Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
Popular Topics
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 3551:
by
Sarah
(new)
Apr 21, 2017 03:13PM

reply
|
flag



I, too, was "underwhelmed" by Brave New World. I contributed my lack of excitement to having read 1984 just before having begun Brave New World. In my opinion, I feel there is no comparing the two works. 1984 is a masterpiece. Brave New World is an alsoran.

I, too, was "underwhelmed" by Brave New World. I contributed my lack of excitement to having read 1984 jus..."
I actually read Brave New World first, but I agree that there isn't really any comparison. But I might just think that because I didn't get it? I was blown away by 1984 though. One of my three 5 stars this year.



Mia wrote: "I finished Under the Skin by Michel Faber. It was way better than I thought it would be. 4 stars. Now I want to read more Faber!"
I just recently read this and also rated it 4 stars. Creative.
I just recently read this and also rated it 4 stars. Creative.

Diane wrote: "Finished At Swim-Two-Birds by Flann O'Brien."
I also have just finished At Swim-Two-Birds, our group's monthly group-read. Apparently only a few others are also reading it- a shame, because he had a great flair and the creative structure was rather marvelous once I got the hang of it.
I also have just finished At Swim-Two-Birds, our group's monthly group-read. Apparently only a few others are also reading it- a shame, because he had a great flair and the creative structure was rather marvelous once I got the hang of it.
Sarah wrote: "Finished The Last Chronicle of Barset by Anthony Trollope. The series was delightful and I'm glad I read them all!"
Apparently the last volume is considered the best- is that your opinion?
Apparently the last volume is considered the best- is that your opinion?

It's well written but I grew tired of the complaints and whining from two characters. To the degree where their sudden death would have been pleasant! Too much victimization and when it hails from a man it's pretty hard to swallow. I'll be curious to see what you think when you read it.




I believe it's more affecting due to the protagonist's maturity and our capacity to relate to her plight much more.

and I also read Cider With Rosie which I really enjoyed.


2 stars
Brighton Rock - English noir. Far more grounded in realism than all of the American noirs I've read and that made it more enjoyable. It wasn't very subtle in its message of pagan good vs catholic bad though.
3 stars.
Titus Groan - It'd been really looking forward to this one and was disappointed. It's amazingly well written - the prose is incredible. A little too much so at times and the little plot there was rather blundered along after the writing.
3 stars

Oh, that's too bad! I was surprised by how much I liked this book, perhaps because I was so hesitant about reading it in the first place. Are you going to power on with the second book since it's also on the list? I might have liked it more than the first, and there is more of a plot.

Oh yes I definitely am. I gave it a 3 star which means I think it was 'good' it was just that I was rather expecting to rate it 'excellent' or 'absolutely fantastic!' and so was a bit disappointed that I didn't like it all 'that' much.

I read Bleak House on serial reader over about 5 months, and I listened to The Brothers Karamazov on audio. I enjoyed both of them.
I feel like I haven't posted in such a long time thanks to the behemoth book I have been reading for the last 2 1/2 weeks. I feel a huge sense of accomplishment at having finally read and completed Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace.

But did you like it? I thought some of it was absolutely fantastic. Some not so much. Some of it downright silly, but some laugh out loud funny. What they hey, it's a big book. It ought to have all that in there.

I think each of our expectations and final feelings of the book are reversed of each other. I was the opposite.
Tricia wrote: "I feel huge sense of accomplishment after finishing Bleak House and The Brothers Karamazov yesterday. I read Bleak House on serial reader over about 5 months..."
I took about that long to read Bleak House also, and when my reading of it was over, I missed it. You're very ambitious to read 2 long ones at once. I'm reading Moby Dick and Dead Souls now and sometimes wish I hadn't taken on both at once.
I took about that long to read Bleak House also, and when my reading of it was over, I missed it. You're very ambitious to read 2 long ones at once. I'm reading Moby Dick and Dead Souls now and sometimes wish I hadn't taken on both at once.
Bryan wrote: "Diane wrote: "I feel a huge sense of accomplishment at having finally read and completed Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace..."
But did you like it? I thought some of it was absolutely fantasti..."
I felt exactly the same way as you described. Parts of it were absolutely brilliant, but other parts were just okay. I noticed that most people gave it a 5 rating. I gave it a 4. I am glad to have read it, but it really was taxing on the brain and I am happy to have it behind me.
But did you like it? I thought some of it was absolutely fantasti..."
I felt exactly the same way as you described. Parts of it were absolutely brilliant, but other parts were just okay. I noticed that most people gave it a 5 rating. I gave it a 4. I am glad to have read it, but it really was taxing on the brain and I am happy to have it behind me.
Finished Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency by Douglas Adams of England. Very off-the-wall scifi-mystery-ghost story. This is a group read this month for the "Read, Share, Enjoy" Goodreads group. We read a book from a different genre each month and next month we're reading The Heart is a Lonely Hunter if anyone cares to join in.

I read it with a fantastic book group and most of us gave it a 5 star rating but at least one person dropped out and one other didn't like as much as the rest of us.
For me it was a book that I found almost impossible to describe. I could throw every superlative at it and still not convey how much I enjoyed it :-)
Nicola wrote: "Diane wrote: I felt exactly the same way as you described. Parts of it were absolutely brilliant, but other parts were just okay. I noticed that most people gave it a 5 rating. I gave it a 4. I am ..."
It is impossible to describe. It is more of an experience than a novel, if that makes sense. I enjoyed it immensely the majority of the time. I think I got antsy in the end because it was the only book I read in almost 3 weeks. I usually read a few books simultaneously, but I couldn't with this one. It demanded by undivided attention.
It is impossible to describe. It is more of an experience than a novel, if that makes sense. I enjoyed it immensely the majority of the time. I think I got antsy in the end because it was the only book I read in almost 3 weeks. I usually read a few books simultaneously, but I couldn't with this one. It demanded by undivided attention.
Just finished Story of O by Pauline Réage. Definitely cringe-worthy, but not nearly as much as I anticipated.

Oh yes...
This was the last comment in my very inadequate review:
I can't really explain this book and its impact on me. It was an experience to be lived through and I'm so very glad I did.

I was surprised to find both of Adams' Dirk Gently books on the list. I liked them (the first much more than the second) because they appeal to my sense of humor in the same way the Hitchiker series does, but I never would have put them in a 'must-read' category. I can support the Hitchhiker series, and can probably even go along with this first Dirk Gently book, but I wouldn't be surprised if The Long Dark Tea-Time of the Soul doesn't get sacrificed in later editions.
(Actually, I'm referencing a list that has all 1300+ entries on it, so I suppose Tea-Time could have already been cut, and I wouldn't know it.)
Nicola wrote: ".
Oh yes...
This was the last comment in my very inadequate review:
I can't really explain this book and its impact on me. It was an experience to be lived through and I'm so very glad I did. "
That really does sum it up perfectly.
Oh yes...
This was the last comment in my very inadequate review:
I can't really explain this book and its impact on me. It was an experience to be lived through and I'm so very glad I did. "
That really does sum it up perfectly.

Good for you! Eliminating the longer reads is very satisfying. Brothers Karamazov was on my list of possible reads this month. Right now I'm up in the air and haven't had anything jump out just yet.

It's brainwashing 101 with physical theatrics for good measure. ;-)

How was it? I'll be reading it soon for a book club.
Bryan wrote: "...but I wouldn't be surprised if The Long Dark Tea-Time of the Soul doesn't get sacrificed in later editions...."
My web site reference for the 2012 Boxall edition lists 2 books for Douglas Adams: The Hitch Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy and Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency. So you're right, The Long Dark Tea-Time was in the earlier edition, dropped from the later one.
My web site reference for the 2012 Boxall edition lists 2 books for Douglas Adams: The Hitch Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy and Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency. So you're right, The Long Dark Tea-Time was in the earlier edition, dropped from the later one.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Sword in the Stone (other topics)Cider With Rosie (other topics)
After the Quake (other topics)
Auto-da-Fé (other topics)
Walden or, Life in the Woods (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
T.H. White (other topics)Laurie Lee (other topics)
Haruki Murakami (other topics)
Elias Canetti (other topics)
Henry David Thoreau (other topics)
More...