Classics Without All the Class discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
What else are you reading?
>
Where is your bookmark?
message 51:
by
Andrew✌️
(new)
Mar 14, 2013 03:07PM

reply
|
flag



That’s the truth. Maybe we don’t like it, maybe we brush it under the carpet to delude ourselves that the world is full of good people and good always triumphs over evil. But the world has its fare share of Dursleys. Maybe not everyone is bad. But J.K. Rowling have focused her lens on the ‘riff-raffs’ of the society, the snobbish and selfish upper class, few good people trying to improve the situation (which even they know in their heart would never be remedied) and all their dirt in sharp detail in ‘The Casual Vacancy’. It’s of course not a happy book to read, but it does keep a person engaged.
But before I review the book further, I would like to state a point that, though I have just read a couple of book written by British authors about Britain, I feel that J.K. had overstated the malice and the dirt a wee bit. Maybe I feel that is because practically every family mentioned here is sick in some or the other manner (except Kay’s family or the Jawanda’s, with Barry Fairbrother cutting across as a figurative saint (though dead)), but yet I refuse to believe everyone to be that bad in the real world. I know I am being incorrect here; the book confuses me as the personalities of the characters cannot be sharply divided into black and white. It’s fucking grey, with some characters a darker shade of it. And the end is uncertain, it is maybe and hopefully a somewhat happily ever after kind of thing, but you couldn’t be too sure.
The story as such is simple. Barry Fairbrother is dead. And he has left a gaping hole in the hearts of those who adored him and a casual vacancy in the Councilor’s seat. There is a fierce competition to get that seat. Opinions are divided. A perennial knife hangs on the fate of the Bellchapel Addiction Clinic and the people who are categorized as the ‘riff-raffs’ (the people from the Fields) may/can be pushed outside the (jurisdiction of) precinct of Pagford, a stupid little proud town with its neat houses and charming surroundings.
People say it’s different from Harry Potter, yet I choose to believe differently. Maybe Harry died in the first 4 pages, but we have Dursleys in Mollisons, a sort of good Wormtail in Colin Walls, Stuart or Fat Walls trying to be a Voldemort but of course he fails in his ambition. We have a Neville Longbottom in Sukhvinder, Hermione in Kay (Elves’ rights or a social worker), Madam Maxime in Maureen (both trying to dress out of their age and height, but at least Madam Maxime was good and respectable), a Molly in Tessa Wall and a Ron (minus the kind-hearted father) in Andrew.
I indeed liked this book. And one of the major reasons has to be that she projected the Indians as good Samaritans. No, here they aren’t exactly geeks, nor are they supremely spiritual. They aren’t as narrow-minded as stereotypically portrayed in Hollywood films and some books on “India” written by foreign authors, nor are they lascivious ruthless businessmen lusting the ‘gori madam’. Nor are there any major goof-ups in Indian names (I sometimes am still amused by Padma Patil and Parvati Patil!!!) and Vikram looks like a Bollywood hero! In short, they are projected as normal people, with religion as a part of their life, but just a part.
From time to time, people like being projected normal. Anyone listening in the West, we are normal!
I must say, J.K. Rowling might have received a Booker Prize (or been a major contender) for ‘The Casual Vacancy’ had she not written Harry Potter prior to it. I liked this book, but it would be too much if I said that, I loved it…


Actually I saw the show then read the books. I had to stop though because I didn't like knowing more about what was to come in future seasons since Jared doesn't read them, but watches the show and I can't keep a secret.

Actually I saw the show then read the books. I had to..."
Ha! I'm kind of terrible at keeping secrets, too. Plus, I end up anticipating how closely a show or movie will stay to the original story.






But so good. What is The Game? What is the circus about? So many good questions. Now I don't want to talk about it because I'll want to re-read and I don't have time for that mess. ;)

But so good. What is The Game? What is the circus a..."
I can't wait to find out!






I haven't time enough to read it now, but I'll start as soon as possible


I have heard so many great things about The Tenant of Wildfell Hall . I wish I had more time to read. There is a burning to desire for me to pick up, as soon as Anna is finished. Please, share with us what you think afterwards.


Oh The Language of Flowers is on my very long TBR pile. Your recommendation might move it up a few spots though! :)





A similar thread for what we're reading? Since this one is only 2 pages I think we'll keep it open. I will take the March date off so no one gets confused.

Author of The Language of Flowers please? I found 3 books with the same title!

Author of The Language of Flowers please? I found 3 books with the same title!"
The Language of Flowers is the one I was talking about. I don't know if was the same as Carina's.

After that, I'll be tackling A Storm of Swords by George RR Martin.


Yes, I thought about opening one this month, but since this one wasn't very full, I decided against it. I just wanted to make sure that is what you were referring to since I wasn't sure in your original post. Until this one starts getting overly long, we'll just use this one. Same as the introduction thread. I had been opening new ones each month due to the constant activity, but it looks like we've slowed down a lot.
Thanks for the help.

I'm currently reading The Woman in white, among others but that is the classic I'm reading! I started a classics challenge with my friend trish on our blogs! It's helping read these wonderful books :) http://diamondlovestoread.blogspot.com



I just bought it on our SF bookstore tour! I can't wait to start it. I just finished Life After Life and loved it. So many ways to live a life and this is just one person. Intriguing.

Anyone who has read this book before?"
I did. I wasn't that impressed with it, some parts are good, but overall I felt it was hugely overrated.




I've watched the anime on TV a couple of years ago and I liked. Do you know if the manga follow the same plot or is different?

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Love in the Time of Cholera (other topics)The Complete Grimm's Fairy Tales (other topics)
A Tale of Two Cities (other topics)
A Tale of Two Cities (other topics)
Love in the Time of Cholera (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Daniel Defoe (other topics)Mark Z. Danielewski (other topics)
Daphne du Maurier (other topics)
Dashiell Hammett (other topics)
Fyodor Dostoevsky (other topics)
More...