and compelling tale.
4/5
Click here to give my review a like


Hurrah - so glad you enjoyed it too Mark
High Dive is indeed a very good book. Here's what I wrote when I finished it....
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
High Dive is indeed a very good book. Here's what I wrote when I finished it....
Absolutely superb.
It was GoodReads friend Susan's five star review of 'High Dive' which inspired me to read this. I am very glad I did.
I well remember 12 October 1984, the day the IRA bomb blew up the Grand Hotel in Brighton, and where the Conservative Party was holding its annual conference. I was living in Brighton then and had, coincidentally, been in the hotel a few hours before the device went off.
The genius of this novel is that whilst we know what's going to happen, and how afterwards five people will have died, alongside numerous others who were injured, we don't know who. Quite probably some of the dead or injured will be characters that Jonathan Lee has so beautifully brought to life in the pages of this book.
Teenager Freya is the star of the show, full of the uncertainty and bravado of youth. Her father Moose is the Deputy General Manager at the Grand Hotel, and she works at the hotel too, alongside a host of other well drawn characters.
One of the bombers is Dan, whose sections are the darkest but which are equally credible. Dan lives with his aged mother in a Protestant area of Belfast where some of the neighbours harass them, and the Royal Ulster Constabulary humiliate him and his Catholic friends. Dan blames the police for the death of his father, who was hit by a brick during a civil rights rally.
To say anymore about the plot is to undermine a brilliantly told story which, despite the dark subject matter, is frequently gentle, funny and life reaffirming. Highly recommended.
5/5![]()
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


Very much looking forward to following Jonathan Lee’s career, and will buy whatever comes next upon publication.
Thanks Mark - that is as good a guarantee of quality as I know. I try to get to Who is Mr Satoshi? before top much longer

I've just finished Room at the Top (1957) by John Braine
I loved it
If, like me, you’ve been meaning to read this book for years, then delay no more, it’s a classic. If you’re interested in social trends, and post-war fiction, then read it. Actually, just read it.
Click here to read my review
5/5
I loved it
If, like me, you’ve been meaning to read this book for years, then delay no more, it’s a classic. If you’re interested in social trends, and post-war fiction, then read it. Actually, just read it.
Click here to read my review
5/5

I have just finished 'Ma’am Darling: 99 Glimpses of Princess Margaret'
Craig Brown, who I have never read before, does an inspired job of taking this rigorously research material and creating a highly original, always compelling, thought provoking read. By the end I was genuinely fascinated by Margaret and felt I had got to understand her.
For all Margaret's snobbishness and privilege, I felt quite sorry for her by the book's conclusion. Her ill treatment by her husband, and the diarists who laughed at her behind her back, helped render her bizarre life a tragedy.
Click here to read my review
Craig Brown, who I have never read before, does an inspired job of taking this rigorously research material and creating a highly original, always compelling, thought provoking read. By the end I was genuinely fascinated by Margaret and felt I had got to understand her.
For all Margaret's snobbishness and privilege, I felt quite sorry for her by the book's conclusion. Her ill treatment by her husband, and the diarists who laughed at her behind her back, helped render her bizarre life a tragedy.
Click here to read my review


I should perhaps qualify my review slightly. It's not a regular biog. Far from it. Quite meta in some ways. Asking how we can really believe anything we hear about other people? It's also, in part, very playful: one incident is rewritten in numerous different styles (angry, as a limerick, alliteratively etc). I lapped all that stuff up but, I could well imagine, other readers might find it plain annoying. That qualification aside, I'd recommend it.
I've just finished 'Black Teeth and a Brilliant Smile' (about the life of troubled playwright Andrea Dunbar). I chose it for my book group.
Improbably Adelle Stripe has managed to make a page-turner out of this material, and that is a credit to both her writing skill, and also to the extraordinary Andrea Dunbar. All the dialogue rings true and the glimpses into Andrea’s thoughts and feelings are also completely credible. It’s a brilliant, concise (230 pages), darkly humorous, tragic, fascinating book which brings a talented, troubled, shy young woman to life whilst also unerringly evoking 1980s Britain. Wonderful.
5/5
Click here to read my review
Improbably Adelle Stripe has managed to make a page-turner out of this material, and that is a credit to both her writing skill, and also to the extraordinary Andrea Dunbar. All the dialogue rings true and the glimpses into Andrea’s thoughts and feelings are also completely credible. It’s a brilliant, concise (230 pages), darkly humorous, tragic, fascinating book which brings a talented, troubled, shy young woman to life whilst also unerringly evoking 1980s Britain. Wonderful.
5/5
Click here to read my review

Books mentioned in this topic
Men in Love (other topics)Spoilt Creatures (other topics)
Pop. 1280 (other topics)
Pop. 1280 (other topics)
To a Dubious Salvation (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Amy Twigg (other topics)Jim Thompson (other topics)
Jim Thompson (other topics)
Charlie Higson (other topics)
Kirkland Ciccone (other topics)
More...
I have just finished reading:
" A Very English Scandal" by John Preston.
This enormously readable account of the late 1970s Jeremy Thorpe/ Norman Scott affair and trial is extraordinarily contemporary and timely. Written almost as a thriller, and despite the fact that one must sometimes ask about the authenticity of the reported conversations and telephone calls, to which there were no witnesses, it is nonetheless a compelling and disturbing, at times desperate portrayal of the corruption, immorality and hypocrisy of the Establishment political elite, closing ranks to protect one of their own.