The straw man that will not die

The reader will observe that the Law of Causation does not state (as some modern writers most unfairly would have us believe) that Everything that exists has a cause. In this form it is quite untrue, since God is uncreated and uncaused. If it were worded thus, the objection, that we first formulate our universal law and then exclude from it Him on Whom all existence depends, would be perfectly valid. But this is entirely to misrepresent our position. It is one of the unworthy devices of the enemies of a priori philosophy. (pp. 78-79)
Yes, you read that right: 1895. (And that’s the third edition.) Yet Steven Hales, Nigel Warburton, Bertrand Russell, Daniel Dennett, et al. still haven’t gotten the memo.
The Church thinks in centuries. The “skeptic” takes centuries to think. If he ever does. I think I’ll have my youngest son legally renamed “Fr. Clarke, S.J.” so he’ll be ready circa 2050 to offer yet another gentle reminder.
Published on September 18, 2014 00:06
No comments have been added yet.
Edward Feser's Blog
- Edward Feser's profile
- 324 followers
Edward Feser isn't a Goodreads Author
(yet),
but they
do have a blog,
so here are some recent posts imported from
their feed.
