If Only I Had Told Her
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between June 4 - June 10, 2025
69%
Flag icon
know Finn would have been worried about her.
69%
Flag icon
When Autumn crosses my mind again, I push away the thought the way I push away fantasies of Finn being alive. I don’t have room in my head for her grief and my own.
69%
Flag icon
Did you hear about Autumn?
69%
Flag icon
Sylvie knew that Finn cheated on her, right?
69%
Flag icon
She tried to kill herself.
69%
Flag icon
don’t need to ask why. And it doesn’t matter how. She’s alive, thank goodness.
69%
Flag icon
“What happened with Autumn?”
69%
Flag icon
“She tried to kill herself. She survived, but she’s in the hospital.”
69%
Flag icon
saw Autumn last week, and I could tell she wasn’t okay.”
69%
Flag icon
“Maybe we’re on our way to being okay. When I saw Autumn, I could tell she wasn’t on her way.
69%
Flag icon
“Why does it bother me so much?”
69%
Flag icon
but why do I care so fucking much about whether Autumn Davis lives or dies?” “Because Finn would want her to live.”
69%
Flag icon
Statistically, there’s a good chance of that.”
69%
Flag icon
“I’ll tell Autumn that Finn would want her to live.”
69%
Flag icon
“But thank you. I’ll be honest. If you didn’t offer, I was going to guilt you into it. I don’t think she’d want to see me.”
69%
Flag icon
“There’re always things that we could have done differently. What matters is what we do now.” It was the rain’s fault. “Yeah,” I say. “You’re right.”
70%
Flag icon
“I’ll let you know if she doesn’t want to see you.”
70%
Flag icon
“You’re on her approved visitors list now,
70%
Flag icon
“Everyone always says they’re fine. Everyone can’t be fine all the time. We all just pretend it’s true.”
70%
Flag icon
“Finn talked about you being depressed, and I could never see
70%
Flag icon
it. No one at school could. I thought he was—or you were—”
70%
Flag icon
“Sorry. I don’t know why I said that. It’s hard to think about anything else.” “And Finn—”
70%
Flag icon
thought you should have this. I probably should have given this to you then.
70%
Flag icon
“It’s more proof that he was coming back to you.”
71%
Flag icon
always thought of him as protective.”
71%
Flag icon
It makes sense, the way we’re seeing the same trait through our different lenses.
71%
Flag icon
She’s pregnant. Autumn’s going to have Finn’s baby. Finn’s baby.
71%
Flag icon
“I’m going to need people to tell stories about Finn, and I’m going to need a copy of every picture you have.”
71%
Flag icon
“They’re going to be happy. But they’re going to be worried about me.”
71%
Flag icon
“She’s glad you’re okay. Or going to be okay.”
71%
Flag icon
“She wants you to get better.”
71%
Flag icon
“Just like you need my memories of Finn? The part of him that loved you is still alive as long as you are, Autumn.
71%
Flag icon
You almost took another part of Finn away from all of us.
71%
Flag icon
“Are you sure Sylvie will still want me alive when she finds out I’m having Finny’s baby?”
71%
Flag icon
“Just know that you have a lot of people who care for you. And everyone, fucking everyone, who loved Finn wants you to be okay too,
71%
Flag icon
“Promise?” “Promise.”
71%
Flag icon
I’ve been thinking about Finn, and for the first time since Alexis’s call that morning, it doesn’t hurt.
71%
Flag icon
I’m so, so grateful that Finn was once alive and that I got to love him. That he got to love and be loved. And be loved still.
72%
Flag icon
There is a piece of Finny inside me to keep alive, so the rest, like breathing, must be endured.
72%
Flag icon
Apparently, gestating a future human does not prove my will to live.
72%
Flag icon
“The baby still doesn’t feel that real to me,” I protested. “I’ll probably get more excited later.”
72%
Flag icon
“You need to show enthusiasm for something, kiddo,” Aunt Angelina said. “You haven’t touched a book since you got home.”
72%
Flag icon
“This is a lot, for all of us. We need to try to focus on the good. If it doesn’t feel real yet, let’s make it feel real.”
72%
Flag icon
I’m sitting on that hospital bed with him, and he loves me, but I don’t know it.
72%
Flag icon
And I can’t change that. I can’t change that. I can’t, I can’t, I can’t, I can’t… Oh God.
72%
Flag icon
Finny is dead.
72%
Flag icon
It was only briefly in my mind that he was alive again.
73%
Flag icon
It had been two days since I’d thrown up. Twelve hours since I’ve cried.
73%
Flag icon
I’ve accepted this new reality without Finny, yet I can’t stop myself from thinking about him. And
73%
Flag icon
when I do? There he is.
1 14 18