Wizard, Elf , Dwarf , Kinght or Rider...

[Elizabeth]

Witch, elf, or werewolf!

[Becky]

If I'm in an adventurous mood, an Elf. If I'm in a more laid-back, enjoy life mood, a Hobbit.

[Donna]

Oh, I am totally a Hobbit. Extra pantries and extra meals. There is none of Belladonna Took's family in me. I would stay in my happy little Hobbit hole with my books by the fire, and let the dwarves tell me about how things shook out under the mountain later, assuming they lived through it.

PS GREAT discussion topic! Love it.

[Lariela]

I'd probably be an Elf or a Wizard.

[Tar]

I have wanted to be each and all at different times but I suppose I hold Riders in high esteem.

[Squidalz]

I would be an Elf-wizard-dragonrider! I couldn't decide between the three ^.^

[Michael]

Has to be a Dwarve! Mining and cutting gems and Mithril, ooh Mithril! :)

[Lia]

I would like to be an elf dragon rider that would be the best and most awesome experience.

[Joy]

I am 100% Lothlórien elf :)

[Lia]

Joy wrote: "I am 100% Lothlórien elf :)"

how nice.

[Joy]

Thanks! If I had to pick another one, I would probably choose an elven dragon rider. :D

[Lia]

Joy wrote: "Thanks! If I had to pick another one, I would probably choose an elven dragon rider. :D"

it has a nice ring to it doesn't it.

[Nicholas]

Nazgul for me :)

[Kyren]

A rider. They are so awesome!

[Joy]

Haha, it does have a nice ring to it... and Arya is so perfect for the job! :D

[Patrick]

Tom Bombadil.

[Neel]

riders rule!

[[deleted user]]

SO HARD FOR ME TO DECIDE!!! But I think being an Elf or a Rider seems really cool, so yeah.

[Reign]

Definitely an Elf.

[Geoffrey]

Hobbits are a bit too conventional for me, although the idea of eating mushrooms is appetizing. I would go for an elf or wizard. I would love to be around Kate Blanchett`s or Liv Tyler`s ilk.

[Sparrowlicious]

A hobbit.
Let's be honest, I like staying at home, minding my own business and food is goood. As a hobbit you're allowed to indulge as much as you want. Plus, you get to have hairy feet without anyone being stupid about it. Which brings me to: no more having to wear shoes. Yes.
(Before anyone has any misconceptions about my health or my weight: I'm an average looking person and by that I mean I'm not overweight but society would still say I should lose weight, lol.)

Edit: some of the things in the first post have nothing to do with Lotr, so you can pretty much exclude 'dragon rider', 'vampire' and 'werewolf'.

[J.D.]

elfs kick ass
admittedly they've had most of their adventures, but they're still amazing

[Geoffrey]

Come on people, it`s elves.

[Jenn]

It's tough between Dragon Rider of Elf. On one hand elves are awesome and have magic, but on the other hand dragons.

[Willow]

If we're talking Pernese Dragon Rider, I'd be there all the way. But assuming we're keeping with the mythos of Middle Earth, I'd choose Hobbit or Elf, depending on my mood.

[Nellie ☾]

The elves look handsome/pretty, it'll be awesome to be one haha :D Hobbits are cute as well, must be because of their height. But I want to be an elf.

[Jenna]

Elf or Dragon Rider :)

[Harry]

Easy! Wizard! After all the Istari were lesser gods...

[Rashmika]

Wizard, elf, knight.... cant I be all of them!!

[Dimitrios]

A Wizard, and not just a wizard; an Istari ;)

[Cybersekkin]

your list is missing humans. Hey look I got my wish :-P

[Befw]

An elf :D

[Tahca]

An Elf! I think their better than vampires because they can live just as long, but their not creepy and they don't suck blood

[Olivia]

I'd like to be a Vampy Elf!

[Joel]

What about Rangers?

[Joel]

Sparrowlicious wrote: "some of the things in the first post have nothing to do with Lotr, so you can pretty much exclude 'dragon rider', 'vampire' and 'werewolf'."

Actually in the Silmarilian, Tolkien mentions what he calls Werewolves, although I'm fairly certain that they're basically just like ginormous talking wolves as opposed to the morphing Lycanthropes of traditional legend. The most notable of the werewolves in LOTR are Draugluin (a big nasty wolf that guarded one of Sauron's fortresses) and Huan (who, it could be argued, is not actually a werewolf, but something else [as he was only allowed to speak 3 times, and the fact that he was good]). And yes, I _am_ a nerd. Or at least, I pretend to be.

[Kyra]

Wizard

[Abby]

Elf.

[F.F.]

were-hobbit

[Robert]

I'm probably best suited to a hobbit, but I can't deny being a Wizard would be very very cool.

[Dave]

Elf or Wizard. Magic rules.
About the question itself, I like what S.M. Stirling did with Rangers in his later Change novels.

[[deleted user]]

Elf, rider, or a witch

[Anna]

Elf. definitely an Elf. or maybe a hobbit...because they are so much fun :D

[Michele]

Wizard, no doubt!

[Onome]

In The Lord of the Rings world? Were there ever werewolves? Anyway, I would definately be an Elf. They are super cool.

[☆Ruth☆]

Elf - I want to live in Loth Lorien and/or Rivendell....

[[deleted user]]

I am totally a wood elf at heart. You just have to get past my beard to find out.

[Ruby]

I would be a Rider of Rohan because I would take pride in fighting for what I believe in. Also, I might meet Dernhelm.

[Bridgette]

Elf, dragon rider, or werewolf, and I love the Ranger idea too!!! :)

[James]

I would love to be a Elf or a Dragon Rider.