First-Time Caller (Heartstrings, #1)
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between September 13 - September 24, 2025
28%
Flag icon
Do you have a celebrity crush?”
Charmie
JKayyy
28%
Flag icon
I’m not picky about where we go or what we do, I just want to enjoy the time I’m spending with someone.”
29%
Flag icon
Lucie is still so convinced the things she wants aren’t things worth talking about. Who made her feel so small? Who made her hide pieces of herself?
29%
Flag icon
It might be the most incredible thing about her. How she’s always willing to try.
29%
Flag icon
“I like that. Thinking that I’m worth paying attention to. Something ordinary made extraordinary by the person you’re sharing it with.”
29%
Flag icon
I’ve decided a little touching is okay. As long as she doesn’t mind.
Charmie
Yes. As long as she doesn't mind.
30%
Flag icon
Her face is so damn expressive. I wonder what it’s like to walk around with your heart on your sleeve.
Charmie
Not good tbh
30%
Flag icon
“Can you process and listen at the same time?
Charmie
Nope. I can't.
30%
Flag icon
I tug her headphones off her neck and push them carefully over her ears, making sure I don’t catch any of the shiny silver hoops looped around her earlobe. I tuck her hair beneath the band and my hand lingers. “Good?” I ask. My thumb rests at the hollow beneath her ear.
Charmie
😏
30%
Flag icon
All I know is it feels like something different and delicate.
30%
Flag icon
She’s a natural. Poised and funny and sarcastic.
31%
Flag icon
Lucie glances at me and I shrug. She’s the boss, as far as I’m concerned. She can play it however she wants.
31%
Flag icon
I’m noticing things I shouldn’t be noticing and I’m not as mad about it as I should be.
31%
Flag icon
I’ve always done better with a buffer around any strong emotion. It’s how I’ve survived.
31%
Flag icon
I can’t believe we’ve been sitting here together every other night for two weeks and I don’t know what she does.
Charmie
Has it only been two weeks?
31%
Flag icon
That resigned look appears on her face again. Like she was silly for ever expecting anything different. I hate that look.
32%
Flag icon
She looks like she could murder me with her pinky toe and enjoy every second of it.
Charmie
I wanna look like that
33%
Flag icon
I used to feel bad about relying on the people around me,
33%
Flag icon
“I think books are sexy,” she says very seriously. “No one at school has quite lived up to Aragorn yet.”
34%
Flag icon
Oh, to have the optimism of a twelve-year-old.
34%
Flag icon
Hoping it might distract me, too, from this pressure in my chest. The fog in my head and the itchy, scratchy feeling at the base of my spine. I’ve been shoved out of orbit and I have no idea what needs to slot back into place to make everything feel steady again. The pages of my instruction manual are faded and too hard to read.
34%
Flag icon
I think maybe this is the only love I need. The best kind. The kind that won’t fade out or burn away. The kind that will stay.
34%
Flag icon
It’s lovely and overwhelming and terrifying and not a thing I ever thought I’d be doing. I still don’t understand why all these people want to talk to me.
35%
Flag icon
People continue to elude me.
Charmie
Trueee
35%
Flag icon
Love has certainly been patient enough for me. Twenty-nine years and the closest I’ve come to romantic love is the way I feel about the armchair in the romance section at Patty’s.
Charmie
Same girl, same.
35%
Flag icon
Just because I’m frustrated doesn’t mean I get to be a shithead.
Charmie
Self-awareness is sexy as hell.
35%
Flag icon
I have ten thousand opinions floating around and the roar of them is making it impossible to hear myself think. I have no idea what feels right, what feels true. All my pieces are scattered across the floor and I can’t think long enough to figure out which one will fit the best.
36%
Flag icon
I don’t think I’ve ever yelled at anyone before and had them enjoy it.
Charmie
I can think of several people, honestly.
36%
Flag icon
“I’ll wait,” he says easily. “You’re worth it.”
Charmie
😏🪭
38%
Flag icon
It’s her choice. All of this is her choice. I’m not going to let anyone bully Lucie into doing anything she doesn’t want to do.
38%
Flag icon
I’d like to use the time to stare unseeingly into the void,
39%
Flag icon
Her cheeks are wet, her nose red. I’m feeling more than a little unhinged. “Who the fuck made you cry?” I snap.
39%
Flag icon
“I’m fine,” she says. “I cry when I’m frustrated. Or when I’m angry.”
39%
Flag icon
She looks tired, burned-out, like the weight she’s been carrying around has suddenly become too heavy to bear. I want to wrap her in a blanket and make her some of my secret coffee.
39%
Flag icon
I’m desperate to keep her here. I can feel it buzzing under my skin, the frantic desire to fix it. Whatever it is.
39%
Flag icon
I would have punched myself in the face too if I thought I made Lucie cry.
40%
Flag icon
He wanted to prove that women who want romance are silly or something.
Charmie
I'd like to hear his take on women who want money instead of romance.
40%
Flag icon
“You need to get back out there. I’m not letting you use this as an excuse to avoid dating for another decade. This guy was an asshole, but we’ve known for a while that your ability to choose an appropriate date is mediocre, at best.”
40%
Flag icon
“But don’t you worry your pretty little head. I’ve thought of a solution.”
40%
Flag icon
But I guess that’s my love life in a nutshell. Underwhelmed and dissatisfied. Print it on my tombstone.
Charmie
Mine too
40%
Flag icon
I think dating is the wrong fit for me.
40%
Flag icon
I feel stupid in this dress. In these shoes. Like a costume for a character I never agreed to play.
40%
Flag icon
I don’t like being sad. I’ve never liked being sad. I’ve always done my best to see the glass as half-full. Find the silver lining. Even in my worst moments, it’s something I’ve been able to do.
40%
Flag icon
I think I’ve put too much of myself into this, shared too many of the things I usually keep hidden.
40%
Flag icon
My heart feels beat-up and bruised and I’d like to avoid it all for a little bit.
40%
Flag icon
His thumb drags up the back of my leg. Down, then up again. More sparks. A glowing warmth that he rubs into my cold skin with his fingertips. “Don’t lie,” he whispers. He swallows hard, gaze tracing my face. He looks so earnest, all the sharp angles of him relaxed into something soft. “Do you need more marshmallows?”
41%
Flag icon
he’s never made me feel small. I’ve been burying the parts of myself that crave connection and belonging for years, and I’m afraid if I stop now, I’ll go right back to the way things were.
41%
Flag icon
I want my happy ending. I deserve it. And wanting it doesn’t make me weak or silly or any of the things
41%
Flag icon
“I’ve already been called a self-important bitch tonight. I don’t think it can get any worse.”
Charmie
I feel like this is a complement tbh. That's just me I guess.
41%
Flag icon
I realized he wasn’t laughing with me but at me.
Charmie
In cases like this, I ramble on a lot more. I make sure to let them feel superior (most of the time). I've noticed it's people like this who try their best for validation but rarely receive it, at least to their level of expectation. Why not fill a cup for a person who lacks when mine is overflowing?