3.89 avg rating — 4,464 ratings

"It has exceptional use of abstract meaning and each story leaves the reader with lots of questions that somehow answer each other. I found myself immersed in it and have read the whole book over at least three times and some of the stories up to five or six times. I mean to convey it has great re-readability and is very intriguing."

3.94 avg rating — 88,023 ratings

"Every time I re-read any of the stories in this novel I still find myself anticipating the ending like it is the first time I have read it. Emily Carroll has done a wonderful job of packing all of our childhood fears into a shiny box with a pretty ribbon. The art and text for the stories do not clash at all and I have spent lots of time pouring over the intricate art on the pages."

3.84 avg rating — 69,345 ratings

really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 7,348 ratings

4.31 avg rating — 3,442,737 ratings