From the Bookshelf of Buddy Reads…

Heartless

Marissa Meyer

Start date: November 1, 2018

Finish date: November 30, 2018

Discussion: Heartless

Discussion leader: Ashley Chen

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 7 topics — 109 comments total

Heartless

Heartless-Reviews
By Aqsa , Dracarys! · 15 posts · 16 views

last updated Nov 29, 2018 01:51AM

Heartless-Chapters 45-54
By Aqsa , Dracarys! · 21 posts · 18 views

last updated Nov 18, 2018 06:15PM

showing 4 of 4 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Jun 21, 2019 JM rated it it was amazing

Gripping, Hopeful, Emotional... Heartless.

Heartless is a book that immediately captured my attention; with its magical world, baker protagonist, scrumptious filled chapters (the desserts mentioned made me so hungry, I actually took note of it, and vowed to search if most of it are doable), and detailed world narration. Being that the world is from Alice in Wonderland, Marissa Meyer did a splendid job in describing vividly how this world and setting feels and looks like. It was easy, for me, Gripping, Hopeful, Emotional... Heartless.

Heartless is a book that immediately captured my attention; with its magical world, baker protagonist, scrumptious filled chapters (the desserts mentioned made me so hungry, I actually took note of it, and vowed to search if most of it are doable), and detailed world narration. Being that the world is from Alice in Wonderland, Marissa Meyer did a splendid job in describing vividly how this world and setting feels and looks like. It was easy, for me, to envision the whole thing, and before I even knew it, I was flying off the pages, and enjoying the world that Marissa Meyer rebuilt.

The romance embedded in the book is noteworthy, because it makes the title, 'Heartless', make so much sense, plus, it makes sympathizing to the otherwise known antagonist character better; especially since I have yet to read the original Alice in Wonderland (blasphemy, I know!). I love how the romance in this book started, I loved the tea parties with entertainment, I loved the mystery, and I enjoyed and rooted the forbidden love affair.

How wrong was I to do that? How naive was I to hope?

Throughout the whole book, there were flickers of hope thrown around every now and then. The love and spark between Jest and Cath were not hard to ship. There were times wherein I thought, they're going to make it, they will have their happy ending... But, I was a fool! From the title itself, from the original work itself (which I have not read or watch), it was a story of heartbreak; and last few chapters were a proof of that. I'm so frustrated and torn because I honestly don't know if the choice Catherine did was wise or not. She saved her best friend but lost the one she needed and loved the most, thus, breaking her heart, and making her heartless... Is it really worth it? Nevertheless, the journey of Catherine AKA The Queen of Hearts was an adventure filled one, albeit it ended tragically.

Lastly, most quotes from the book exchanged the characters were worth noting, but one that seemed to capture my attention was from the first chapters, a dialogue between Margaret and Catherine;
"... an endeavor to capture attention could lead to lifelong arrogance and vanity. It is much wiser to let your inner beauty shine through a drab gown that to attempt to conceal it with physical accoutrements.">i.
I believe that this quote alone speaks so much about the reality of how the media has corrupted us on what beauty is and what it should encompass. ...more

4 likes · Like · see review

Oct 19, 2017 Simi rated it liked it

Shelves: hardcover

3,5 stars:

I don’t know why it took me so long to finish this book. I was very excited about it but a few chapters in, I realised (and I feel quite dumb for not having clicked sooner) that this is ultimately published Alice in Wonderland fan-fiction. That’s not a bad thing, but as a fan of the original story, I struggled with aspects of the new canon. It was still enjoyable though!

Like · see review