date newest »
						  
						newest »
				
		 newest »
						  
						newest »
				 Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really. I'm old for a new writer..."
      Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really. I'm old for a new writer..."Kurt, I'm an older writer, too. I didn't write my first novel until I was in my mid-thirties. I've been writing ever since and doubt anyone knows my name. So, I'm reluctant to believe a lot of the advice out there as well.
You hit the nail on the head when you said that your path wasn't necessarily their path. There are many different paths to writing success and no one-way is best for everyone. I've stopped looking for the advice in posts like these and started looking for their motivational factors, which I see a lot of in this post.
However, I think that anyone who sets out to write should do it because they want to, not because of any extrinsic reasons; that'll ultimately lead to failure. Following intrinsic motivation, there's only one person you have to worry about satisfying: you.
Anyway, just felt like responding to your response and hope you don't take offense at anything I said because none of my response was meant to offend. Basically, I agree with plenty of your ideas and felt like expressing myself, too. Best of luck to you.
 J.R. wrote: "Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really. I'm old for a new writer..."
      J.R. wrote: "Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really. I'm old for a new writer..."Kurt, I'm an older writer, too. I didn't write my first novel until I was in my mid-thirties...."
No offense taken at all. I love Hugh Howey's work and the original post as well. I just didn't like the "You have to do this. . .You have to do that. . ." aspect of it. Probably just because I am older and behind and think if these imperatives are true, I will likely fail.
I did that sort of thing years ago. Forced myself to get to a goal of about 1000 words a day. It was mostly fruitless. I wrote a lot of the same things over and over again. Maybe I didn't do it long enough to achieve the right level of flow or maybe back then I didn't have a coherent plan about how to develop my ideas into something that was actually readable or interesting to anyone. I think there is a sort of mysticism to automatic writing - just keep repeating the ritual until something magic happens. It didn't and now I need to think about having actual project/ideas to specifically work on instead of just writing automatically.
I am glad for Hugh's post and your comments. In a very real way, trying to write more reviews and react more to posts on GoodReads has been the best motivation for me. An exercise in directedness.
 Kurt wrote: "J.R. wrote: "Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really.
      Kurt wrote: "J.R. wrote: "Kurt wrote: "I'm hesitant to believe anyone's advice on anything really.Wow, I feel like you read a different post then me. I can't speak for Hugh (but I'm going to anyway), but he was not telling aspiring authors that you HAVE TO WRITE this way. He is literally commenting on CL's post and pointing out how her WRITING ADVICE resonated with HIM.
Hugh and CL's message was "practice, read other genres, and do what you love". This general advice applies to everything in our lives that we want to be good at.
I bet that 99% of published authors would agree with the opinions expressed by both Hugh and CL. That you don't comes off like hubris, which I am sure was not your intent.
The topic of this post is WRITING ADVICE. Offering an opinion in dissent without offering some sort of alternative, doesn't really add anything of value to the post and discussion.
Your very first sentence states that you don't take advice. So you knew you weren't going to agree regardless of what Hugh wrote. Real improvement and growth starts with acknowledging that everything we do in our lives can be improved upon. Not being open to advice in general means you better be a genius cause you are going to have to figure it all out on your own.

 


 
I think that maybe your advice is well intentioned but then, I think, maybe just doing it will serve better than ideas about writing a million words or reading outside my genre or anything else. Or maybe you are right in a way and wrong in a way, maybe things are much more specific. Maybe my path is not your path and reading your description of what you had to do inspires me to go my own way.
I can finally not be led. I can do my own thing because someone thinks they have to write a million words before they can reach their goals I can do my own thing because someone thinks that I have to do this or that to get to the level they are at. Maybe my own problem is that I was unwilling to give anything of myself because it felt wrong or I thought I wasn't good enough. So thank you, your actual advice might be beside the point but it might help.