Jeffrey A Gregor asked:

This question contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

2 likes · like
2 years ago
17 answers

To answer questions about None of This Is True, please sign up.

Dave

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Robert Blumenthal

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Buttercup I believe Josie was telling the truth because she mentioned it before to Walter, this is what she said "I'm probably going to tell Alix about the girls" "I'm going to tell her what happened. What we did" "She'll be able to help us" "It's happening, Walter. Whether you like it of not. I'm going to tell Alix everything. I can't live like this anymore. We're moving on". When she said this he got really angry calling her insane and warning her that Alix will be calling the police on them.
Which means he knew exactly what happened and was part of it. Roxy also had history of aggression towards others, she broke her sister's arm and another kid's finger.

flag

judith Why is everyone so willing to believe Roxy & Erin? By all accounts, they are both seriously disturbed too, so some of what Josie says may be true! It's left open-ended, but she likely cracked under the weight of her horrible life & can't distinguish between her imagination & reality. She's portrayed as a twisted teen, then an adult stalker & manipulator who gloms onto people, & a thief/ kidnapper/murderer, but how much of that actually happened & how much is in her mind? Other characters refute her story until at the end she doesn't even know her own truth That being said, Walter's a sexual predator who could not be trusted, & Josie's surrounded by other emotionally scarred people, so if "None Of This Is True," aren't you just left questioning everything?

flag

Elizabeth

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Victoria McVicker I think that’s purposeful and up to the reader to decide….

flag

Josiepearsonyahoo.com Despite the ending Josie is still a murderer, she killed Nathan and attacked, then left Erin for dead, tied up in the broom cupboard, so I think the question of who is telling the truth is mute

flag

Sue S

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Lisa

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Ruby Luk

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Amanda

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Liz Kolon According the Lisa Jewell’s Insta the character in the final chapter is telling the truth (Josie). There is a bonus chapter coming soon soon!

flag

Amy Windsor

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Paromita Haha, confusing is a real understatement. The writer just means that we are all liars or we bend the truth when it suits us, but only Josie becomes the villain. A good way to justify the bloopers in the book certainly...

flag

Anna Riley The author is leaving it intentionally nebulous so you wonder who'S telling the truth unfortunately i just don't think she executes the "twist" very well it also could well be a huge mix of truth and lies and Josie has a hard time keeping track of the truth.

flag