A Goodreads user asked:

Does the ending seem to imply that Henry will go on the Africa trip so can kill Phin?

flag

6 likes · like
5 years ago
27 answers

To answer questions about The Family Upstairs, please sign up.

Anne

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Nancy

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Chaya Yes I think so. The author has planted in the reader towards the end the unsettling idea that there IS evil in Henry, and so who knows what will happen when he goes?

flag

Anita Yes, I think so, although I don’t know if it will be to kill him or just to see him again. I’m wondering if she will write a sequel.

flag

Lauren I wondered this too - especially after his "inner" statement that Phin wouldn't want to see Libby and never cared about Libby - it was a bit creepy. I think we're supposed to be left wondering - depends on how you see Henry.

flag

Jaylynny
Yes.
** Goodreads flags because answer is not long enough.

Hell yes.

flag

Meena Mistry Does it not state that someone from South Africa bought the house? Phin??!!

flag

Leasa this is the initial impression I got! Though, Henry has this weird love/hate or push/pull thing with Phin... so I wouldn't be surprised if he killed him in the moment, but also wouldn't be surprised if he didn't. Only 1 other person in my book club caught on to that

flag

Susan Reeves deMasi

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

lauren lese I think even if you could ask this question directly to Henry himself, he would not be able to answer. It is intentionally ambiguous just like Henry is an ambiguous character. He is absolutely a narcissistic sociopath with no empathy or morals but he is not sadistic - he kills only when and if it is required to protect his interests, not for pleasure. Personally I don't think he wants to go there specifically to kill Phin but certainly would if he deemed it "necessary" for any personal reason.

flag

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Stephen Gaspar Honestly, it never even occurred to me that Henry would want to kill Phin. Especially given the reveal at the end, when it turned out that Phin kissed Henry back, before leaving him in the middle of the night. Maybe I’m a hopeless romantic, but I saw the ending as a chance for them to finally be together.

flag

Sarah Yes, that's how it came across to me. Henry was quite a creepy individual. For a long time through the end of the book I thought Phineas was going to die, but it would be good to understand how he ended up where he did.

flag

Joanne

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Elizabeth I think its just another nod to how flawed Henry is. He's always been obsessed with Phin, and when he learns that he's alive, he couldn't NOT seek him out. It's a love hate relationship on Henry's end for sure.

flag

Victoria Possibly, Henry is certainly an unpleasant character. Did anyone else think it odd that no mention was made of having told Phinn's mother and sister that he was alive?

flag

Carolina

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Grainne Flag this question as containing a spoiler so people don't see it when searching this book!

flag

Cassidy Crowe

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Allan Lopez Well I started thinking of the time when they got high or whatever on the acid and Phil told Henry about his dream and how Henry should come visit whenever his dream was realized. Henry a little crazy but I dont think he would kill Phill

flag

Michelle Currie

This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

flag

Carissa Voth That's the vibe I got-that Henry will be visiting F/Phin in Africa. I am hoping so because I would like to delve deeper into Henry. I felt like a lot just wasn't adding up with him

flag

John Stanley It could be, though I didn't see it as him wanting to go in order to kill Phin but more wanting to go because he was so obsessed with him and this was another chance to have him back in his life. I don't think he knows what he will do when he meets him necessarily

flag