Let's Play: Create an Ominous-Sounding Mystery Title

Posted by Marie on April 1, 2019
Goodreads Mystery & Thriller Week 2019

Mainstream mystery titles have the uncanny ability to turn the ordinary into the ominous. Like a macabre version of Mad Libs, sometimes all a title needs is a combination of a person and a place to achieve maximum foreboding. The Body in the Library, The Couple Next Door, and The Woman in the Window are all prime examples of this. And if you want to turn the terror up a notch, you can never go wrong with adding the word "girl" to let readers know that trouble isn't too far away.

The rules to this game are simple: Match your birth month and shirt color to the chart below. Then stand back for that spine-tingling (or snicker-inducing) effect. Who knows? Your title could be the next big name in the mystery genre!





What's your mystery title? Share it with us in the comments!

Check out the complete coverage of Mystery & Thriller Week:
Top 100 Mysteries & Thrillers on Goodreads
24 New Voices to Discover in Mystery & Thriller
Spring's Most Anticipated Mysteries & Thrillers


Comments Showing 301-350 of 1,666 (1666 new)


message 301: by Eszter (new)

Eszter Ádám The Stranger in the All-Night Dinner


message 302: by Martha (new)

Martha Evil in the parking garage


message 303: by Dr Rashmit (new)

Dr Rashmit Mishra The Shadow in the meat locker


message 304: by Cate (new)

Cate The imposter on the fire escape


message 305: by Rachel (new)

Rachel Green Debra wrote: "The Body at the DMV"

That sounds like something that is fairly likely and has probably happened...


message 306: by Dee (new)

Dee The Liar at the Two Star Hotel


message 307: by Krissy (new)

Krissy White The imposter in the cementery


message 308: by Beth (new)

Beth The liar in the emergency room lol


message 309: by Christina (new)

Christina Cueto The Imposter at the Car Wash


message 310: by Pao (new)

Pao The Liar in the all-Night Diner


message 311: by Aviana (new)

Aviana Murder in the Cemetery..........seems quite fitting!


message 312: by Lou (new)

Lou "The Liar In The Swamp" - oh look, apparently I'm gonna write a book about Donald Trump :D


message 313: by Derek (new)

Derek Keeling If you want something new to read, look no further than Nomad's Island. A novel that will keep you on the edge of your seat with twists and turns that will keep you guessing. Nomad's Island will whisk you away to a ruthless place where life struggles to survive and eyes taunt you from the jungle's edge.


message 314: by The lady in Red (new)

The lady in Red murder in the meat locker...lol


message 315: by Ana (new)

Ana The Woman on the Fire Escape


message 316: by Laura (new)

Laura The body in the all-night diner


message 317: by gillian (new)

gillian The liar in the casino.


message 318: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca The Shadow in the Vitamin Aisle


message 319: by dudinha (new)

dudinha rezende The widow in the meat locker


message 320: by dudinha (new)

dudinha rezende Iru wrote: "The shadow in the meat locker...
Sounds good"


meat locker too ><


message 321: by D (new)

D The body in the elevator


message 322: by Rachel (new)

Rachel The Body at the Empty Zoo


message 323: by Matisse (new)

Matisse The Liar in the Casino.


message 324: by LAUЯA (new)

LAUЯA Death at the Farmer's Market.


message 325: by Angie (new)

Angie Williams Evil in the Cemetery


message 326: by lou (new)

lou The widow stranger in the panic room


message 327: by felineShaikha (new)

felineShaikha Murder in the broom closet !


message 328: by felineShaikha (new)

felineShaikha Prissy~ wrote: "Murder in the Broom Closet

(could be scary or funny as hell)"


HEEEEYYYY were the same !! lol


message 329: by Caro (new)

Caro The Widow under the stairs (this could be really intense...or just a weird retelling of Harry Potter)


message 330: by Lou (new)

Lou The Stranger and the Widow (I'm wearing a black and white top) at the Two-Star Hotel.
Sounds more of an erotic novel than a mystery xD


message 331: by Gina (new)

Gina Ledwich Evil at the DMV. Wth, that's not even a mystery. That's nonfiction.


message 332: by Sangita (new)

Sangita The Devil at the Botanical Garden


message 333: by Jay (new)

Jay The Body in the Landfill.


message 334: by Phrynne (new)

Phrynne The Shadow in the Elevator.

That actually sounds quite creepy. Imagine being shut in an elevator on your own and there is a shadow of another person on the wall.....


message 335: by Gisselle (new)

Gisselle The Devil in the Fun House


message 336: by Lisa (new)

Lisa McNee Evil at the Car Dealership!


message 337: by Kristy (new)

Kristy Gates The stranger in the meat locker (Yikes!)


message 338: by Ernesto I. (new)

Ernesto I. Ramirez The Devil at the car Dealership


message 339: by Tonia (new)

Tonia Evil in the Cemetery


message 340: by Shelley (new)

Shelley The Widow at the Two-Star Hotel


message 341: by Adanna (new)

Adanna The Widow at The Botanical Garden.


message 342: by Leah (new)

Leah The Body In The Swamp


message 343: by jennyreadit (new)

jennyreadit Alison wrote: "The Liar at the Car Wash"

ditto! We should co-author it!


message 344: by jennyreadit (new)

jennyreadit The Liar in the Car Wash.. lol .. I was always freaked out by car washes when I was a kid.


Delirious Disquisitions The Widow at the Botanical Garden


message 346: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca Trotter The Body in the Wardrobe


message 347: by Emily (new)

Emily Death at the DMV....dun dun dun :)


message 348: by Patti (new)

Patti Murder In The Elevator

hahahahahha... I hate elevators, very appropriate ;)


message 349: by Leela (new)

Leela Martin The Stranger under the Stairs aka Harry Potter from the Dursley's perspective.


message 350: by Anne (new)

Anne Williams miller The Widow in the Vitamin Aisle
Sounds depressing, rather than mysterious.


back to top