Mrs. McGinty's Dead in Reading the Detectives

Jun 12, 2021 Anissa rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: 2021, british-fiction-uk-ireland, mystery-suspense-crime, series

I really enjoyed it! The barbs at Poirot that Christie laid out were a complete scream. Actually there's quite a bit of humour in this one. Also, Ariadne Oliver is my favourite and for the little she was here, I just adored her. She left abruptly and I was sad to see her go. I loved Poirot playing matchmaker for a couple who complement one another perfectly and would be happy together. It was novel because they weren't the usual and I was pulling for both to be happy at the end of the story. I w ...more

46 likes · Like · see review

Feb 04, 2019 Christine PNW rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: read-my-hoard-2024, 2024

This was only my second time reading this book - the first time I read it, I remember being extremely underwhelmed. Like other Christie's, this one improved the second time I read it. This makes me wonder if rereading Passenger to Frankfurt will somehow turn it into The ABC Murders (kidding, kidding). I attribute this to the fact that I'm less concerned with Christie's high-wire mystery act, and rather I allow myself to be absorbed into her world.

Mrs. McGinty's dead has several wonderful side ch ...more

13 likes · Like · see review

Nov 10, 2014 Kavita rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: mystery, uk, golden-age-mystery

Mrs McGinty’s dead!
How did she die?
Down on one knee, just like I!

The title and the mystery is based on a British children's game. I've never heard of it and apparently neither has Google. But it must have been pretty prevalent during Christie's time. This is yet another masterpiece from the Queen of Crime, featuring Hercule Poirot and Ariadne Oliver. I absolutely adore Mrs Oliver as a character and any book with her in it just shines for me. This case is also one of the only two cases in which P ...more

11 likes · Like · see review

Nov 19, 2021 Lady Wesley rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: mystery-golden-age-or-similar, mystery-other, listened

One of my favorite Christie/Poirot books, impeccably narrated by Hugh Fraser.

5 likes · Like · see review

Sep 25, 2025 Bev rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: british-mystery, mystery, mount-tbr-2025, vintage-mystery, bought-1994

Mrs. McGinty's dead!
How did she die?
Down on one knee, just like I!
The old children's rhyme comes to life (or rather death...) when Mrs. McGinty, a woman who made her living cleaning for others (down on her knees, as it were) is found killed. She was hit over the head by an unknown weapon and apparently for her small savings of about thirty pounds. All signs point to her lodger, James Bentley. Bentley is an ineffectual man who had recently lost his job and was badly in need of money. But would a Mrs. McGinty's dead!
How did she die?
Down on one knee, just like I!
The old children's rhyme comes to life (or rather death...) when Mrs. McGinty, a woman who made her living cleaning for others (down on her knees, as it were) is found killed. She was hit over the head by an unknown weapon and apparently for her small savings of about thirty pounds. All signs point to her lodger, James Bentley. Bentley is an ineffectual man who had recently lost his job and was badly in need of money. But would a man hide the money under a rock in the backyard?

Even though the evidence pointed to Bentley and a jury of his peers found him guilty and the man has already been sentence to hang in a very short time, Superintendent Spence isn't happy about the verdict. He can't say why exactly, but he doesn't think Bentley did it. So, he calls on his old friend Hercule Poirot and puts the case before him. Poirot is interested enough to go stay in the village of Broadhinny to see if he can spot anything that Spence missed. The detective's attention is drawn to two things: the bottle of ink that Mrs. McGinty bought two days before her death and a newspaper article cut out of the paper used to wrap her shoes. When he discovers that the article featured four women who were involved with old murder mysteries, he's sure he has found a trail to follow. And when a second woman, who had said she recognized one of the photographs associated with the article, is killed, Poirot knows he's on the right track. But he won't be able to name the killer until he can figure out which photograph both Mrs. McGinty and Mrs. Upward recognized.

I had a good time reading the book and then also listening to Hugh Fraser narrate it on Hoopla. He does excellent voice work and manages to give everyone their own vocal qualities. Given how large the cast of characters is, this is quite a feat. It's always fun to listen to "Captain Hastings" narrate an Agatha Christie story. The novel was a palate cleanser after the Beeding I just finished. It was so nice to sink into a nice straightforward detective story after Beeding's spy-thriller. Christie does it again--clues strewn about in such a way that you don't necessarily pick up on the right ones...or, if you do, you don't look at them the right way. We've got four women from the past, one of whom just might be hanging out in Broadhinny, and we've got to figure out where she's hiding. Or do we? Somebody killed Mrs. McGinty for her money. Or did they? She recognized a photograph and if we find the right photograph, we'll know who the killer is. Or will we? Christie managed to keep me in the dark (mostly) until the reveal. I had my suspicions, but couldn't quite put the clues together properly.

While I enjoyed the scenes with Mrs. Oliver and Robin Upward wrangling over his adaptation of her book to the stage, I'm not sure she fits in well to the story. I mean, yes, she does provide one of the means (can't be more specific without a spoiler) by which Poirot begins to see daylight, but otherwise she really doesn't add to the investigation. In other appearances, she provides more information and data that Poirot needs and she seems a little more integral to the plot. But overall another great outing with Poirot.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. ...more

1 like · Like · see review