Harry Potter discussion
This topic is about
Harry Potter Series Box Set
Books
>
Should J.K Rowling continue our beloved Harry Potter Series?
No... I think Harry Potter is done.I do wish she’d write proper books of the Fantastic Beasts series instead of those stupid script books.
Yes, I think she totally should! I have loved all of the movies. I've been wanting to read the books for a while now. So I am currently reading Prisoner of Azkaban. It is my favourite film, so I wanted to start reading that first. Once I finish it, I will start reading the 1st one then so on
No, I don't believe the series should continue. The Harry Potter books are utterly amazing. For generations to come, they will go down as some of the best children's literature ever written. The characters, magic, values, events and scope of the world are all a joy to read. However, the series has to end somewhere. I felt, from the seven books, we were told Harry's story. The last three words of Deathly Hallows summed it up - we had read and experienced his struggle and no more was required. I think a fascinating debate would be 'What was the case for J.K Rowling killing Harry at the end of Deathly Hallows?' That could create lots of conversation.
If anything I'd like a prequel, after that disaster of a sequel the Cursed Child was. Unpopular opinion, I'd like to read about maybe Beauxbatons and life there with maybe Fleur as the main character. I think that'd be interesting.
I think that she should write about when james and lily were at hogwarts
I've always disliked the idea of sequels. E.g. suite life on deck after suite life of Zack and Cody. Don't get me wrong, I loved the show after watching the first episode i saw. But I've always hated moving on from the original. So, I would prefer it if J.K. Rowling would write more on the adventures of the Golden Trio in Hogwarts.
Emma wrote: "I think that she should write about when james and lily were at hogwarts"Me too!!
Harry Potter is by far one of my favorite series but I feel like it should be left as what it is and left where it was ended
I would love for there to be more added on to the story, but after the disaster that is The Cursed Child, I'm so disappointed I absolutely don't want anything else to be potentially damaged.
Dana-Rae wrote: "Harry Potter is by far one of my favorite series but I feel like it should be left as what it is and left where it was ended"YES! Completely agree! Cursed Child was a total trainwreck, if you ask me.
- ̗̀ jessica ̖́- wrote: "I would love for there to be more added on to the story, but after the disaster that is The Cursed Child, I'm so disappointed I absolutely don't want anything else to be potentially damaged."If the rules of the original books were followed, maybe another book would be fun, but "All was well" was really good enough for me, and I loathed Cursed Child.
Bookworm234 wrote: "Emma wrote: "I think that she should write about when james and lily were at hogwarts"Me too!!" I agree
I just think she should focus on Fantastic Beasts and the Ilvermony Houses. Is she wrote books about Ilvermony that would be the best thing ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🤓🤓🤓
Mikki Elodie the Ravenclaw Faery wrote: "I just think she should focus on Fantastic Beasts and the Ilvermony Houses. Is she wrote books about Ilvermony that would be the best thing ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🤓🤓🤓"I would totally read any book taking place in Ilvermony!!! I'm dying to know more about it besides just the houses!
Julia wrote: "- ̗̀ jessica ̖́- wrote: "I would love for there to be more added on to the story, but after the disaster that is The Cursed Child, I'm so disappointed I absolutely don't want anything else to be po..."Same omg. Cursed Child was an abomination. A disgrace xD The series ended at All was well for me.
please keep writing more books in this series! i would love to see what happens with the relationships. if they have kids and stuff like that.
Yes. I don't think she should try to make a sequel or continue the story as they tried with cursed child, but do as she's been doing, write books - Such as 'Quidditch Through the Ages', 'Short Stories From Hogwarts', and 'Tales of Beedle the Bard' - in order to expand the Potterverse. She might even consider writing a prequel story about Voldemort'ss childhood, or DUmbledor's childhood. Build upon his relationship with Grindelwald, the death of Arianna, and his search for the Deathly Hallows. I would also love to see a story that goes through the lives of the Marauders, and their countless escapades and adventures. So, in answer to the question, yes, JK should write more books, but not continuing the story we all know and love, but expanding the ever-changing universe of Harry Potter.
I do not think she should continue on in Harry's story either, i think that that story is done, but I would love to see more of the Hogwarts' library.
I feel like she should, I want to know what happens after the Battle of Hogwarts. The Cursed Child disappointed me, and it did NOT feel like the Harry Potter world/series at all...
No, Cursed Child didn't live up to expectations, and I would want to know what happened, but I think that she left some strands dangling, and left us to imagine what happened afterward. I think that when an author leaves the rest to her readers imagination it keeps interest in her series, instead of just cutting all loose threads, she has set loose our imaginations to fill in the blanks. of course, it would be nice, but then what would we have left to think about?
The Harry Potter series was a great read. And I didn't want it to go. I remember when it first came out in 1997 and me and my friends loved it. It would be great if she continued the series!
(I probably already posted my opinion in this chat, but I'm too lazy to go back and check). I don't think Rowling should do anything else with HP. Fantastic Beasts is great, but its time to be over and done with.
Oh J K Rowling has moved on from Harry Potter. I read news about Ickabog, new JK Rowling book announced today.
I got a craving for harry potter once again (though I have a full collection of 7 books paperback). But I am thinking of reading similar books like
This list of 20 books like harry potter
I am thinking of The Night Circus in particular.
I would love to see more books on the HP world. Cursed Child was good in its own right but there wasn’t too much on Harry and his friends, which detracted from the story, as I kept expecting more about them. Every time I read the series, I’m always aching to read more.
I just reread the books , I am devastated, HELP!
Although I was sad when it ended, I thought that the ending was peaceful and simple. The Cursed Child and the Fantastic Beasts movies seem like a bit of a money grab for JK Rowling. :(
The books ended with a good finale, but I would love to read more in the Wizarding World. Harry Potter is a very easy and enjoyable series to reread, yet something new--maybe a prequel series about the prior generation or a sequel series featuring the Golden Trio's children.
Yes, I have some interesting ideas that everyone should appreciate. First, I want to say right away that Harry Potter is my favorite character, who always inspires me. I even want to make a digital quest room in the style of my favorite hero. Unfortunately this is not my idea, I read the article https://www.raisingedmonton.com/you-c... and realized that I want to make it happen. It seems to me that this is a genius idea, because there are Harry Potter fans all over the world, from the smallest to the adults. Since now there is a global pandemic, people are inventing a variety of ways to entertain the people.
Given her recently surfaced hatred of certain people, I've cooled on her. She's disappointed me severely, and proven she's a hypocrite: She rights are equality for all and not judging people throughout all seven books, and then goes and oppresses people and judges them. Nah. Harry Potter was fun in the past, and now it can stay in the past, IMO.
I’m not sure if I would want more stories in the Harry Potter universe to be released now. I used to want more quite desperately, specially about the next generation characters. After The Cursed Child and the Fantastic Beasts films not living up to the original in my view, I’ve taken refuge in fanfiction. There’s some good next gen fanfics out there. That isn’t to say that I won’t go and watch the play if I ever get the chance though
I don't really like the ending of Harry Porter, there's too many losses. But still, it's good enough, so I don't want it keep going. It's better to stop here so that we can keep our good memories about it. Few days ago, I found this Harry porter t-shirton the internet, well, we all know that it's about google ads (and they follow my clicks), but it really touching, you know, after many year being a fan, now I just realized that it's 20 years since the first time I read the story about that boy Harry, and I dont wanna my fav series to lose its magic, so yeah, I don't need any more books.
I believe Harry's story is great how it is and does not need any additional books for his story. Still, I would not mind any prequel stories to other characters we have met in the books even if just some short stories.
I am very happy with the whole 7-book series JK Rowling rolled out on Harry Potter. Best part of it was her writing and ability to describe each character so perfectly. I think it will be very difficult for her to do justice to the book(prequel/sequel) if she rolls out another in same series. May be a different series on a completely different character altogether could be good option. Like on Ted Lupin.
I feel like expanding more on the Harry Potter series is like adding sequels to the original Star Wars movies: it would just take away the magic of the series and make it tacky.
I badly wants J K Rowling to continue the series , but I don't want poor Harry in more trouble , he has had enough in all his 7 years at Hogwards. I think it'd be fantastic if she wrote a book on the marauders
OF COURSE
So I am a really fast reader i finished all the books in 8 days I want more lets make a petition ......lol
So I am a really fast reader i finished all the books in 8 days I want more lets make a petition ......lol
I think Rowling should write a book about The Maruders or a prequel from Snape's pov. I really need a prequel.
Zara wrote: "I think Rowling should write a book about The Maruders or a prequel from Snape's pov. I really need a prequel."
YES YASSSS
YES YASSSS
I don't think she necessarily needs to continue books based on Harry. But I would love to see more books or short stories based on others in the Harry Potter Universe. It would be awesome to read more about The Marauders, or Hagrid's life after he was expelled, or Snape's life when he first joined the Death Eaters, etc. It would even be cool to see more adventures at Ilvermorny.
If she were to write more, I would like them to be fact checked as necessary. Don't want another Fantastic Beasts situations, where there were mistakes made, such as McGonagall being a grown woman when she shouldn't even have been born yet.
Sarah wrote: "While I think Harry's story ended well, I'd like to see a prequel about the years with the Marauders, Lily and Snape being its told quite a bit in the HP series, I think there is much she could sha..." yeah that would be good
I think the series ended on a good note. I also like the little branch books that have come out of it. They are informative and entertaining. I like learning about the Wizarding World.
I think that the end to the series was wonderful, and...honestly adding another book might ruin it a bit for me. I think that side books like fantastic beasts and where to find them are great though
I think things ended perfectly in deathly hallows. Many people, myself included, were disappointed with cursed child. We all have this version of the characters in our heads from our childhood, and seeing them change through such a large period of time was sad to say the least. That being said, I would definitely love more wizarding world content, just not a continuation of Harry’s story. I know many people would enjoy a marauders series. Or perhaps even Harry’s story written from someone else’s perspective (dumbledoor’s, hermionies, e.c.t)
What needs to happen is a Marauders series.
No. People are already mad and I'd rather the series be left alone. Plus it would be boring because, tbh, I wouldn't want to read about the trio working at an office and managing life. I used to think a Marauder's prequel would be cool but I think it should be left to fanfiction.
☾ Luna ☽ wrote: "No. People are already mad and I'd rather the series be left alone. Plus it would be boring because, tbh, I wouldn't want to read about the trio working at an office and managing life. I used to th..."Yes, or a movie should be made.
Let's hope it doesn't come to a fanfic like Cursed Child being official.
Gourica wrote: "☾ Luna ☽ wrote: "No. People are already mad and I'd rather the series be left alone. Plus it would be boring because, tbh, I wouldn't want to read about the trio working at an office and managing l..."Yeah.
Cursed Child is a perfect example of a money-grab; if she'd ever write a new story (which would be very controversial) it better be genuine and not OOC.
I completely agree I can't believe she let it be published, although my grandfather liked it, my mother and brother are on the fence, I felt it ruined my perception of the wizarding world.