The New Caleb: Mike Vogel or Joseph Morgan?

Well, I just can't freakin' decide! Damn you, Charlie Hunnam! Damn your sexy mouth, penetrating eyes, and nearly non-existent inhibitions! Phew...over it.

Anyway, after much sweaty research, I have narrowed it down to TWO gorgeous, talented, and adventurous men. Since I can't decide, let's vote!

First, a Caleb character description from Epilogue: The Dark Duet:

Height: 6’4’’ Weight: 210? Desc: blond hair, Caribbean blue eyes. A full mouth made for kissing. He has a canine tooth that is a bit sharp and slightly out of line with all of this other perfect teeth (the first time I saw him smile). Muscular, but lean—not bulky or overly muscled. His skin is tan from the sun, not a machine. He has almost invisible blond hair everywhere (kissing his back, they stood on end—super soft).


Mannerisms: Caleb always seems to think something is funny or amusing (that ridiculous smirk). His eyes can be beautiful or fucking terrifying (peaceful waters v. dark murky water). His mouth gets tense when he’s pissed and trying not to show it. He scowls a lot and sometimes he does it while he’s smiling, which usually means he’s about to do something especially cruel (that first whipping).

Below I have pictures and scenes of them in action. Enjoy the man nummies.

Mike Vogel




Joseph Morgan




VOTE!
13 likes ·   •  52 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on September 13, 2013 10:06
Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)    post a comment »

message 1: by Melanie (new)

Melanie Douglas Neither ;( Charlie Hunnam will always be my Caleb 3 Paul Walker kindaaa came close in a picture someone used on pintrest. Damn the casting director of 50, how dare they steal Calebs doppelgänger :p Ughh


message 2: by Jodie B (new)

Jodie B If i had to, my vote goes to Mike Vogel... although none of them seem dark enough for Caleb! :/


message 3: by ♔Beth♔ (new)

♔Beth♔ XoXo neither, i dont care i want charlie humman. he's my caleb <3


message 4: by Kianne (new)

Kianne Joesph Morgan


message 5: by Rozel Bianca (new)

Rozel Bianca Adenig Mike Vogel


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm bummed!!! I wanted Travis Fimmel!! They both seem to pretty. But I'll go with mike Vogel.


message 7: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Neither. This may sound strange but my Caleb has brownish black hair and blue eyes. You didn't tell us he was blonde until later in the book. Lol. So I'm stuck with my creation.


message 8: by Sofia (new)

Sofia None. Seem too boyish to be Caleb. Caleb is a man not a boy.


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

Sofia wrote: "None. Seem too boyish to be Caleb. Caleb is a man not a boy."

I agree. Not rugged enough. But it's her vision, but not what I thought.


message 10: by Ilze (new)

Ilze Mike Vogel, as much as I love Joseph Morgan he doesnt have a body to be Caleb.


message 11: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Salard Joseph Morgan


message 12: by Anna (last edited Sep 14, 2013 09:12AM) (new)

Anna Mike Vogel. But considering the idea about Joseph Morgan - the "hybrid", it would be better if it's Ian S - the "vampire", but to be blonde hair-colored for your movie. Mmmmm... Like a dream came true!!! ;)) I just wish to see Ian S in some erotic movie and your is for sure better than FSoG - having so much action and many many hot erotic scenes... 8->


message 13: by Andbme (new)

Andbme MIKE VOGEL!!! Gah, he oozes sex, would be a perfect Caleb.


message 14: by Mary (new)

Mary Neither, I am an Alex Pettyfer fan.


message 15: by Exile. (new)

Exile. Mike Vogel-


message 16: by Daisha (new)

Daisha I'm not feeling either one of them... but I will vote for Joseph Morgan...


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Mike Vogel works for me. I agree, however, Charlie would have been better.


message 18: by Andbme (new)

Andbme I really don't think Charlie can b anyone but Jax from SOA


message 19: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Vogel. He just looks like he could get the job done, you know? Maybe because of his character in Under the Dome...


message 20: by Miana (new)

Miana Neither, I have to agree with Sofia and Stacey they're not dark enough and rugged enough. Caleb is supposed to be a man not a boy.


message 21: by Sofia (new)

Sofia Charlie Hunnam 4ever!


message 22: by Jade (last edited Sep 15, 2013 08:34AM) (new)

Jade I would have to say neither as well...


message 23: by Vs Various Reads (new)

Vs Various Reads NEITHER! I know everyone is a Charlie fan but I picture Caleb as Chris Hemsworth... Swoon


message 24: by Mayra (new)

Mayra Vanessa wrote: "NEITHER! I know everyone is a Charlie fan but I picture Caleb as Chris Hemsworth... Swoon"

Ooohhh! I like the idea of Chris ;)


message 25: by Isabel (new)

Isabel  Marín Vanessa wrote: "NEITHER! I know everyone is a Charlie fan but I picture Caleb as Chris Hemsworth... Swoon"


I like this idea too!! He would be a perfect Caleb for me :)
http://www.fotoswiki.net/Uploads/foto...

Mike and Joseph are good but they aren´t dark enough


message 26: by Vs Various Reads (new)

Vs Various Reads Oh yeah, that picture confirms it. Chris Hemsworth is most definitely my Caleb.


message 27: by Silvia (new)

Silvia Ruiz Joesph Morgan


message 28: by Lectus (new)

Lectus Vogel is gorgeous but I don't see either one as Caleb! but Gerard Butler!!!


message 29: by Laura (new)

Laura García Joseph Morgan


message 30: by Rosalía (new)

Rosalía If I have to choose between those two: Mike Vogel. Caleb is supposed to have a pretty face and I think Joseph Morgan is handsome but not "pretty".
But if I could choose any other actor (with the exception of Charlie Hunnan, of course *sigh*), I would say Travis Fimmel.


message 31: by [deleted user] (new)

Lady_eithne wrote: "If I have to choose between those two: Mike Vogel. Caleb is supposed to have a pretty face and I think Joseph Morgan is handsome but not "pretty".
But if I could choose any other actor (with the e..."


I agree!!! Travis Fimmel was my choice- he can do pretty- pretty and rugged, sexy-as-hell pretty


message 32: by stacey (new)

stacey If I had to choose... my votes for Mike Vogel, have you guys seen his role in Bates Motel??? He's got the human trafficking sex slaver role down pat


message 33: by Mayra (new)

Mayra stacey wrote: "If I had to choose... my votes for Mike Vogel, have you guys seen his role in Bates Motel??? He's got the human trafficking sex slaver role down pat"

Well now I'm going to have to watch that tv show :)


message 34: by Anita (new)

Anita Powers I would pick Joseph Morgan, he is plenty dark, if you ever watched him on Vampire Diaries you would see his evil side and his sexy side, yum. He can lose it at a drop of a hat and show such anger and he can be cruel and look ya right in the eye and smirk.


message 35: by Jaimy (new)

Jaimy MIKE VOGEL! Because Joseph's role as Klaus ruins Joseph.


message 36: by NA (new)

NA I love Jospeh but I can't see him as caleb so it is gonna be Mike


message 37: by Mary (new)

Mary Stacey wrote: "I'm bummed!!! I wanted Travis Fimmel!! They both seem to pretty. But I'll go with mike Vogel."

I am with you, they are both to pretty


message 38: by Mahsa (new)

Mahsa Saber I'll prefer Mike Vogel as Caleb


message 39: by Sweeta (new)

Sweeta yummy Caleb....those eyes...that accent...sorry, I got distracted. What are we supposed to be doing?


message 40: by Nadz (last edited Sep 19, 2013 01:10PM) (new)

Nadz If I had to choose... Mike... BUTTTTT! I LOVE Chris Hemsworth!!He looks like he could be damn well scary but as sexy as can be!! He's even got that Caleb hair!! Mike is too boyish looking and Joseph doesn't have the Caleb vibe to me!


message 41: by Vs Various Reads (new)

Vs Various Reads Nadz wrote: "If I had to choose... Mike... BUTTTTT! I LOVE Chris Hemsworth!!He looks like he could be damn well scary but as sexy as can be!! He's even got that Caleb hair!! Mike is too boyish looking and Josep..."

Awesome! Another one for Chris Hemsworth! You made my day.


message 42: by Kathy (last edited Sep 20, 2013 06:40AM) (new)

Kathy Please don't hit me, but neither. I'm sorry but, although these two possess the hot factor, neither seem to be 'manly' enough to pull off hot, sexy, AND sinister. If we are going this route now, I wish you would consider Alexander Skarsgård. This man exudes sex; he can be violent, while at the same time have you as putty in his hand asking for more! Moreover, he has depth as an established actor and probably can hit new depths, if ya know what I mean...oopsie! Did I just go there? Hell yeah, I did! ;-D


message 43: by Steph (new)

Steph Neither for me. They just seem to young and innocent. I do like the suggestions of Chris Hemsworth, Travis and Paul Walker.


message 44: by Heather (new)

Heather Mike Vogel <3


message 45: by Angelstars5 (new)

Angelstars5 Travis Fimmel is my perfect choise but the two guys you choose .. I think Mike Vogel could be the part


message 46: by Beverly (new)

Beverly  Cindy Well Charlie Hunnam is now Christian Grey, so i have to go with Joseph Morgan (Yummy)


message 47: by Catarina (new)

Catarina If we can't have Charlie, I think Paul Walker would be a better option. But between Joseph or Mike, I would say Mike Vogel


message 48: by Bk (new)

Bk Mejia zellner Joseph................. but no doubt charlie will always be caleb...


message 49: by Maddy (new)

Maddy Madigan Neither - too boyish. Definitely Travis or Charlie!


message 50: by Jade (new)

Jade Turns out Charlie Hunnam is no longer in the cast of Fifty Shades of Grey. I am sure that makes you very happy :)


« previous 1
back to top