Please Hold, While I Be A Complete Bitch

Things I intensely dislike:


1. People who are nasty for no reason

2. People who don't pay attention



Reparation hasn't even been released yet, and it already has THREE fake ratings. A 5-star, given by someone back in October when NO ONE had been given the book. A 3-star followed soon after that. And today, a 1-star from someone who either couldn't have possibly read it, or they received a pirated copy - which I find hard to believe, but still isn't cool.

Now, maybe these people like to just randomly rate books - based on covers, based on my previous books, based on my social media presence, whatever. Still not okay. Still not fair. Even the 5-star makes me mad - I like to EARN my 5-stars, I like to EARN my high ratings. And low ratings - that's just nasty. Who has time to be mean just for mean's sake? Over a BOOK? I wrote it, and even I know it's just a BOOK. I don't take time out of my day to troll Goodreads to down rate books I've never read - I'm too busy WRITING BOOKS. If I EVER have that much free time, please, someone get me professional help.

OR, as has happened in the past, maybe they accidentally rated the wrong book. They just got done reading a book with a similar - or even the same! - title, and just didn't pay attention to what they were clicking on. Understandable - but still fucking annoying. Places like BookBub, and major author signing events, look at your ratings on here and on amazon, so by someone NOT PAYING ATTENTION, they are potentially HURTING MY BUSINESS. And this goes for 5-stars, as well! A bunch of random fake 5-stars makes it look the author is paying/begging/bribing for high rankings, which I don't do.

Because that's what this is - yes, it's fiction, and it's beautiful, and it's sexy, and it's a craft or a gift or a talent, whatever. But a lot of people forget, especially lately, it's a business. A business that generates income. For some authors, their ONLY income.

People don't seem to like to acknowledge that side of it - I think that's part of why there's such an uproar in the Indie World, with authors blaming fans or other authors for bad sales. Because no one wants to admit that creating art is still a business. It sounds seedy and cynical and cold-hearted, but that's the truth. If you spend money, and want to make money, you have to have that mind set a little.

Plus, it's just fucking rude and hurtful. I work hard on my stories, so it sucks when someone just randomly clicks a button without thinking about it. Hours and months and sweat and tears, for you to just look sideways and click a button.

I have lots of 1-stars, and DNF ratings. Which are fine - people are entitled to their opinion, and I can honestly say I have learned from those reviews and I am thankful for them (holy crap, I DO say "laughed" a lot!).

But if I'm going to have battle scars, I'd like to EARN them; DESERVE them. Not just have someone blindly lash out.

None of you would appreciate it if we showed up to your jobs where you work really hard and love what you do, and knowing nothing about what it is you do, we then put on a blindfold and filled out an evaluation form about you.

Not too cute, is it?

Playing around with your paycheck and your self-esteem isn't okay - please remember that when you're here, that's what you're doing to us.

There is a person behind the book you're rating. And as shitty or as amazing as that book may have been, they worked hard on it. So if you're going to give it a 1-star or a 5-star, KEEP THAT IN MIND.

Someone worked hard on something and put it out into the world. So show them just a tiny bit of respect and at least pay attention to what button you're hitting.
23 likes ·   •  17 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on November 24, 2014 11:21
Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mariam (new)

Mariam Well said, my dear. Well said. Can't wait for Reparation.


message 2: by Lexi (new)

Lexi Cubbins Don't let them bring you down! Heads up and fuck them. They don't understand the hard work, sweat, tears and blood an author puts into their book. Since these people lack a certain level of intelligence, you can't make them understand. Once the book's live, the rates will go where they belong. Up! xo


message 3: by T (new)

T I'm sorry, hon. That is really nasty stuff. I don't like to rate before reading but in this case I will. I know I will love the conclusion of this story. :)


message 4: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome T wrote: "I'm sorry, hon. That is really nasty stuff. I don't like to rate before reading but in this case I will. I know I will love the conclusion of this story. :)"


Hahaha thank you, I liked it a lot. I was trying to say that all fake reviews are bad, high ones and low ones. I love knowing that someone actually read my work and found it worthy of rating. That's what's important to me.


message 5: by Taylor (new)

Taylor Harbaugh BLAH! People suck...but hey! I still love you soooooo......that's really all that matters right?? hahaha


message 6: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Taylor wrote: "BLAH! People suck...but hey! I still love you soooooo......that's really all that matters right?? hahaha"

Bahahaha, it's all that matters TO ME!!!


message 7: by Randi (new)

Randi So sorry, but you could give me a copy and I will give a true rating


message 8: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Randi wrote: "So sorry, but you could give me a copy and I will give a true rating "

BAHAHAHAHA that is the most amazing response, I am very tempted


message 9: by Fatima (new)

Fatima *slow claps* .. Sooo true !! Can't we just , like , grab hold of all the fake reviewers and lock them up in a room or something ? It irritates me when I see a book that hasn't be released rated , specifically the one star ones . I'm all like , ' Oh god .. This person may have been blessed by some sorta divine intervention ' .. But then I'm like , ' nah , people are just stupid that way ' ..


message 10: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Fathima wrote: "*slow claps* .. Sooo true !! Can't we just , like , grab hold of all the fake reviewers and lock them up in a room or something ? It irritates me when I see a book that hasn't be released rated , s..."


Drives me nuts! I've never read Pepper Winters, and I don't know her, but before Indebted #2 came out, right after #1 was released, it got a couple 1-stars right off the bat. Who has time for that!?!? Made me feel bad for her. It's a large part of why a lot of authors choose not to be interactive on Goodreads. I guess stupidity is going to reign no matter what, or haters gonna hate.


message 11: by Andrea (new)

Andrea I'm so sorry babe but this are the people nowadays.
You know how much I love and appreciate your work. You rock! *hugs*
P.S. Can't wait to read Reparation!!! Not to mention that I'm dying to see the cover.


message 12: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Andrea wrote: "I'm so sorry babe but this are the people nowadays.
You know how much I love and appreciate your work. You rock! *hugs*
P.S. Can't wait to read Reparation!!! Not to mention that I'm dying to see th..."


Awww, thank you. And three more sleeps till the cover! I got the absolute final copy of it just this morning. So ready to show it off!


message 13: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Sasha elle a.k.a. Mrs. Liam Callahan! wrote: "And people who give nasty reviews BEFORE the book is out. ......"

Ermagurd, dying. Also, I love Jenna Marbles. LAND SHARK!


message 14: by Marita (last edited Nov 25, 2014 02:57PM) (new)

Marita Hansen Yeah, a lot of my books get rated before I've even finished writing them, so it's impossible for the person to have read them. And it does hurt, because you know other readers will think those ratings are real. Also, they bring down your rating average badly at times, thus putting off readers. I understand sometimes it's an accident, but unfortunately the author is left with the damage.


message 15: by Stylo (new)

Stylo Fantome Marita wrote: "Yeah, a lot of my books get rated before I've even finished writing them, so it's impossible for the person to have read it. And it does hurt, because you know other readers will think those rating..."

Yes, that's it, exactly! They don't realize the potential damage they're causing - a real negative review is fine, I am fine with that, it validates the good and can even help us be better writers. Fake bad AND good reviews are hurtful, though.

And the worst, it turns me into a nasty person and I wanna get mean right back, which is never okay, and I've never actually done anything. I don't like being that person. That's usually when I close the Goodreads screen and work on a story, HAHAHA. Hey, maybe I should thank them *no, nope, won't do it*


RelentlessBookChic Ramblings & Reviews I know another author who is having the same issue. Her books are receiving low ratings and she hasn't even sent out an ARC yet. People need to make better use of their time. Well said Stylo but I wouldn't expect anything less from you!


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Screw them. Once your book is released all the phenominal reviews you get will bury the fake ones deep. Plus, those who offer reviews can always make a reference to the fake reviews letting others know they are false. I'm gettin' antsy for this book!


back to top