Krystal
Krystal asked:

Why doesn't Inspector Gamache like Yvette Nichol? What exactly did she do wrong?

To answer questions about Still Life, please sign up.
MJ Gamache reads people very well and he could tell through her behavior that she was not a team player. He only wants team players working with him and people willing to admit they are wrong. Based on her not being able to see that SHE may be the problem (when looking at her reflection in the mirror and then the window), it was obvious that she is self-centered and not willing to she herself as ever being wrong.
Ali Nazifpour
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)
Terrie She mean, snotty, childish, narcisistic -- nothing is EVER her fault. Creepy.
Ariel
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)
Rebekah She starts out very likable. But her character is slowly revealed to be not just inexperienced and naive and bumbling, but very flawed.
Nicholas The real question to me, in this first novel is why he put up with her poor behavior for so long.
Susan Kinnevy She's annoying and seems too stupid to be on that police force. I am so tired of this characterization of females in detective fiction. I'm going to reread Carol O'Connell's Mallory series -- I love her
Carolyn
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)
Gigi What did Yvette Nichol do wrong? She stumbled into this book is what she did wrong.
Abhirup Nichol has great potential - but like many other characters in the book (and this seems to be a consistent theme) - sees the world in binary - right or wrong, good or bad, and everything is about herself.

That is what "Still Life" means - many characters act childish and blame other people for their problems - Nichol, Yolande & at least 2 more people revealed which are spoilers - instead of taking responsibility for their own lives and being active.
Kay Dee (what is your storygraph name? mine is in my bio. join me!) Meadows you should read those scences again. then read the other bookin the seriesls to fully get why nichol rubs people the wrong way. and gamache doesn't dislike her. he dislikes how she treats others and doesn't do the 4 things listed in a previous question.
Lou Hi! I googled the same thing ....
Isn't she autistic?
Melody Smith To me, you don't really get Nicol in her intro. She is ambitious and wants to be a success but like many cops her personality holds her back. Sometimes I thought she was a little on r he autism spectrum in her rigidity. This book was written before we understood what we do now. She appears in a later book, and Gemache has to trust her. She doesn't change much, but he understands and uses her skills while correcting her social weaknesses.
Deb Having read the series (except for Devils Are All Here) twice, I think looking back that Gamache is impatient with Yvette because she does not respect even herself. He is disappointed.
Debra Stockton Only one way to answer this question: READ ON! All the Gamache books reveal a long arc of the plot... over time.
George As I remember, he eventually places her in jobs where her personality and character don't get in the way.
Rita Appio She does not understand human complexity and she feels that she, and her wishes, are the centers of the universe.
Artemisia She is not a team player that is true, she's too headstrong, and there's something else I can't quite put my finger on, needs a little more finesse or something when dealing with others? - but I've only read one book so far. She's a very green rookie is all I can say.

However, Jean Guy and Chief Inspector Gamache have the kind of relationship from years of working together, and that is going to be a little tough to break in to. Jean Guy also seemed to be a little leery of her.

I love the character of Jean Guy Beauvoir so far. Yvette does seem only concerned with herself, how she appears to her boss, and advancement.
Image for Still Life
by Louise Penny (Goodreads Author)
Rate this book
Clear rating

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more