Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4) Breaking Dawn discussion


382 views
(*SPOILERS INCLUDED*) Breaking Dawn Movie Part 2

Comments Showing 1-50 of 125 (125 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by mal (new) - rated it 5 stars

mal (MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with relief when you realized none of it actually happened
-ALL OF THE ABOVE :)

and tell me which of these you did IN THE THEATER. I know for sure that I did all of the above, just like pretty much everyone else in my theater. ;D


Sarah Someone told me what happened so i knew they weren't all dying but even so Seth brought me to tears. And Alice and Esme's cries were so realistic. Caius death was so disgusting with the jaw ripped apart


message 3: by Jazzy (last edited Nov 18, 2012 08:37AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jazzy I literally wanted to scream. I was like they can't kill Carlisle and Jasper, my two favorites! The way Caius died was disgusting. I looked away for a second.


Jennifer Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


Agree!! ALL the above!!


message 5: by Angie Elle (last edited Nov 18, 2012 09:16AM) (new) - added it

Angie Elle Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


There were no tears, and I have to admit that I was quite proud of myself for that. I do love this series and was afraid I'd get emotional when they were over. Sad, but true. LOL

There was a bit of screeching and clapping, however. And giggling when Jake was undressing in front of Charlie! LOL

I wasn't sure how I felt about the movie for a while after I watched it, but I did like it. I just wanted a bit more Edward/Bella screen time.

In the end, I think they did a fantastic job with it, and I love that they were able to shock us fans.


Jazzy Ya just seeing the look on Charlie's face though haha. It was hilarious


Jennifer I was impressed that the readers were able to be shocked by the movie! I felt empty at the end just like I did when I was finished reading the books...it was happy, but it was over. I was able to get immersed into their lives..into the story. I know their are a lot of critics, but it is more than "sparkly vampires". It is a timeless story of love, and taking the difficult path of resisting temptation and doing what is good.

I am so glad they did the scene where Jacob takes his clothes off in front of Charlie...hilarious!!

Also, Alice's kick to Aro's head? Woo hoo!!


message 8: by Angie Elle (new) - added it

Angie Elle Jennifer wrote: "I was impressed that the readers were able to be shocked by the movie! I felt empty at the end just like I did when I was finished reading the books...it was happy, but it was over. I was able to g..."

Yes, I did love that at the end, it was the Cullen women who had the upper hand and were able to defeat the Volturi. They do know how to fight for their men!

I agree, Jennifer. SM wrote a love story, and in this day and age of books where the lead characters just fall right into bed with each other, the depth of love that this book exuded is so rare.


Reepa Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


words cant explain how I felt... but your description above just about sums it up :D


Taylor Hamdorf Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


All of the above! I literally cried during the whole part, it seemed so real! I did cheer when Aro and Jane died, not to mention laughed at all of Aro's facial expressions xD


Sarah Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh


Taylor Hamdorf Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

My whole theater started laughing so hard, I personally thought it was halarious(:


message 13: by Angie Elle (new) - added it

Angie Elle Taylor wrote: "Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

My whole theater started laughing so hard, I personally thought it was halarious(:"


It creeped me right the heck out! LOL


message 14: by Global (new) - added it

Global Donnica I was just busy screaming.....


Jennifer First reaction was laughter until it sunk in a few seconds after...then major creepy factor! lol


The Succubooks Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


Yeah, all the above.

I didn't actually scream when Carlisle died, but I gasped and jumped in my seat and felt sick. I was like "Oh, crap! Not Carlisle! He's my favorite!" Then when Jasper died I was like "They're killing off all the awesome guys!" For a second I almost believed that they were going to kill Edward too, but then he helped Bella kill Aro. The whole theater cheered when Aro died. . .then the whole theater laughed with relief when we realized it was all a vision of Alice.
I went to see Breaking Dawn with a friend and as we left the theater he said, "When Carlisle died I thought I was going to be sick!"
I think it was the best Twilight movie yet.


message 17: by The Succubooks (last edited Nov 18, 2012 08:08PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

The Succubooks Angie wrote: It creeped me r..."

LOL, agreed.


message 18: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam I haven't seen this but is this the surprise ending they did away from the book? They killed the volturi???


The Succubooks Sam wrote: "I haven't seen this but is this the surprise ending they did away from the book? They killed the volturi???"

I don't want to spoil anything for you since you haven't seen the movie, but they don't REALLY kill the Volturi.


Emily Aro - so creepy! Pretty sure he'll be in my nightmares tonight giggling it up like a five year old girl.

The entire audience gasped when they saw Carlisle! I just kept repeating over and over, "I CANNOT be seeing this!" At one point I thought I was actually having a bad dream about the movie!

Such a good ending to the movie and entire series.


message 21: by Angie Elle (new) - added it

Angie Elle Emily wrote: "Aro - so creepy! Pretty sure he'll be in my nightmares tonight giggling it up like a five year old girl.

The entire audience gasped when they saw Carlisle! I just kept repeating over and over, "..."


Yes...when Jasper went down, my friend said, "We need to leave!" LOL


message 22: by The Succubooks (last edited Nov 18, 2012 08:29PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

The Succubooks Emily wrote: "Aro - so creepy! Pretty sure he'll be in my nightmares tonight giggling it up like a five year old girl."

LOL, I know, right.


And I, too, was thinking I was having a bad dream about the movie when Carlisle died.


The Succubooks Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

Do you mean that weird squeaky noise? Yeah, I chuckled and said to my friend, "Um, ok." and he said, "That was a little weird."


Nicola Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


ALL OF THE ABOVE!!!!


Nicola Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

hahha yes!! I was like ha willy wonka much
When jacob started too take his clothes off, me and the people around me all cheered and i was like Keep goin!!!


Haidi Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


Yep I did all of these apart from the last one. I didn't sigh with relief, I began to laugh with relief and the whole cinema followed along!


Carrie P laughed @aro when he giggled like a creep & loved when jacob stripped but didn't cry at all during the fights & deaths, only cheered, cuz someone had already *spoiler alerted* b4 i watched it :)


Süheyla I was really shocked when I saw all the good guys died. I thought that the scenario has been changed. After the war scene, I was relieved and glad to know that we were seeing Alex's vision.


Asser Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


I did all of the above! LOVE the ending!


message 30: by Celeste (new)

Celeste Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-laughed when Aro died
-sighed with relief when you realized none of it actually happened
-ALL OF THE ABOVE :)

all of the above.


♥*♥* The Jokers HarleyQuinn ♥*♥* Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

Yes :D


♥*♥* The Jokers HarleyQuinn ♥*♥* Mallory wrote: "(MAJOR SPOILERS)



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."


As soon as that happened to Carlisle i was like wait a minute something is up but i never imagined it would be that i almost cried tiny bit but then i watched a second time and turned my head when the lovable characters you know and i smiled when the evil got their asses and head kicked.

I thought it was funny with Aro 'friends there is no danger here' i would love if someone called him a crap bag everyone in thetre laughed too as if they were thinking the same thing.

I loved Breaking Dawn Part 2 and i am sad it's over but we can always re watch it again and again and again and never get over it, apparently they were thinking about doing a tv series about renesme i was like no becuase that would ruin it but it would be goon for Steohanie to write another book with all of the characters in again just one more time Spehanie please :)

so yeah all on all i laughed with Emmett and Bella, laughed when Edward was helping Bella and yelled at Emmett, i laughed when Edward was enjoying Bella kicking Jake's ass and i pretty much laughed at every single bit, but i ALMOST cried at the lovable charcters fake death but when i saw it was a vision i literally blew out a sigh of releif.

I am going to see it a third time becuase i love watching it on the big screen and i can't wait for it to come out on DVD. plus the Bella, Edward and Renesmee scenes were just so cute :)


Denise OMG, All of the above most definitely. I practically had a heart attack! When I thought Edward was gone I grabbed my pocketbook and told my sister I was leaving bc I couldn't keep watching. I thought, how could they ruin this ending so much??? So glad it wasn't real and the movie had the happy ending the book did. Great movie, besides that twist it stayed true to the book. So sad it is over, I have the empty feeling too just like I did after I read the book. I so wanted more, I didn't read for almost a year after I finished the series, I just wanted more.


Luna Belle Pris Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

Yes. It was silly. In fact your post made me laugh again:)))


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

I love this movie!!!! It made me cy like a baby. I started to cry when during the flashback when Edward walked into the cafeteria for the first time, and the song was all like: The day we met. Frozen I held my breath. Right from the start. I knew it I found a home for my... The tears just started falling, and they wouldn't stop. I thought I would never stop crying.


Joannne said "what the hell" when carlisle died"
said "OMG" when jasper died
cried when seth and leah died
threw a party when jane died
as they say in south africa in afrikaans "het groot lekker gekry" when aro died (was super stoked)
and had mixed feelings when it was all a vision


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

in shock when carlisle died
even more shocked when jasper died
pulling my hair when seth and leah died
cheered when jane died
happy when aro died
happy and shocked when its a vision


message 38: by mal (new) - rated it 5 stars

mal Just wanted to say thanks to anyone who contributed in this little rant, it's fun to see everyone's different reactions to the twist ending :)


Jordan omg i started to cry i thought it was real. I swear i have never been more surprised in my life. I was like "I don't remember this from the book!!!!"


Jordan Oh and I met Peter (Carlilse) So I was like "Noooo! He touched my arm! You can't kill him!"


Jordan Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

omg yes me and my mom couldn't stop laughing! It's funny that you mentioned that i didn't know anyone else noticed lol! omg cracking up right now haha!


 Bella Marie jane is such a btch....oh my god. I didnt hated her in new moon or in eclipse, I thought she was the most coolest volturi but hell I wanted her dead in BD2. When she started to run it was awsome. I totally freaked out when the fight started. It might not be exactly like the book but it was awsome movie. Still twilight and new moon are my favourite...unfortunatelly in my town twilight saga isnt popular at all so in the theater I was almost alone :(( Favourite scene anyone? when jane started to run....


Jordan Bella wrote: "jane is such a btch....oh my god. I didnt hated her in new moon or in eclipse, I thought she was the most coolest volturi but hell I wanted her dead in BD2. When she started to run it was awsome. I..."

I know! I was so happy that you can see that without her power, she is such a coward. And the fact that Alice grabbed her! OMG I was like "That's what happens when you kill Jasper!"


Emily All of the above!!! I hadn't read the book yet so I thought that's what actually happened! And I was freakin out and I went to see it with my friend(and she read it) and she was like hyperventilating and was super freaked out. :D And then it zoomed out to Alice again and I swear I stopped breathing for a minute or two. I was so relieved!

When Carisle died, I gasped and my eyes got wet.
When Jasper died, I got angry at Stephanie Meyer and the movie people for putting that in. I also got mad at the people that killed him.
When Leah and Seth died I was sad for Seth but I don't really like Leah so I was ok with it.
When Jane died I wanted to yell with happiness.
When Aro died I think I froze but inside I was screaming with joy. :)

BEST MOVIE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Jordan I saw it and than went right back in the theater to see it again! LOL me and my mom are twi-hards!!!


Emily I think the best two parts in the movie were when:

1. Bella and Emmett have the arm-wrestling contest. Emmett is awesome! One of the best characters ever! He has the best lines and I always wanna laugh no matter how serious the situation is.

2. At the end when Bella and Edward are in the meadow and Bella lets Edward into her mind. Super amazingly awesome part! I wanted to cry when it ended.

Renesme was sooooo adorable! She looked like an angel! And the other man that was born the same way didn't look 'pretty' at all to me. He was actually kinda ugly. :(


Jordan I loved the meadow scene! I was scared to see it because it's my favorite part in the book so I wanted it to be perfect, and they did it perfect!


VIVI  GARCIA Mallory wrote:



Comment and tell me if you:
-screamed when Carlisle died
-screamed when Jasper died
-cried when Seth and Leah died
-cheered when Jane died
-cheered when Aro died
-sighed with re..."

I so did that


Lauraleigh omg i loved it i was watching it and i was just like OMG WHAT THE HECK IS HAPPENING when it turned out to be alices vision i was like oh thank god i was so sad when i thought they were dead :P


Kelli Sarah wrote: "Did anyone else burst out laughing when Aro had that little laugh"

Hahaha totally! My friend and I couldn't stop laughing


« previous 1 3
back to top