This list is for non-fiction books covering the Middle Ages, c.406-1492.
General histories, social histories, political/military histories, and biographies are all good. Historical fiction is not. :)
General histories, social histories, political/military histories, and biographies are all good. Historical fiction is not. :)
813 books ·
323 voters ·
list created March 16th, 2011
by Catelyn May (votes) .
Catelyn
643 books
32 friends
32 friends
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
3386 books
851 friends
851 friends
Themis-Athena (Lioness at Large)
546 books
365 friends
365 friends
Bettie
15674 books
19 friends
19 friends
Donnahensley
1154 books
19 friends
19 friends
Melisende
3732 books
1035 friends
1035 friends
Without Feathers
2260 books
34 friends
34 friends
Rebecca
1590 books
127 friends
127 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Themis-Athena (Lioness at Large)
(last edited Mar 17, 2011 11:30AM)
(new)
Mar 17, 2011 11:29AM
I notice a few primary source texts from the Middle Ages are beginning to sneak in, as well as at least one novel (Scott's "Ivanhoe"). I take it the novel will have to go ... but what is your take on primary texts from the era?
reply
|
flag
I created the list specifically for histories & biographies, excluding fiction. I think non-fiction work from the era is fine (I see Aquinas' Summa Theologica up there, and I imagine someone might add the letters of Abelard and Heloise). Those are fine. I'd prefer the list didn't turn into primarily source material, though. There are two other lists: "Best Medieval Literature" which is fiction from the period, and "Medieval Books and Classical Writings..." which is primarily source material, fiction and non.
I wish there was some way I could remove the historical fiction though.
I removed "Ivanhoe" (and added, with pleasure, the letters of Abelard and Heloise ... had been tempted but didn't want to add anything you'd rather not see on this list).What about "The Death of King Arthur" and "The Song of Roland"?
Themis-Athena wrote: "I notice a few primary source texts from the Middle Ages are beginning to sneak in, as well as at least one novel (Scott's "Ivanhoe"). I take it the novel will have to go ... but what is your take..."Primary sources are fairly safe here given that they represent the real world perspective of medieval people - the genre does not make the source any less valid. The whole of idea of 'non' fiction is reductionist in that it only labels what a publication is not - rather than describing what is other than fiction. Richard McKeon's 'Truth and the History of Ideas' is illuminating here...
Mr. Costain was a historical novelist, yes, but the works of his in question on this list are straight non-fiction.
Just thought I would add a few titles I have acquired in my library that are missing here. Not sure why they are on the list or not but they definitely make it into my list for researching the period. Good money spent; though I have not read through them all I did compare them to what books are extant on their subject. I find the want of books representing the study of medicine to be rather appalling for the ambitions of a list such as this.
While I am careful with my choices to equip my personal reference library, I would not consider myself a scholar or even a finder of rare books.
YESS! Norwich! How about some Ammianus Marcellinus, by the way? True, one could lump him in with the "classical era", but still, if you're looking for primary sources...Also: Peter Heather's Fall of the Roman Empire? How about Ian Mortimer's "Time Traveller's Guide to the Medieval World", or Marc Morris's "The Norman Conquest." Also another delightful book that's practically only sold in Scotland: "James IV" by Norman MacDougall. EPIC biography of the king that anticipated Machiavelli almost to the letter...
Anyway, just some suggestions. Really good list- some of these books look positively mouthwatering...
Ian Mortimer's guide to 14th century England is in 2nd place.You can add books to the list at the top of the list, at the tab next to "all votes."
The Decameron is not 'non-fiction' as the description says (This list is for non-fiction books) and has been removed.
Booklovinglady wrote: "The Decameron is not 'non-fiction' as the description says and has been removed."Is The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri non-fiction?
I mean, we've likely all gone through hell for our art, but not literally....
Booklovinglady wrote: "Waldo wrote: "Is The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri non-fiction?..."Nope."
That explains why it is at #66 (whoops! Missing one point on The Star)
Looking further up, and though I have not read the book, I also draw attention to the fact that "King Arthur" is a character of fiction...
Waldo wrote: "Looking further up, and though I have not read the book, I also draw attention to the fact that "King Arthur" is a character of fiction... ..."Votes are out on whether King Arthur was a real person or a 'character of fiction' 😉
#226 (The Song of Roland) is definitely not 'non-fiction', #275 (Sweeney Astray) is not either.
#337 (Gods and Myths of Northern Europe) is non-fiction alright, but I'm not sure it covers the Middle Ages specifically, although mention is made of the period occasionally.
Booklovinglady wrote: "Waldo wrote: "Looking further up, and though I have not read the book, I also draw attention to the fact that "King Arthur" is a character of fiction... ..."Votes are out on whether King Arthur w..."
History records that the tales of a courtly Arthur are, in deed, as non-fiction as The Decameron. Whether the kernel of truth is a Britain-Roman soldier of the late "Dark Ages" to Early Middle Ages, the idea of chivalry and so forth is straight out of a Miss Manners Handbook of the times the story was being told. The comparisons to the Welsh Merlin as the Odin/Woden of Norse belief are apt. So if the book is about knights in shinning armour rather than the discussion of "the real" King Arthur, then it has no more claim to be on the list than The Decameron or The Divine Comedy (still hanging on at #66).
Excellent documentaries on the subject include "Arthur King Of The Britons", and "King Arthur's Britain" as well as another documentary by Michael Wood, the name of which escapes me.
I highly recommend the non-fiction book by Guy Halsall "Worlds of Authur".
I wryly note the name Arthur in all those titles, but they are there for marketing value rather than for historical verification. At best, the story of Aurthur is inspired by real events and is thus a fiction, and historical fiction at best.
PS: Is there a way to search this list for a title? Once upon a time I went through the whole list - even posting about books that were not listed without adding them. I would like to use such community efforts to create an accurate list for my own research purposes. Searching would make the act of verification much easier.
Related News
For devoted bookworms, the new year is an exciting time. Specifics on the year’s upcoming books start making the rounds, along with release...
Anyone can add books to this list.










