Top 100 Mysteries & Thrillers on Goodreads

Posted by Hayley on March 15, 2018
Culprits, spies, bad guys, and women with vendettas: There's something so very satisfying about spending your time with the criminal element. And by that, we mean following the clues and solving the capers when you sit down with a great mystery or thriller. Always in search of a great book, Goodreads recently set out to uncover your 100 most-loved thrillers and mysteries.

There are, of course, rules to this game. Namely, every one of these books has at least a 4.0 rating from the Goodreads community. That means it's a bit of a popularity contest; for example Gone Girl is represented with a 4.04 rating, but another girl—Girl on a Train—just misses the list at 3.89. Then there are the usual suspects you won't find on this list: The Maltese Falcon (3.92), Angels & Demons (3.87), and Strangers on a Train (3.81) among others. It may seem brutal, but the readers have spoken.

Of course, many of your favorite writers have stayed with a character for a while, so in the cases of serialized mysteries and thrillers, we picked the books that, again, are over 4.0 and have the largest number of ratings.

It's time to unveil the top 100 Mysteries & Thrillers on Goodreads, arranged in alphabetical order. How many have you read? Tell us in the comments.








































































































Tell us how many you've read in the comments!

Check out the complete coverage of Mystery & Thriller Week:
Spring's Most Anticipated Mysteries & Thrillers
'My Favorite Murder' Podcast Hosts Share Their Favorite True-Crime Reads
The Best Mystery & Thriller Adaptations Since Gone Girl


Comments Showing 101-150 of 949 (949 new)


message 101: by JMV (new)

JMV 13 but I’m coping a few to add to my “to be read” list.


message 102: by Cheryl A (new)

Cheryl A 37 for me. I've been reading mysteries for 40 years - the list is WAY heavy on thrillers (and some are only marginally a thriller at that!!). It would be nice to see separate lists for each genre - top rating 100 ratings for each genre. Pop culture titles like Gone Girl probably pushed out titles like The Maltese Falcon and other notables.


message 103: by cathy (new)

cathy I only have one of these on my to-read list, haha. Hey Goodreads, any chance you'd make one of these lists with mostly YA books? That's mostly all I read!


message 104: by Susan (new)

Susan Dirk wrote: "19

I just started on the Alphabet series by Sue Grafton, who sadly passed away before she could finish with Z.
I m currently reading E, so a couple more to go before I reach your choice (M)."


Because you'll be reading them faster than Grafton wrote them, you'll be very aware of the change of tone as Kinsey gains experience. One of my favorite Grafton lines is in D Is for Deadbeat: Her hair was so dry and brittle that I worried about spontaneous combustion.


message 105: by Prasanna (new)

Prasanna 12 of them but I have now loads on TBR list :)


message 106: by Bonnie (new)

Bonnie Huard 15, and some of them read many years ago.


message 107: by chris (new)

chris 46


message 108: by Annesha (new)

Annesha Read 27 & 11 TBR :-)


message 109: by Mirtha (new)

Mirtha 18 so I’ve got a lot to go


message 110: by Jenine (new)

Jenine er.... 1


message 111: by Steph (new)

Steph 20. But dozens more are on my tbr list!


message 112: by O. (new)

O. 14


message 113: by Amela (new)

Amela Nukic 14 :)


message 114: by Mara (new)

Mara Pemberton I've read about 40% of the popular Mysteries.


message 115: by Diana (new)

Diana Long 21


message 116: by Dyah (new)

Dyah I'm sad that John Connolly is not on this list


message 117: by Aarthy (new)

Aarthy Ramamurthy 13; got quiet a few added to my TBR.


message 118: by Chaitanya (new)

Chaitanya Sethi Can I personally recommend this really underrated author, Mark Gimenez and his first two books, 'The Color of Law' and 'Accused'. Both the books are absolutely brilliant and I would love to see him get the recognition he deserves.


message 119: by Richard (new)

Richard Jalbert 9


message 120: by Mertan (new)

Mertan Deniz 5% :)


message 121: by Daniel (new)

Daniel


message 122: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Twelve.


message 123: by Marjorie (new)

Marjorie Smith Have only read 22 so far, but my TBR list just got a lot longer!


message 124: by Deanna (new)

Deanna 27 but may be a few more


message 125: by Joann (new)

Joann Have read 44 of the 100 with another 10 or so on my want to read list


message 126: by Eileen (new)

Eileen I have read 7 on this list and I have more on my TBR list.


message 127: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Foster-clements 37. Very good selection


message 128: by Giulia (new)

Giulia Magnanini only 19...


message 129: by Arithy (new)

Arithy MV 10


message 130: by Karen (new)

Karen Ireland 13 read so far :-)


message 131: by Judith (new)

Judith 11 from this list, though I've read many more, including all Agatha Christie's books.


message 132: by Linda (new)

Linda Only 6! I don't read Agatha Christie, David Baldacci, John Grisham or a lot of the others. So many other good authors missed out on the list for all those Agatha Christie's


message 133: by Wade (new)

Wade Kristie wrote: "Can’t believe there is no Robert Crais on this list!"
I agree!!!


message 134: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Carden 60


message 135: by Kristy (new)

Kristy Johnston I've only read 11 of these but several more are on my TBR and I see more to be added!


message 136: by Pamela (new)

Pamela Mclaren Mario wrote: "45. I know I have read more of these but so long ago I can’t remember exactly."

Same with me, Mario. I counted 39 but there were a couple that I think I've read and of course, at least three that are sitting on my 'want to read' list.


message 137: by Aleeyah (new)

Aleeyah 7


message 138: by Andrea (new)

Andrea Michel Only 12 but I added several to my “to read” list


message 139: by Pat (new)

Pat Cray-Hollis 24 I have read.


message 140: by Jim (new)

Jim 34 read

8 on my TBR shelf


message 141: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Nolan 29


message 142: by Josephine (last edited Apr 03, 2018 07:32AM) (new)

Josephine J Only 8 of these...but quite a lot on my TBR list.


message 143: by Hasnamezied (new)

Hasnamezied 9 books.


message 144: by Victor (new)

Victor T 35. And I think it misses a number of books from my top ten, Like a "DAUGHTER OF TIME" etc. Plus I don't like mixing genres. Thrillers are different from Mysteries and should not be mixed. Just like SF and Fantasy.


message 145: by Marina (new)

Marina 20. But there are more books from same authors that aren't on the list.


message 146: by MH (new)

MH 32 although GR doesn't list that many.


message 147: by Michael (new)

Michael Gora 40. Many of my favorite mystery authors who are not American don‘t appear in this list at all. And many of my earlier American favorites are also missing. But that‘s just the nature of the Goodreads rating scheme.


message 148: by Patricia Hall (new)

Patricia Hall 18 new ones. Have read 10 of the listed ones. Some I’d like to read again.


message 149: by Joseph (new)

Joseph Haas Disappointed not to find anything by three of my favorite suspense writers - Greg Iles, Laura Lippman and Robin Cook - on this list. I've read a few, want to read a few more, and have seen movies based on several.


message 150: by Gina (new)

Gina 27 and I totally forgot how mesmerizing "The Boys from Brazil" was when I read it so long ago. I'm going to the local library and check it out to see if it is still top notch to me years later.


back to top