Breaking Dawn
discussion
(*SPOILERS INCLUDED*) Breaking Dawn Movie Part 2
message 51:
by
Ireland
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Nov 24, 2012 02:31PM
I was actually a bit disappointed with the movie. The fake baby face was terrible and I couldn't help but laugh at it. It was all really rushed and really cliched compared to the rest of the movies in the series which I loved.
reply
|
flag
Ivy wrote: "I was actually a bit disappointed with the movie. The fake baby face was terrible and I couldn't help but laugh at it. It was all really rushed and really cliched compared to the rest of the movies..."I did think that Renesmee sometimes looked fake, but that's okay. I didn't let it bother me. I thought this one was definently the most comical. I was so freaked out at the fight scene though.
Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was hard to believe all kinds of major characters were dropping dead. Oh well, not everybody can be happy.
Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was hard to believe..."OMG, yeah at first I think I wanted to kill the director, I was like "That was not in the book!" everyone gasped in the theater when Alice said that it was a vision. It cracked me up.
Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was hard to believe..."Can I ask which parts you think didn't follow the book? because I felt it followed the book really really well, in fact better than the other movies did.
Well I read the books so when I saw what was happening i'm like "WTH THAT'S NOT IN THE BOOK" freaked me out a lil bit!! lol
Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was har..."me too, this movie is like, perfectly put together!
Amanda wrote: "Well I read the books so when I saw what was happening i'm like "WTH THAT'S NOT IN THE BOOK" freaked me out a lil bit!! lol"ikr, i thought that the director was crazy, but SM was also on set so I was like, "I can't believe she would let this happen!" I was so happy when Alice was holding Aro's hand again.
Jordan wrote: "omg i started to cry i thought it was real. I swear i have never been more surprised in my life. I was like "I don't remember this from the book!!!!""Yeah, me and my friend were like "What the heck! This wasn't in the book!"
Bella wrote: "jane is such a btch....oh my god. I didnt hated her in new moon or in eclipse, I thought she was the most coolest volturi but hell I wanted her dead in BD2. When she started to run it was awsome. I..."One of my favorite scenes was when Jacob started taking his clothes off in front of Charlie. I started laughing. My friend was sitting next to me and was like "oh, my gosh" and laughed. They made the scene totally awkward. Also I liked all the scenes with Renesmee and Edward/Bella together.
Oh, and my theater was packed! I was lucky I found two seats together. :)
Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was har..."Well, in the book there was no future fight scene, when Bella shows Edward her mind she sees herself in the third person (not possible), Bella was mad at Jacob a lot longer and almost killed him, and there were no extra wolves coming from random places to join the pack.
Ivy wrote: "Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake si..."maybe, but the whole thing with the volturi in the books was a whole mind game, which is nearly impossible to show on screen. I liked the way they portrayed it.
I was like, woah. The Twilighters, or whatever they're called, are going to be PISSED. But when I realized it was just a vision of the future I was just like, woah, again. That's when it hit me that this movie was Stephanie Meyer's baby, and was the coolest thing she could've helped create to finally finish the Twilight saga. Because by watching this movie, you get to see the story from a perspective we would have never been able to understand in written form. So it makes me honored that I've read the books and experienced all the other awesome little things hidden in the books, and been able to experience Breaking Dawn the way the author really wanted it to be.
Jordan wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene..."Well, everybody has their own opinion.
Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake since it was hard to believe..."i thought it was real for a moment. anyway twilight the movie and twilight the book were quite different too.....
I adored their house!!!! it was devine.
Ivy wrote: "Jordan wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling ..."true. Sorry
These are my favorite parts:Bella kicking Jake's ass
Bella beating Emmett at arm wrestling
When Bella shielded Alice in her vision so she could kick Jane's butt
When Jake asked Edward if he could call him dad and Edward said umm...no
The Meadow scene
i did ALL OF THE ABOVE!!!!! omg did you think Aro's laugh was so funny i couldn't stop laughing i still laugh when i think about it!! lol I thought it was a great movie and a great way to end the series i personally loved it and think it was the best movie out of all!! (:
Emily wrote: "Aro's laugh was by far, extremely freaky! I loved it though! GIFSoup"
omg wasn't that the best thing ever? I busted out laughig in the theater!
idk i don't remember. I guess I'l have to go see the movie again!
Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."
Every... single... one...
The movie was so action packed and full of drama! This was the best movie! I want to just watch it over-and over-and over- again... :D
Abby wrote: "I love this movie!!!! It made me cy like a baby. I started to cry when during the flashback when Edward walked into the cafeteria for the first time, and the song was all like: The day we met. Froz..."I know right! I also cried at that part... They're not doing another movie... *sigh* I keep listening to that song and then... oh-my-gosh! I cried... And then everybody's all looking at me like: -.- -.- -.- And then i'm just right there... sobbing my heart out. I loved the song! That was the best part! So.. yeah: I agree with you completely.. :D
I keep listening to that song and I won't be surprised if I randomly start crying. That was one of the favorite parts of the movie. She takes of her shield and lets Edward read her thoughts... And then the song... Excuse me, I need to go cry at the corner over there. And the his voice when he was like, "Hello, I'm Edward Cullen" sigh.
(You're probably like •__________• "What's this weirdo doing?")
Anyways, yes... I had the exact same experience as you. SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS!!!!!!!!!!!!
I cringed at Aro' s laugh. Nothing was more shocking than that.
Ysabela wrote: "Abby wrote: "I love this movie!!!! It made me cy like a baby. I started to cry when during the flashback when Edward walked into the cafeteria for the first time, and the song was all like: The day..."I know right I was actually sobbing on my way out of the theatre such a sweet moment in the meadow and I couldn't think of a better song to accompany it then Christina Perri's a thousand years.that song is my favorite song too!!
I also liked how in the ending credits they showed everyone who ever played in a twilight movie even if they weren't part of BD part2
Ysabela wrote: "Abby wrote: "I love this movie!!!! It made me cy like a baby. I started to cry when during the flashback when Edward walked into the cafeteria for the first time, and the song was all like: The day..."I was crying softly throughout the movie but I just broke down sobbing at the end credits...wasn't it just beautiful....I mean everyone was there, from the start to the end....I loved it! I couldn't stop crying! Everyone was walking out but I was just sitting there...sobbing my eyes out!
Jordan wrote: "Emily wrote: "Aro's laugh was by far, extremely freaky! I loved it though!
GIFSoup"
omg wasn't that the best thing ever? I busted out laughig in the theater!"
Hehehe.....it was like the most awesome evil laugh EVER!
Emily wrote: "Ysabela wrote: "Abby wrote: "I love this movie!!!! It made me cy like a baby. I started to cry when during the flashback when Edward walked into the cafeteria for the first time, and the song was a..."I know right it was at that exact moment that I realised that's it no more twilightt and I felt sad yet happy at the same it was so beautiful ...I mean ive been a twilight fan since even before the movies when the book came out and back then I never thought twilight saga would make it this big
Ivy wrote: "Haidi wrote: "Ivy wrote: "Yeah. But my other complaint is that the movie didn't follow the book at all like the other movies did which was a real downer. I had a feeling the fight scene was fake si..."The fight scene was not what I was talking about, we all know that wasn't in the book,(and I think most people agree it was clever to add it) but as far as the actual movie not "following" the book I disagree with you. As far as bella being angry with Jacob for alot longer, well, it is a movie and they cant spend the entire movie focusing on one particular event in the book. And the part at the end when Bella allows Edward into her mind (and it's in 3rd person) it had to be shown in a way that was appropriate for the cinema. It doesn't really matter how it was shown, the fact is, it was in the movie and they didn't leave it out.And as far as the wolves are concerned, if my memory is correct, and it stated it in the movie also, the "random" wolves weren't from just anywhere, they were members of the tribe and because there were so many vampires in the area it caused the kids to turn into wolves. They were part of the Quileute tribe. So my point is, they followed the book really well.
i almost cried when carlisle died, ue I have read the books.. so I was more upset about them not followig the books then anything else :P
Michelle wrote: "i almost cried when carlisle died, ue I have read the books.. so I was more upset about them not followig the books then anything else :P"It did follow the books. It was all Alice's vision and in the books they all used their mind tricks to fight off the volturi and that was her mind trick.
All of the above:) well, well, i watched the movie today, and i can't believe i'm saying that but actually it was good, that fight scene near the end of movie was breathtaking.
Narmin wrote: "All of the above:) well, well, i watched the movie today, and i can't believe i'm saying that but actually it was good, that fight scene near the end of movie was breathtaking."
Lucky! I've seen it twice on the same day! Haha! It was back to back.
Jordan wrote: "Narmin wrote: "All of the above:) well, well, i watched the movie today, and i can't believe i'm saying that but actually it was good, that fight scene near the end of movie was breathtaking."
Lu..."
I'm watching the fight scene again and again. it is an incredible well done addition.
Narmin wrote: "Jordan wrote: "Narmin wrote: "All of the above:) well, well, i watched the movie today, and i can't believe i'm saying that but actually it was good, that fight scene near the end of movie was bre..."
I know, they did fantastic! I think I screamed in the theater!!!!
They made this movie absolutely beautiful. It made everyone experience different emotions. Shock when Carlisle died, anger when everyone else started to die, and happiness when the Volturi (especially Jane and Aro) died. They also did the end credits great. Everyone was there- from beginning to end, and that just made me start to bawl. Why? Why must this be over? It's just... not right. *sigh* My life won't be the same anymore.
The end- when Bella put her shield down and let Edward read her mind just killed me. I died. It was so beautiful! I started to cry! Gosh... The song by Christina Perri, and everything just... was too perfect, to say the least.
I wish that it wouldn't end. They were right. It was the movie that would live forever.
I saw it yesterday and was tempted to check out this thread before I went. So glad I didn't. It would have ruined the shock of the fight scene. Loved the addition. Aro's laugh, Jake undressing, Jake making fun of Aro...all great.
I also gasped at those scenes, but I also loved that scene when Jane realized that Bella was shielding everyone away from her powers and the hunt scene, and the part when Bella sniffed Jacab and said " Yeah, Now I know what they meant, you really stink" LOL. And my heart missed a beat when Bella realised that Alice had previewed hers and Edward's death and I was like, no way they don't have forever and Reneesme will have to grow without her parents... No way! And I also loved that part where we see Reneesme full grown with Jake and Edward and Bella!
Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"Me and a friend were in hysterics! We couldn't stop laughing!!!
Jordan wrote: "omg i started to cry i thought it was real. I swear i have never been more surprised in my life. I was like "I don't remember this from the book!!!!"" Haha I did the same exact thing ;)
Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."
I did all of these things. To tell you guys the truth i cried and then i felt stupid when it was just the vision Alice was showing aro
huum... I don't know, because it has been a long time since I first read the books (4 years?), but that doesn't happen on the book, right? Because I remember they discussing, and Jane's brother cheating, and trying to attack them while they talk and all, but don't remember major fight scene... so could anyone refresh my memories?
Nalu.chan wrote: "huum... I don't know, because it has been a long time since I first read the books (4 years?), but that doesn't happen on the book, right? Because I remember they discussing, and Jane's brother che..."I was the same i don't recall any fight scene or even alice showing him a vision. i know Jane, Alec and Chelsea were chesting Jane trying to hurt Bella while she protected everyone, Alec using his powers but failing becuase of Bella's gift and Chelsea using her ability to let them think they wanted to join the Volturi but again failed becuase of Bella's gift. There wasn't a fight scene there nearly was becuase or Irena's death but no fight scene but it was a cleaver idea to show what could have been to Aro. i like how everything turned out fine in the end though :)
Comment and tell me if you:-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with relief when you realized none of it actually happened
-ALL OF THE ABOVE :)
AND SOME CURSING WAS INVOLVED!!
Peace wrote: "i think i did all the above.."Have you seen the new film now Peace?
Oh, I just thought, from your posts that you had seen it. Will you be seeing it soon?
Yes I've seen it twice now.
No I've not seen any of "the making of" but I'm sure it is interesting. I've seen the making of all the other twilight movies.
Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."
Exactly what happened to me, then the people next to me were like "shut up its just a movie! Plus it's all fake" and they tell me the rest of the movie and I'm like, excuse me! I was furious!
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
