First-Time Caller (Heartstrings, #1)
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between September 13 - September 24, 2025
41%
Flag icon
That I was self-important and unrealistic. That someone who had a kid should be grateful for any attention at all. That I shouldn’t be trying to dictate the parameters of anything. That I was damaged goods.
Charmie
I knew it was one of the self-proclaimed high-value men.
41%
Flag icon
He keeps looking at me. The same steady, studying look he always seems to be giving me. Like I’m an equation he can’t figure out. Or a particularly interesting constellation that he’s trying to orient himself with.
41%
Flag icon
let myself drift to a place where expectations don’t exist and my feelings aren’t a fragile glass balloon.
42%
Flag icon
“Nah, Lucie.” In my dream, he brushes a kiss against my forehead. “I think you’re the magic.”
43%
Flag icon
She’s got questionable taste in music, can’t bake cookies to save her life, but has the most generous, kind, beautiful soul. I would commit terrible, violent crimes on her behalf.
44%
Flag icon
I don’t think I realized that because I was choosing to be brave, other people might decide to be brave too.
44%
Flag icon
The long-buried romantic in me screams, Yes! while the always pragmatic part of me whispers, Maybe take some time.
44%
Flag icon
“You’re gonna make me work for it, aren’t you?” he murmurs. “You like it when I make you work for it,” I fire back.
44%
Flag icon
“Ah, Lucie.” Aiden smiles, his fingers fanning out wide against my back. “I’d know you anywhere.”
45%
Flag icon
“I also liked…being someone else. I liked putting my problems away and existing as a new person.”
45%
Flag icon
“I liked talking to people. It was purely coincidental I ended up on a show about romance. I liked talking about love until I…didn’t, I guess.”
45%
Flag icon
“I started to see this common thread with callers. How love could make them miserable. How it could tear them to absolute pieces. And once I saw it, I couldn’t unsee it. I think I started waiting for it. Bracing myself for it. It felt easier that way.”
Charmie
I saw this in the relationships of all of my friends. The reason why I never dated, and when finally I gave it a try, the mf proved this right even before starting.
46%
Flag icon
The way he’d look at my mom when he thought no one was looking at him. Like his heart was being ripped out of his chest. Like he wouldn’t survive it if she didn’t.
46%
Flag icon
“Secret swoony boy,”
46%
Flag icon
She took her hand back about an hour ago, before the aforementioned beers, and I’ve been silently scheming on the other end of the table for ways to get it back.
46%
Flag icon
“I need to have fun, Aiden. I never have any fun. I am always the least fun person in the room.”
Charmie
Sameee
46%
Flag icon
I missed the part of life where you can be an idiot without consequence. I’m—I’m being nostalgic, I think. Or romanticizing. I’m very good at romanticizing.”
47%
Flag icon
Lucie is as off-limits as it gets. She’s looking for romance. Happily ever after.
Charmie
Why tf is she off limits?
47%
Flag icon
I’m staring too long. Thinking about too many things. Coming up with too many excuses.
47%
Flag icon
“Focus,” she says, and I swear I would if I could.
47%
Flag icon
My imagination is having a field day.
Charmie
Isn't that like every day?
49%
Flag icon
I know I’m an affectionate drunk. Grayson calls me a cuddle monster. I think it’s my body trying to make up for the lack of touch I secretly crave.
Charmie
I wanna get drunk to know what kinda drunk I am.
49%
Flag icon
Maybe if I pretend to be calm, I’ll start to feel it. Fake it till you make it.
50%
Flag icon
He looks like a jungle cat. Some other massive predator.
50%
Flag icon
A fragment of a conversation floats back to me. You’re bossy. I certainly can be.
50%
Flag icon
Aiden is looking at me like I’m a bag of contraband coffee shoved into a cookie tin.
52%
Flag icon
everyone who has called in has either been a bumbling idiot or a self-serving asshole.
Charmie
See what we have to deal with?
52%
Flag icon
I clear my throat and try to do something with my face that doesn’t say, I dream about you naked now.
53%
Flag icon
I swear to god, this woman reduces me to the most stubborn version of myself.
53%
Flag icon
“I don’t concern myself with the fragile egos of men.”
54%
Flag icon
luckily, I don’t hold myself accountable to other people’s impressions of me.
Charmie
Yes!
54%
Flag icon
Yes, I’m fine. Except for the feelings I’m not supposed to be feeling and the dreams I’m not supposed to be dreaming and the excuses I’m not supposed to be making.
56%
Flag icon
it’s good, to know that I’m not alone in all this. That I’m not the only one who can be awkward or silly or slightly out of place.
Charmie
That truly is a relief.
56%
Flag icon
Did I embarrass myself at the bar? Was I too much?
57%
Flag icon
“I’m a completely unbiased sounding board. You can confide in me.”
57%
Flag icon
But it is what it is. I can’t change how my heart feels. I can’t guide it somewhere else. I suppose I’m going to see it through, for better or worse.”
57%
Flag icon
I’ve always been good at avoiding the things that make me feel like shit. Content to compartmentalize, a therapist told me when I was younger. But now all the heavy doors I’ve locked everything behind are rattling on their hinges.
Charmie
Dude mine told me this too.
59%
Flag icon
I’m counting to ten in my head, visualizing a sunset over the ocean or sheep over a fence post or whatever it is the hospital-appointed therapist told me to do when the anxiety felt like a noose around my neck. Content to compartmentalize.
59%
Flag icon
When I feel shaky and exposed, it’s easy to distract myself with things that feel good.
59%
Flag icon
“Don’t bullshit a bullshitter, Lucie Stone.”
59%
Flag icon
“I don’t think I’m the measuring stick you should be using. My situation isn’t exactly ordinary. I think when the right thing comes along, I’ll know it.”
60%
Flag icon
I’m possessive of her, apparently. Of her time and her laughter and her smiles that stretch so wide her eyes slip shut.
60%
Flag icon
“I want to feel it first and think about it second. I want to be in the moment and not worry about what’s coming next. I don’t want to twist myself into circles over the idea of a partner.”
Charmie
Right???
60%
Flag icon
I’m torn between who I am and who I want to be.
61%
Flag icon
It feels like my brain has been rewired to only think about it. About her.
Charmie
Awww
61%
Flag icon
Give me a reason, I want to beg. Please. Make the choice for me.
61%
Flag icon
Maybe if I give in to this pull, it won’t feel so goddamn intense. Like swiping your finger along the icing of a cake. Just a taste to cut the craving.
Charmie
I don't like this
61%
Flag icon
I don’t want to take anything from her she’s not willing to give.
61%
Flag icon
“You might not be what I’m looking for, but you’re what I want. And that’s enough for me. Trust me to decide for myself.”
Charmie
But won't they clash later? You'll end up putting your expectations on him when he isn't it. And then it won't be fair to him either.
62%
Flag icon
Aiden is bossy, I think faintly as his kisses turn rougher. Messier. More desperate. He’s holding me like I’m going to disappear under his grip,
Charmie
I think I like this. lol