Racists, Transphobes, Misogynists and Me

Last night I got to take Tyler Dewar of The Freelancers: The Mercenary through a turning point.

“Army,” he breathed as he was led into the visiting room. He never would have recognized-- The young man that stood when Tyler entered had scarcely left any trace of his former self...

Tyler had never been able to think of Army as a man, but now it was undeniable.

He wanted to hug h-- He didn't know what to do with himself. The invisible chain prison had around his neck jerked him back. No touching.

Probably for the best, he wouldn't be able to keep himself from thinking about where those breasts used to be and how soft and vulnerable the girl
he once was--

The girl,
his girl.

But the man in front of him could read his mind. Experience made it easy, Tyler supposed. He always knew that as much as Tyler tried to say the right things, the right thoughts weren't in his head and Tyler couldn't make himself think them.

He was a bigot. Quality time with bigots had taught him that. And he wanted to be better he just didn't know how.

“I missed you,” he said.


I love writing Tyler: he's misogynistic. he's transphobic, he's basically an ass but he desperately wants to be the good guy, which gives him a certain degree of charm. He wants to help people, but usually ends up doing more harm than good.

Fun thing about antiheros: when things get tough there is no outcome that isn't emotionally satisfying. If the antihero suffers it seems to confirm the rightness of the world, they're only getting what they deserve really. If the antihero thrives it plays into the reader's innate desire to be the most clever of all too.

Plus cartoon heros and villains are boring.

But the trouble with writing racist, sexist and otherwise bigoted MCs is that people don't always understand that they are not meant as an endorsement of the flaws you assign to them.

I love Tyler's relationship with his transexual paramour Army. Without it I think it's too easy to assume that Tyler is a good guy. After all, he puts his life at risk to thwart gangsters and government corruption. He cares for the little guy, no life is worth sacrificing for the greater good...

It's only through his relationship with Army that you see that Tyler does these things for completely the wrong reasons. He's controlling, patronizing ... he does good primarily for narcissistic reasons.

So while I really love Tyler and Army ... I'm also really scared of writing them. I think it's clear I'm not trying to advocate transphobia... but I've been surprised before. I thought the flaws of stereotype loving Harry were clear enough to avoid any misunderstandings about The Condor's critique on racism ... errr ... not everyone agreed ^o^

It's probably the hardest part of writing. Dealing with the people who don't like the book are easy ... dealing with the people who completely misunderstand what you're going for are very difficult.
3 likes ·   •  30 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on February 23, 2013 18:07
Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Interesting....this makes me want to read it.


message 2: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Anna (Bananas!) wrote: "Interesting....this makes me want to read it."

It's almost, really, I mean it, almost done XD XD XD I swear!


message 3: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Writing is HARD. :)
And I need to read the first one first. Will PM since it's that incognito release thing.


message 4: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Also, hope you're enjoying writing it. It seems like you are.


message 5: by Syfy (new)

Syfy As a fan of this series, I implore you to not pull any punches! Please?
No fear Isa, no fear.
;P


message 6: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Anna (Bananas!) wrote: "Also, hope you're enjoying writing it. It seems like you are."

I am now. This one is tough because it feels like two hours of research for every sentence sometimes @_@ I just hope it's not completely boring to everyone else LOL


message 7: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Syfy wrote: "As a fan of this series, I implore you to not pull any punches! Please?
No fear Isa, no fear.
;P"


If I told you life was MUCH WORSE for Tyler in volume 2 than it was in volume 1 would that ... ah... reassure you? ~heh~


message 8: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Nah, doesn't sound boring. I'm interested just by that bit.


message 9: by Syfy (new)

Syfy You don't go for shock value or PC; you tell an honest tale. This more than anything reassures me that whatever Tyler's journey, it will be brilliant!
*can't hardly wait*
;P


message 10: by Santino (new)

Santino Hassell One of the main characters in the series that I co-write is a racist, misogynistic, disrespectful tool who makes no apologies about the way he is. He's not a villain, but his behavior and attitude is deeply ingrained and it will never change.

Over the years there have been a few people who have been offended by his behavior (I always expected there to be more, honestly) but I can only think of one incident where a reader didn't get the distinction between his behavior/opinions and mine.

There will always be people who don't make that distinction, and there will always be criticisms of the presence of any un-PC behavior at all, but I think for the most part (in my experience, anyway), readers can tell when it's part of the character and not something inherent in the writer that is coming across in their writing.

This genre needs complex, multi-faceted, flawed characters. Your dude sounds like he is right up that alley.


message 11: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Ooooooooo... I didn't realize that about Company of Shadows :D


message 12: by Santino (new)

Santino Hassell :) he's someone that comes along halfway through the series, but when i introduced him, i was POSITIVE that he/i would get hated on pretty hardcore because he's such a disrespectful fuck.


message 13: by LenaLena (new)

LenaLena Sonny wrote: ":) he's someone that comes along halfway through the series, but when i introduced him, i was POSITIVE that he/i would get hated on pretty hardcore because he's such a disrespectful fuck."

Instead, the opposite happened. Many readers like him better than the MCs.


message 14: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Just guessing but is that Emilio?

Aren't the extreme characters the most interesting anyway, the ones you can't necessarily relate to, but they're unapologetic and intense and interesting.


message 15: by Syfy (new)

Syfy Great! Now I have something else to read until Isa *ehem* hands over the next installment of Freelancers... LoL!
;P


message 16: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Also, I don't see the point in arguing morality in a character. Why do people get offended by a fictional person? Escapes me. It's not the real world.


message 17: by Syfy (new)

Syfy Anna (Bananas!) wrote: "Also, I don't see the point in arguing morality in a character. Why do people get offended by a fictional person? Escapes me. It's not the real world."

*highest of fivers* Anna B
;P


message 18: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Anna (Bananas!) wrote: "Also, I don't see the point in arguing morality in a character. Why do people get offended by a fictional person? Escapes me. It's not the real world."

I think the problem in my case is that I tend to focus on subtle "passive" kinds of bigotry. The stuff that gets passed off everyday as "funny" or normal by ignorant people. And for people who have to deal with that sort of bullshit every day it can hit a nerve :(


message 19: by LenaLena (new)

LenaLena Isa wrote: "Anna (Bananas!) wrote: "Also, I don't see the point in arguing morality in a character. Why do people get offended by a fictional person? Escapes me. It's not the real world."

I think the problem..."


And the people who do that themselves may not even notice it.


message 20: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Lol, Syfy, I recall we've agreed before. Back at you. :)

Isa, I don't know you that well, but if people think you're supporting misogyny and transphobia...they're kinda dumb. Joke's on them imo.


message 21: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Fiction seems like a good place to me to explore offensive ideas....I guess I can see people being bothered by it, but again, don't hold it against the author. Read something else.


message 22: by LenaLena (new)

LenaLena And then there are books like that one that I forgot the name of, that is set in some alternate future where white people are oppressed by black people and the whites are called 'pearls' and the black 'coals' and they all behave atrociously towards the poor suppressed pearls. Sure, it's fiction, but sure the author is still a racist.


message 23: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Marleen wrote: "And then there are books like that one that I forgot the name of, that is set in some alternate future where white people are oppressed by black people and the whites are called 'pearls' and the bl..."

Lmao, you may be right. That sounds like a unique book.


message 24: by LenaLena (new)

LenaLena I found it: Revealing Eden. Just read some of the reviews.....


message 25: by Anna (Bananas) (last edited Feb 23, 2013 09:07PM) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Awww, care bears. You make some interesting points, Weasel. Characters are always a reflection of the author in some way, whether they're advocating, railing against, or just exploring a viewpoint.
I am bothered when I feel like I'm reading the author's opinion, when it's soapboxy to the point I can't enjoy the character. The author's job is to make me forget the story was written. I want to feel like it fell out of the sky, fully formed... maybe I'm silly.

Definitely looking up Revealing Eden now.


message 26: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Marleen wrote: "And then there are books like that one that I forgot the name of, that is set in some alternate future where white people are oppressed by black people and the whites are called 'pearls' and the bl..."

Oh yes.... that was the most fun drama. It wasn't just the book, the marketing campaign included plenty of black face and for a while the author seemed to just be running around the internet trolling people *lol* Like YOU GUYZ YOU DON'T REALIZE HOW WHITE PEOPLE ARE SO OPPRESSED!!


message 27: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Henry This looks really interesting. Can't wait to read it!

I agree that the difficulty in making a whatever-phobe character sympathetic or even likeable is that readers might misinterpret it as an approval of that prejudice. It doesn't have to be. People are more complicated than that, and characters should be as well.


message 28: by Shadow Jubilee (new)

Shadow Jubilee I wish GR would come out with a Like button for comments. Until they do, I'll just sit here and sadly keep hitting the invisible Like button for comments.


message 29: by Isa (new)

Isa K. Personally I'd prefer to minimize the amount of things that GR can fuck up


message 30: by Anna (Bananas) (new)

Anna (Bananas) Isa wrote: "Personally I'd prefer to minimize the amount of things that GR can fuck up"

Lol, and you know they would.


back to top