Outlander Series discussion
How did you find the Outlander Series?
message 51:
by
Leslie
(new)
Jul 01, 2009 08:19AM

reply
|
flag

Well started the book today and am enjoying it very much.

Hi I'm Fiona & I'm an Outlander-a-holic! lol

My question is, are the references to the land and the area in Scotland portrayed in Outlander accurate? And are the people of Scotland like the ones in the books?

I would consider myself a non-fiction guy and still can't believe how this happened. I stumbled into historical fiction a while back with Pompeii. Then a friend I met here through Goodreads in my audiobook group recommended Outlander to me. I love Davina Porter as the reader, am on book 4, and still can't believe I like something my wife would refer to as chic lit.
It's a great series but I'm not out there discussing it with my buddies. It has to be my own guilty little secret :)

It's great to see a man reading and enjoying this series. I'm on ABOSAA now (pg. 590) It's a real page turner for sure! Drums of Autumn was my favorite of the series, but A Breath of Snow and Ashes is quickly becoming a favorite too.. oh, who am I kidding, I love them all!

It is great to see a man enjoying the series. Grumpus, I would love to know how you feel about Jamie and Claire? Is Jamie and unrealistic "man" figure to you? And what about Claire? How does she look throught a man's eyes?

Mike, I can't wait to hear your perspective on these books.

I am also interested in Mike's perspective on Jamie and Claire, what an interesting question! I'll be looking for his response!

Wow, I feel like I have to come up with some deep, insightful, sensitive answer here. But I'm a guy...a guy who wishes he could be as smooth as Jamie. Tough when he needs to be tough and sensitive when he needs to be sensitive with a high sense of morality. I can see why women love him and from my perspective, men would want to be like him. He is the ideal from the perspective of either gender.
I don't envision Claire as the ideal woman in a physical sense (which is unusual for us men) but in every other aspect she is so very attractive. Her attractiveness to me comes from three things in order of importance, 1) her devotion to Jamie, 2)her understanding (of most things...a tad jealous...but I could understand why), and 3) her feistiness.
I have to say, I've listened to Davina Porter narrate these books and I would also have to confess that Davina's voice as Claire is a turn-on and she probably would not be as attractive to me if I was reading the books and had to come up with my own voice for her. When I'm listening to these books, I hear Davina doing the voices of Jamie and Claire in my head throughout the day. I sometimes even hear my own thoughts in Jamie's voice. That is a tell-tale sign of a great narrator!
I've listened to the first 3 books and have switched back to non-fiction temporarily for a break but will be on to the fourth book within the month...just don't tell my buddies :-)

I have not had the chance to hear Davina Porter narrate the books yet, I did rent the abridged ( no unabridged available) version from my library of Voyager...of course lots of things were left out and I HATED how this lady did Jamie...I had to stop the CD..yuk..oh weel
Now, you need to read the rest of the series!!!( just like a woman telling ya what to do!) we won't tell your buddies we swear! We just like your input!!

I would love to hear the audio version of these books. I've been listening to the audio version of the Twilight Saga and I know what you mean about the voices getting in your head. It *is* the tell-tale sign of a great narrator.
I (we) look forward to hearing more from you when you get back to Volume 4!

Do I need to purchase the disc's at a bookstore? Then do I have to download them on my computer in order to download them onto an I-pod or do I have to join something like Audible.com or the such?
Any help would be greatly appreciated!


OMG! you should at least get through Voyager it picks off where DIA ends and ties up lots of loose ends! I think it is one of the best out of the series! Have fun!




Cynthia I bought Outlander on iTunes and it was totally easy. It was just like buying music. I'm sure one of your kids could show you how to do it! thats who helped me!! LOL
I've also heard it's easy to do at Audible.com and they have that first 3 months/books for 7.95 thing. I keep meaning to do that!


My question is, are the references to the land and the area in..."
Hi Wendy, thanks for the warm welcome.
I'm not sure i will give the answers that you want but i will try my best. The refrence to the land is as close as it is ever going to get for the highlands, what i've seen of them. I always find it rather nice hearing how someone else discribes the Scottish scenary & land areas. I live on the north east coast but about an hour by car from Culloden, eerie place especially at night.
As for the people of Scotland well mostly we are all a friendly bunch who can be extreamly patriotic & passionate. Most of us love our food & a wee dram just like everyone else. There are still loads of places in Scotland i've still not visited but i was lucky as my mam & dad lived beside Glasgow & moved up to the north east so i spent alot of time travelling north to south & vise versa to visit Grandparents.
I hope this has answered your question.

Well, I have to say I am officially a complete addict. I am on the second book and absolutely love them. My husband is even reading the first one now. I want to thank all that recommended it!!!!


I always look for the thickest book I can find and these certainly fill that bill! I don't usually read romance novels - always preferred a good murder mystery, but I was hooked on Outlander from the start. Now I've read the entire series at least twice (the older books even more). I'm really glad that my hand landed on Outlander when I was looking for a new book to read.

My question is, are the references to the land and the area in..."
I'm not a Scots but I did spend three weeks in Scotland last year exploring places mentioned in Diana's books. My base was The Highlands. Since I've read them at least four times each, I am fairly familiar with the locales in the books so I visited as many as I could. I toured Culloden (eeringly haunting place is an understatement!) and talked to a guide there who'd met "Herself" when she came for the opening of the new Visitor's Center. Couldn't speak enough kind words about her.
Every Scots I met was a friendly as you could possibly imagine and very, very proud of their country and heritage. I think it safe to say they invented humorous self-deprecation. The land...well the land is achingly beautiful. I spent lots of time in the Highlands and Inverness, visited Fort William, Edinburgh, Stirling, Glasgow and toured the northwest coast including the Isle of Skye. I highly recommend a visit. Can't wait to go back.







Sappy is all goooood!

Yeah, I go back and read DIA when I'm needing a good cry.





I can't for tomorrow!
My best friend recommended the books to me three summers ago - and I almost didn't read them because I thought they boring old romance/chick lit (which I *really* have to be in the mood for, otherwise I've got too many other books on the To Be Read pile )!
And then two or three pages in when Claire talks about how full the shops are, I almost stopped reading. Heck, rationing went on in England until almost 1950! But then I thought, well maybe it's the copy editor's fault not the author's, and I kept reading. Plus I liked Claire and didn't like (smarmy) Frank. And then when she set Jamie's arm! I was hooked.
Thank goodness I didn't stop reading. Now I know it *was* the copy editors, not Diana, given the amazing quality of all her research. And to think of all the stuff I would have missed out on - a brilliant series, more books to come, lively discussion groups, a friendly writers forum, and so much new knowledge and vocabulary and avenues of interest... Wow. Not to mention all those funny, romantic, exciting, thoughtful scenes in the books.
:-)
Deniz


So it was on my "to-read" list forEVER (about 1 month)when I found the paperback at a thrift store. What a treasure!!!! I was hooked. I laughed, I cried, I worried... and I stopped a few chapters into Breath of Snow and Ashes. I don't want to read what I think is coming. But now with the new release I HAVE to. After Voyager... I just don't trust that everything is going to turn out all right because Diana is so... so... realistic. And that's what I love the most. I'm hoping to make it to her signing in a few weeks. I'm going to have to suck it up and get through Breath and Echo.
Angela - Definitely go on the trip!!!! I'm planning for 2012... I want my daughter to be old enough to remember and appreciate it. I sooooooooo wanted to go the the gathering this year... I need to win the lotto
My sisters (who both live overseas from me) were going on about how great this series was. I bought Cross Stitch earlier this year and as soon as I started reading, I couldn't put it down. As I worked my way through one book I was buying the next in eager anticipation. I have never read a series of books that I just couldn't get enough of. Yay - I'm just about ready to read Echo in the Bone now just as it's coming out in the stores, so that's great timing.
Diana will be here in Wellington, New Zealand for the launch and I'm hoping to get a ticket and get my new book autographed. I've always enjoyed reading but have never been as avid a reader as I am now. I used to read heaps when I was young and loved reading in bed. However, once I started working and got married, reading seemed to become less of a priority. Whenever I've had a spare moment I've picked up the book and read and read and read. This series has reintroduced me to the joy of reading again. To be able to write such a series is an amazing and rare skill and I am so happy that I have got to enjoy this series.
Diana will be here in Wellington, New Zealand for the launch and I'm hoping to get a ticket and get my new book autographed. I've always enjoyed reading but have never been as avid a reader as I am now. I used to read heaps when I was young and loved reading in bed. However, once I started working and got married, reading seemed to become less of a priority. Whenever I've had a spare moment I've picked up the book and read and read and read. This series has reintroduced me to the joy of reading again. To be able to write such a series is an amazing and rare skill and I am so happy that I have got to enjoy this series.


What a great website!! Anyways I just happened to discover a bookshop magazine yesterday and my fave author was on the cover! Yes Diana Gabaldon!Her new one is coming out!
I "discovered" her when I was at school over 10 years now. Friends at school read it and I read it in the holidays. I gave it to my Grandmother and then it went to my Grandfather then my Aunty and then my Uncle. Then back again to my best friend!!
Absolutely mesmerising I think and I tell every one about it that they should read it!!
BTW Mellady77: Have you thought of putting that book on HOLD?? haha I do that all the time.
Im about to start reading TFC. Had it now for 8 years haha! Just never got around to reading the 980pg book.

Books mentioned in this topic
The Bronze Horseman (other topics)Into the Wilderness: The Long Hunters (other topics)
Dragonfly in Amber (other topics)
Gone with the Wind (other topics)
Dragonfly in Amber (other topics)
More...