From the Bookshelf of 2015 Reading Challenge [Closed]…

Water for Elephants

Sara Gruen

Discussion: . Week 2: Romance

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 108 topics — 841 comments total

. Week 2: Romance

* Week 2: Introduction
By Jessica · 43 posts · 618 views

last updated Feb 03, 2015 01:13PM

* Week 2: Progress Post
By Jessica · 54 posts · 221 views

last updated Dec 30, 2015 12:26PM

showing 10 of 10 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Jun 16, 2011 Kat rated it it was ok · review of another edition

I like Water for Elephants. I can't say I absolutely loved it but I didn't hate, or dislike, it either. I think the only word to really describe my feelings is like.

There seems to be so much crammed in to this book and yet so little. Some of the characters and characterisations just didn't come across well to me. Marlena just seemed a little bit bland and I wish she'd had a bit more of a personality. All I really know of her from this book is that she looks good in pink sequins and she has some I like Water for Elephants. I can't say I absolutely loved it but I didn't hate, or dislike, it either. I think the only word to really describe my feelings is like.

There seems to be so much crammed in to this book and yet so little. Some of the characters and characterisations just didn't come across well to me. Marlena just seemed a little bit bland and I wish she'd had a bit more of a personality. All I really know of her from this book is that she looks good in pink sequins and she has some sort of power over horses. Similarly August seems a very odd character to me. His illness seems to come a little out of left field and doesn't really seem to be portrayed in a very realistic way. I suppose I just don't really see him as character who has that condition. I did like Camel and Kinko / Walter and thought the pair of them were very interesting and their ending very sad.

But certain characters charmed me – which is impressive given those are the characters who don't exactly communicate much. I'm talking about Rosie and Bobo. My favourite characters in this book were an elephant and a chimp. Although the twist with Rosie was a little bit bizarre and probably not all together realistic.

I did like Jacob and found the nursing home scenes to be very well written. In the circus he seemed such a humble character. He's harder and more grumpy in the nursing home but I think that's more the sadness of his situation and missing the life he led more than anything. I did like his ending.

Certain scenes in the book seemed to be a little bit over the top – primarily those in the Hooch tent and the Barbara / Nell scene. I don't think the scenes really add that much to the book and could have been eliminated from the novel or toned down and it wouldn't really have affected the story a great deal. I don't have a problem with sex in books but this just seemed strangely written.

I think from this book I take away a greater interest in Elephants, the treatment of animals in the entertainment industries and of circus life in general. Would I rush to buy another Sara Gruen book? Probably not. ...more

Like · see review

Dec 24, 2012 Liza rated it really liked it

This book was as wonderful as people said it was. The title is misleading; I looked over it a lot when seeing it everywhere I shopped. So I picked it up just so I would stop seeing it. I think the whole book was about love and family, dysfunctional, but a family none the less. It was a soap opera that featured a circus. (It actually made me think of the old HBO series "Carnivale", loved that show!)

The ending was beautiful! ...more

Like · see review

Jul 20, 2017 Sharon rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Great! Depression era circus tale!

I did not know that a circus could reflect an era, but this story utilizes the backdrop of the traveling circus to do just that. This is two stories in one; set in both the past and the present. What a fantastic, historical novel!

Like · see review

Jun 23, 2009 KatieDMD rated it it was amazing

The book was so easy to read, and incredibly absorbing! I was almost sad when it ended - I was fascinated by the down-and-dirty circus life that we don't see or ever imagined. The character development is insane. ...more

Like · see review